High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/153/2019dismissed

The Commissioner Of Income Tax ( Exemption), Chandigarh v. M/S Shree Durga Mata Mandir, Village-Pipliwala Town , Chandigarh

2020-03-02Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan6 pages

!"# $$ % &'( ) #&&

* ! " # ! "$" %&'&()

% &(&'*+,-."&(/%"),(0/(12('&- %)*& ,33&--,() +(,-,."- *&%&4&(2&/'/(,33&,-2(0&%"&5)/( )*&(57&,8 5).69 %'*%). )*&5) :,1,/('))*&%0&%0,)&0;

<3,''&0=+ )*&(57&,833&--,)&%/=2(,-.*,(0/1,%*9 %'*%). )*&%/=2(,- :

5-,/7/(1 -->/(1'2='),()/,-?2&')/(' -,> @9/: #*&)*&%()*& )*&5,'&)*& /'5%%&5)/(0/%&5)/(1)*&%&1/')%,)/()=&,55%0&0 /(')&,0 %&4&%)/(1/)=,5A %%&B&8,7/(,)/(/()*&-/1*) C201&7&() )*& ( =-& --,*,=,0 /1* 2%) /( ,33&,-

/()*&5,'& . &&%2)$' D'

%2'). &&%2).>*&%&/(/)>,'*&-0)*,))*&%/=2(,- 52-0 *,4& %0&%&0 % '&))/(1 ,'/0& )*& %0&%

&1/')&%/(12)*%/)+%& 2'/(1%&1/')%,)/(=2)/)52-0() *,4&0/%&5)&0 %%&1/')%,)/(')%,/1*),>,+/(,'725*,'

)*&%&*,')=&',)/'

,5)/(%&5%0&0=+)*&&1/')&%/(1 2)*%/)+>*/5*>,'-,5A/(1E 9//: #*&)*&%()*& )*&5,'&0,(0/( -,>.)*&( =-&/'5%%&5)/(/1(%/(1)*& ,5))*,) )*&,''&''&&'5/&)+*,0'21*)%&1/')%,)/(2D' , )&%

F+&,%' /)'3&%,)/(>*&%&,'(51&()%&,'( %)*& ,33-/5,)/(()*,4/(1=&&(7,0& %)*&-,') F+&,%'>,'

'2=7/))&0))*/'

/5&E 9///:#*&)*&%()*& )*&5,'&.)*& %0&% )*&( =-&/'5%%&5)/(*-0/(1)*,))*& 9: *,' () 7,0& ,(+ '3&5/ /5 /(0/(1 % )*& ='&%4,)/(/(*/'%0&%)*,))*&,''&''&&'5/&)+/'() >%A/(1)>,%0',5*/&4/(1/)',/7',(0=C&5)/4&'>*&%&,' /()*&9: '%0&%.)*&%&,%&5-&,%-+ /(0/(1')*,)7')

)*&=C&5)''&&7/(1-+,%&1&(&%/5/((,)2%&,(00( )1&) 54&%&0 =+ )*& 4,%/2' -/7=' 5*,%/),=-& 32%3'&'

&(4/',1&0/('&5)/( 9 : )*&5)E 9/4: #*&)*&% ()*& )*&5,'&.)*& ( =-& /' 5%%&5) /( 7&%&-+ *-0/(1 )*,) )*& 0/''-2)/( 5-,2'& *,' =&&( ,00&0 ,(0 0/'%&1,%0/(1 )*& 4/&> )*& 9: )*,) () (-+ )*& ',7& *,' =&&( /(5%3%,)&0, )&%)*&,33-/5,)/(>,'7,0&=2),-')*& %&'-2)/( *,' () =&&( ,55&3)&0 ,(0 %&1/')&%&0 =+ )*&

/5& &1/')%,% /%7',(0"5/&)/&',',3,%) %&1/')&%&00527&()2(0&%)*&&1/')%,)/(5)<6 &%& 3,''/(1 ,%&'-2)/())*&&

