High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/375/2010dismissed

Bakhshish Singh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab

2022-09-05Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat14 pages

!"#$ !"!%"& !"#'

(# )*( + +

+, -

)*( + ++-, !"# $ %&'() *+%'*,'- /

$ % /'( (&!

+, -

/''

(%'/ / )'* 2 34 5336(

* ,

7 . 13

* (' * .*/ 2 '(!

//**(.

..* '/!*'

835(839(2'/*'

8: / ,( /* % )'* . * )'*'

(

( / * )'*

$ )(/ / *' 2 3;

5336( /' * *( * %<//'. =**+-

/* )'*

/0 !123 &!"4&2 + &24!"

+ "2 "&

</'/' / 835, '. '% ' % ".' 8333>?

'. "% ..' ./

'<%&'' / 835>8:, '. '% ' % ".' 8333>?

'. "% ..' ./

'<%&'' / 839,

" ".' 8333>?' . . "% . .'

</'/' / 839>8:,

" ".' 8333>?' . . "% . .'

/ * )'* !* % ') . % / )'* )'*'

+ -(( !* % '). %/* @' /2'/*+-+ -(!*%'%

/%!"/ , )'*' , ((/)*/ '/%(/ / /'A* '' /'

/', * -

/ *'

(

2/'*/=/'!'B?>5'' /'.

%& ' / . 2' ' / / % '

/' /( 5337(2// 2'//' ./'' /2 '' '/'/ (/!

6 83$(/'*<//'/ ' /((/' '<%&'' /*%'. .// ((/"

!"<' /% ./' ./'' /(!' /'%(

2/'*/ /' ./ ' ' /( ( /' ./ 2'' /(!'/'.

%* % .//

/"*% . // (<//'/ ' / )<'. '&' /' ./'' / .' ./*/( !

%(( /'!*<'(('<%&'' / .<//'/

' /' ./)' /' ')<'.'&' ! 2/.*

)+%-(( /.' ./ !

% ./'.

%(2'/''

<'/% /'' /'./ * % ./!

% /'.

** ... %/*'%'(( '*'A$ '( $ 'A /'.2". %/

2'//' *') 2

/ % ') . / ) ( ' /( <//'/ ' / ' /!'''<' ((/' ./

/'%. %* %' '@ ((<//'/' / .!/' ./' <* ''

/'.

% %'/'./2' ' /(( ./'' /(' '(%'.

/' *')% 5+

+ :

/!' ..

'% ./* '( **'

85:(839,2 ' /.(' ' /**%! /''&'(*/(*'

835 ./, 2 /')' '

2 ((/** 2

. * '

. ')' '

!" / ')' '

..'** *(' / + -(/''..'%')

198, , (!.

/, %%' *( '!

//**

((*

+ ;

'' / ..**'

835(839, ! =*')"'!!"/, .'

(/* %%'' , )' 59 5337(* %%'/* /,

6 /'

(%' *

.'' '%.*'*(*/ *'

835( 8392'/*'

8: ./,!*%.%( '!

// **( 2/'*//" '"((*'%'

. / *'

*( / *'

=%' '= 2' . * '

. * ' . /

. / *'

2'( / ''

* *(2 *' (*'

818 ./ , , ( ! /'( / ** *'% . '% '*'

( (

' **

.* *'

./'((

+ -(!"/''

(%'(/

* %</.

)'* .* )'*'

(( %/ @/2'/*+ -(

+ (++ + *

**+

/* .

/ ')* )'*?

/'(/)'

" !.

/', (//'% )'* .* )'*'

(* @/2'/*+ -( '%

(

/* )'*?

/!* %'2'/ '.'%'" . %'

*''

( ?

*''

. / )'*(='' * /.

(// //

! ** ( ( / )'*( */ !. /' , ( ! @/('

+ (++ + * +

/ //(/* /

/', (//& %(*/ !.

/', (' 2%'( 2"'.*

+ +( + ,+++,.,/" ,

)' /*/ + -2 '/* )'*( / *'

%'*

*2' / ***(2/ *')"

' /2'!

=( B?1(B?5(B?4 $ )(/'&)'*'%+ -('/' =%''

?'?*/'.(/ %*/ ' (/ /.."( 2// 2'//'./'' /(/' & ' / 2'' '/'/ ((<' 2'/*/ /(/<//'/ ' /((/' '<%&'' /(*% '// (( <//'/' //' ! /'./( 2/'*//'./ '' /!*% * % .// (( B?1( !'/' & ' /(!*% * % .// ( (/<//'/' /('*/ ( ')<'.! 2 /. ' ./*/!

%((!*<' ./'./'' /

B?12'' /' /'&)'*'%((/'.''/' =%''

?'?*/'.(/* ?* )'*'<%&'' /')' <'. ! 2 /./(!

%( /'*/(2/'*/'/ % *+- ./'!

%')' / // .B?1( & ' /(' '*'/'=%''

?'?*/'.( ! )'!/*'%'! ** ../'

/(/'.'/.* %%''

./!

