High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/355/2010dismissed

Mahavir Singh v. State Of Haryana

2017-04-26Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal,Registrar-Judicial22 pages

!"#$# %& '( )(

& +,(--(-(- +,(---

! "

% & ' " " () () *((+!,"""-

% " " " % " .(* *(/0 1!/23(45015-6 7 ' " (2 () *((+! ," % " '

' 8(((9-!

' " % " .(*01 , " '

' " % " *(/01 : ", " "

0 !" " " *+9.( (3 *(()!%/* (8 '

;-. 0% " "' %, ""-

- < :% : 1 ! " 7

" 7 => = $%, 1' ''>' " "

" => ?

%, "'

" !',#0! $!

"" %#0! (/ () *(()

" " ''>' % ''>' !"

" 0% !,", , ,1 %"

@ (* () *(()!;-*-:1 4"'

6"' " !1 '' %- A< , %B(!

,,' % '

<:%4""-

6!, ,

' " '!%- A "' ,%, $ ,% %- A , , ' 0 "%- A!

"'" !1, "'

;-2-0 "- , '"" ,", %"'

-:1 "

% A< !%"'

"' , ' , " */ (3 *(() !%- A< <:%4""-

6, " ," %- A% '% ""-

- < :% , ""'

% , %!" "' '

<:%4""-

6,%" ' " @ %' '%"'

-: 1 !?0=> 1,

$!;-20 "-

5!,"," " , ''=>

""" "=> A $! , " "%;-/30 "- @ /8 () ()!0 " , "'

, , 1, ! " ;-/*- ' '

''!""-

"'' @

! ,

@ ! "' => " "%" "' '% , " > 0 ""' !""-

" >' % $ ">=> C, !,", " ''=> C9/ $!

""-

"'% ' % %- ";-/-' ;-/*-

$'% , ""'

+./88-).//.

$'," " , ''=> :

@ " !

", ,1 %" !1 !" '% '%=> 9. " '

" '=>

, "' , "" ;-/.-1 ' ">"'

%;- /8 ' !, => $9/ &, '' "%"%, , '

$"> "", ? " " " A%! % ! >' $! "'

! " /).11' "!/+).451 5- 6, % 1C" ! ,"''"1

$""-

," "

% " .(* *(/01!(8 /* *(() ,"""-

0 % "! " >' ' , %% ""'

)

" " "! ""-

,>' " ./.1 !" ' "' " "' " '

$ ""-

" % ' "

$ ! " "%' " " ",>' , "

" " " " % " ! C !! " "

% " .(* *(/01' & ' " " () () *((+ , , " ' %'

7 ' " (2 () *((+

, & ' " " "!

% %

; " '">' ""

0 ' ! ! "!

" ""-

% '

" " ' "'

! " , ' " (3 (3 () ! ' % ' $! " "" " % " %

" "'

"' ,' , "", , "" */ (3 *(()!% " , " $ 0 @" & "

,' " ,""-

''%"" "! "

" " ""-

>&"" %;-)

& ! , >&""

" " ;-/- '

" " '% ""' "

" ' %% $!

""-

<:% " ",'%

+./88-).//.

" , ' ""-

"'''"- A<

" %% > ?A=> 9 $!" %> , "

" " "" %, % !""-

- < :% $!" ""-

" ","'' "' % , " "% 1

@ ! !

" " " % ""' " " % % "'""!," % "' ""' " $""-

,%" '

! ," "' ""' " '

$ !;-/-' !%'' ! "' '% +./88-).//. "" ""''" "

' %% '

" '

" ' ' 1'' ! &" "% % %% " %"' ""-

!'% , "

>% " "! & ", %,> " ' "" ",7%, " "",," ' 7 $" , "" $!" ' " "

"% 1

;" "

$" " % ""' " " ""'' "',%

$ " ,"" 5 "" % ""' "!," " % % " % !, " % %, - D/

$ " % % " , ""E$ % > % >" ""

$ ""' " % " "

$'%" ""'

% " " " , " " "" ' , '

%%"'% %""

0 " F ""' "!17 " %" "'

% " """

;" "'

, " " " ' ' " " %'

0 & " % ""! ""' " ", """ !' %" " "" "' E$""' "%'% " " " ,

""!,'

" " "" %'" .#/0$(- !!1(/ %$1!"

3#"!45/61 3#"!- # %40!33 2!

' )((

2#6#%37'74 82#$.%%0$(- !

9-:12!6! :2 $!$

23(

9 -.2;#2;.#".%;-2;0$(- !

.2$. 2

97))-

'( *(

;>' " , " ,

0 "! " , "' ""' " - /

"%"- A< '""-

%" " ""-

"'' "'

$" """-

<!2/

.!;!;= ;/

;!"!$!;- .%,3>- %:

6 .!.

:$!

