← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2370/2007dismissed

Satish v. State Of Haryana

2022-09-26Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

 

         



 !"#$%$ &'()*) 

$%+ ,)--..

&

/0%1% 

 ! &

,) %- &"&

 '  34 ) )) 

 !"

# $!#% &&''

(# )* +%% , ' -   ....

))5)  /%*+  && '  *+  *"#   *(+#  #%  ,(#   #  & ++*#*!( '++*!(+0 !( *1%*"%!( "!("'+*!(!$#* ' &&''

(# #*+% ""+*(23!  #  4$!#%!$$("+("#*!(+5 36*+# 1*#%6!'*"# #*!(   !(1 +"!( *"#$!!$$("+( "#*!(+    (  5 36  1% +  "7*##  !$ #% "%  ( "#*!( 36 (*(#,+!$#%! #4 %1 +(#("#!(!*!!+*,&*+!(,(#$! &*!!$+*8,!(#%+ ("#*!(36 (%1 +$#%+(#("#!(!*!!+ *,&*+!(,(#$! &*!!$#1! + (#!&  $*(!$+5 9 ( *($ '#!$& ,(#!$$*(#!(!$#%*,&*+!(,(#$!

 &*!!$5 +$!#%!$$("("#*!(536 !#%#% +(#("+1!#!("!("(#' 

*$'+# #$ "#+!$#%"

+ +&#%&!+"#*!(+#!

  #% #  !(   4  #  !#  :  ,  ,#;

+%'  1*$  !$ "!,&'

(#%% *(%% !(#!% % &'!#$!!*(+!, 1!<=  $#  #(*(  %!,  ,#;

+%'  #!'  %  %+ (  #% "!,&'

(##% ##%*(*%! #*+%

""+%  +% (% +%!', #! '*>%*+,*+# <=#%"!,&'

(#1(##!%*+ %= %1 +$!''!1%*+1*$,#;

+%' +!( (!

( %#*( '

1,#+%*'

=#%"!,&'

(#*(7*$!,#% ""+ +#!1% %%  +%*+1*$% *(#% # ""+ #*+%1(##!!!$!$%*+ %!+ (#%1 *"< ##%$!,!(#%"!,&'

(#%*##*(%*,!( %*+% =#%+"!(*"< ##%!1(#% ""+%*##%"!,&'

(# !(#%,*'$*(!$%*+*%#% (=1%(,#;

+%' 1*$!$ "!,&'

(##*#!+"%%+ (#%"!,&'

(##% ""+ #%1 (!#%*"< #%*##*(,#;

+%' !(#%*%#+*!$% %  ( "<=1%( (!

"

,$!1 #!+ %*+& (#+#%(#%

""+"

,!1($!,#%!!$ (  8'!1#! (!

%*##*(%*,!(%*+*%# +*+* *( $*+#'!1!(%*+ "<=#% "!,&'

(#& # *+ '

,1%*"% ## "# ,+%+!(!$%* ?

'

1%!*(# ( (+"#%"!,&'

(#+*$!,#%"'#"%+!$ #% ""+=,#+%*'

1*$!$ (!

1%!*+ %#*('

1!$#% "!,&'

(#%  '+!+$$*( *+*(#%*("*(# !,&'

(#%% *(%%*+1*$,#;

+%' ( +!(@ (!

''#%#%*( 1,! #!6+%&

'*-!+&*# '

!(  1%  #%  1  ,*"

''  # #  (  ,*"!  ' ''

 8 ,*((*(#*, #*!( *(%!+&*# '*> #*!(!$#%*( 1 +(##!6!'*"# #*!(*# !($!,1% 1*'++,++ 1 $'

+%#!6!'*"6!+#

+% %& ("*&#!$#% #*($!, #*!(-  # 6 < +%1(##!6+%&

'*-!+&*# ' !(-"!''"# ?+!$#%*(  (!# *("!,&'

*(#A86!$"!,&'

(# %% *(%1%*"%1 +(!+%*,/%(BB!:A86A +  "!  /%  !"#!  %   !&*(  #%  *(   !(  #%  &+!(  !$ %% *(%#! (!+#!'*$231 +*(*#* ''*+#$! #%!$$("+("#*!(+ (536+7(#'!("*&# !$+"%,*"

'!&*(*!(1*#% #!#%*( *+$!(!(#%&+!( !$%% *(%#! (!+#!'*$"

+ '(#1 &!( !$$("("#*!( 361 +  /%*( +#* #*!(*(#%"

++# #/%3 1(##!#% +&!# (&& !%+*#&'

(!$#%&'

