High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1144/2012dismissed

Mahavir v. State Of Haryana

2017-08-18Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri21 pages

# $% &'('%# )*!"

,%'%

-& ./- '%#$ 0%12 ./- '%#$'324(1

%#& #421'*23 $# #1#

- 5'-##*22# 23 $#*67#1 - - 0151*%%%##23 $#*6

888888 '324(1*

-131% 2#1%#$1((1%$ 3$# '24$# 9"! 2 2* ):";

%1 #< .=%$ 22320'2(# 2#2 !

!%%2/6#14%% %'2(*>#1 1# '#32

22#2 ?

!%#$2#1$$'%2# '2( % # $ ##( $'24$# 9"!

9);@

A =2#2

'24$# 9"! *7% 2(2#

$4## 42*>#1* #1/%% %###;@

= /

4(1$ 22/6%$# A4 %17>';

C :=

1 (%# #1%###71#%#2# (%12%% 7%& D%2# / 3 #222%% 13%#'22'#

%%)#1 27 5%//3(>

C) / #1%2%%#%26% /(#1 6/ #1 7

62%%#%2#,('211 -6%%# -'#3%2# -13%

*%# %2# 1'211 417%/%%27#1!% %2 2'(1# 26

*#/ '#B #1 (6/ #17-13$2 1%1

:+:

:?" 6 /

B9??:) 9"2%2#1# 6%%#-'#37% '# 1$ # 22%#/( #2623%2*%122 #%## 12#1 *1 12521#/ '#)A) 9" #1 ( $3(#1%2 # 2 #1/% #1 6$12,(1'211##11 '% 6%%# -'#371-'#37% '222*%2 /

2*%2#1

27%

E( '# 112* $15%*$52 / #1 112% -6%%#1%/ 52/66/ #17-13%

%# %2# 1'211 F($# /#5(%#1 1326%###71$1%$ $#

1 $$ 2'$#23%#(# $'2(H'%# $2(%*(

'(1%# #1$ $$'$*$ 2( %###% 7#%%% '24$# :

%# #@# 22/ 26

-'#37%( #$ 2'$#2 1$$'%27%%#2 #1%26 #13( 1$$'%222%$ %'%###@

# #1 $##1# 1125#$ $2#1@'%2 #1$ %% $21% /1 71##5

1%1 '%2 6157/ '# #1% '%'## #1 %22%$ %'%###@

*#1$$'%2 2#1 $#6# #12%$ %2$2( ##1@2#1 /1 $ 3271$17#5# %%%% 32$ 36 @

$ $'% 3%#(# *#1 $ 2 #'2%$# +9

#1 '# 22# 1 '2$ -(%##* >#1

*71 2(#1##1 $#% $2%$ %2$ %%

$'24$# 9"! *71$1%@$'%36#//6#1 '#

4%% %* $ ##2 #1 $% # #1 '# 4%% % 32 2 2#2

F24%% %'2(*>#1*' 2(%' $#( '2%# %' #1##1$$'%212$ ##2 $'%1/'24$# 9"! * 2 $1(% (%# #1 $$'%2 + ")

# 71$1 #1 $$'%2 22 #('#62$2#

1 2 # %#/%1 #% $% @2 % 6 % :

7#%%% C 41*4$''#1 E2 2 $*4F* >#1 32#1#% #%$# 1

:+:

:?"

C!4%174(1% $7#%%71

2 %2(2($ 2( @

A ' $# 'H @

C9 %#/ 7%71 12#51 # (1% #1$

$$'$* 32#1%%@

# C>#/4(1% #1 $7#%%(2(236 %$ #% C?

F@4(1* #% 32#1%$2%# $ $$'$% @

C: /4(1*$ #%##2#'7#11%%### @

2# #1 $(2(#1$$'%213( 21

#/ '#) ?) #1#112'221%%%#-'#3 2 %2#1#' $# %2#1 $ #1$$'%2* 1% /1

:+:

