Sukhchain Singh @ Sonu v. State Of Punjab
Sumit Gulati 2017.12.04 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh
!!!!
""#$$%&'()*+*%,&,&-**%./,$#0'*#"1#.#&'%""#%$%-%,&.' '*#2(0-#3#&'4/+4&5,+',4&%&0410#14/.#&'#&+#0%'#0 "%..#0 67$#%1�$#..,4&.(0-#%&-1(15,0#8*,+**#8%.+4&5,+'#0 (&0#1#+',4&9 : %&0.#&'#&+#0'4(&0#1-4$,/#,3"1,.4&3#&'%&0 %$.4 (&0#1 #+',4& :;< %&0 .#&'#&+#0 '4 (&0#1-4 1,-414(.
,3"1,.4&3#&'/4197#%1.%&0'4"%7%/,/ .
=%&0,&0#/%($'
'*#1#4/ '4 (&0#1-4 % /(1'*#1 "#1,40 4/ 1,-414(. ,3"1,.4&3#&' /41 .,> 34&'*.8*48%.1#."4&.,6$#/41'*#0#%'*4/*,.8,/#%'5,1 %(10#+#%.#0 +433,'',&-.(,+,0#4&%++4(&'4/3%$'1#%'3#&'=*%1%..3#&'4&%++4(&'4/ &4'61,&-,&-.(//,+,#&'04817
*#+%.#4/'*#"14.#+(',4&8%.(&/4$0#04&'*#6%.,.4/'*# .'%'#3#&' 0%'#0 ;
?>@=A 3%0# 67 /%'*#1 4/ '*# 0#+#%.#0 4-,&0#1,&-*8*,+*,.%.(&0#1 B
!"
#
$
%
#
% $
& $
'
#
(
)
#
) (
'
!
$
)*
+
$
,
+ ) -
-
9
!
#
.
/01
$
#
( 2
#
%
$
$
#
#
"
3
45
.
C
&'*#6%.,.4/'*#%645#.'%'#3#&' 4 90%'#0;
(&0#1#+',4&9 :=9: 4$,+#'%',4& 4&-48%$,.'1,+'%&-1(1 ?>@ =A 8%. 1#+410#0 @ ()*+*%,& ,&-* 8%. '*# ,&5#.',-%',4&4//,+#1,&'*,.+%.#"4'8%.,&."#+'#067*,3%&014(-*.,'# "$%&?>@ =A8%."1#"%1#0'%'#3#&'.4/8,'&#..#.8#1#1#+410#0 &D(#.'1#"41'>@ =8%.%$.4"1#"%1#0%&0'*#0#%064074/%'5,1
%(18%.'%)#&,&"4..#..,4&%&0'*#.%3#8%..#&''4 ,5,$4.",'%$ %&-1(1/41"4.'341'#3#>%3,&%',4&143'*#"$%+#4/4++(11#&+#4&# 6#0 .*##' %$4&-8,'* '84 6$440 .'%,� .%$8%1. 8#1#'%)#& ,&'4 "4$,+# "4..#..,4&5,0#3#34>@= &9 %++(.#04-,&0#1,&-*
: %&0()*+*%,&,&-*E4&(8#1#%11#.'#0 &:; %++(.#0%-"%$
%(1%&03%&0##" %(18#1#%11#.'#0 ++(.#0%-"%$ %(1.(//#1#0 0,.+$4.(1#.'%'#3#&'>@<=%&0-4'1#+45#1#04@''$#4/"#.',+,0# 8*,+*8%.'%)#&,&'4"4$,+#"4..#..,4&5,0#3#34>@<= :
/'#1+43"$#',4&4/,&5#.',-%',4&1#"41'(&0#1#+',4&
1 8%..(63,''#0%&0'*#%++(.#08#1#+*%1-#.*##'#0(&0#1#+',4&. 9 :%&0:;<=9: '48*,+*'*#7"$#%0#0&4'-(,$'7%&0+$%,3#0 '1,%$ & 410#1 '4 "145# ,'. +%.# '*# "14.#+(',4& #>%3,�
8,'&#..#.