"!$!""(" +A86; -  #!!<  *(#!  &!++++*!(  *!+  ,*"

'  !",(#+  ""+  1

+#*(#%*+"

+!(C 4 B*(#%"!+!$*( +#* #*!(#% ""++$$

*+"'!++# #,(#A86?#% #%% <&#"!(" ' 8+ %*,*(#%*("*(#*(#%!!,!$%*+%!+ (%"!'##%+ , "!   +7(#'  *(  &+ ("  !$  #%  *+"'!+  +# #,(#

""+!##% 8"! 1%*"%1 +# <(*(#!&!'*"&!++++*!( *"! ,,!A86/%+*#&'

(!$#%&'

"!$"!  A861 +&& # #,(#+!$1*#(+++1"!  $#  "!,&'#*!(  !$  *( +#* #*!(  (  !#%  $!, '*#*+ "% ''

 *(+##% ""+1 +&&  ($*'*(#%!#!$ ' (*#*!( '%*$0*"* ' *+# # !(

D D

(  &+(# #*!(  !$  "% ''

(  *(  #%  !#  !$  ' ( *#*!( '%*$0*"* ' *+# # !("!&*+!$!",(#+ '*&!(*(#%"% ''

(1+&&'*#!#% ""+$!$"!+#+ &! *("#*!( 6/%($*(*(#% ##%!$$("( "#*!(  36*+ 8"'+* '#* '!#!$++*!(+' ( *#*!( '%*$0*"* ' *+# # !("!,,*###%"

+#!#% !#!$' (++*!(+0 !( *! # 4 $!,1%*#1 +(#+##!#%!#!$' (*#*!( '++*!(+ 0 !( 5

("*&#!$"

+*(#%!#' (*#*!( '++*!(+ 0 !(!+ *(#% #&*, $ "*"% $!!$$("+( "#*!(+5 361 +*+"'!+  *(+##% ""+%1 "% +%# ""!*('#!1%*"%%&' (!#*'# ("'

*, #* ' 4 B*(#%"!+!$*#+ *("#%&!+"#*!(8 ,*( #%$!''!1*(1*#(+++ 6E- !(+# ' # 6 < +%+# ##% #!( 4 1%*'%1 +&!+# #6!'*"# #*!(   !(!(#% # !( "*&#!$1*##(*(#*, #*!(A86$!,6+%&

'*-!+&*# ' !( % '!(1*#% !(+# '1(##% (+,*## &&'*"

#*!( A86 #!#%!"#!*(7**( !#$*#(++!$*( %% *(%#!

, <+# #,(#=#%!"#! *!&*(*!(A86 9"'

%*,$*##!!

+!#% $# +# #,(# !$%% *(% A86 1 +  "! !( 1%*"%%, %*+(!+,(#A86B!(#% +*+!$1%*"%BB !: # 41 +(#-$#%+# ##% #%% ,! 

&&'*"

#*!(A862+<*(!&*(*!(!$#%!"#! !#( #!$

5 *+  !(  #%  &+!(  !$  ;

+%' (  *  !&*(*!(  A8629  #% *+1"'

#!+*,&' (!( +*,*'

 &&'*"

#*!(A86

$*'%*,1*#% #!#%*( *+!(#%&+!(!$ (!

#% !"#! *%*+!&*(*!(A86 9% "'

#%*( *+#!* !+ "

+1*#% '(#1 &!(-$#% #% #%% +,*##

&&'*"

#*!(A86-+<*(#%!&*(*!(!$#%!"#! !##%( #!$ #%*( *+!(#%&+!(!$%% *(% ( *!&*(*!(A86-9 #%!"#!"'

#%*( *+#! (!+/%1*#(+++# ##% # !(#%+ , $!, '23("#*!(+95361 +"! 3

*(% (#% #!(D 4%% ,!  &&'*"

#*!( A860$!# <*(!&*(*!(!$#%!"#! *(( #!$*( *+!(#% &+!(!$%% *(% (#%!"#! *!&*(*!(A8609"'

 #%*( *+ + (!+"

+ '(#1 &!( ($!#% # +!( !$$("("#*!( 361 + ""!*(#!#%*+1*#(++% % !(#!#%+&!#!(#%+ ,  (% && !%+*#&'

!$#%&'

"!$#%*("*(#A86 (#% $##%*( +#* #*!(1 % (! #!3;

 (*(% !*($#%#%1*#(+++# ##% # !(C 43;

