Kulwant Singh & ORS. v. State Of Punjab

  

  !"#$%&$ '$$  $ $( $ 

 )*+,-./,0121-345

6789*3+13:;*3/-+;,<2 555==,88*3+2 >,<272 +*+,-.73?*@ 555,2=-3/,3+ 

$AB C%DA E#F $A$ $($ '  GGGGG <,2,3+ 25H*28,,36*7<I/J-0*+,.-<*==,88*3+K-56789*3+13:;5 25L*<;,,3 *?9*I/J-0*+,.-<*==,88*3+K-5  ,*3+13:;5 <5*?*+M*7+*NI/J-0*+,.-<*==,88*3+K-5*O;*313:;5 <5?1+67N*<;*<N*I/J-0*+,.-<*==,88*3+K-5 K*<*1313:;5 <5*31=*813:;+9*8I)MI73?*@5  GGGGG  $A$ $($ 'E#E P;, /,*+; 0,<+1.10*+, -. *==,88*3+ K-5  ,*3+ 13:; ;*2 @,,3 =<-/70,/ *2 =,< 9;10; ;, =*22,/ *9*Q -3

5 5

R5 00-</13:8QI +;, =<,2,3+ *==,*82+*3/2*@*+,/S7*;1N-38Q5 5
;*88,3:, 13 +;, =<,2,3+ *==,*8 12 +- +;, ?7/:N,3+T-</,< /*+,/

5 5

I =*22,/ @Q +;, 8,*<3,/ //1+1-3*8 ,221-32 H7/:,I U7/;1*3*I 9;,<,@Q +;,*==,88*3+29,<,0-3J10+,/*3/2,3+,30,/*273/,< 6789*3+13:; ..,30,7T2 VN=<12-3N,3+ L13, ),.*78+2,3+,30, V
V.-<+9-Q,*<2   V
V.-<+;<,,Q,*<2 25R

V.-<-3,N-3+; 4 V
V.-<+;<,,Q,*<2 25R

V.-<-3,N-3+;




 !

"#

 $%$

 %"& 

 !

"#

 $%$

!$ '$( )!* !$'$( !$+,!

!'$'$( $&-." %/ '"$%$ 0'$ 1!-2 "$ $& 


 !

"#

 $%$

3 


 !

"#

 $%$




 !

"#

 $%$

22

"$ $&"4  + +  -$&$&-

2 #

# -&&'$& !& '

5 ! '$( &%/2!'$!$ %!+ ! %$



/2'&

$

#

)

!2$(4'

'" 4' !$+

"'

'$( '$

'"

-") !22

!&&-"+ &!%

 6-!

2 $"-+ 4$

%# 8-24!$ '$( !$+

!&&-"+ &!-"+ 724"



'% !$+

'" 4'# $ 0 &!%

 7

('"

+!(!'$"

!&&-"+# # 

&%/2 '$  '$9"

'(!

'$) '$!2

/

-$+ & '$ 
##
# 4!" / "$ '$

-

!(!'$"

!&&-"+!//22!$ "# $ '$+'$( ! / '%! !&' &!") & (" -$+ & '$" . .3.

 
!$+ & '$

   %" & !%+ !(!'$"

%)

 '&

/2!++ $ (-'2 !$+ &2!'%+

'!2#

# :

/ "&- '$ '$ +

 '$(

%

(-'2 

!&&-"+ ;!%'$+ !" %!$ !" <"# $ &2"-  / "&- '$ 9'+$&) %$ 

!&&-"+!//22!$

& ++ -$+ & '$ 
##
# :

+$'+ !22

'$& '%'$!

'$( &'

&-%"

!$&"

!//!

!(!'$"

'$

/ "&- '$ &!"4 '2/2!+'$(!2"'%/2'&!

'$7

/2'&# # :

2!

$+

'!2
-

!

'$(

2!

$+ &-$"2 

/!

'")&$9'& +!$+"$ $&+

!&&-"+!//22!$ "!"$ '&+!79# # (( '9+!//22!$ "!

7

'"
-

#

   

!" # $% &&"" $!' $ $%  $!$' ()*!

%"" ( $ $%

*) $)

&+! # 

) $% ! $

 ,  $ &&"" $! -.% ) (%

-) ) (% $ $% &) "

( ' )$ /) $%!

 +'  $%!' 

+' !& $)*"+'

$% (

$%$ $%+ /"

$ $% & !$$ $% )$+1 !" / ,)

 $%) #0)")!1 %*)

%)"

 0)(/" (1

* 0)! ! $%

!!) /)"

%* / # ) ($%( +#&$ $ $)"#$%"!$ +! 2  $% $% %

' "  $$

!" ! /0)$! $%$ $% $)"
 $ #$ && )$) $% *) 

 " /+ $% &! $) ' %! )(%$"+

*) $

! $

 $% &&"" $!' $%#' &+! # $%

)!0)!!" $% &! &&" ' %,*'

/"! $

$*$ $%

) *"*0 $% &&"" $! 3 &$ &&"" -4 ", ) (%' ,% )! ) *"* )

0/

!!' ) $%

)0) " !

$%&)

( /+$%0 5  $%" 

!" )$%!) 

& ! $% 6*)  $"+' 789 ) (%' +,)$ !!!:

0&") $' ) %)!

&!)$) !& )#) ""+

0 $% &&"" $!

$%) "!' ,%) !$

/$ /+ $% !$$0 $! 7  ;)$ 4 

72: " ) (%' ,% , $% + ,)$ !!!7' < , ) (%

&! $%$ %   $%

)!

