High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/177/2011disposed of

Dharam Raj And Others v. State Of Haryana

2016-02-03Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary27 pages

!""

$% "

&&& ' ( $ % ( ) *$ $ + !, ""

( , "!,- % &&&

.""

( (/ )* +

* $ 0 $ 1* $ 123 4'5 $ 6 ! ! # + 7 ! $

8+ $ " ,

9 : !

* , $

3 4'5 + " " 73 " + + " " ;

9 : !

* , $

* $ 3 4'5

+ + " " 73 " + + " " ;

9 : !

* , $

* $ 3 4'5

+ + " , " 673 " + + " " < ;

9 ,: !

* , $

1 * $ 3 4'5

+ + " , " 673 " + + " " < ;

9,: !

* , $

1712* $ 3 4'5 + +

" " =73 " + + " "

;

9, : !""

* , $ 6 ! !

+ + " " "

73 " + + " " . , " * ." "

* +

" " ! +" $34

"$'

$ + $ % > ' $ $ "* " ' $ 0 6 06 " * * (%5 "

,?%5) ,7 @ 0 +* " * "

** * +

+() A ! $34

"$' $ + +* !$4 " !$4 $ +%5$ +

?%5 " ( -, " ++ @ %3?3 + , !

) % *?%5) * +*

/, + + +

* * ?%5 $ +@ 1=* + // /

! " * *

"" , + * . * * /3 / + @ '

363=61/ 5/ +*

+ . , + @ 2=27B 1 *

+ "* *

) + ).

$ 8 .* "+" < * * , "6 .*

" + 6* =*

?%5) "

* ( + @ %3 3=16/%% $"

* ?%5) .*", * * /3 / + +* 6

7 + 1* +C *

" . " + + " * / "

"" +" . " +* , + * /3 / */ " , ", ., * *

4 "" / * "

* "

+ +

" +* 6

1 $

61124'5 $

6! ! A* "" +?%5 ) ' $ + ! 4 @ 0 0 6 * + ' $ + , + $34

" $' $ ++"

"+" +

, *""

?%5 $ + " + 6*

" " 4 A " " *

0 6 * 5%5 - " 3 > " * + BC ,

+8 $34

"$' $ +* / "

. "*

$ D( * +" > 0 6 * > +

+* 3 "

# "" "

% +*

3 * (

* " . "

/ * *+ + % 3 " "

" '

+, "

$34

"$ ' $ +

(/ ) 6 0 6 > 1 6 6$4$ $ +

( > + " * +,6 , +

?%5 ) +

, + *"

$ D

$ *

* !"

, + "

* ""

* + * "

+ "" " < *

'B5 $ + $ +** " ' $ ?%5 'B$ ) "* *

+ 'B5

/) , " "4 A(+ 0 6 %

, "

$ D( 0 6 6* * , (%5$ ) 'B0, '* % A) "" "

?< '!"

0 6 6 'B6!$4@ 2 6 6 * ' $ )

%5$ +?< '

D +5 /$ + + , + 'B)" $ + 0 6*

" " ""/ * $ ,

+$ - ( ! * / + 4

( $ "

$ / 5/ .

" "" > " " ! ""* - * * *

+* >

+ " +* $

($ +/ + ! + 3 * , + " * * ,

+5 4*

+ *

! /

> <

+ ,

+*"

! +* $ " * * * + "

* "

+ +"

%"" "

" *

*/ * / + " " % ?< ' 5" 'B2# / ) " 6 6 " "$%>

+' $ $-

* * /3" * +

+ ",

?< '" *

3 *"

* * /" " ,

+@ C" " +, "

6 "

, + / ' + , 6 "

* * / "

, ?< '7 %" 6 6 $ * + " " *

+ /" 6 + "* ,

+ , '

?< '? $ +,6 , +

+* " "

* * / "

+,?< '?7 'B= 5

) , ?< '

, 'B1!$4 $ +" 0 6 , ""

+" ?%5) $ + ! " 3 , "

* "

$ +$%>*/ "

, , ?< '

7 'B !$4 $ $ + 4 + ' D

$ " ( . > 3 / % % + + @ %3 3=16 *

@ 0' $ , + , + +> * * / "