'%'#3#&'.4/%++(.#0(&0#1#+',4&99 1 8#1#1#+410#0 $$'*#,&+1,3,&%',&-#5,0#&+#8%."(''4'*#%++(.#06(''*#7+$%,3#0 ,&&4+#&+#%&0/%$.#,3"$,+%',4& *#7%$.4$#%0'*##5,0#&+#4/@ %1.*%&,&-*%&0@44'%,&-*,&'*#,10#/#&+# *#'1,%$ 4(1'%/'#1'%),&-,&'4+4&.,0#1%',4&%$$'*#3%'#1,%$ #5,0#&+#%5%,$%6$#4&1#+410/4(&0%++(.#0()*+*%,&,&-*-(,$'7/41'*# 4//#&+# (&0#1 #+',4& 9 : %&0 :;< %&0 1#+410#0 +4&5,+',4& %-%,&.' *,3 48#5#1 '*# 4'*#1 '*1## %++(.#0 8#1# %+D(,''#0 4/ '*# +*%1-#.
< #&+#'*#"1#.#&'%""#%$ ;
#%1�+4(&.#$/41'*#%""#$$%&'*%.5#*#3#&'$7.(63,''#0 '*%''*#"14.#+(',4&*%./%,$#0'4"145#,'.+%.#%-%,&.''*#+4&5,+'%""#$$%&' 6#74&0 1#%.4&%6$#04(6' #%1� +4(&.#$ *%./(1'*#1%1-(#0 '*%' '*# "14.#+(',4&*%.$#5#$$#0%5%-(#%$$#-%',4&'*%''*#+4&5,+'%""#$$%&'(.#0
'4*%1%..'*#0#+#%.#04&%++4(&'4/04817%&08%.0#3%&0,&-34'41+7+$# 8*#1#%.'*#+4&5,+'%""#$$%&'48�%34'41+7+$#3(+*"1,41'4'*#0%'#4/ 4++(11#&+#'*#0#+#%.#0+433,''#0.(,+,0#0(#'4*#1.,+)&#..4.(+* +43"$%,&'1#-%10,&-0#3%&04/34'41+7+$#*%0#5#16##&$40-#067'*# +43"$%,&%&' 41 %&7 /%3,$7 3#36#1 4/ '*# 0#+#%.#0 4 ,&0#"#&0#&' 8,'&#..8%.#>%3,C'*#"14.#+(',4&,&410#1'4"145#,'.+%.#.'*# 8,'&#..#.#>%3,#1#+$4.#$71#$%'#0'4'*#0#+#%.#0%&0%1#,&'#1#.'#0 8,'&#..#.'*#1#/41#'*#,10#"4.,',4&+%&&4'6#1#$,#0("4&,&410#1'4 +4&5,+''*#%""#$$%&'
&'*#4'*#1*%&0$#%1�+4(&.#$/41'*#'%'#*%..(63,''#0 '*%''*#'1,%$ 4(1'*%.46.#15#0#%+*%&0#5#17%."#+'4/'*#+%.#%&0*%. -,5#& %8#$$ +4&.,0#1#02(0-3#&' 8*,$#+4&5,+',&-%&0.#&'#&+,&-'*# %++(.#0%&0'*#1#/41#&##0&4''46#,&'#1/#1#08,'* @#*%5#*#%10'*#$#%1�+4(&.#$/41'*#%""#$$%&'%.8#$$%. '*#$#%1�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
F 0#+#%.#0%'5,1 %(1'*#1#/'#1.#5#&0%7.@4-,&0#1,&-*1#+#,5#0 %'#$#"*4&,++%$$/143*,.%&4'*#1.4&,&$%8%.8,&0#1,&-*'*%'%'5,1
%(1 *%0 0,#0 *#1#%/'#1 *# %$4&-8,'* @ 4-,&0#1 ,&-* %&0 %.8,&0#1 ,&-* *,. .4&,&$%8 1#%+*#0 4&-48%$ %&0 3#' @ ()*+*%,&,&-*%&0.'%'#3#&'4/@8%.1#+410#067@ :