:?"*1 (7#11% #12 #1$ 3(% 21%#'$7## 3(1'2117122/ 26 1% %%#7%6(%2

#11 '% #1$$'%271$17%/( %30'%2/

27%

E( '# #1%

C+12#%##2#1#%1%%%# 2$%2-'#32#1#1 1'%/22-'#3J%1'%/2/ #1%2#16%2( %#6 412 %2#1#

71%17%%#11 '% %1121%%#J%%$(2%17# #1

22# #1 '% 1%%#71%1%7#1$$'%2*71 ' %(1 2 #11 '% 412 %2#1##1 #%17## 1%1 '%2%71%%#

13(0'%7#1/

E( '# #1% 41%2' 71$1 #1(1/ 1

2$#12#1 #%1/$ '$ %$ '% 41 '#1%##2#1###1###1$12 #1$$'%2 1226( # %$1

)

C) 42471 12$ 2'$#2 %# #@# #1 22/ 26 -'#3 32#1 %# # #%@

711 2%$/2#10'% '2 #122/ 26 -'#3% 7%&

$%27 '2@ $%# #$1571$1 7% #$ %1 2 (' ( @ # 17% $#''26($15/ 2#( (%%%# #1 '#1 ##2 /

27%%# '2#17 '2%2

$%2 7 '2 @ $ %# # # ( %# 6/ '#!$## 2 1 '27%/ 2

#1$%27 '2 %E?@ $7%%#

$$#( 1(7%%#%$ 62$ ##2/

27%%#26

#1%$ 17 '27%%5'2 (#1 3'# #1%5' #1 7% $ #'% #1 / $16#1/# $$#(

$%27 '2@"

?$%# #1(1#%2

#1$5$2#%3%6 # #7%!

$2#1

$%27 '2 %E@ $7%%#0'%#/ #1 (%/2#1/ 7 $5%##1 2@#2(# 72% #%$'( 22%%$# #7% '2# /9$2#17#1 $#''26(3#//

'/ 2 #12@!$$'%120'67#1 #12% $# -

;#1(%=0 # ## (

C) 424 '#1 2#1##1$'% 2#17%%1 $52 1 1(2'# 120'62 #10'% '2 #122/ 26

-'#371$17%' $## $'%2#1 CB2 %#/ 7%2 C " %#/%174(1/ #1 $7#%%% #22#1 23#%@

>2@

F32$ C

%1 >'*' % '$%-(* $ '$# F#2 > 32#1$# 2$ 6 # $2 -13%@

-A

2 -A!

% 32#1#%$ 2#(# /1

B9??:) 9"

-A9 C !-0#% $$'%2 -13*(2 96%*%##2#1##16!/ #1%2 %%#2#1#

#) 1 (7#11%/ #12%%#12( # %$1

##5(%271#16 ##11 '%1% #121% #17 %##11 '% C 912%##2#1##1$$'%2-13% 5 7# 12#1#1( # /$ $# /(

:+:

:?"

%%'21% 72#1%7%(3# $$'%2-13%122 #132##6$22#1#-137%'%(#1% C -13 4(1% -64(1%##2#1#112( # /%$ $# /(

B9??:) 9"%%'21%2#1%7%/('%2/6

/4(1%17% #13(62##6

C ?424(1 %##2#1#1122%% $#27#1%$# %17>' #1 3%#(# #1%$%212( # #11 '% $$'%2-1371 #122/ 26 7%6( %##2#1#3%#(#( $ $ 22%### $ # /4(11%%$2 #2 /

26( #17#1#11 %7/2'##1%%#$ $ #2%2#1% '#1%##2#1# #1%26%1 4(1/ #1 $$'%2 2'$2-13/ #171 7% 6 %#2/6#13%#(#( $ % 2 %2(2(#12%$ %' %###@

2/6#1$$'%2 !"

2(2($ 36

#1@2 /1 '%'$# #1%22%$ %'%###

C :%$# %17>'71 %3%#(#( $ #1%# $%%##22#%$# #1#3%#(# $ 2'$#2/61 #1%#$%(1# $ 2(#1%### /4(1'# #1 ( $1 32#12 $'#%22'(3%#(#

#1$%$'2(#1H'%# #*2%$ %'%###*$ 36 % #$

$ $'% #1 32$*%### #1$$'%27%

$ 22#% 4$# 9 9

71#$#(32$ (%#17%'## 1# /1# @#1%/'##1$$'%2 22 %$# #1( '2#1#11%%#2# %7#1 6 1%7% 32$7%*1 73*2/6#1$$'%21% 2 $

