High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/447/2010disposed of

Mahipal And ORS. v. State Of Haryana

2015-09-28Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik9 pages

" #$%&% '( ")*+,- . /% '# "/& 0

&'"(

/% 12 ,#0 $ "

/%3 / %2 ,#0 $ " "/ '"&

/%4%05 %'%,&&%&" '", 6 '

"/& '#'"

" "

! "

# $ "%$ 78&9&6$/ " %$ 7*&" '$&$",:+- ;/%' ")'"% '# &"/$"<, '#%'# 7" 6)'" %',"

7'#8 7"/%)%& ')'" % # '6 $/= / 0%'8*'

7'#%' &&&&% "/5% 8 )& $/ &2%"/ 7" '6)%" %$'$

$&& 6 $"& *%6 ' "#, " "/ $" "/ " "/ '"&2 /'## " ' 5 %#*6"/ %$ '"/# %' #%"62 " "/ %72/%#%0%'8 . 7"%$ 2%"/ 7"/ 0%'8'7)* " '"/ '",$ )%'8 )"/&%# '&%/ 25,3 ' '&%'8 "/ %$ "6,"/#%0"%#"

"7'* $5"

2 #& '&%/ 25*7"/ 2 & /'## '82%"/$ ,2/%$/* '7)* '"/ &%#*%'8

>> ::/6 7'8* 6&2&%""%'8%'"/$ 2/ #%&$ &#"/% ' )& &. /% , ) '#

%'8/,&'" '"&/2 & $ )$ 7$ "/* 8*"2'"/"2 & "&%'&%#"/$ '

&7&%$% ','

"%$7'# '- "/ $ "%$ 78&9&6$/ " %$

7*&" '$&$",:+-2 &&0#,2/7 ' "/6 7"/ &# %"/%'

"/'0&"%8 "%'8%$ $/ "/* 80 #$/ &%'"/* 82

& )& -8 )& $/2& "# '#"/) %'%'8$ '" * '# 2%8/#"

5% 8 )& '#: 8 )& / ", "/'$&& 6 ) %"%& & $ '") "# 7'# "/ $" 8 #%'8 $ 06 2 $ )"#

)"/$/$5%'8 "/# &/* # "/$ , ' ;?><

"/$ '# ' %# 0%" '# %'8/;?< '82%"/"/$ 2" 5'%'"

&&&&% '0%#)) ? "%"&7&2 & / '## 0"

"/'0&"%8 "%'8%$ 7@ 2 &&'""

"/ %$

" "% ', '"/* &%& 2/%$/ ) 2 &$ ##*6 ) %'8/

%" ' "/ $ $ 062 & # '#&" ")'"& "/ 2%"'&&&2$ ##"/ $$7&#2 &"# "/ $$7&#,2%"'&&&,$ & "6 '#& )&2 #7$#* /% 137) ,'&$"

, %$ " "% '%"63 ' 0%%$ "% "/ $"&,2/ , "%'@7%6 * 7""/ $"& "/$ & )"/ $$7&# '#"/2%"'&&&,7"/%&& '"/& )& &2 & "/$ & "6 '#"/'#%$"#"/'0&"%8 "%'8%$" # &%""/ & )2%"/"/. "/ %$ " "% ' "7'# '- "/ $"2 & # '>+,"/'0&"%8 "%'8%$"

5"/$ & "6 &2 &"/& )& )"/. "/ %$ " "% ' '# #7$#"/ & ) &2 &"/ $$7&#* "/ @ . 8%&" "*6) 0%'8 '

%$ "% '7'# '- "/$";?+<'0'"

6?:2 & #,/ "

8 /&?"

?+2" 5' '#"/ ""/ @ . 8%&" "%&&7#$"%%$ "?:"$ )"% "/%'0&"%8 "% '&, "/$/ '2 &&'"#%'"/$ 7" "%

%'#%'8 %) $% $ & 8 %'&" "/ $$7&#, "/6 2 $/ 8&/"#7'# ' #2%"/ '+ "/$","

2/%$/ "/6#%#'

" #87%"6 '#$ %)#"% '&7 " %"&$ &,"/ &$7"% '? )%'#&%?2%"'&&&, 2/ ),*7" '2 %$ %$% &A> '# %'8/%&"/ &"2/% 2' "/) 7"%$ %'0 0#%'"/$ ))%&&% "/$%) "$ '$7&% "/ &$7"% '0%#'$,&" ")'"& "/ $$7&#2$ ##7'# '>> '# "/%'$%)%' "%'8

) "% %'8 8 %'&""/)%'"/ &$7"% '0%#'$27""

"/),"

2/%$/"/6#'%# $/ &$7"% ' 8 "% ' '# ##"/% %''