) *'%'*'+-(/**.2". %/' ***

/./ .B1('' /' **%!'/ '

7 /'&'')(

/' !"* ?* )'*<//'/' /( 2/(' * ./'*')' %@/'&'.. !"/'%('@ /%(

/' (!"* ?* )'* '<%&'' /(/

!*%/ ''C 2 '%'/, ' ' /'=%''

?'?*/'.( // )/' )'

%* '2'' B?1

../ .=*' * =%''

(("' /* / .(/.** .' '*'. %/'%("

*/ ' @ /

+- + -( ( * ' ' /' =%''

?'?*/'. / !' '( .( ( * ')

(**' !' /

.B?1

'*B?1'/'=%''

?'?*/'.(/

/ /*'%' 2'//'% &'((/' & ' / 2 )'!( ( 2/ !

/ / !

)(

/' *')"' ' /2'!

=B?5((B?4(/)' /' *')" =%''

?'?*/'.( * "

+-+ -(%!"B?1 "

2/// /* !

('% /

./ '&)'*'%(*/(**(' !' /

A / *2' / *** /./ %' ' ' ** /

./ *2' /

***(!* %

)'/.*%(/*/ ./2' /)

2'/% * '*"(( !. ."'( ( "!%'/ .*/ "'% )' ( (%!'/'

/' *')"% )'

%'2'' /(/2/ /"

!. ."'?( ('?* '*'

(

" /' , !* % * " * )'*( / % )''" *'" ' ! ' /' *')" % '.'*'

( *5 / / '%*" ' ! ' *'! * ** !"/ *'

2'(/*'

./ ' ./ *'

2'(!"!. !

/ ' @' !%!"%'*)'*

)('' /**%! .'&'+ -( !*%'

/' !"<//'/' /(/ //' ')' <'.! 2( /.' ./*/!

%(( /'!*<' /*'' /'''"!*%% % !" B?:

B?: / ' /' =%''

?'?*/'. % )'

/'%<' %'*=%''

( .' ' /(/' !)'

/'!

"(//'.=*'&' D1 *' 2 . / 8 '*/ ' / *')"!'

*'2 . 2*/=' /

% /%'(8'*/' /

'*'2 (''*/' /( /' / +!*<-(!' ."

B?:'/'=%''

?'?*/'.(/ *'.'*"*/ / / * . / . / * ' ' /( '

!!''" . % %') !' **' . %/ !

) .2

/( ' /' =%''

?'?*/'.( / % */ ' (/

/'%<' *'*'=%''

+- ./'&'

**' /!

" .'&)'*'%2'' /(/'%<' /

$ /'.=* !)'

D1 ;'*/'*'2 /./ %

:'*/'*'2 .'.

8'*/'*'2 ..

%( '

5'*/'*'2 .!

5'*/'*' .' .*/'%' *

;

: '*/ '*' 2 2'/ .* . '!

' 2 4 ;*%! 2/'&"

;

$ )(' /* ./'=%''

?'?*/'.( //%*'*'

(//!

)=*'&'2 *! / / . / 2

A / *')

./!

' ./!

) /.

(/!

)=*'&'(!* % ) ! **' / *')!

' ./ A=%'(

.'*/' " " )/ *)'

(! *'" ) /A/ ./'*'%' "2

..*!"/ )'*

$ )(B?11/ )/$F 22'/ * '&)'*'%2'' /(( 2/'*/=/'!' ' ' (('/'=%''

?'?*/'.(// */ (//'

!)' ( /!

" .2'' /(//'.=* '&'

D1 '='*/'*/2 )/ % .. /=' . %/ * ..'=.' % ./

'*/ '*/ 2 ) / . ' % ' / 2 1>8 =' / '

/'*/'*/2 )/..

% ) /

*!' 6*%. %/2'& '

2 '*/'*/2 )/. *

* 2 '*/'*/2 )/. *

./*/'/

;

'*/'*/2 :*%

' '&"

'='*/'*/2 )/.''*.

19 *%'*/ 2 )/ * . 2 !

% $'

!' .'/! 2'* '

) /!*< .*/ $ )( / % * %%'*'

' /' =%''

?'?*/'.(/'&'

1(5(8(:42'% 2/('&"

;2 '.((2*!" / 2

( /)

./!

"(!'(/ / *(/)'&"

92 '.(( /'2*!/ /A ./ 2

( / )

./!

" ./)'*'% +

(( *5

' ./!

)

(%!"B?:(( B?4( .

%'!

/', (/'/ *'' /../'%''* @* / '*'2 (!* %=*!

)(( /', !* %.

%'!"* )'*( * *//"2*! / (/ / ./ 2

+- / *')

./!

" ./* "(/!

)

!"B?:(' * ./* .%' .* '' /(%* *'

(/// /*'! * ** !"B?4/**@'/*. '.'*'

$ )('*!

)2'/!

/B?:((B?

11( )' /'% .'% (2( ') '&'( / . '& )'*'% 2' ' /( ( 2'/ !

)' (//'% / (2/ / ./ 2

(*/(2/ % ./'&'*!"B?

4 ! '.(/.

(/!