&5)0&'( )7,A&)*&3,3&%

-&1,--+ )&(,=-& ,(0 ,07/''/=-& /( 3%5&&0/(1' )*,) &8)&().)*& )*&'5/&)+/'/73/(1&0=+,-,5A

0/''-2)/(5-,2'&E 94: #*&)*&%()*& )*&5,'&.)*& %0&% )*&( =-&/'5%%&5)/(/1(%/(1)*& ,5) )*,),'7,--3%)/( )*&%&5&/3)*,'=&&('*>()=& '3&()(5*,%/),=-&,5)/4/)/&'>*/5*%&1%&)),=-+5,(()=& 5%%=%,)&0>/)*)*,) )*&,/7',(0=C&5)' )*&'5/&)+ /(,='&(5& ,(+&4/0&(5&(%&5%0','()*&%3%

*,4&=&&('2=7/))&0 %)*&5*,%/),=-&,5)/4/)/&'5(025)&0 =+)*&'5/&)+E 94/: #*&)*&%()*& )*&5,'&,(0/( -,>.)*&( =-&/'%/1*)/(/1(%/(1)*& ,5))*,)'25* , -,%1& ,72() 5%32' 2(0 ,(0 ,55272-,)&0 ,''&)'

%&7,/(&02(&83-,/(&0,(0)*&5%32' 2(0'*,4&%&5&/4&0 >/)*2)>%/))&(/(')%25)/(' %&4&%/()*&,='&(5&

/(')%25)/(')*&,72()0&'( )1&)54&%=+)*&3%4/'/(' '&5)/(,(0 )*&5)E 94//:#*&)*&%()*& )*&5,'&.)*& %0&% )*&33&--,)&%/=2(,-/'5()%,%+))*&&4/0&(5& ,(0 7,)&%/,- ( )*& %&5%0 )*& 5,'& ,(0 )*&%& %&.

3&%4&%'&EG *&=%/& ,5)',%&)*,))*&%&'3(0&()B'5/&)+/'/(3&%,)/( '/(5&&=%2,%+.< *,4/(1 -->/(1,/7',(0=C&5)'

@9,:)),A&')&3'),5?2/%&-,(0 %5(')%25)/( ,)&73-& 9=: )5&-&=%,)&/73%),()%&-/1/2' &')/4,-',(0*-0 2(5)/('

F )*(2%)*&7&7%+ 1%&,)7&( )*21*),(0,5)/(H 95: ),%%,(1&32=-/50/'5-'2%&('2=C&5)'5((&5)&0>/)* ,(5/&()(0/,(*&%/),1&H 90: ) 7,/(),/( 5772(,- *,%7(+ =+ &8)&(0/(1 ,5)/4& 53&%,)/())*&3&3-& 4,%/2' ,/)*'/(,55%0,(5& >/)* 1%&,) '3/%/)2,- *&%/),1& (0/, ,(0 *&% '&52-,% ')%25)2%&,(0,-')3%7)&=&))&%2(0&%'),(0/(1,7(1 )*&3&3-& 4,%/2'=&-/& 'H 9&: )*&",=*,/'')%/5)-+()3-/)/5,-G 33-/5,)/( %%&1/')%,)/(2(0&%"&5)/( )*&5)>,'

/-&0(6

6*&77/''/(&% (57&,898&73)/(':%&C&5)&0 )*& ,33-/5,)/( 4/0& %0&% 0,)&0

; 7,/(-+ ( )*& 1%2(0 )*,) %&1/')%,)/(>,',33-/&0 %,-7'), )&% F+&,%' %57/(1/()&8/')&(5&H )*&%&>,'(0/''-2)/(5-,2'&/()*& &7%,(027 ''5/,)/(,(0)*& ,''&''&&B'5/&)+ *,0 *21& 5%32' ,' 573,%&0 ) )*& ,72() 2'&0 11%/&4&0 )*& %&C&5)/( ,33-/5,)/(. ,33&,- >,' 3%& &%%&0 *& %/=2(,-,-->&0)*&,33&,-(;

<*&%&-&4,()3%)/( )*&%0&% )*&%/=2(,-/'?2)&0=&-> @ #&*,4&*&,%0)*&!0&3%&'&(),)/4& )*&3,%)/&',(0 ,-' *,4& 1(& )*%21* )*& %&5%0' ( 2% 4/&>. )*& %&1/')%,)/())*&,''&''&&'5/&)+*,'=&&(>%(1-+0&(/&0=+ )*&!09:*&%&/'('3&5/ /5 /(0/(1%)*&='&%4,)/( )*&!09:/()*&%0&%)*,))*&,''&''&&'5/&)+/'() >%A/(1 )>,%0' ,5*/&4/(1 /)' ,/7' ,(0 =C&5)/4&' *& ,''&''&&'5/&)+/',%&-/1/2'=0+,(0/'&(1,1&0/()*& 7,/()&(,(5& "*%&& 2%1, ,(0/%,) ,(/7,C%,"25*