$'$ "/ %'8* "/"/$ "/ "%& '# %&%'8"/ '"% 0%#'$ '# ) "% ' $ #, "/ "% $ 7" $ ## )'"% '#17#8)'" $ '0%$"% ' '# # '&'"'$ A / 0 / # '# 7'& "/ "%& '# 8 ' "/ 78/"/'"%) "% $ )%'8 '$ #

%&" ,%"2 & 87#*6 '# "/ $$7&# '"&"/ ""/2 &'

%'#'#'"$ * "% "/0%#'$ 0 % * '$ # &"/ &$7"% '$ &,"/ $ 8# $ 06%& 7*%$ $A- B %" %'8/# &#"/ " '&%$/ 25%& *7&6 $ 2$ )%'8 '#8 %'8 ""/ ""%) 7"/ # &#"/ "/"%#"

1 %'"/7*%$& '&%'"/%'0&"%8 "% '&*7""/6 ?&&#"/%%' *%%"6 & &" "#"/ "/#%#'

"" 5 '6 $"% '

8 %'&""/ && '& A%"/"/%&&" ")'" '0&"%8 "%'8%$,%"%& 0%#'""/ "'

? ' "% '%&8%0'*6"/'0&"%8 "%'8%$ &"

2/6 /#%#'

"" 5 '6 $"% ' 8 %'&" '6 "/ &7*%$& '&2/ 7&# "

1 %'"/%'0&"%8 "% '& "/$ &%&&%)&" ")'""/ ""/7*%$ & '&?&&#"/%%' *%%"6"

1 %'"/%'0&"%8 "% '%&'

"&7%$%'""

*& 0"/'0&"%8 "%'8%$ /%&% *%%"6"

1 %'"/%'#'#'"

2%"'&&&%'"/%'0&"%8 "% "/$ & 0' "/2%&,&" ")'" '0&"%8 "%'8 %$ "/ " "/ 7*%$ 2%"'&&& 7&# " 1 %' "/ %'0&"%8 "% ' %& 0 87 &" ")'" '# $ ''

" * *%0# 7*%$

- 2%"'&&&2 0 % *"/'"/6&/ 7#*1 %'# '#%'

","/'& ) & ' *? ' "% '&/ 7#*8%0''"/%&8 #,// & & $%"# .

/%'# %'8/0 $%&'"("%( '&$)

"/ '"&

+ $% '

"("%( ' #

* * , - * +./*0

'0&"%8 "%'8%$ +.!(1 23

+./*0

4 2 ,

5 ",&&,

6 '0&"%8 "%'8%$ 6

* 7 "/ '"&

/ 1 5 89- : - '# "/

" ""/ "#7%'8"/$ 7& $/$5%'8 "/0/%$,"/$/ &2 & 7'# %' * 86%'8%'"/$ $$7%#*6"/ $$7&# '"&,"/ ,%"%& $ & $/ '$$ 06/$/ &2 &'

"$ 0# )"/& "/ $$7&# '-%& %$ * '6%'"/ &$ &&2/"/$/ & 2 &$ 0# '& ' & $/ "/ $$7&#/ & & $%"# #0

%'8/0 " " 7'1 *,::+;< ;<>'"/ "$ &,%"2 &/# "/ "%'$ & $/ '$$ 06, 0%&% '& '- "/$" '

%$ * 3%'8%'0%2"/ * 0 87)'" '# "/

" " '#7"/"/ $""/ "0'"/ 78/ '- "/$"2 &'

%$ *%'"/%&$ &,6"'

"%$&7'# '- "/$"28%0'"

"/ $$7&#2/%$/ ?/%*%"# &?-"

? '#"

"/ &'

"%$&,

$$7&#8 0"/%6?+"

? &%'8$ '%#'$%'

"/'0&"%8 "%'8%$ & $/ '#7'#"/ &$%$7)&" '$&,"/ '0&"%8 "%'8%$ "/$ &"

5"/& $/ "/* 86%'8%'*"2'

"/"2 & "& "/$ &&7$/,"/ * 0$ '"'"% '# 7'& "/ '"&%&'

"&7&" %' * "2 &'?" 87#*6 '# "/ '"&"/ "%'

"/%&$ &,$ 06 %$ &2 &"/'0&"%8 "%'8%$%&"/& ) 2/%$/%& 8 %'&""/&""# 2 &"/$ 06 %$2 7#8 7" "/ 2 6"

&/ 2&7$$&& /%&$ &*6 # "%'8 '6) '&&&7$/,&%'$"/ %'0&"%8 "% "/%&$ &%&$ '#7$"#*6"/ %$ %$2/ $ '#7$"# "/& $/ '#&%D7 "/$ '" * '#,"/ ,"/ $$7&#%&'"%"#"

$@7%"" / * 0 87)'" '# 7'& "/ $$7&# '"&%&#0 %# '6 $ &%'"/%&$ &,2/'"/ %$ "62 & &'" ' " '#0/%$$/$5%'8 " 8%7 #' / 82 % & 8'$6, ) 7"% $ $$7%# *6 "/ $$7&# '"& 2 & &'