.!"":$!;11!33% ( **

?'' ;-.- 0% !"' *+9.( (3 *(()!%/* (8 '

! " "' %, <:% : 1 ! $! %",

" 7 " => = 7

" !0 @""' : ! " 1 "; 8!, " " <:%4""-

6 ' % , ,

'A! &' "' ' % '!%" %" % $0 @" " ' 'A #! &' : 1 !

$%"%' <:%4""-

%!0 @"""'' % "" "' ", " , ',%,"

$ ""% %' :!' ' " , 9" " % " "7 $ " " " %, '"

0 !,' 0 @" 0 %

1 " >' " " " " " $ 5%

>1 "(:%#11%%; .!2$ <$(- !

6#3;:4

9-'*!> ,

, '

D$'% " " ,! %>' , %0@ , " % % "" $, ," %" % "7 0 '" " ' % " !

" " "' &" ' ,% ;% "

"' !"

," " ! % " >' " "" !"! , "% ,> % ," "%&"

$! &"" "' $" " " " %, % *B

$' % % 5%

>1 "-./63.

$.0$(- !

?!$ !%534

(( 2#6#%3**

5!$.-#%5.0$(.=!!2-#%5. 2$(

' )((( 2#6#%3*( *8

0 "!" ' " " ',% A< % " %

' ! "' "% 0% 4;-.6!,' %, <:%4""-

6 , 0

@" "! ' , % %, '

," ' 0 . ..

.( (3 *(()" !1," 7 => = ' " ' "!%, <:%

$ ""-

" ' => !

, " " ">% " " ' ! ">' 0 ' " ./. 1 ! ""-

" " " , "" 7 % '

$ ""-

",>" 7 $! ""' "!" %" "', % A< ,"% ""-

'" " ' ;-/8

' !," ''>' %"- A< '' => H!

, &, - /

$ ", F)"'>/ 8"' " !""' !%7 ," ."' ' !B 8"'' % ' +"'% @ " ,""' % ,

"* 8"'

$, ", ."'>/"'

" !/"'%,&, ."' '

@ " > " ' "! "!" , %

: % , " , ! " " 3 8 "' % ' '! " , %

" ! ,"% %!% " , '% , " : ,7 ' " ,"'

, "'

, %%

"',"'

A ,'

',"'

> @ , "'

'" " " /(( ""'

%" ' " '' "' A " "' A! , "'

: , '

@ "'

" ", &"% '' "'

" $ " " , "'" >' ' '%, & ,'' %, ''>' ,% , 0 ,% A< ' & , ""-

' $",% &"'%

, " , ,7 > $ % %"% , %% , " % ,!" " >" , , % '

% " " %"," ", , "" ,""

," " " !"

/(30 = " ""' % " > '""!% '

"' "" %'" -.6=: .0$(.!- !

@6!24 9'-((( 9994- !

?!$ !%530$(#2 .66; 624

)((( 2#6#%3 )*4 -.2#".%;0$(- !

.. #$52.4

2#(,( *74 # #%2620$(- !

2A.%;4

)2#(,((97)( *2

0 "">"

" " "!""-

"' , > ,% '" & "'% ! '

" /(3 0 = " " ', " $!"%' ""-

"' "9""' " % '

( =$"

%;%"!

.!"":$!; !2 .!"

66#$$# %

"2#6!( *+

0' ?0=> 1""-

,' ' ""' % % " /8 () *(() !,%" "'' "' '% $ 5%

>1 "=#%;2 8:623>2-#%5.0$(!1:=3#"

%;#4

(((

2#6#%3') , %" " "" "'' "% " " " 2 = " ","% " , " 0 "-./63.

$.0$(- !

?!$ !%53 -:12 5%

>1%"

" , "" $!%" """-

'% "" "' " " "' ""' " " ""' "

( !"

<!2#!$ 6 .!1 $$!$$# %

"":$!;( .(

""-

" ' => ," '' ;-B1 % !

;-/*- ;-/30 " 0 " "' !""-

- <:% ">!,", ''=> C9/

" "'% " ' '% +./88-).//.!,", ''=> :

$ "'% ""' ""-

=> %'' ;-/*- ;-/30 " '!" >'

"" ' %'' ;-B-1 % !

;-/*- ;-/30 "

$ % "

""-

" ",'% +./88-).//.

" % " ?'' ;-//1 :!

@"! "1'' " !A $,?

>! &!0 $ !1 !"' '% '%,;-/-' % " '

" '=> "'

" "=> 9/ %!;-/-' ''

" " :!

" , ", " %",'" :!" %"" > ," % % "" "" %'"8.:@@#3#$ -:2!%;2 #B2# 0$( - !

.;/ 2;!$. 99 (((

2#6#%3 7 $.B2-#%5.0$(- !

2/%

) (((

2#6#%3

;-/-' ' $ % ,4""-

1 "' *+ (3 *(() 2 (( + ((

, '% " " +./88-).//.

'% $

' "''%'$

% '' , '% +./88-).//.

