← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1716/2004allowed

Surender v. Hy.State

2025-09-17Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti13 pages

          

 

 !"

#$ %$

 ! &!' !" $ ($

& )!

)!*+ 

 ,-, .

- /-!-



0" 1 2 0$  0  

   

      

   ! " 

  

Ms. Aditi Girdhar, AAG, Haryana.   

$  

#   %

$  



&&&&& 0 3 $  

'

     # #        (

   )

 # 

  *+,-*,,.   /0     1 2      $  / 2+#*,,. *,*,,.  3

 4 562+7+ *-*,,+ 

+,8#6  $ -8, 9#  

 :6$;<     

    =

  



  

* -4 .

 !

)', ..!' 5

!,!'   +,8#6$ !      

 #     #  0   0  #  # ₹,,,'    #   0

##  #

    

  # 

 *  #

#  *-*,,+6  $    6

      $ 0   

    /  ,7+,     



   /0  (/  > 6 # # 

      

    6   

  /

  

       

 ?  

@

=    0 (/   

 0 AAB  >   "

   

/ =   "   $ / =   >  *7*,,+ @/  

      

  (/     /      0 / /0 /     " ?

   

   /    #      >  C

 )

  

  (/       /   

          

/ #   #  (/    #   #  

#9 

<   

/   

 # $ 



      (/   #

 "

 # /0

0    /    

0 6 

 0# "  

    

+ +   

    )     

 /0#

 /(



  # #

 



  

 #

    

 8 $ $ #

 #

 

    

+,8#6$

 5  

   

 7+ $ $    /

/#  6 )  

 . >  



      0 #

  

      

 *,7 # $ $ 

 ##

  / 

+,8#6$ D  0

 //0 $

  #    1    

 6  $   

 $

#  12 #

 



 ,8,*,,. B ?    1 2  #   

  *7,*,,. #    

    

 +,8 # 6$     D              

  

      #  #  ##

 

 .A-'+,* 6$    

   

 +,8 6$ =       # = $

   B,7*,,.    $    2+*8#*,,.   # # 

 ) 

#

  

+,86$ 0 8    #

 #     D   

 >## $=$   E6?D

E* (  E+ (      E.

. =$  /   EB 6   E8 @/    E7      E- =$ @(   EA  6   $  E,!  #  /   # 

    

,-,.*,,. >

#    

#

 E 

 E.  (    E8 6  E7 @/   E, 6   $  #  #

D 

7 

      

 ++ $ $/0

 $

 " 

 #      "= # 0

     =#  

 B, #  #     

#  #   = #    /  

  

   

    

 #  

 - #



D  



 6

6!6   E (

$ "  E* F=$ (  E+ A #  

 

/0 /    

  



 0  

 

+,8#6$  (

 )

#

 *+,-*,,.

 /    /0     1 2  5   # (

 )

#



'

 #

  

B , ?  #  

   (

 )

#

 *+,-*,,.   /0     1 2        #



!

 

      

 #   # 

0 

  #

"  (/   

 / ,-0   !0     

0  )

 

     0 "  #  

# #

0 

 0   "  ,            # 6

E8@/  

E7   

E- 

     

D 

 #  

  0

 /#  6  

  

 

   #  0 /0

 

 

 @/  E7  0/ "/0 

!

# 

 /

     E-  

 6       #  

   /   ,*  ? 

 



 #  0  

 

   # (/   



 #2    #

6 E8 

   

D 

 

  /   /0

 /            +,,,,'  

 # /0 

! )   # 



8 

   0    

 ! #

        0# (

$ "D   E* 

#  



#

/ 

2 =+BA-.,6  #



D 

 



0

 ( /2 @ "$

 2  ,+  !   

  

 0

    # ##

 !    

 

  

 

 /  0# /

 

  

#  #           ##  

  1

)

#

 *+,-*,,. /0

 $

    #  ! #    

 /0 

'

  0" 0/

 0/ )

#       >    



#=

  #

 #    

   0   

      # 

 +,8 # 6$ 6

   

 /D  E8 >  /  # 

   *-*,,+  ,  9FD5< 

 56  FDC6

 0

     

/0 /   / 

   # 0# 

@/ 



      # 

  *7*,,+

   /   )       # 0 /  >     0 

7

 /  

 # 

 6  

 

  0 # 6  E8  #0 

 /0 @/  E7    E-

 >## E    

 

 # 

   FD 

)  # 

 

  FD@ 6 )     9FD$<  /0 

F



 

 /0 6   $  /0 E,  # #

 " /0  (       D    E+    FD*  FD,    FD  FDA       # 

  FD=        9FD< #   #

    /0  (      $  $

     E. >   # 

 

   

 /06?D

E*? 