$ )%'8 ) '&%/ 25&%#'&%'8"/ %$ "6,"/#%0 "/ & %#$ "7'#* $5"/0/%$"

2 #& '&%/ 25 '# "/ & $%$7)&" '$&, "/ '0&"%8 "%'8 %$ 2%"/ "/ / %$

%$% &$ 7# /'#"/$ ""/& " '#"/ " '%'@7%6,"/ $$7&# '"&#%&$ &#"/%%#'"%"6 '#"/ " '$/$5%'8 "/ $ , $ )$ 7$ "/* 82 & 7'#%'*"2'"2 & "&%'&%#"/$ "8%0%'8'

"%$7'# '- "/$" '# *" %'%'8%& "/ $$7&#,"/& $/ "/ & %#* 82 &$ '#7$"# '#"/&

+ $%$7)&" '$&,"/@7&"% "/'0&"%8 "%'8%$*%'8$ ) %' '"

"/$ &# &'

" %&"%& $ & $/ '$$ 06 "/$ '" * '# *6"/ %$ %$2/%/2 & '#7"6 0/%$$/$5%'8 "2 & &"6 87#*6 '# "/ '"& $$7&#"/ "&%'$"/ 8#$ 062 &) # ) * 86%'8%'"/ $ , "/ , %" $ ''

" * & %# "/ " "/ $$7&# '"& 2 %'

$ '&$% 7& &&&&% ' "/ $ '" * '# &%)6 *$ 7& "/6 2

$$76%'8"/0/%$,%"$ ''

"*& %#"/ " $/ ' "/)2 &%'

?$7&%0 &&&&% "/$ '" * '# / * 0 87)'"%& 8 %''

"&7&" %' * &%"%&"/&""# &%"% 2"/ "%'$ & '6 "/ $$7 '"& "/$ " 5&7"/ #'$"/ "/2 &'

"5'

2%'8"/ ""/0/%$2 &$ 6%'8 $ '" * '#, // &"

&/ 2"/ "/2 &/ 0%'8'

2#8 * 7"%"

' "/ $$7&#/ &" 5'&7$/ #'$2/'"/%&" ")'"&7'# '>> 2$ ##/$ "/* 8$ '" %'%'8>5% 8 )& $/ &2 & 7'#6%'8%'*"2'"/"2 & "&%'&%#"/$ . /% 2 &#%0%'8 "/ & %#$ 2/ & ) 2 &&%""%'8 '"/ & " '#

%'8/2 &&%""%'8 '"/& "'?""

"/#%0& "/06 $" "7'%'8 * $5"/$ '&%'8"/ %$ "67"/&/ 2&"/ ""/ $$7 '"& "/$ 20625'

2%'8 * 7""/&'$ $ '" * '#%'"/$ 2/%$/"/62$ 6%'8 %'$ "/"/ $$7&#2 $$76%'8"/ $ 2/%$/2 &$ 6%'8>5% 8 )& $/ &,"/ , "/) 0#"

*%'$ '&$% 7& &&&&% "/$ '" * '# '"/'#,%" 2 & & 87#*6 '# "/

'"&"/ "%'$ & / #%'8"/ '"

$$7&#87%"6,'%'"0%2 ) 6*" 5'8 #%'8) "" &'"'$"2 &&"&&#"/ " "/"/ '"

$$7&# 7') %#="/6 "/&&="/6/ 0" &7 "

"/% )%%&"%&"/%%&" '$ '#'

" '6"/ ","/6 & "

%& "/% 2' )%%& 5%'8%'"

$ '&%# "% '"/ & %# 87)'"& '# "/ '"& $$7&# '#7"/5%'8%'0%2"/ $""/ " %"%& $ & $ ))$% @7 '"%"6,2 "/0%2"/ ""/'#& 17&"%$2 7#*)"%"/&'"'$ "/ $$7&#%&#7$# )6 & "

6 &&&7$/,"/ '"

$$7&# ##"

7'#8 %8 7& %)%& ')'" % # 6 & $/ '#"

6 %' & $ $/ $ ))%""%'8"/ '$7'%&/ *7'# ' #2%"/

'+ "/ $ "%$ 78&9&6$/ " %$ 7*&" '$&$",:+-, '# %' # 7" 6)'" %', "/6 &/ 7"/ 7'#8 %8 7& %)%& ')'" % # '6 $/'%" '+ * & 8%0'"

"/)

"/ & '&$ ## * 0,%'#%'8'

)%"%'"/%& , ) %'" %'%'8 "/ 17#8)'" $ '0%$"% ' # "# : '# # '

&'"'$# "#,2%"/"/) #%%$ "% '%'"/ # &'"'$, & %'#%$ "# * 0,"/ %&#%&)%&&# ;

<; < #