Tarsem Singh v. Balwant Singh & ORS
!" #$% &' ()&*&+, - './
- &+012.
''+ 3+* &4&'12.#'.+ 56'
! "#$%&!&%'
+') $+3&7.&1.2&/6(&'/ +'.5''+ $+38&&./1+6(&'4'. $+ .&&/6(&'/ +'.+56' 99999 &%' ("
.5+'+&''.'&( '.5''+:5&' 6+('6 &2&' '.05*26 +6+ 6&'6
! ";*+ :
%/ 4.+7,'.&55(&' 6*6+ +6+< * ! +&060' '.5&'42''.((*++( '.*7=*''/.&7 606
''+:5&' 6 '. *' &2&' '. +56': 6 6&' +5&4+(&025( (5+ +0&( '. &2+0''6&'6 >
<+5(' &60&*+2
8&& $&+&4+/4.'.*'4&&''.'&'&2/5&+' '.&6 0&*+2 > 8&& ! 0&+& 4& &(=*+6 7, '. &'& 2.4&, *'.+', 6& +462 '.+&64 *(.(+(*0'&(/ '.5+04&*2.''05&6'.& +0'6&5&+',
.'+&*+'6(6'.&55(&'4+/ -
! 6'.*+'4&656 6+6+6&'6 > >
&6 '.&55(&' +05&60' '.4&&46 4+/ 6*+2'.56(, '.+5''/5''+:5&' .&6& 6&&55(&'6&'6 !
!";*+ :
% +&060' '. 5&''4(*'//4'.+2&+6'+ *6 &+'0,&6 '.'.+65'0&67,'.5''+4'.'.6 6&'&24'. '+'? @5+&*0 +0'.6&' 5&,0' &+'0,&6 +0'.6&' &(.65''5&,0'.'.+5&+' '.&060' 4& +''0' (05&'42''.7+&(. '.&2+0' .'+&(*+'.&6&46'.&55(&' +&'+&'+ + *6 &+' 0,/ 7*' 66 ' 2+&' '. &060' 4'. +2&+6 ' '. (05&'.05*26+6+/'.*/* + +02&',/ +/4. 602'.&55(&'/'.'+&*+''.*2.'(6'.5+ 1(' '.15( ( ('/ -<A" +.+'/'.('%7*'66'
'+5+'(++('5+5('*55+' '.& +0'6&+0'/ + ++6''.B*620' C7'.1*5+0(*+'#)*+,+ - ./)0)1(,.2(+ -)$/)/+*1 -+,%/) 13/%*4 ** )+ - ./)( $14)* 1).+ 5(4.(..& 75&67,+,2*5'.+&'6(66(*6*'"+3-/$ 3/ 0)1 +../1$ 3/(66$75
+6+'7*''+.&+2*0'/&+6(**70''6 '.&''4&'5+0&'*+ +'.*+''54.'.+'.5''+ ''6 ' (05&' & '. ;5+ D &66' 'E .& 7 (+5+&'67,&060''.('4 - -
.'+&*+'
.*6.&85''.=*'5'&6B*6(&'&''.'&'&27*'
8 .*6'.&5+:05'6+'&8&4&,'.+2.''.0&+ &606.&060'&*7=*''4.(.4&''. 8462&'.*'4&&+&6,562&6&'.0++&.*6 .&7&46
+('+&/$+38&&./&+61+*&'67, $+ .& &/6(&'/+5+'2'.+56'*70''6'.&' 7'.'.B*620'+ ++6'&7/5+'&6'&(=*' &5'/ 4.+&'.'&'(&/&(=*', +>8&& !0&+&*'
8&& 0&+&.5''+&5&' .&&+06,*6+'.F&6 (=*' (' 72 & &2+0' .6+/ '.*2. & 5+ '. +&' 6(66(*6*'7,C7'.1*5+0*+'$ 9+) + 1*+
: 1-0)1 ;1*"/+ + - ./)(5 <8 $75('.&2+0'.6++5(' &(=*+6&6.&+2.' '(&0(05&'.&''' '.(*+'4&&6+&4''. 5+&,+ '. &55(&' ' ('6 '.&' ' ' (05&' & ('05&'6*6+'.5+ 1(' '.('/7*'*6+'. F&6(=*'('&6/'.*/5+&,6 +60& '.+5'' 4'.;05&+,(' .&.&+6'.&+6(* +'.5&+'/&55+&6'. 5&5+78&6 '.4'.&''.+ +(&60+''.*70 $+1.2& '4*67'. ' '.2';'+&(''.(607 5+&,++B('67,'.'+&(*+'.&0+&6'.*): D
!"
#
5
$ %& '& % ' '( ')%'(%'
*% ' %!'+') '*%!' & %'%,' & ' ,' *%& '
# '
$- .*2. '.5+&,+0&6'.&55(&' +(&02 (05&''76'+067,'.F&6(=*'('+72'. &2+0'.6+/7*' &(''.5'.&6*7'&( '.&55(&' +&'.&'5&+' '.&2+0'42''.&(=*' &6.& 7(0*:;(*'&7 + 1(' '.('&7'.*+'
'&4&+6'.(05&'&6&&060' '.5&' +'.&8 7+',/1(' '.('+&6&*6+):
. /
'
' ' '
$ .%/ ' '
' 0
0
#
'
' 0
$ .&/ ' '
'
1 '
' 0
$ .
/
0 '
)& 2 ' ()%$
.!/
0
3 0
' '
'0
1'
$- ' 4*6 7 ' &+ '(.6 ' (00' 4.'.+ '. (05&'*2.'7,'.5''+:5&' 4*67'+0 '. F&6(=*'(''76'+067,6+('&6656'6( '&604'.'.5+ '.('"*5+&%1('.*'&''. '&2 6(/7'.'.5&+'/& '+&060' 5&'/0&,&6 6('+0 '.5&62&6+7*''.&0&((+6&(4'. &4'4*6/0,4/.5'.(*+'&6B*6(&' '.& &+ &62&0&+ '.B*620'('6 *5+&7,$+1.2&/&''.'&2 2.*+'/'.&6/*7B('0&''+ '.&2+0'/4&&(=*+6' '.(+(*0'&(/'.5+ 1(' '.('4+5+6 '+(
+'.+&0'6&7/0,4/'.05*26 +6+'*'&&772 &&(*+4'.*'B*+6('.&0 .+7,':&6.&55(&' +&060' '.5&'&46
''+:5&' 5+0''6'(+5+&''.&060'&605+ ++(&'2 '.&66'&*&6=*&,/'.6 6&'&+2 7+',' '.&0664+'''&'0'&6'.'+&*+'.&6(6 '.(&&((+6&(4'.&4&;56'*,&57
5'''&6&46
7 , 7+&' 0&6 &7 .& ' 7 ('+*6 & ;5+ 5'.0&*' "+ 1+)26./(6 &%' )+*/ "#,:!
'/./)4+= 3>)+ - ?>
'/./)4 ).+@
?>