Rakesh Chander Goel And ORS v. Atul Kumar

 



   
  

  !"# $%&  



  
     ! " #"$"% & '()* +,%'-./ (012(

 '

() *+ #!, '

  $"% (

*#!*  '

( %& # *#!* &

(012(3

 

*, ./ .0 ./ 10"2%3. !.%* .%&"2 &

 !

%     2 %

4 & /% 5     #!"  ,    

     

136 %/

13,&       7"    3  ,  7   

4  -

& " &./,/ &

2 % 9

4 & ! 2 3    "

2     &/       "*     & 1 

 .  ,& 9

- !22 !  &&"

2 &/ &&*" !% % !,&/

 :

"%

%

4"&/%* 22 37" !"

  &./ 
"

<, .<- &/% .%, ,

  % * , " .% !.%- &&&  4

 %., -

7"2 3

- %  3, 

13, .0%2 3  ".2 ./%2   .2 !./ %& %, ,% 2 %- .0 !2.%./  
"

.,*  .%&"2 &  = ".% ". 2 %,7" / 

13 ,&./   "

 % , 

5,! * * !  && , % ,-

2 %

   ,&/   :

"%, 



%

4"&/% 22 7" !"

  &./ "

<, .<- %".2&./

&1&

22  .%   , /.2 

 ! %" .% 3?  %".2 !./ 3! / , .% .", !,! %& "/* &%2/


13  3  = "

".% 3"2 .2 ./

! &    7./ 
 *, & %. !, 0"2% 5<. +"& %
"




    

 +

 ?, "

".%  ! 7"&& ./ &* % .  &/., 
 *4*

13  

13"2  

  ?, 2"./  !, %%./

.

#&&
"

 , &&,& * / ,. 

<, .< -  . % 3 /&" 3 %2    %/    &"        2  ?  ,  "

".%  +  +%&#*  /& % 7" 3 . &    8 @  *

".%  2 %,7" 

13* 3.7"  %"- %"&/.% / & 

5* % .% 3? 3&!"  7   ./ 
 *.%&"" + 9# +%&# .& %  2 ! %#

%2  , *<, .< 3  * &".%  

!/.0 %A   ./  2 2+  +%&#*  &".% % && / /.2," % 22 , 9 5  & " &&

.  "&"      2 %

4 & /,5 #!",

 

136 %/

13,&- 3, .7" .

4- "2  2 2  , & /"2 ."

% 2 %* ,! *

 % !",  &./,/ &

2 %./

 9

"

2 &/ *

,

  &  ./     & 3! *  *     %  ,     

9

!&   7 .,3 B?       "  &

   &./,/ &

2 %>"& / ./ &

 &  &-     7"  !"

 &

, 

,%

%   !2 .       -         "

 7"  5%/   #!"& / & 2 % "&./ &



4      !  2 /

! & "& /* 2,

&

2 7"

"2 &  ,-   .  ,C ?   *

, 2 3 , &  ,% )" , 22 !&

&&2 0"2%   "

8

?,"2 . 2"./  .0,% /2%* &,  /, ) %/* 2

2 ,

%%. #&&
"

   /,2&/ .  :

"%

%

4"&/% 22 7" 

!"

  &./ "

<,  .<, &  ,% - % "

7 .,3 B+ #&&,2&/ .  :

;

&, 

4"&/% 22 7" !"

   &./ "

, .5

 "  % &/%, ,% 

%/* 2, " .%

!  .  %*     &&  %/  .    2/C

@ %/*&  /%% . #&&
"

2 2 % %./" !& /  &&  % - % & 3 7 .,3 B? !   % 
" #&&?2  %%./ "

    #&&  -   &&  %/  .    2/C

?, .  %., &            =,  #&& 
"

       &&  

4

- 22 8

"

&3! / /,22 3 7" %& %

!.

#&& 
"

  ?    2   *    

 7"    9

 &/  %2        .   "2 ,".
 *4*

13- ,"%  
 *

13"2


13&      %/  ?        3  7  ,     7" &&* ,%


136! , *<, .<, % ,

 /.2- * .0  %".2 ! /

%

!., ,
 *

13* %  !.% 3, , 2/ 2 - .0, %

? %   ./  7  3.2  %

!., . #&&
"

*    %"  .2  &  "2           . % , , 2/2 

8 2 %

4* ,  ,


13- 3,.7"

.

46! " ./

& ./,/ &

2 %,  2 7" 3 2 %

4 &/%    .       ?  ,     !*  ,    22 ! &&2 %*, "/ 7" &/% .  5 % 2 . #&&
"

, ,&/  :

"%, 



%

4"&/%- , "&, ,2  &/%

.       5    "     &/        !2& ,   %&  ,  *" , & &  %"" ., & /-  %".2 !./ ! 3 ," /

&2/.2 &./ & "%"

,%/ 

+". .- %".2&./ ! ! "2   .%   3 ! ""

% 2/

 6! " 2!+  +%& #, % 22& /*   %"  2 ., % 22 3!  !&"% 22%/   /" 

#  2 2%2

, *<, .< * &

 / %,. &  3* * , &2 %*  .2! %

 ?!, %/ "* %&"2 & ./ 
"

.,- 3 ,.2

./%2  *

9 .2&./ ! ! ./2 , *< , .<*" ./ &

8 ! &  2/



 0 ) ! D"2  &