High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/223/2011dismissed

Parmjit v. State Of Punjab

2017-09-26Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri9 pages

Sumit Gulati 2017.11.03 09:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

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

))%-(.(!%(!$(.7(*( *0(*(0% *2!$ !$2**(!%)4

-($&.( /%-('* .($2%# !#!3*#(/#.%-&% !@ 6

A&3&)#!1-*($(#"(0&%()('- !#$+(..&1(/* + #"#) .'#%&)&)&!0-&* *(1&*0#!1&0+#..# ! /%-('* .($2%*#= B-#)(%-('* .($2%*#=7&.&1(0 !)484(&*.&!0.-(7&.2!&3)(% +&C(&.%&%(+(!%-(*/&%-(*&)#' 2*+2;B8?1 %*($ *0(0-#..%&%(+(!%7-#$-#.&./ )) 7. D

# $

% &' ()# *

# # #!

+ # ,-((../&,01

!* # !

&2#

! &#3 45

# &

3 !

&& # 0! % 5 '!

+ & &!

3 !

# & 6 # # *

8 # 5

# 3

& # &!

!%-(3&.#. /%-(&/ *(.&#0.%&%(+(!% 0&%(0 @ 6= ;?7&.*(1#.%(*(0&% )#$(%&%# ! &+3*&#.%*#$% &)&!0-&* -(.' %7&.#!"(.%#1&%(0 #%(')&!= 7&.'*('&*(0 !

%-( .&+( 0&4 %-( &$$2.(0 7&. &**(.%(0 &!0 +(0#$&))4 (=&+#!(0 34 * (.- &,(0#$&) //#$(* #"#) .'#%&)&)&!0-&*"#0(&'')#$&%# !

= &!0 -('* .($2%*#=7&.&). +(0#$ )(1&))4(=&+#!(0&%

#"#) .'#%&)&)&!0-&* (&)(0'&*$().$ !%&#!#!1%7 "&1#!&).)#0(. %7 "&1#!&).7&3.&!02!0(*7(&*7(*(.(!%/ * -(+#$&)=&+#!&%# !

.'(* -(+#$&)=&+#!(*:.*(' *%;= A?.'(*+&% E &7(*(0(%($%(0 #!%-($ !%(!%. /%-*(('&*$()..(!%/ *(=&+#!&%# ! @

!$ +')(%# ! /#!"(.%#1&%# !' )#$(*(' *%2!0(*($%# ! 8 *

7&./#)(07-(*(34&$$2.(07&.$-&*1(.-((%(0&!0$-&*1(. 2!0(*($%# !.8885&!08 7(*(/*&+(0&1&#!.%%-(&$$2.(0% 7-#$--(')(&0(0! %12#)%4&!0$)&#+(0%*#&)

! *0(* % '* "( #%. $&.( %-( '* .($2%# ! (=&+#!(0 F 7#%!(..(.

-(.%&%(+(!% /&$$2.(02!0(*($%# !88 *

7&.

*($ *0(032%-(0(!#(0%-(&))(1&%# !.&1&#!.%-#+&!0$)&#+(0#!! $(!$( 3(#!1/&).()4#+')#$&%(0 ')(&7&.%&C(!34&$$2.(0%-&%-(-&0&

@ G2&**()7#%-$ !%*&$% *2!0(*7- +-(&.7())&.$ +')&#!&!%&)#' 2*+27(*(7 *C#!1&!0#%7&.&%-#.;$ !%*&$% *?#!.%&!$(%-&%&/&).( $&.(-&.3((!1 %*(1#.%(*(0&1&#!.%-#+

-(%*#&) 2*%&/%(*$ !.#0(*#!1%-(("#0(!$( !*($ *0 $ !"#$%(0&!0.(!%(!$(0%-(&$$2.(0&''())&!%&.0(%&#)(0&3 "(

(!$(%-('*(.(!%&''(&)

(&*!(0$ 2!.()/ *%-(&''())&!%$ !%(!0(0%-&%%-(*(#.! ("#0(!$(% '* "(%-($-&*1(.&1&#!.%%-(&''())&!%&.! %(.%7&. $ !02$%(0 (/2*%-(*$ !%(!0(0%-&%%-(&''())&!%-&.3((!/&).()4 #+')#$&%(0&%%-(#!.%&!$( /%-($ !%*&$% *&!0%-(' )#$(-&0/&#)(0% $ !02$% & /&#* #!"(.%#1&%# !