"!  !$$0

! 4 ", ) (%'

/!)! ,%) %' % ($  *  / ( #0 %)! % ! *)   *+ 00 6378:   () $% (% $% *) 



 ' $% &! $) %! &* $%

! () !$ $% &&"" $! =% !' $% )!

& # ) $#

 ) $% #)

) (!  

" !) )* $/+$%$)"
 $!!

%'$%)

*) $) )! &%"

 =%)!
 $ ) >?@ABC DEFGH CIJ DK?KB LM N?OP?F? '

8 

 ")   2 ' /+ #"",) $%

) $ 0 ) Q?IEO CIJ DK?KB LM RKK?O SO?ABIHT

<


 5 '

$%)!
 $ ) U?VLO DEFGH CIJ DK?KB LM N?OP?F?T



 


)0) " 

W?GABBX DEFGH Y QBBKZ CIJ DK?KB LM SZFV?[T







  ! "# "!

" ! $"

%  $ "#  " & "# $ " "#' (

)$

!

*)#+,#(-

"'

 

"#$ ./+ &  $% "#
$" 

 $ "#  $  "  )  '*

 "

 "#  "+ ,#  *( $'
$"   -+ "

" 2""



#%

3


 4 %

"#
$"   5   !# -+ "

"  )



 




( 

'  !# 7 1"$ -+ "

" $ *%






- 8

(  -9 -  "# &  $  "  '*

 "

: "#  "

 $ "#  " " "# '

(

)

!

 "# ' & "

$"

 &"#  + 4+ $

( -  !# 

!

 "#



)+ ,# $!# #

 "

"

$ "#

"#% #

$  5$)

-"

'

" "# * )+ ;$"#% #  5$"

) 

"# " 9# "# $ " 8 '( + ,# $

8 '(  "# ) 

+ 

 !

$

( -  !# " (

 "

! "# <' ' " &  " '  *) "# "
$" 9 $(

& "()  "# ' &$( (& "#)

#  " (

&" *$) ! "# ( ! ")+

; 

(( "#  % "# 5$ !

-" '

 *) "# "
$"



 "

$

( -  !# "



& $" "#  " ' 

#   $ " "# '

(

)

!

*) #+ ,# &

"#

& $("  " '  *) "# "
$" &  "# &&

 "   3

"

  " "

& + 3& "# &

 $ 

'

 9"#

 "# &  "#

" "# 5$ ! "%

$

( -  !# # ((

! "#

& $("  " '  *) "# "
$" &  "# '"- && += + >?@?A BCDEF ?D@ GAHI JHI BK?KL MN O?P?HKF?DQ 4/4  RS1

 9# "#

-"   $

 " T 3

 "

  "     *) "# !#
$" *$" "#  "  " "# '

(

)

!

*) #  " " 3

"

  "%

  ! "# "# $ " 8 '(  4/

# 

"  - (- 

) "#

+ + UCD U?V?W JI BK?KL MN ULWFC XY@ZDI[ X\DCMD ]LAACKMAV MN ULWFC[Q 44 

 % "# "
$"

-" "# "#

$  ($  ! "#



 !

"# $ %
& '

!"

)* +#

,#   )+ - '  # ./

)   *
#

#/' 0"

)

) !"

,' + #* $ !

# ) "##+"() *#

)' -

 (# /-)"*1 1 % 23456 7 893: ;3: <=>=? 8@ A>B>3=4>CD 1 1
"*"

  E#1$FG$$ ,) /-

) !!

' 

')#H ,' !# 0"!



 !

"# 

 %%  !

"#

F %
+#

- ' 

) !!

'  !)#   I ( * ,  !# 0"!

 +# #++ !

 !

"#

F %
+# *#

)'&

) "()
#

/- ) !"

) +"

/ "

) J & !

) '

!

)  "#  -

 (# &

H"

!# '"  "#

)

) !"

##H ! $F1 1 % A>BKCL?9 <KCM4 2CL 8=4?93 ;3 <=>=? 8@ NOCB>P
1 0"'"# E#1 $ #+

&

) !!

' J"

 "

()& " Q0"

 "

()&  H)*"

 "

()&   "

()& ) "

 "

()& E"  J "

()  R "

() ,  !# 0"!

 '

/'



"- +#   "# #+

,# - ' 

-  +"

#+ '1

G

 !

"# '  G G

GG FG %
1 S) "()
#

,)" *"

"

) !# 0"!

"# !

) '

! T 

) "* "'# *

#+

) !!

' "#  ' # ) "# -

 (# 1 1 U","

) * "'

"!-& 

E#'1 

)0"

'

++ 

) "( #*"

- #+

" '"

! # (V '

!!''+ - ,  #++

)" ! "* # '' 0"

 #+  ''# V

)" '#!"#!# #*"! !" !

*'

 !'&

)"'
#

+"

' W

 "#

/ "*"!"

1 S) '& ,#  ' 0

) ' #+ J '

"!

!

)" '

!

)  "#  -

 (# & )#,0 & H"

) +"

!

 0", #+

) +!

) 

E#1 "' 0#0 ) !''&

)"'  T  )"* "'"'*"''1 1 S) #  #+ '

!  

1 1

"' *#"+"

) +# '" W

 ''

!)& ) '

'

 ' -#,1

  

!



# !"% "&

' () *#

' !"#! #
'& +) !$, $

 &"

# $ #

' % "! # $$#

$%%,,$# -". % ,$/ 01213451675189:  ;67<=  >?@AB@BABC '"D E' ' %$D#F $ "# G F-" E' ' %"

$H, G F-"