# = 





 

          

 0     /0

6 E8  # 0/ D  

     

  



 

 /0  ! # (

 )

#

 *+,-*,,. /0

 $



) 0

#

 * 6  

 

/# /0



 

'

 



# =  

  

  $

  / 

 56   

#6 # #

G

-

" *7*,,+

 

 / #   (/  !

#

  

   

  $ /  =   

  (/    

 6  



 0 AAB>   " 0 



   F  ,70 # 0   ,B0 #  0    ,+0 #  # 

 $     C

 )

       ?     

0      # 

   #  (/   /0  # #  "#  # 

  /

# ##

  / 

+,8#6$#  /

  # /0 # (/    #  @/  

 

 # 

*7*,,+   (/    

  

/   /0 / 

)    # 0/     @/      /  # 

  #

0  

/  + ! 

#

 #

##

  / 

+,8#6$

+,8#6$     $ 7,4!, .

&)')" 6# 0     

  /  #   / 

  

 #   

  #     0 D 0    / / # 4

A /

#  

,7#6$     3 $ 7,4!, .

- ,+)!*   /  #  

  6   0   H

F         



0 #    #  #

    "      

 # 

0    # H  6

0  /0

     #   I  /0 #

 /0 #

 

#   #

/   

0   

     /      #

  IE    #



     # 



/0 # 

 

#     #

4 !   

  #

/ 

(

#&8 4  & , .

!)-  )4)!-9 88-9  $ ## .

: ) )!* &, .

2: 9$;

 $ (# .

;3 ') !

 $ $

 3-/8 )!+  - )!

)!+ +- - < 

$ =

&

,-, .

&>- -,4 

#:;

: )4)!-9;

( "

2-?

)!

 '

@  %   2-    3   



   !"  # $

%   &    



  '

  $

  

   %

   $ 

  (    '

 " % 

"           

  &   %

&

,      

  '   ' 

      

 %  

      

  )  * #     '

   '

      ' %   '

    +   '  %        

%  , 

 "      - '

  

% & %

'

     #        "   &   

    % 

    

 )   %

     ./ ! / #(

      

/   

 ##

 

+,86$ /

    

 



      # 

 .       #   

'

 

+,86$  D  6

 E8@/  9 

< E7     9

<  E- #  

 

 /  





  #   0  

  

 ? 

D 

# #  

 0

 

 /#   



  0 

  /0 #  

 0    # 0   

    0 #  /0

 @/      

"  (/   0 

    

     



 " 

     #     #   #

  

   

    

 B ##

# /

 

  /    

    /       ##



 

    #   ! #    /  

    

 #    !

/ 0

 

  /

>

" # #   

 # 0      

  

 !    ! #        

 #



 #    /       

  "   /  ,- 0   !0   # 0!    /

    

   /# 

 0 2

      

/# 0$



 #

D   ( E+

/         



'

 

    #  



  # 2      # 

   8*,,+ 6     

 D 

# 6

E8 

  0

# 0#  / -, 0   

  0#  0

  6   #

#  

   / 

#    #   2   6 

 E8         +,,,,' # 

   

 5

   

'

 

*

     # 0 #     "

 

  

 #      

  #     2    ? 

 

 0

  0 #  ( 

 $ " E*   

 #

/ 

2=+BA-., # 

! 

 0

/ "/ #

 

 

   0  

 8 2/    #

 

E     

 

 # 

 FD 







/

 " " 



 "

 0   # "  

 /

0 

   /  #* J* 

 

/  

 / 0 

  6  /

 D  ( / /0  #  3 0D   /0  



 

## 

  ##4!  



  "# ( 0  

   / 0 "  # 0  

   

 #! #     

 / /



# 

  

/0

 7 $   #   #

      0       #   /      # 

    #

+,8#6$/0   #   / / ! # (

 )

#

+ *+,-*,,. /0  12 

0       

 /0 

 

   

0   )

# #    /0  / # #/ -      

9< # 0 

9<  #

0 :0 ;

 $ ($

#   E  " '

   K'2 E 

/  K'2