2*%-(* %-( '* .($2%# ! -&0 /&#)(0 % (=&+#!(23-&.#+ %-(* /%-('* .($2%*#=

!%-( %-(*-&!0)(&*!(0$ 2!.()/ *%-(%&%(.23+#%%(0 %-&% %-&% %-('* .($2%# ! -&. '* "(0 #%. $&.(3(4 !0 %-(.-&0 7 / *(&. !&3)( 0 23% &!0 %-( &''())&!% -&. 3((! *#1-%)4 $ !"#$%(0 &!0 .(!%(!$(034%-(%*#&) 2*%

(&*0)(&*!(0$ 2!.()/ *%-('&*%#(.&!0'(*2.(0%-(*($ *0 $&*(/2))4

-(#!.%&!% 7&.*(1#.%(*(0 !%-(3&.#. /%-(.%&%(+(!% +&0(34&)#'2*+2B8/&%-(* /%-('* .($2%*#= B8$&%(1 *#$&))4 0(' .(0%-&% !@ 6&%&3 2% '

+ 7-(!-(7(!%% -#.- 2.( / *)2!$-%-('* .($2%*#=7&.')&4#!1 2%.#0(-#.- 2.(7#%-%-(&$$2.(0 &!0-(() '(0&/%(*. +(%#+(7#%--#.0&21-%(* (.%&*%(0.(&*$-#!1-#.

0&21-%(*&!0-(&*0-(*$*#(./* +%-(G2&*%(* /%-(&$$2.(0 B83* C(

5 '(!%-(0 * /%-(G2&*%(* /%-(&$$2.(0&!07(!%#!.#0(&!0'#$C(02' -#.0&21-%(*7- 7&.3)((0#!1&.3) 07&.$ +#!1 2% /%-('*#"&%( '&*%. /%-('* .($2%*#= -(*(&/%(*B8% C%-('* .($2%*#=% #"#) .'#%&)&)&!0-&*&!0/2*%-(*0(' .(0%-&%-#.7#/(23&.-#&). $&2.(0 #!,2*#(. !%-('(*. ! /%-(&$$2.(0&''())&!%

B + &*C&.- 0(' .(0 %-&% ! @ 6 -( 7&.

7 *C#!1&.% *(C(('(*&%&!!(0#$#%4 .'#%&)A-&+3*&&!0&% &3 2% '

+ -(7&..%&!0#!1 2%.#0(-#. //#$(7-(*(B8&)#' 2*+2&!0-#.7#/($&+( (&$$ +'&!#(0B8&)#'2*+2&!0-#.

7#/(% %-(G2&*%(* /%-($ !"#$%&''())&!%#!.(&*$- /%-('* .($2%*#= &!0. 2!0 /$*4#!17&.$ +#!1 2% /%-(* + /&$$2.(0&''())&!%

-(0 *7&.3* C(!&!0%-(&''())&!%7&./ 2!0#!!&C(0$ !0#%# !&!0 $ ++#%%#!1*&'(2' !%-('* .($2%*#= B &). 0(' .(0%-&%3) 07&.

$ +#!1 2% /%-('*#"&%('&*%. /%-(%-('* .($2%*#=

B* -#"&4&)&)#(0#$&) //#$(* #"#) .'#%&) &)&!0-&*+(0#$ )(1&))4(=&+#!(0%-('* .($2%*#= !@ 6&%&3 2% 5'

+ &!0/ 2!0%-(/ )) 7#!1#!,2*#(. <*3#4,7

9 *3#4( 7

# 6& & ! & & !

> B#!-#.$* ..(=&+#!&%# !$&%(1 *#$&))40(!#(0%-(.211(.%# ! /%-( #!,2*#(. !%-('(*. ! /%-('* .($2%*#=&.&*(.2)% //&)) !-&*0.2*/&$(

B* &!,#%A&2*&7&(0#$&) //#$(* #"#) .'#%&) &)&!0-&* $ !02$%(0 +(0#$ )(1&) (=&+#!&%# ! / %-( '* .($2%*#= ! @ 6&%5 5'

+ &!0*($ *0(0%-(/ )) 7#!1 <5

,.( 4 #:

& 8

& : : #+

B&). 0(' .(0%-&%&/%(*1 #!1%-* 21-%-(*(' *% /%-( $-(+#$&)(=&+#!(*;= A?&.'(*7-#$-%-(.'(*+&% E &7&.0(%($%(0 ! =.

