Rajinder Singh v. Dhiraj Mattoo
! "#$ %& '(')*+ ,-
%./+012 &&+ 3+4 2+%.#%&& 5/&
!"#$% %$&
+&( #+#%2 +%*2%6+-/'%&-
+&25&&+ 77777 %$&'!
#8 ,9
+ &2 +% )&/ &2 %55'%&- :2'2 455+&/*;%%
/%&-/%; 8</%; 1&2+5&& '// #&%//5/
2 5+& + /+'&/ %1%& &2 +/+ /%&/
8
%/ <5%/*;&2 +&55%&4&2+&;%/&2
&&++-)+&%+-:2+*;&25&&+2%*+/+/&* '&/ +)&2/)/5+)
5/&9%/+/2+%.#%&&412&&2'& &2 5&&+9&%& +)25*%+1=2%%024)%+8 , >?39< ) 4;2:+/&2&5%&2 :11+4/(9 %$
+%'&;@ *$ ++%+ +&@
'$ //&%/%&+%&@%/ /$
&%/4% +24)%2%*&%& &:%%1/&2%&%5+&2+&&/%&/ < ,,A-:2'2 :%+/4'/&:+&1*&:&25%+&-&2+%& +& &225 /54&:% B/%C8 >95+)&2:&2'+% 8 >9% &++;
;%+ 2 5&&+ &2412 2%/ &%6 &2 /)/ 5+) + 4/+&%61&%+1:+6-*4&:&24&5+)&%+&//1*4 /2254&/&%1*1 8;%+/+1%+/&2 5+% '&;- & :% &%&/ &2%& &2 +5/&9%/+/ :% 5 25:2'2:%&4
'& +&254+5 +41 4& 0% *4- :2'2 +D4+ 5%' +
' + &2 :+- )5;- % :+625- 2:+) %/ % 5%' + 5%+61 &2 2'2%/+//'/%*4&&2&2+&:255
+%.%012%/*+&2+ &25&&+-%);-04+%.#%&&%/- &24-%&&)5&/&')5;:&2&2&%&4&+;5+ &2+&:2%&
4.%* +*% & &+'&'&- ,A, 25&&+55/&2'&5&&%/%
+)/&2%& 2:%4/+&%61&2&%+1:+62%1/%//&-%&+%& %/&2%1 &225:+)52%&'%;// 2 & &++- &2 *% &2 % +)&/ 5%/1- +%)/&2 :14(9 E
( ! " # $ 2 +5/&9%/+/ B%)/ F9 *226 #2+%-
F9 =4/5 012 04+- F9C 2& 45&% %/ 2) % F9A- :2+%&25&&+9&%&2) %55%+/% F9C%/%B%)/
F9 +/+012- F9%:/+012%/ F9A0:%+%.012 2 &&+++/+/&2.'&)&&21+4/
5+% '&; %/ %//& %/ %&+%& %55%- &2 +& 55%&4&2+&;++/&2 /1%//&%/%&+%& #+#%2 +%*2%6+-%+/'4%55%+1*2%
&25&&+9&%&-455+& &21+4/ +-4*)&&/&2%& &5%B 2:/25&*5/*;&25&&+*4&&2 &5%:412&&*5%'/+'+/*;:%; %//&%/'- /5'&/&2%&&2&&%5&5/*;&2%/+/-&2+%+4)*+
&2+25-)4'255%';1%'%& )+&-24*)&&/ &2%&&2:& &2%/+/%/)&&/:+25 4+25*;&2 %/+/- *4& &2 55%& 4&2+&; // & &%6 '1G%' &2 ''%)& &255%'&2&5%B
%)%*%/B FC>
+=2%+% >2:&2%+%)%4+1C6%%
)%+%%/ %/+/%/)&&/'+9B%)%&+1%+/1:+25 &2%/ :2'2/5'&/B4+ 2%&&& &24+&:%% /+%:&&2'+9B%)%& &2%/+/-:2'2+ '&/5/';
&2'&5+'/15/1%1%&%&2+&%&+%.%012 2% 2%+/ &2 %+/ '4 + &2 5&&+9&%&- %55+%/&25%5+*6%/ &2:&2%&&2+ +'%/)+& &24*) &2%+/'4- +-&2%/+/&2+&5&& /'/%*4&&2+&:25-5 +%.%012%/
) %&2+:&2*+&2+ &25&&+04+%.#%&&-&2+ +-&2+ ')5%' 5+ 0'& C!C$!%$!$!%$%/!*$ &2'&&/ &&2)4&2 &2&%&&*.'&&&2)%&%%*&; &2 5&&+1%+/19')5%'2&%&'%&&&&2*% // &2 %/+/ 4& %/ 4 & %'&4%&/ 4& )%' 5& B&'+9B%)%&+%;&2+/'4)&%+;/'5%'/ +'+/&/;&2.'&)&%''4& 5+%'&;2'4+& *:2%&&&2%+)'2%+ &2%/+/%/B%)&2.'&)& 5&&'45/:&2/'*+412&+'+/&2+:+/-&2&%& '%& /'&%&&2&+)&&2%/+/:2/ /1&2.'&)& 5&& //&%/'412&&*5%'/+'+/%:4/ &25&2&%&/
+1:&2&2''4++& /1 %'&+/+1 '& 5+% '&; '//;- &2 /)/ 5+) &4%&/&2 %/--'))+'%%+%025*1 8;%+/ '%&*%1+4/ +94&1&2.'&)&%)%*%/B
%/
FC>+ '&/&2:+25 +/&%5+)&2%)'&;
+&2+%)&/%*-/& /%;1%&;+ 5++&;&2''4++& /1-:2'2%+*%/%55+'%&
+%%//'4)&%+;/'2+5&&&%//)/ D4&;-%55'%& +%//&%/'%/)/ *+,-./' %$& .0,1 !"*2 &131.405 67.0 8 97
&131.4 .30- 97