F2$ '% #1#71%%(#1'(20'2(#1% %'/##2#1##1%#$%%$% /2'22#1% 6 7#%% # #1 $$'$ # 1% / %'/##2 #1# #1$$'%## 32$#1#' J%#%J32$$126/%2# //% #1%%#1%1 #%# 6 #1%%#2% #12$%271

7/ #1#%#27#%%% #1% '#1/%'/##2#1##1$ 2

#1 $2#%2' /6#1 $ #$ $##1 $$'%27#1#1 $$'$6%'$1%#1%2 % # 2%$ %#1$ 3%# #1#613#5$ F2$ '%1% '#1%'/##2#1# %# 6#1##1$$'%21% $2#1 $ #2# 21#1#112'22#1%%# #1$ #% 1(16 //22 % ## % #1% '#1/ %'/##2#1##1#3%#(# %##271$17 '2/32# #1 $##1##1 $/( 3E '%1%%1 7$ 36 !@%%#2

##7 2 # #% #71$1$62$#%#1# 1%/22(32$$% /2'2 12$ '%1% #1'%%'/##2#1##1'(20'2(#$ #%'%#21%62

%##(%2#1%2 $H'## #1$$'%2

#1 #112*#12$ '%%#(#14##1%%'/##2 #1# 3 #1 '(1* #1 % 6 7#%% # #1 $$'$ /'# #1 $$'%##32$ $ 2%#/%1%#1#5%#1$1

32$% %# $ $##1$$'%27#1#1 $$'$H'%# 1 2$ '%1%#1'%62 2%%% #1

C13$ %22#13%'/%% %22%%2/ #1% '# 2 7#1#1%%%#$ 2$ '%13% '%2#1$ 2 #1$%

% %#1 $#' 2#1 -'#3%%'# 0'%%$ $2

C) 424*71 $ 2'$#2#1 %# #@# *1% 2%$/2#10'% '2 #122/ 26 -'#32#71$1 #1#' ?$%27 '2% $15*12*$5212% C)1% $#( $6 2#1##1$'% 2#17%2'# #1120'62

#10'%71$17%' $## $'%2#1 $ '% 1%2

C 7% / 6 $ %%@2 /1 #1 $$'%2 /'# #1( %'/%##$ '2/$#22'(#1$ '% $ %%@# % %#

'/##13$#6 #1 $# %%'$1*7 2#1##12$ 32$2/6#1 %#'7#1#1 $'3% (2(#1 71$1#10'%7 $#2 #12$%2

4$*#%$%71$# $#(0'%1% #/7#%%2/6

6 *#1 *#1 %5%# %#/%1#%$% #1/%%

$$'%##32$ 1 %# ##/(#1J%#%J32$ #1%1 #%# 6 C+12#7 1(7%%# #1 2$%2 13#@#$# 1@# $1 % 2'$2 / 7& D7%2#3(1'217#11(7/ '#

: +6%(

1( 6%%#-'#37#1 -1/$$'%2*%##1 '#*7%% % E2 %'# '%6 -6%%#-'#3*%$2$%2*7% 13(#1$12 2%# #1%-0#*(2/ '#

96%*6 '(# 1%-%1*(2/ '# "6%2 '(%# %-%1*71 %)6% 2 #1 %$1

( ( 1$$'%2261'%/2/ #1%

C%2(%#6 -6 #1712@22 6 #17>%13'%2# %27#1-'# 3 # 12#1 # #12#1 6%%#-'# 31# %7#111'%/27 #$ 2 #1 %# 726%

7%%##61 '% 1 12%$% 6%%#-'#3$ ( 1

%'2#1##7%#1'#'2%'#2##1%##

17## #1

22# #11 '% 6 %%# 1$$'%2 %(%#2( #1

12 2 1%1 '% #17## 1%1 '%2%7#1#6 %%#7%13(0'% 1% 2/

27%

E( #10'% 1%2 71$1 #1 (1/ '1

2 $ $#2 #1 1 # /$

'$ %$ '% ##1###1$12 #1$$'%212 26( # #1%$1

1 ##1 $$# 2( #$ 226%###/ #1 $ ) +

#(#1/ 3 $#%

1 %2#%# 6 C+12#%% '(1## /%%2/6 #1( '2#1#1%###'24$# :