, ?< '- 'B!$4 " 0 6

" "

?%5) @ 0 *"

" $4$' $ + -, " "*

?%5) ?%5 $ + +

/" . ,

?%5 $ +*

+* /3 /

> + +

@ '

363=61/ 5/ , +

* "+" < *, " ?%5) " + 6 * /3 / , +

, *

/ "

,?< '% )

" + 6*/ "

, , ?< '8 "

* $ + * +

*/ "

.3 * ?%5)

?%5 $ ++ "

+ +

6 + *

+ %

" $4$' $ +

+8 "*

*%% ++

%3 3=16 * + / "

, ?< 'D %

?< '( + + +

" + 6

* *" *A !

(/ "

- 3( * + " * A

+* ( $ "+

+$ " 0 6 " "/ !

* * "

$ "

B *"

+ A , , + "

* + 4 $ " +" B

" $ "

( *

. " * "

+ + + % /" "

(* *

* + 4 * "

+* 'B$4'"$ +' $ # ) @* 2 0 6 , + 4 @ 22 0 6 $

=624'5

6 2! ! 4 $ "

* ) * /

" %

A " ?< '@7 $ "

$ "" 3, A ?< '@7 "

$ "

, , <" + * +C , + 1" +

1*, . *"

* (%5' $ # ) 'B$4 , * "

+$" $$ " = 6 6 > +* "

+@/ ./'

+ != " * ,

+@ %+, * 3

" %*,

+ 3 /"

"/ " " " " ." " * " * ,"* @ =

$ ( % , "

6 +* " + * , + 4@ =0= 6 6 $

2764'5 $ 6! !

+* + ' $ )/ %

, +

+ , , + + +*"

'B05 6 0 6 2 " (/ *"

+ % , ,

, " * %A + " %

1 0 6

! +* $ " (

" +"

* A " , '

" ,

+ *

$ "( * + % 3 "

% )

* ,"" + + " % " (/ " 5*/ 'B6?%5$ 5 , ?< ' , 'B%5$ )** " (%5

' $ 0 6" ?%5 $ + ?%5) + "

" @ 2 !

( )

3 ++ @ %3 3=16 *+ , + 6 , + > 06" , "

+?%5 ) * + ( )

+ $ A $4$' $ + +*

" "

@ 9?< '.: +* $4$' $ + %

" + , + $4$' $ + " "

+" + 6

+ / ?%5 ) ?%5 " " + 6

" "

+ *"

*" *

0 6 > 0 6 ""

$ D( +?%5$ 5 > 6 6 $4 $ ' $ + "

" 6 +* "

$ D ( 1 6 6 + 5

) >

6 6$4$$ +" "

+ ?%5) , +

+6 + % "

$ D( 'B2!$4)" + + ?< ' $4 $ ' $ + " * + , "

# 'B=!$4)"$ + + @

30=* @ + @ ===* @ 02 *

' $ + * * +C 2 , + 1 'B1 8+ '+"

0 6/ "+" ?< '0?< '0* , "

+ , ?< '00?< '6 'B $4 $ ' $ + " +* , + "

+ (%5$ )?%5) " * +* "

+ " ?%5) ?%5 $ +

" ,, 'B $ !

" 0 6 " +* 4 $ ' ',

- "

$ +

* +

F ?

* / * 2 = C* < /

" " * + +*

?< * <" +

" * + +"

+ +, + , "+ / ,

G %" "

* + .

%" 6 " +* 4 $ ' ', -

)

* +

F ?

* / * < 0 , + /

" 4 + "*" 2

+ +

D ,* * + +*

, !

* C< !

< "

+ " .