&!0.-( '#!(0%-&%' ..#3#)#%4 /.(=2&)#!%(*$ 2*.((=#.%(0

B* (.- &,(0#$&) //#$(* #"#) .'#%&)&)&!0-&* $ !02$%(0+(0#$ )(1&)(=&+#!&%# ! /&$$2.(0 !5 6&!0/ 2!0%-( / )) 7#!1#!,2*#(. !-#.'(*. ! <*3#4,7*3# # & !

53 #

2- & ! & 6 ( : *3#4( 7

! & !

3 3

# *3#427

&& !(; :(

&#&

& *3# 4-7

& !

*3#4;75 !

B* (.- &,/ 2!0%-(&$$2.(0/#%/ *'(*/ *+#!1.(=2&) #!%(*$ 2*.(&!0&). '#!(0#! -#.$* ..(=&+#!&%# !%-&%%-(&/ *(.&#0 #!,2*#(. !%-('(*. ! /%-(&$$2.(0$ 2)03(&.&*(.2)% /3(&%#!1.1#"(! % -#+

B@A&3&)#!1-7- 7&.%-(#!"(.%#1&%#!1 //#$(*#!%-#. $&.(0(' .(0% %-((//($%%-&% !@ 6-(7&.' .%(0&% )#$(%&%# !

&+3*& %()('- !#$+(..&1(7&.*($(#"(07#%-*(1&*0% &0+#..# ! /%-( '* .($2%*#=&% #"#) .'#%&)&)&!0-&*&!0-(*2.-(0% %-( #"#) .'#%&)

.%-('* .($2%*#=7&.&1(0 !)484(&*.&!0.-(7&.2!&3)(% +&C(& .%&%(+(!%%-(*(/ *(%-(.%&%(+(!% /-(*/&%-(*B8;&)#'2*+2?7&. *($ *0(0 ! %-( .&+( 0&4 !( &*#!0(* &) &!&1(* '* 02$(0 %-( &$$2.(0&!0-(7&.&**(.%(0 -(*(&/%(*-(1 %%-(&$$2.(0+(0#$ )(1&))4 (=&+#!(0 /* + #"#) .'#%&) &)&!0-&* ( &). 1 %%-('* .($2%*#= +(0#$ )(1&))4(=&+#!(0/#*.%)4/* +B* -#"&4&)&)#(0#$&)

//#$(* #"#) .'#%&)&)&!0-&*7- ! %(00 7!%-(#!,2*#(..2//(*(034 %-('* .($2%*#=&!0. 21-%%-( '#!# ! / 4!&(('%% -(*(&/%(*B * &!,#%A&2*&7&+(0#$ )(1&))4(=&+#!(0%-('* .($2%*#=&!0-&!0(0

F "(*/ 2*'&*$().7-#$-7(*(.(!%% %-( -(+#$&)=&+#!(* B@#!-#.

$* ..(=&+#!&%# ! -&0 0(' .(0 %-&% ! @ 6 -( *(&$-(0 #"#) .'#%&)&)&!0-&*&%&3 2%@ '

-( $&.( / %-( '* .($2%# ! 7&. 3&.(0 ! (4( 7#%!(.. &$$ 2!% B8&)#'2*+2/&%-(* /%-('* .($2%*#=&.7())&.B

+&*C&.-1&"(&! $2)&*&$$ 2!% /%-(#!$#0(!%7-#$-7&.02)4 $ ** 3 *&%(034%-(+(0#$&)("#0(!$(&002$(034B* &!,#%A&2* &7&&!0%-(*(' *% / -(+#$&)=&+#!(*:.*(' *%;= A?"#0(7-#$- .'(*+&% E &7&.0(%($%(0 !%-("&1#!&).)#0(..7&3.&!02!0(*7(&* / %-('* .($2%*#= !.#0(*#!1%-(&!&)4.#.+&0(34%-( -(+#$&)=&+#!(* #! -#. *(' *% = A B * &!,#% A&2* &7& &). '#!(0 %-&% ' ..#3#)#%4 /%-(.(=2&)#!%(*$ 2*.((=#.%(0 2*%-(*B* (.- &, &). / 2!0%-(&$$2.(0/#%/ *'(*/ *+#!1.(=2&)#!%(*$ 2*.(

