Malkit Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
!" #$%$ &'' ()* +
,' -%' + + '''+ +
( .)('+
( +)
( +)/0)1
! "##$%##& ' (
## )* #)#+ ,- .$/ - 0"
"123(.2 # ! )6 **#
" '
" !0 #7 # #)) 0 8
'
" 99" 0
#:
)6 #))$ ! 0
"
";4 ! "
""
4 0 0
7 ):
#))& 4 <4 " " ' ! "" 0
)# )6 #))& 4
= "
'
!
" < " " 0 0 "
# )6 #))6 ! '32 #*77#))* '( " ! '
+) ):
#)#+ " >( >( 0 "( 0
$ )+ #)#+ 4'
6#> " ' !
0" >( ""4 0"
"
( 0 " 12 3(.2 ! " -
$ )+ #)#+ >(
+) ):
#)#+ 4'
. ?
$ )+ #)#+ @
! " "
"
#$ # %
&'
(& )()* #$
+,#-
#
.
#$ / &'
) #$ # %
&'
(* )()* /
-
3/ " / 3
"
5"
-/4 6)7'8)042
-795
- ##- 6)5 # #
?
+) ):
#)#+ && :9 02;
!
02;
&< 02;
!
&<
! 0 2
==
== >
&)
%
5"
-
6
"
? + '
## )* #)#+ 0 4 0 0 "4 "123(.2 45
0 '" "
0(
""4 !0 "0 4
0"" 0(0 " 0
"
A" $ #
"A" *+7 ,1A"5/ !0 "4 "
! 0 ""00A" $ #A" :
" 0 "
" ;4 ! " 0 " 0"" 8 "" "
80
0 ' 0
$ " 0
" & ! 0( 0 .
**##))$ 0 "
;4 ! ""4 " ""
4 ! 0"" " !
0"" 0 !'
+) ):
#)#+ " >( 5 >( 0 " @2 3(.2 45
( 0 !
+) ):
#)#+ 4 ' 0 4 ! "( >(
( 0 "( 1>( 5 !"4 '@
'@ !
"#
$%&' "
0 ""
"
4 !"
0 " 0"" "123(.2 * !'
+) ):
#)#+ ">( 5
+) ):
#)#+ >( "4 >(
" 12 3(.2 ! 0 0""
0" 0 ' !' ( -
( 0 ! 0
""0 4 0 >( -
( 0 " 4' 0""
>( ) ! '" 3 2 #*77 #) * ""4 4
( 0 ' 0" (
0 " "
"
4" .
B
4 4"
'32 #*77#) * "0. @ ivil writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying for the issuance of a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari quashing the impugned orders dated 25.08.2006 (Annexure P-9), whereby the petitioner has been imposed a very harsh punishment of dismissal from service and the impugned order dated 14.05.2007 (Annexure P-11); dated 02.03.2007 (Annexure P-13); dated 19.05.2008 (Annexure P-15); and dated 20.02./05.03.2009 (Annexure P-17) passed by the respondent police authorities dismissing the appeals/revisions filed by the petitioner before them by passing illegal and arbitrary orders without any application of mind and without considering the proper facts and circumstances of the case. And For issuance of a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to take back the petitioner in service and give him all benefits including all arrears of his salary and other allowances due to the petitioner.
And For issuance of such other writ, order or direction in favour of the petitioner, which this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case." B "
; 4"
0
""4 4
" ; 40 " ""
0 ""
40 "" "
4 4"
-'!#(")%* + ,% -%.) &#/ 0 +)&(&/ 01 +
"
0 0" "; "4 ;
( 0 ! " - "0
$ :
"
$
" $ "
7 "
7 "
4
"
" !
"
$ 7
"
7 " ! 7
"
7
- &&9 + &A<8
!
7 " $ 7
"
7
"
$ "
7 $
"
$ "
))' &*'
7 " "
"
7
7 "
$
7 " "
$ "
$
"
1
$
" "
9B9
"
" 9
; "0#2
C
D ; " 0#2
C
0&A8A2 ) - 6( : &A8A - E-2F*G
'
.
-
H #
D0)((82) - <** : 0)((82 &- 0 E-2 'F&G
7 "
$
. 5 D ; "0#2
C
0&A8A2
) - 6( : &A8A - 0 E-2 F*G D- H I
, 99 0&A6(2<- <<*:&A6&- 0 E-2&'G
$
7 " ? 34# ##()5 # !0 4'4
"
;4 ! " ""
4 0 ! 0"" 0 0 "
! 0 '
'0 4 ! 4' 0 4 0"" . A" $ #A" B
4" - "0. @
! " "
"
,
#$ # %
&'
(& )()* #$
+,# -
#
.
#$ / &'
) #$ # %
&'
(* )()* 01 /
-
3/ ; " / # 3
5"
- 6)7*) 4
&& (6 &AA) )< &) )((&
)F (6 )((' 0
/ 2 !
&'&*)9*A7- )F (6 )(('
*( (F )()* #$
,
#$
/ &'
) #$ # %
)) (A )()*01 /
-
3/; "/# 3
4
"
> "-/ 6)7*)042
? + B "
; 4 0 "4 !"
0 ! 4 4 " ; - 4' ! 0 4
4 4 !0 " "4 ! "0"40
"".
! -;0"
" "
"
" " 0 ""4"4
. "4"
" "4 "40 0
4 0( ! ;
"4 0( . 0
4 ; "" 0"
""
- 0"
"
400( !"
" "
4
' 4 4 0 0 (
'
"4 + ) #)#7 2( +)3 3 (% C%2 3
" C%2