, "

G %

" "

* , +

* 4 * 'B%5$ 5

$4 '" $ + ' $

$ # ) " + +@ 30= +* , + +C * * "" 4@ 22 0 6 $

=6 24'5 $

6 2 ! ! + ' $ # ) * *, "

$ " 'B'/ (+ $ "+ ?< '#7" ! ! 'B0$4) * $ + = 6 6 * " !$4$" $$ " = " +* $4 , !$4 ,) "" $ ( * "

6 +* " + * , + */ "

, ,?< '> 'B6 $ $ + * "

$34

"' $ 1 6 6 $ ( * * " 8 (+ 5

$ " > 6 6 + $ ( *

?< '? +" "

+* 3 * 3

/ + "

3 * "* ,

+8 % / 6

, + * /" +* ) *

"* ,

+) %

" ) / 6773 . " " + ,6 , + )

" " "

, + """ $ 25 ' 5 * * "

5 'B$ )D 5 /> $( $ , + @ 2=27D'

'B2$ +

+' ?<" = 6 6 ,* , "

6 + , +"

+ "

+ + +" ! " "

+"" "?< ' 'B= 5

$ ' $ # ) 4@ 22 0 6 $

=6 24'5* + ' $ # ) "

"% 'B1$4$ $ +( . > ' D $ " 0 6$4$' $ +/ "

" " + 3 +@ %3 3=16

+ *

' ' , " ?< ' ?< '7

$ D " , B < $ 5 ' 5

< , ! +

+ ++, , 5 ," , , ""

, D

" ,

* @

" 'B)" $ +* , * ""

$ ( $ "9

: " ?, , ,

+ " + "" ., ?%5 ) "

$ ( "

" "

* + . 'B0 5 * "" , ?%5) <

, ""

(/ * * " " * ""

* ," > $

" + , ,

* ?%5 ) ?%5 $ + . " *

, + , 5 %, +

+ + + 5

, "

+?%5) +*

*" "

** (%5' $ "" 'B $34

" $ ' $ + $ % > * " *?%5)

?%5 $ + + , +

B /3 / * * * ?%5 $ + > 5/ ++ @ '

363=61 , + ""

* "+"* +

" !

" + 6*

+ . 3 + + @ %3 3=16 / % % $"

* * + * "

+ 6 + 1 ! $4$'

$ +""A?< ') ' $ * 4 ?< ')7 * !$4 @

* * * " " +

, + 3 * ,

+ 8 .

$ D +

" +" 3 . * 5 , % " $ "

" 3 'B$34

"$' $ +

0 0 6 +""

+ * ?< '(" * +, "

* /" " /

+ @3? , "

-, -

$ ,

+@ C" ." ""

, , + * *

+ " 4 "+" 'B $ )D 5 / > $ ( $ ", , , , + ?< ' ""

. 6 "

+ , ""

3 $ 6! ! , " 'B'/ (+ $ "", ?< '#7 " +""

! ! 'B6$34

"$$ + 6 6 +""

3$ ( *

?< '?" * + , ?< '60 ?%5)

6 , + ?< ''=1* /" *

'*% ,

+) $ 'B$4 , " = 6 6"" ""

$ (

+ / "

6 "

+* "

* , + *, 4

+" 3

?%5) 'B $ !

* * + .

6 "

3$ ( *

$ D ( " # " ?< '7 !

/ "

6* /

B79 $D@ 67 32 4@ =0= 6 6 $

276 4'5 ! ! ' $

)/: , / 7 . "

, , ""

$ (

" 5 + ""

(/ ) + + , ,

+ "

$ ( $ "9

8 , "

+ "

* ?, *

. "" " + +

" " 5

?%5) * <

'B0 * 6 0 6 2 " ""

(/ ) *"

+ !""

(/ , ,

, " * %

1 0 6 +* $ "

(

* /*

" +"

, *"

, *A %

* ,

3 $ "( * + * "

3 "

" 'B05

" /(/ )* ' $ - " 5*/ *"(/ ) ** /

3< ""

(/ ) +,

+8 *

* ,

+ ,

+8 *

/ %

/ *(/ ) ",

* % * D ,

+' )"

+ , * 'B0 5 + " ""

(/ )* ,""

, , + ,

+ * */ " % / *""

(/ )",

** + 'B05 *

D ,

+' * , """

(/ )

+ + < !" +

, , *

, , ""

, *, 5

, * "+ + "

5< , + +""

$ ( + +

! " " " ""

3(/ ) "," , *

5 3 , " " " ""

$ ( ! , ""

(/ ) 3 A + +

."" " &

()*+,*- .# & '