?'$ %!7 '% $! " %" '% " '%

" ?'' ;-/- '!

" ,"" " "' @ ! ,"'$ % ,'%

:! ' ,'% +./88-).//.

7 '% ! ;-/",'% , ,% , "' $ %

7 '% '$ %

0!, , ,"'$ % *+ (3 *(()! ,"" "' $ % 0,;-/-'" " , ,'% ' $ % ?'' ;-/*- ;-/3-0 " !"''% % +./88- ).//.,"'

! " '" " , ,'%

;-/-', -

;-//-1 : "=> 9.

,", ",'''%

+./88-).//. *+ (3 *(()*/ B( /. */ 8( B8 /)B33B8/*8 $$ "4 6/)B3

5 . ...( (3 *(()!" !1 7 => =,", 38B/*8 '%" !1 $!"'""' "'

'% +./88-).//. " 1 % " " ' %, <:%: 1 ! 0 , ""-

, '

" $!"'% '-" +./88- ).//. ' ""-

" ""' "

"!""-

>' ""' $> , "%;-/8- '

" => $ , & " "% %,> ;-/8- '

=> $9/ &"% ''

" %"% , $! ;-/8- ' ! & " "% %,>"'""

%! ?

A=> !% " %" > :!""" "' => ,> ,

!%' % " > ! : "1 "@ 3!2>830$(.!- !

:%@=

((( 2#6#%3*+B , % "% , "" " " " : " 1 "@133#$@:%; .!2$0$(- !

2/%

'((( 2#6%3), - D$" % , 4=> -86 $" ' A ' 1 4;-/(6, "' 4=> -*36 & <&4

/6 0 ' !, "% " *3 (* *((( ,"& <& 4

/6 , 0 ' " ' 4=> -*36!% %& <&4

/6 " " 4=> -86%' "'' "' ' 0 "" ' 4=> -*36! 4=> -86," $ " 4=> -*)6, & <&4

/6 "! ," , % " "''4=> -*26 0 '?A 4=> -..6!

%, 4=> -86,%& < &4

/6 "' $ 1% " "" */ (* *(((%+ (( '!

, , "%""& <& *3 (* *(((!!,,""' % ' !" > '" " %, "' $ 17

= ,'%" % ! " " " ", ?A '"% " ' " " ! -" % >"'

" " , , " $!, " >% "'

""-

"" ' )( %;:"

.!"":$!;11!33% ( .3

$" """-

$%", !,", ' , 0 %%

' :!

% ' "

$! *+9.( (3 *(() ' "%% , " % '% ;-/- ' $"

..( (3 *(()!" 1 , ' , %' ,

0!""-

"'' "!, '" "

'% '% ' !' %" '"'' " $!" """ "'

""' " '

( #<!( .)

$" % "

, '"'' "%

" % " 0 " ' => ! % """-

" !7 $ ?A=> , "," ""!,"" ' ""%""-

"' " $0 @" $ => .",7 ," " ',"" " " " %, "" $!7 %, " ""-

, ' "'' "' ! 5% '1 " .:%# ;<<$(- !

#.2%;% .!24 99*-:12!6!

:2 7, ' "' " " " @ " ' ' ' ,"'

' " " 0 ,, " " >" %'"'' "" "

: " 1 " 3=#2-#%5.>!!20$( - !

:%@=4

((( 2#6#%3

% " ' % " ""' "" " "","' ' " " ?"' " -> " '! @@52 -#%5. 0$( - !

:%@=4

((( 2#6#%3 -((! 5% ' 1 , " ""' "'' " "%% " ', " " '

"," ' ' "" " '%', """ 0 " %%:- 0$(- !

#.24

((( 2#6#%37 ! 5% '1, - D; ' ,! , " ' % %%" " " "","'' "! " % % "% %% G .2

0 "(2$.B% .0$(- !

82% A4

-:12!6! :2 9 )! 5% '1 , - D0 ", ' ""%!

'" "" ""' " 0 " " "

" " ""' " "%

,! "% ""' ", ""' ""'

" "!" % % " '! ""' " " 7 " $% "'!,! "

" F ""' " ' " " " &" " $ % , % " ' """ %" " " .(*01 G

0 " ;/8:620$(- !

82% A4 -:12!6! :2 * 5% '1, ' ""' ","'' "% " % % " ""' ",% " 7 " % " , % ""' " B(

0 ," ,, "%!' % % "" " % " ' % " ""' " " "

! "7 " ,' "'

;-*-: 1 4"'

6! % "' %,' "(3 (3 *(() '(3 (3 *(() ;-*-:1 ,

1 $", $!'" "'

'" "(3 (3 *(() ' , " " " "

$! , " ! "' ""' " " % %

" % $"" ,

" , " " $!""' " ' %%% ' A < % "'' %

<:%

$! ," !, ' " "

"% 1 ",'

' ' %'

-(-(-

*3!*(/) ; 9 I9 ; % I9