 (*(%% *(#! # ""+ #*+%*(%*+ &+("*(#%"!+!$1%*"%#% ""++$$ *+"'!+ +# #,(#A86? (!(#% +*+#%!$%!##% 8"!  1%*"%1 +# <(*(#!&!'*"&!++++*!( *"! ,,!A86 6E 1 (;, B %#+, (+# ##% #!(: 4 %1 +&!+# ++"%*(#%!$$*"!$6 !( (!(#% # % % !(#!#%+&!# (!(&!*(#*(!#!$"!,&'

(#%%  *(%%% && +"

'+*#&'

(A86 6E3

*(%&!+#% #!( 41%*'&!+#

4

#6!'*"# #*!(   !(!("*&#!$+# #,(#A86!$ "!,&'

(#%% *(%1*#%(!+,(#- # 6 < +% A86B  %  %   "!  $!, '  23  A86  -  %   &!   %*+ (!+,(# +A86A9 6ED%% *(%6E (!

(6EC;

+%' ''

!$#%,*(*( &! *#%1*#(++ ""!(#!$#%*("*(# +&&!#*(#%&!+"#*!(+#!!(, #* ' +&"#+ 6E53(+&"#! #& '+# ##% #!(DD 41%*'% +&!+# +- #6!'*"# #*!(   !(!(#% # !( "!,&'#*!(!$*( +#* #*!(*(#%*+"

+%% && &!#( "#*!(6 6E4BB& < % #* +# ##% #!( 41%*'% +&!+# +!(+'# (# *!'!*+# #6+%&

'*-!+&*# ' !( !(#% # %%  *!'!*"

''8 ,*(%% *(%$#!

%*,B # 8( (%!+ ++&"#'*( $ "#*( #%'$#$!(# ' (& *# '!(+ *%*+&!#A86B $#+*(8  $*',+A86 (A86 /%  1*#(++  +# #  #% #  !(  #%  + ,     %  %   *!'!*"

''8 ,*(*( ;

+%' #(!!(*( 1 +$!( !(%&+!(-+,*##%*+&!#*(#% #  +A86A (8  $*',+A86 (A86D 6E:3 ( ,+# ##% #!(: 41%*'%1 &!+# #6!'*"# #*!(   !(*(#%*( +#* #*!(!$#% "

+%% "!+# #,(#!$ 1 (;, B %#+, ( +%*'

!(55 4 (#% #%% "!''"##%# #,(#"!!$#% $!,6+%&

'*-!+&*# ' !(

 6E B # 8( +# ##% #!( 4%1 &!+# +!(*(6+%&

'*-!+&*# ' !(/%*+1*#(++%  !%##%# #,(#$*'+!$;

+%'  (!

(%% *(% 1%*"%%&'

"!("! +A86 A866 (A86F+&"#* '- &! %*+!&*(*!(1*#% #!#%( #!$*( *+!(#%&+!(+!$ ;

+%' +A8629 +*,&'*(( # (!

+A86 9

* !+*(( #1*#%'(#1 &!( (%% *(% +A86-9

 (!+*(( #+&"#* ' 6EB(*' !'1%!% ,*"!' ''8 ,*(#% #%*( !( 4 #6+%&

'*-!+&*# ' !(&!+*( #% # &! *(#%?+!$#%*(  (!

+A86;

+%'

+ A86 (%% *(% +A86/ /% *( *+ $!( !(#% &+!(+!$*( 1 +$!''!1+ &610$% & +-0% & ! & 6  ?

" #  1!(  *%#     '*(  1 +  &+(#  (# '

 !+++#,"!(+"*!+!*(# &610$% & +-0% & !7 1%+.2

 ' ('

" #1!(C8",! $!(#!& *# '*!(

'*(1 +&+(# &610$% & +-0% & !++

0$&8+  ' ('

" #1!(48",! $!(# '*!(1 +&+(#  ' ('

" #1!(8",1 +&+(#! $!(# '*!(  ' ('

" #1!(D8",1 +&+(#! & *# '*!( 6E3;

 (*(%#%3( +#* #*( $$*"!$#%*+ "

+  &!+  1*#%     #!  #%  *( +#* #*!(  "!("#    %*, *("'*( +#*( ""+ #*+%!(C 4 (*(#! #*(%*,

C *(#%"!+!$1%*"% ""+ #*+%% +$$ *+"'!+ +# #,(# (!# 8A86"! $!,%*+&!++++*!(*(&+ (" #%!$1%*"%% (# <(*(#!&!'*"&!++++*!(  E*#%#% ##%&!+"#*!( *("!#"!("' C # #,(#!$#% ""+1 +"!("#*!( 6*(1%*"% ''#%*("*,*( #*("*",+# ("+ && *(  *(+# %*,1&##!+"% ""+#%(*#% '' #*!(+"!(#(*( #% #%1 +*((!"(# (% ($ '+'*( !' *(#%*+"