)+3& %&-/1/2' ,(0/%' ,%& () 3%/4,)& 3%3&%)+ ,(+ /(0/4/02,-%,(+'5/&)+.*&(5&.)*&3%3&%)+ '25*&()/)/&'

5,(()=&),A&(4&%%0/')%/=2)&0,7(1)*&7&7=&%' '5/&)+" ,%,')*&,='&(5& 0/''-2)/(5-,2'&./)>,'

=%21*) /( )*&A(>-&01& )*& 9:)*,) )*&,''&''&& '5/&)+ '2='&?2&()-+ 3,''&0 , %&'-2)/( >*&%&=+ ,

/''-2)/(5-,2'&*,4&=&&(,00&0))*& &7%,(027

''5/,)/( )*& '5/&)+ " ,% ,' )*& ,55272-,)/(

5%32' 2(0' &)5 /' 5(5&%(&0. /) >,' &83-,/(&0 ) )*& !0 9: )*,) 5%32' 2(0 *,' =&&( 7,0& 2) )*& 0(,)/(' %&5&/4&0 %7)*&7&7=&%' ,(0)*&0&4)&&'

"*%&& 2%1, ,(0/% % 7,/()&(,(5& 7,(0/%,(0 32%5*,'& (&>3%3&%)+,(0)*,))*&',/0%&5&/3)'>&%&02-+ ,552()&0 %,(0)*,))*&/(')/)2)/(>,'&'),=-/'*&0>*--+

%%&-/1/2'32%3'&')*,'=&&( 2%)*&%&83-,/(&0)*,))*& 5%32' 2(0 *,' =&&( 2%)*&% ,33-/&0 % =2/-0/(1 (&> *,--D%&-/1/2',5)/4/)/&',(0 2(5)/('.'),

',-,%+,(0-,(1,% ,5)/4/)/&'9 %&& 0:*,))*&5%32' 2(0 '.

.< DB ,' ( ,%5* .

; *,' =&&( 02-+ 2)/-/I&0 % )&73-& 3%&7/'&'. 2%(/'*/(1,(0 /))/(1',(0(2)&('/-' 6 ) /' &4/0&() )*,) )*& ,''&''&& '5/&)+ /' &(1,1&0 /( 7,/()&(,(5& ,(0/%*&%&/'(,--&1,)/()*,))*&%32'

2(0%)*&'2%3-2',55272-,)&0 2(0',%&=&/(12'&0 %)*& 32%3'&)*&%)*,()*&,/7',(0=C&5)' )*&,''&''&&'5/&)+ *&5%32','>&--,',55272-,)&0'2%3-2','/'5-,/7&0/' =&/(12'&0 %7,/()&(,(5&,(00&4&-37&() "*%&& 2%1,

,(0/%>*/5*/',%&-/1/2'3-,5&4/'/)&0=+)*&0&4)&&' ,(03&(),--G !&,%(&052('&- %)*&,33&--,()/'(),=-&)0/'32)&)*,) )*&%&/'()*/(1(%&5%0)'*>)*,))*&,''&''&&>,'()>%A/(1 % ,5*/&4/(1/)',/7',(0=C&5)'%)*,))*&,55272-,)&0 2(0'>&%&2'&0 % 32%3'&')*&%)*,(,/7',(0=C&5)'&*,'()=&&(,=-&)'*>)*,))*&

/(0/(1'%&5%0&0=+)*&%/=2(,-?2)&0,=4&,%&&%%(&2'725*-&'' 3&%4&%'&('25*5/%527'),(5&'.(?2&')/( -,>725*-&'''2='),()/,- ?2&')/( -,>,%/'&'/()&% &%&(5&/'5,--&0 %/()*&%0&% %/=2(,- *&,33&,-/'0/'7/''&0

+(,-,.! -/0*!

-1.-1.

7A #*&)*&%'3&,A/(1D%&,'(&0

&'D #*&)*&%%&3%),=-&

&'D