7% $ 22#1(16/#2%#( 73*#1###1%(2%7 %##2 1 J/@ '#*0'2(# #2%

#$% %&%% ' ()*+)$ %)*#1%12#1#26 @# 7#%%/63%#(#( $2 % # ) ,%5%#1 3% %'%$# 1 J/4' '# #10'2(# #2%$"

"% )) +- ./" +) $% %01 %2 *12#1##126$ 2(%###%

7#%%%#% 4$# :

7 '2 #$1#1$2/#6

%'$17#%%%'%%3%#(#( $%%52H'%# %/ '#26 $ 2(%###%2@# %% '(1# #17#%%%%# 716 #1%###%7$ 22# #1%#$%'% #1 %### #13%#(#( $%1 7%#1# H'%# 7%3'##

1 /1 #1$$'%2%# 716%### C+12# #% 4$# :

7%$ 22/#26 %%'$1*#126 $ 2(#1%### 12#/6#1 $ ) ,% 7 '2 # $1#1$2/#6 #17#%% C+12#

#1%#$%*7 2#1#2%#(#16$ %%@# C+

#1( $ '2 / / '(1# / '# # %15 1 $2/#6 # 2 '/# 1 %$##1% # C+% $##'7#%%/(/ #1 6 #1$$'%271 7%%2(@## #11 '% #1$$'%2 1 $# #11 '% 1(71'%/2 C+12#%32# #1%#@

71$1%1 7%#1#1 '% C+%20$## #1 '% #1$$'%213($ 7 1#'#1 '%% #1%2 7#%%%%#(#12 #1 $##1#%122 #$1 %# %###1#%112 $#'67#%%2#1$$'%2$'%(0'%*#1 '(1*%1$ '21336 $ 3#6%##2%

'#1%#* C+/6%#(# 7#%%/ @7% 56# $'#17#1 11'%/271 %/ #1 $$'%22%1 '2 #13#5#1%5 %#(1 7## %$%%1 12 #$#'67#%%2#1 $$'$

)

C '#1 2 #1# #1 #%# 6 C+ 12# % 2% $ / # #1%### C !-0#*71 %6 '(%

2$%2*(2 96% C !-0#7%/ 6H'EE2/6#1 %2( $/ $ 2(1%%###2 #1/%% # %7% '%12/61*17% '2# /$ ##7#%%21%%### 7%$ 22 C !-0#1%%##2#1#

#/ '#) 1 (7#11%/ #12%%# # %$1

##5(%271 #16 # %$1

1% #12 #17%##11 '% 1%2 7#%%7%/ 6$ %%@2/'# #1(%'/%##$ '2/$#2 2'(#1$ %%@# % %# 2 '/##13$#6 1%%###

#1#%# % C+12#2 C !-0##%32# #1#$$'%2-137%%#1%1 '%#1 (#/ '#)

#126 $$'$

C) 424 12$ 2'$#2#1 %# #@#

#/ '#? %%%$ $6$ 22#1 %# # # @

C)1% 2#1##1#%2/#7#12#12#1 %# #@# % !1 '% #17 2%#12#112 $$'2#1 (

#% 1 '(1*#12$ '% #1$$'%21% ###2# %%#1$% #1 #1/%% #1

$# (2(#1##1#%27#1#12#12 %# #/6 %'/##(#1#%#1%2 #12#17 '213 $$'2#?

71%#1$% #1 %#1##12#1 $$'2 #) /'# #1%## (2(#1# 2#1 #1/%% 2$%$$ $ #/%2# /$$'## 36'#21 '2#% 6/ 2 %## 71$1$/2 3 4)* ( %*+)$% %5 (*.

' ()*# $

*#1 J/4' '#12% 7%& 67%) )%% ( 8

)% %* %%*,"

1( , "

( * 1 ,."

))%))% )*(%* %

1( ,)%%

, ,

%*%*(,

1( ,5)#%*,"

%)% . % ))* ) 8 %1( % .1

"1) 1) (,

1( ,# * (,

1( , 4) %* ,"

%)% . 9 # %* % 9,) 1 % ,% %*

,))%*1

% 1( ,: 1# *%*(,

1( ,8)) %* %%,

% ."