+!(

""!(#!$& #$ "#*!( '*+,*(#% *''

=#%"!,&'

(#1 +% *(

( *'!(%*+&'!# (1 (##!!+#%*,#%$!,=!( 4 %1 +!(#*( !'( (2 ,-!+ +  $!,C &, #!C  , ( *+&#1 +!*(!(#1(G*'*(% (#% "!,&'

(#& # : ""+*(!#'  ( *("*(%*+$("   $#% *( ,(#+' (#* '!#"!( *"# ( +(#("#% ""+ +,(#*!(+& 

(  (  &&'*"

#*!(  % *(  (  $*'    %*,  %  1 ' +!(*(#*, *'#!( '%*,#!$*' && '*(#%*+!#  "% ,(#!$"!( *"#*!( (!!$+(#("'$#

""+ *  (%% +$*'#%&+(# && '1%*"%1 +# <( &!(   (*#1 + ,*##$!'

% *( (!(#% , !( &&'*"

#*!(("#*!(C:6% *(($*' #% &&''

(#9 ""+$!++&(+*!(!$%*+, *(*(+(#("#% ,1 + ''!1 (, *(*(+(#("!$#% &&''

(#9 ""+1 ++&(*(#%&(("!$#% && ' (#% &&''

(#1 !#!' +!( *'+ "##!#%+ #*+$ "#*!(!$%*$0*"* '

:  *+# # !(  !1#% && '% +"!,&$!$*( '% *(  3% % ' ("!(+'$!#% &&''

(#@ ""+ "!( *"#  ' (  '   !"

#  ( '  $!  #%  # #  !$  - 

+*+!*(#%!%#%"! D 3(  #%*+  "

+  #%  !"'

  +*!(  1 +  &! *   #% *6ED%% *(%6E (!

(6EC;

+%' ''

#%  !$  #%,  +&&!#  #%  &!+"#*!(  +#!  !(  , #* '  +&"#+ "

#!*"

''+# #*(#% #*#1 +#% ""+1%!% *($'*"#*( *+#!

#%,/%1"!++8 ,*( #'(#%!(% '$!$#% ""+# #%+#"<#!#%*(+ ("!'(!#+% ##!( (, #* '&!*(# /%+1*#(+++% *(+$$*( *+*(#%*("*(# +# ,& 1*#(+++ (#%*&+(" ##%+&!#"

((!#!#2!#%  +!(#% ##%+1*#(+++% +$$*( *+( #!$*( *+!( #%&+!(!$%% *(%!&*(#! (!+#!'*$ (!

* !+*(( # (;

+%' +*,&'*#1!'% ( (+# ( !!$ ''#%#%1*#(+++#!(+#% ##%&+!(+&!(+*' $!"

+*(*( *+#!#%,*+!%##!!!< (*+&(*+%+*# '  #%#% ##,&#*(#!+%*'#% "# '"'&*# (*( !' +!, *((!"(#&+!(*(%*+&'

"1*#%!# (%,! +!(/% ""!(# !$  #%  *("*(#  * (    #%,  *+  ( # '  (  &! '  *(+&**( "!($*(" (3$*(#%+ ,#!1!#%!$'* (" 5 /%  ,*"

'   *("  '  "!!! #+  #%  !"'

  *("/% ""+ $#%*+ +#*(*(#! #*!(% !##%

8+*(#%*("*(#"! $!,%*+&!++++*!( 4 /%*( +#* #*!(*(#%*+"

+% +("!("#*( $ *



(*,& #* ', ((/%3 *+(!#+%!1(#!%  (,!#* #!

"% ''

(#% ""+*(#%*+"

+1!(' (#!&!+  *(+#%*, $ '+'#!+"%*+"!( *"#*!(  /%, *(*( *(" "#%&!+"#*!(*+!$ "!!! #* ( # (+&&!#+*#+"

+, #* ''/% ""+%  $ *'#!( ( +!( '!&'

+*'8&'

#*!($!%*+ '' $ '+*,&'*"

#*!(*(#%*+"

+/%&' # <(%*,#% ##%*+&#% 

*+(+*("#%"!,&'

(#& #1 (##!# <$!"*'&!++++*!(!$ #%&'!#$!,%*,#!+%!1#% #(!# ( (*!# !$ *("% +( !%#!("!#% ""+*(#% # !!#&*, *'*#*+ #!$#%&!+"#*!(#!&! *#+"%   *(+##% ""+!(

+% !1!$ +!( '!# ( ""+*+(!#8&"##!&! %*+ $("  +*!(  1*#%  + ,  8 "#(++  (  *!  1*#%  1%*"%  #% &!+"#*!(*+7*#!&! *#+"%   *(+##% ""+##%( +!,&'

+*'8&'

#*!(+%!'#% +#!1%!#!$+"% +# &!&'

#*!(  #%  ""+  % +  (  # #    %*+  '''  $ '+' *,&'*"

#*(%*,*(#%*+"

+ C + ' !+ <&*(*( *1#%( #!$*( *+ +$$%% *(% ( (!