-($&.( /%-('* .($2%# !7&.'*#+&*#)43&.(0 ! $2)&* %(.%#+ !4 B8&!0B -&"($&%(1 *#$&))40(' .(0%-&%%-(0 * /%-( G2&*%(* /%-(&$$2.(07&.3 )%(0/* +#!.#0(&!0%-(43* C( '(!%-( 0 *&!0/ 2!0%-(&$$2.(0!&C(0$ ++#%%#!1*&'(2' !%-('* .($2%*#= 7-#$- 7&. 02)4 $ ** 3 *&%(0 34 %-( +(0#$&) ("#0(!$( -(*(/ *( $ !.#0(*#!1 %-( &/ *(.&#0 $#*$2+.%&!$(. &!0 %-( $2)&* %(.%#+ !4 $ !02$%#!1 /%(.% /%-(&$$2.(0'&)(.#!% #!.#1!#/#$&!$( -( //(!$( 7&. $ ++#%%(0 ! @ 6 &* 2!0 9 8 '

+ -( '* .($2%*#=7&.(=&+#!(0* -#"&4&)&)#&% 5'

+ !%-(.&+( 0&4 &% 5 5 '

+ %-( '* .($2%*#= 7&. +(0#$ )(1&))4 (=&+#!(0 34 * &!,#% A&2* $$2.(0 7&. &). &**(.%(0 ! @ 6 &!0 7&.

6 +(0#$ )(1&))4(=&+#!(0 !5 6 -(*(/ *(%-(&$%# ! /%-( $ +')&#!%&.7())&.%-(#!"(.%#1&%#!1&1(!$47&.'* +'%

-($ !"#$%&''())&!%-&0! %%&C(!&!4')(&#!-#..%&%(+(!% 2!0(*($%# !88 *

%-&%%-(*(7&.&!4'*("# 2.(!+#%43(%7((!

-#+&!0%-($ +')&#!&!%H *-(0#.'2%(0-#.'*(.(!$( !%-(.' % -( #!,2*#(./ 2!0 !%-('(*. ! /%-(&$$2.(0&''())&!%-&03((!.2'' *%(0 34B8&)#'2*+2/&%-(* /%-('* .($2%*#=%-&%%-(.&+(-&"(3((! $&2.(0 34 -#. 7#/( 23&.-#!# 0(/(!$( 7&. )(0 34 %-( &$$2.(0 &''())&!%#! *0(*% ,2.%#/4-#..%&!0%&C(!#!-#..%&%(+(!%2!0(*($%# ! 88 *

%-&%%-(*(7&.. +(0#.'2%(7#%-*(1&*0% '&4+(!% /7&1(. 3(%7((!-#+&!0%-( !%*&$% * !7- .(#!.%&!$(-(-&0&))(1(0)43((! /&).()4#+')#$&%(034B8&)#'2*+2

! "#(7 / %-( &3 "( %&C#!1 #!% $ !.#0(*&%# ! %-( (4( 7#%!(..&$$ 2!%&!0%-(+(0#$&)("#0(!$( !*($ *0#%#.-()0%-&%#%7&. %-( &$$2.(0&''())&!% !)4 7- $ ++#%%(0 %-( -(#! 2. $*#+( -(*( (=#.%.! *(&. !% 0#.$&*0%-(7())$ !.#0(*(0,201(+(!%'&..(034%-( %*#&) 2*%$ !"#$%#!1&!0.(!%(!$#!1%-(&''())&!%

!"#(7 /%-(&3 "(%-(,201(+(!% /%-(%*#&) 2*%#.

2'-()0&!0%-(&''(&).%&!0.0#.+#..(0

('%(+3(*

2)&%# B-(%-(* (' *%&3)( (.

B-(%-(*'(&C#!19 (&. !(0 (.