) '&'( !*%'!"'&)'*'%2'' /(/ !* % /*'%)2/'*/ **/*'%'((2/'*/ /!

2'/% * '*"!"/ *2' + -( /*'%) +(

(

% %

(=/'!'(!*%2' * . / * *'( ' @ % % '&'( !* %' .

" ./*('&'2/ . %'2'//'&'(!*%'.'!"B?:()' ' ' !/'*<( 2/'*/=/'!','' =/'!'

*'/'

(2/'*/!* %=*/'.(@ /'A!* %' /* .%' ./* ' '.'*"( 2//% %'&'+ -

(2'/% '? !

!"B+ -( !* %*!"/* )'*A(( 2'/ /' *') '.'*'

%*/' / /'. =*

'' /'!* %' @!"/ 2

+- "/ *'

/ )/( / 2

(!"/* )'*+-* *( /!

" ./ * $ )(!

//* )'*A*@/!

)%' *'' /(/ '*'

.& ''!''"((*'' *'

8: ./,

8&' .% % ' '*!"/

(* ./'/'* '/% / / *< .'&"

52/'*/' ..'*'' '"* . */ E + +

+(+

5 (( 9+:

' /* .')' '

!' %' /

..*!"/')' ' ..'** *(/* / ' '* % . * ?* )'* <//'/ ' /(

2/'*/ =/'!' ' ' (( * / ' '* % .* ?* )'*'<%&'' /( 2/'*/=/'!' ' ' ' . /' *')" % '* %( )( / " !

/ * .' /'

'*'

('/*'%)(! )/'A)'*' /' ' ** )' ./)'*'%' "'%( / ')' ' ..'** *(( )(/ /* )"

%% +- *')"* ''=/'!'

(('=/'!'FF( @ /' *')"*' / ) * )'( / ')' ' ..'** * /!

)2'* % 2/!* %' !"*/ ./* ?* )'*(( 2/ /" / %<' .

' * )' /' *') '*( / ')' ' ..'* * * * @*( *'"' !% /!

)2 %% +- / / / ' ' .*'"/ 2 !* %2 "(2//"/ !"'(/='* ./' *')' / (

( / ..'**'

" ) / / ) * )'( 2 '( (* ')/ /*) %!' "!"

/')' ' ..'** *(!"' ./

.B* *( )(//!

)

'!=* "

(/*.

' /)''"2 / ./!

)2 %% +-(!* %' ..'**'

" )

@(!

//!

)2%% +-*@'*'

)'"2 / "/" * !

)*'!

*** @/ *'

*(( * !

/%'*** ' */

A ..*(!*%* )/ // * )" %% * ' ' =/'!'

( ( =/'!' FF( (

*' 2/2'/( / ' '* %A . / )'*A22((!* % *')"%!

''=/'!' ( ( ' =/'!' ( ' !* % !@" / '2 <' /F* *(.

/'%<'

2///!

'A*' /)'%(/! ' /!

./*(( /!

./ '&

./F(

2/ .!* % =* /'.(( 2/'*/ =/'!' '' ( .

(// '2 <' /( %<' =%''

'A*' /)2

A ..*(/' =/'!'. %%<' ..'%')

/ (@ /'A .!

('."(*'/ ! ' /!

./*( ( /!

./)'*'%?'&( (/ "

'//)'*'%' "'% '2'//%!

, @"(/'

!"/ F * *(

'' / !

'A *' / 2

A* *(/ ! ' /!

./ *( ( /!

./'&

D/=/'!'* ''/ *(, '2'//%!

/(/!

)'* *')'"

( ".

"* *'

. %/', (//* )'*A) .'' .*@'!* %' * /!

)'.*!* %

)'/'.*%(/'' "'!! .( / ./')' ' ..'** *( /%<'

''?%*/' '?/!

'A(*' /'*'%' "2

A ..*(2'//!

./ *'' /( (2'//!

./'&?

2'' / / !' /(/.' * *. %/ .%'"%%! ./*( (. %/.%'"%%! /'&(/' *')$,()' /'/!

./*( ( ./'& "('./!

)/ ! ((2/. )" / '* *(

@/'!* %' !".*'' %</!'? ' +-( ('?%*/' (( "'.// ' *(/

'//'*< .* '?%*/' ( //)'* .*@'2%! !* %* !"

/', ( /2'

'"( '* / $ , '*' / !

./*( ( ./'&()!*%* *!"

/')' ' ..'** *(/. %/.%'"%%! /*( (. %/.%'"%%! ./'&((

2/'' !* % /F* *( 2'// / ) '*'%' " '% /.

( / ' * *( !*% ! %< / !

' '? %*/'

6 , @"( "'* *')'"

' * ./!

'A*'/ (! ' /!

./*( ( /!

./'&( ("/' , 2)'* .*@'@/* )'*A

* @*(/' %''/

(('' '%' / '% )'*+-( ( * @ /2'/ *+-+ -..'%%''

"('."(!2'/'** *2'/ 2./= '" '

.'%''

/.'' .

/* !.

/2'/ 2 9+

+, -

9++-,:

' <)' / ,3

;

/<4"=>

/ !"

2/?@