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
*#8%."4.'#0 %. ,5,$4.",'%$%&-1(1#%$4&-8,'*1%$2,' %3%$%&01 (3%&0##" 1#8%$+4&0(+'#0"4.'341'#3#>%3,&%',4&4&'*#0#%06407 4/%'5,1 %(1%&0/4(&0'*#/4$$48,&-,&2(1,#. B?,A
$4''#06$440"1#.#&',&'*#5%-,&%$+%&%$%/'#1+$#%&,&- '*#6$440+$4'8,'*.8%6%&0"#1."#+($(3#>%3,&%',4& 4/5%-,&%$+%&%$GH %+#1%'#084(&04/+3>+3H .*%"#"1#.#&',&"4.'%-,&%$+%&%$ ?,,A #/'.,0#4/*#%1'8%.#3"'71,-*'.,0#8%./($$4/6$440 ",#+#4/*#%1'$(&-$,5#1),0%&0."$##&8%..#&' /41+*#3,+%$#>%3,&%',4&
?,,,A '43%+*%$4&-8,'*,'.+4&'#&'.',#08,'*04(6$#$,-%'(1# %&0%",#+#4/.3%$$,&'#.',,'*,'.+4&'#&'.%&0$%1-# ,&'#.',,'*,'.+4&'#&'.8#1#%$.4.#&'/41+*#3,+%$ #>%3,&%',4& ?,5A >'#1&%$ -#&,'%$,% G 8#1# &413%$ +$4''#0 6$440 8%. "1#.#&',&5%-,&%$+%&%$4&"#1."#+($(3#>%3,&%',4& '*#1#8%."1#.#&''#%14/H.*%"#+3>+3,&"4.' %-,&%$8%$$ '#1(.&413%$,&.,I#%&0%""#%1%&+#4& +('.#+',4&('#1,&#+%5,'78%.#3"'7C F @4",�'*%',&2(1744&'*#0#%064074/%'5,1 %(1 +%&&4'6#1#.($'4/&413%$,&'#1+4(1.#%&0'*#.%3#,."4..,6$#,/.43# /41#,-& 6$(&' 462#+' ,. ,&.#1'#0 ,& 5%-,&%$ +%&%$ /'#1 1#+#,"' 4/ '*#
*#3,+%$>%3,J.1#"41'@4",�'*%''*#+%(.#4/0#%'*,&'*,.+%.# 8%.0(#'4+4&.(3"',4&4/+*$414+43"4(&0-14("4/,&.#+',+,0#8*,+* 8%..(//,+,#&''4+%(.#0#%'*,&'*#410,&%17+4(1.#4/&%'(1#
@F %1.*%& ,&-* -4' +4&0(+'#0 "4.' 341'#3 #>%3,&%',4&4&'*#0#%064074/%'5,1 %(1/143 ,5,$4.",'%$%&-1(1 #0#"4.,'#0'*#"%1+#$4/+$4'*#.4/0#+#%.#0%'5,1 %(1%&05,.+#1%8,'* '*# *#3,+%$>%3, *%1%1 < @ ()*+*%,& ,&-* 0#"4.#0 '*%' 4& ;
*# %$4&-8,'*4'*#1"4$,+#4//,+,%$.8#1#"1#.#&'&#%16(..'%&0 4&-48%$/41 "%'14$$,&-8*#1#@4-,&0#1,&-*%$4&-8,'*@%10*%,&-*+%3# "1#.#&'%&0-4'1#+410#0*,..'%'#3#&'>@=4&'*#6%.,.4/8*,+* ?>@=A 8%. 1#-,.'#1#0 *#1#%/'#1 *# 1#%+*#0 %' '*# "$%+# 4/ 4++(11#&+#%&0,&."#+'#0'*#."4'"1#"%1#0,&D(#.'1#"41'%&01#+410#0 .'%'#3#&'.4/8,'&#..#.*#1#%/'#1'*#0#%064074/%'5,1 %(1.#&''4
<