;, #%*+'*##'&!++**'*# !$#%*% *(++#*## '"'&*# ""+1*#%!# (%,!  +!(/%!#%$ "#+ ("*",+# ("+!$#%"

+&!*(#!##!1 + %*+*( !' ,(#*(#%"

+ (%*+% *("

+*( *+#!%%  *(%   (!

(  ;

+%'   /%  ""+  % +  (!#  '  ( ! '  ! !",(#  *("#!+%!1#% #%% *($ "#(*(&!++++*!(!$ #%&'!#$!,1%#%"!,&'

(#& #1 (##!!+#%*, : (!#%*,&!# (##%*(#!+(*+#% # ""+1%*'

 *(8 ,*(("#*!(6% # <(& &' !$ '** "!(#(*(#% # + , ##!$$ "#%1 +!(#*( !'( ( ,-!+ +   ##%' (##*,3$#% #1 ++!%"!'  1''+,,!(%*+,&'!! (!#%+&!(+*'&+!(, *( #% $$ *+!$ !'( (2 ,-!+#!+%!1#% # + , ##!$$ "#

""+1 +!(# # !'( (2 ,-!+ ##%#*,!$ *("*(# (%"!'(!#&!++*'#% ##%+&!#+*,'# (!+'

#(!+"% *("% ( "   /%  *+  (!#%*(  !(  "!  #!  +%!1  #% #  ""+  %  +,*## (1*##(&+(# #*!(#!#%%*%&!'*"!$$*"+! !#%1*(+!$ ,*(*+# #*!(#% #%1 +*((!"(# (% ($ '+' *( !' *(#%*+"

++ ' !+ #%3 % (! +!(#!

*( !' #% ""+*(#%*+"

+1!('2 '+*,&'*"

#*!(*( "*,*( '

"

+*+  +*!+!$$(" ( &!'*"!$$*"*('*(*(+"%#& !$#%*(+(+#%*+<!$+$$*(+*!+'*(%*++ *"" *(

*#*!(#!#%&!++*'&!+"#*!( ( (!*(#!

*'/%$! ('++  +#!( +!(*+#%#%&!'*"!$$*"+!(!#*('*( +'

&&*($ '+"

++&!(*((!"(#&+!(+( ''/%"!,&'

(# & #!+(!#"!,!##!"

*( %*%$*( ("* '!&!'*#*"

'

"'!#+! +#!, <#%'!"

'&!'*" ("#!*#+#(+/%$!&' !$ $ '+*,&'*"

#*!(&#$!1  ""+"

((!# ""&#  /%&!+"#*!(% &! *#+"

+  *(+##% ""+ "!("'+* ' ( $$*, #* '!( +% !1!$ +!( '!# /% ,(#!$"!( *"#*!(& ++#%#* '!#*+1'' +!( !( +&!(&!& && *+ ' ( &&"* #*!(!$ *(" ( "!"#*(#&# #*!(!$'

1/%*+(!*'' '*#!*($*,*##%*(

  + +#%+(#("& #<&*(*( *1#%(,!$ &+!(+#!1%!,#% ""+% "

+*( *+#%( #!$*( *+ +$$#%, (#%$ "##% ##% ""+% "

+*( *+#!

#%,1*#%!# (&! !"

#*!(#%+(#(" #!#% ""+  #% && +#!!('!1+*3( ("

+#%*+"# *('(!

+"!&$!"#*!(*(7 (#,!$+(#("  ++"%#% ,(#!$"!( *"#*!( (!!$+(#("

&%'1% + && '*+$!(#!1*#%!# (,*# (#%+ , *+*+,*++ ""!*(' D &&''

(# #*+%*++# ##!!( *' (##!%*, #%*+!#-*+ *'*+"

("''%*$0*"* ' *+# #  ,*+ *"##!*++ +#1  (#+#!#%*, +#+! +#!, <%*, (!#%, *(*(+(#("    ))

()*)     0$6 E%#%+& <*(9 +!(  H+9!

E%#%&!# '  H+9!