,5,$4.",'%$%&-1(1/41"4.'341'#3#>%3,&%',4& 143'*#"$%+#4/ 4++(11#&+#*#'44),&'4"4..#..,4&4$440.'%,#0.*##'%$4&-8,'* '846$440.'%,�.%$8%1. *#+$4'*#.%&05,.+#1%*%&0#045#167'*# 4+'418#1#'%)#&,&'4"4..#..,4& &9 %++(.#04-,&0#1,&-* %&0 +4&5,+'%""#$$%&' ()*+*%,& ,&-* 8#1# %11#.'#0%&0 4& :; %++(.#0 %."%$ %(1 %&0 3%&0##" %(1 8#1# %11#.'#0 ,.+$4.(1# .'%'#3#&'8%.3%0#67%++(.#0%."%$ %(14&'*#6%.,.4/8*,+*4@''$# 4/"#.',+,0#8#1#1#+45#1#0 /143'*#7%10 4/ *#1*4(.#,& '*#+41 %$4&-8,'*'*#8%$$ ;
*#3#0,+%$#5,0#&+#"140(+#067'*#"14.#+(',4&-4#.'4 .*48 '*%' %'5,1 %(1 *%0 &4' 0,#0 ,& &413%$ +,1+(3.'%&+#. . "#1
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
; .%/#$7*#$0'*%''*#+4&5,+'%""#$$%&'*%0%34',5#'4+433,''*#4//#&+#
*#0#%064074/%'5,1 %(18%./4(&0$7,&-,&'*#*4(.#4/ '*#+4&5,+'%""#$$%&'..(3,&-/41'*#.%)#4/%1-(3#&''*%'0#+#%.#0 %'5,1 %(1+433,''#0.(,+,0#'*#+4&5,+'%""#$$%&',&*,..'%'#3#&'(&0#1 #+',4&99 1 *%0/%,$#0'4(''#1#5#&%8410'*%'*48'*#8*4$# 4++(11#&+#*%0*%""#�#*%..,3"$7.'%'#0'*%''*#0#+#%.#0(.#0'4 1#3%,&.,+)%&08%.'%),&-'*#3#0,+,/#",$#".7/143 *##3%%&0 %&.%44+'418%.#>%3,C'*#+4&5,+'%""#$$%&',&*,.0#/#&+#'4 "145#*,..'%&0 4"1#.+1,"',4&41%&7'*,&-8%.$#0,,0#&+#67'*# +4&5,+'%""#$$%&',&410#1'4"145#'*%''*#0#+#%.#0(.#0'4'%)#3#0,+,&# 4/#",$#".7 1(# ,' ,. '*%' &4 +43"$%,&' 8,'* 1#-%10 '4 *%1%..3#&' 41 0#3%&0 4/ 04817 *%0 6##& $40-#0 67 '*# +43"$%,&%&' "%1'7 %&0 &4 ,&0#"#&0#&' 8,'&#..
*%0 6##& #>%3,� '4 "145# '*%' *%1%..3#&' %&0 +1(#$'78%.6#,&-3#'#04(''4'*#0#+#%.#0&4(1.4+,#'7/,1.'$7#5#17 #//41',.3%0#'461,&-"#%+#%&0*%134&7%'/%3,$7$#5#$8,'*'*#*#$"4/ &#%1.%&00#%1..4'*%''*#3%'1,34&,%$$,/#4/'*#+4("$#3%7&4'-#' 0,.'(16#0%&04&$7'*#1#%/'#1,&+%.#4//%,$(1#,',..*%1#08,'*4('.,0#1. 41'*#4$,+#%('*41,',#. '*%.+43#,,0#&+#4/@%&0@'*%' 8*#&'*#0#+#%.#08%..#&'6%+)'4*#1"%1#&'.*43#/4161,&-34'41+7+$# @%&0@%$4&-8,'*4&#('%,&-*8#&''4*#13%'1,34&,%$*43# "%+,/,#0'*#3%&0%..(1#0'*#3'*%''*#,10#3%&084($06#3#'.44& *#1#/41#'*#%1-(3#&''*%'&4,&0#"#&0#&'8,'&#..
*%1%..3#&''4'*#0#+#%.#0$4.#.,'.8#,-*'
./%1%.'*#%1-(3#&'3%0#67+4(&.#$/41'*#%""#$$%&''*%' '*# +4&5,+'%""#$$%&' %$1#%07 48�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
*,3&41*%.,'+43#,,0#&+#'*%' '*#+4&5,+'%""#$$%&'*%0.'1%,#$%',4&.8,'*@%10*%,&-*5#& 4'*#18,.#@4-,&0#1,&-*,..'%'#0'4*%5##,-*'0%(-*'#1.%&0%$$ 3%11,#0'*%.&4'+43#4&1#+410'*%'*#$#5#$$#0%&7%$$#-%',4&%-%,&.' %&74/*,.4'*#1.4&.,&$%8#5#1*#1#/41#'*#1#8%.&4-4401#%.
7#%1.K4$0/%'*#1'4,3"$,+%'#*,..4&,&$%8,&%/%$.#+%.# :
*4(-*'*#"14.#+(',4&*%./%,$#0'41#+45#1'*#/41#,-&462#+' %.."4)#&'467@11,'"%$,&-*,&*,.#>%3,&%',4&,&+*,#/8*,+* 4'*#18,.#8%.%&,3"41'%&'",#+#4/#5,0#&+#'4"145#'*#+*%1-#.6(''*%' 67,'.#$/,.&4-14(&0'4%6.4$5#'*#%""#$$%&'4/'*#+*%1-#.%-%,&.'*,3 &5,#84/'*#%645#,'+%&.%/#$76#*#$0'*%','8%.'*#
+4&5,+'%""#$$%&' 8*4 +%(.#0 '*#048170#%'* 4/%'5,1 %(16#.,0#.
'1#%',&-*#18,'*+1(#$'74&%++4(&'4/61,&-,&-,&%0#D(%'#04817 F . 1#-%10. '*# .#&'#&+# 4/ ,3"1,.4&3#&' '*# %""#$$%&' ,. /%+,&-'*#%-4&74/+1,3,&%$"14.#+(',4&/41'*#$%.'341#'*%&.#5#&7#%1. *#.#&'#&+#4/$,/#,3"1,.4&3#&',3"4.#0("4&*,3/41'*#4//#&+#(&0#1 #+',4&9 : ,.4&'*#*,-*#1.,0#&0.4/2(.',+#.*%$$6#.(,'%6$7 3#',/'*#.%3#,.1#0(+#0'4'8#$5#7#%1.
#.($'%&'$7 '*# +4&5,+',4& 4/ '*# %""#$$%&' (&0#1 #+',4&. :%&0:;< ,.("*#$0,..#&'#&+#4/$,/#,3"1,.4&3#&'/41'*# 4//#&+#(&0#1#+',4&9 : ,.1#0(+#0'41,-414(.,3"1,.4&3#&'/41 '8#$5#7#%1.*#.#&'#&+#4/,3"1,.4&3#&'%&0/,&#/41'*#4//#&+#(&0#1 #+',4&:;< %$4&-8,'*,'.0#/%($'+$%(.#,.3%,&'%,'*'*# .(6.'%&',5#.#&'#&+#.4/,3"1,.4&3#&'.*%$$1(&+4&+(11#&'$7 < *#%""#%$,.%++410,&-$70,."4.#04/
45#36#1
($%',=,&#.* @*#'*#1 #"41'%6$# #.
@*#'*#1"#%),&-= #%.4� #.