)"%

))9 %. %* ,"

1( , 1(# %* ,"

1( , . 9 ()9 1(D 5 8"/* ;<)1$% %3 - )%* #

#1 J/4' '#*71@(%%%'71#1 %# # ## 2#1##12#112 $$'27#1!1 '% #

%# #@# 71$122 ##$17#1#1 $%12 #1#16%$$ 2# #1/ 26 #2#17 '222 ('/

$$'%#$%A $# %2 #1($/%27#1$##62#1# 2#(#1%%'*3 '% $# %%'$1%(21#1$ 2# #1 2$%2*$#$2# %1$$ 2# % #1$ $$'$2 #1 $ 2# % '2 71$1 #1 / 26 % %32* H'2 # / $ %22 ) ' ) ( ; <) 1 $% % * # 33

#71$ %2(%%%'*#1 J/@ '#12 #1#@$## 2#1$ #/%#/%12%$# $62$%6

'37*#1 #1 $# %##(#1##12#112 $$'2

!1 '% # #1 %# #@# %H'##'7#1#1$%

#1 71$1%# #1 $##1##12#112 $$'2/ B

37 #12%$'%% 2/ 3*7 2#1#$$'%27%%1% 2#/ #12#1 1%7 1%1 '%

#%#1$% #1 #1##1$$'%22#1 $# #1

$ ##/ '#B

2# 21#1#112'22 -'#3 1 $#' $ #1#1 #1$$'%2# #1 #1 #1$ #%2'6%#/%12 #1$ 2 $2#% @

-A971$1 $##1#$7%2 B :+:

:?"#

B9??:) 9"#/ '#B

C2 2#1##1%%(1# 3# #1#7 $ 2% 2'$2/6/ #1#1#1 $ %

C1%@

#1$7%2#) ?) - *@

-A9%1 7%#1# # /B - 1%23# $367/@2/6#1 $##1##1 $ '#7 '2$ 2#$$ 2$7#1#1$ $5#%##1 $ '# $%#1$ $5##$'$ '#%%#!'#% 23$*#1#1$ 2%7 '2%1 7#1## /23$/6#7

'#% %%'$1#1%(1#3# #$ #/##2# #1##1#%$ 2%$ $#

2 '/#*#1%21 '/%7 #%%'2#1% $$'%2 -132#1$ # /4(1/'# #1#%# % C 122 C -134(1% -64(1#%/ '##1# #1612( ##1%$2%%%'2#1%2122 3#1%#

#1 $$'%2 -13 2 $ # / 4(1* %$#36 % #1 $$'%22$ #7 #13(#12##6

#1' %

%%'$ %$2#1 7% %%'$1#1 3% (2( #1 $#' $$'%2 13( 2 #1 $ # #1 $ ##/ '#B ##1'2 1%7 %#2%%'/%###2

#1$ $$'%##32$' 71$1#1 %% #12%$ %'%###@

'%'$ 71$1#1$$'%2(26 ( #@21% /1 $ 32 1$ 36 #1%2@##1 %#$ #1$$'%21%/2%/32/6#1# '# #1( '2 #1# @%% %##2# 13/$ 32 #1% # #126

$$'$#% '(#1$ %%@# 3%#(#( $;

:=%$# %17>'*17%$ #27#1%$# #;@

= (#@#%7%#1%$ $ #;@ !=71$1 #13%#(#( $2##2# /#1%71$17122 3#

1/6#1$# '% 3%#(# #;@ =%1 7%#1# #1@%1 7# #1 (#@#/6#13%#(#( $7% %$#2/6#1 (#@# #$( (#%/'# (#% 7 '2 #1% '% #1%$ $ #;@ != %1 7% #1# #1 %$# $ # $ %( 41 * 4$# $ %%%## 2 > * ( #% @# $12 #1 % # # #1 3%#(#( $# 2#1##1# 266-'#312/

'2 22 2 #1 %$# $ # 2 #1 /%3# % (2( #1 $ 2# #122/ 262(2(@%#$ /

22/ 5 /(%2/

2%#2J4"

*(>

1 '(1*$ 36 #7 @%#1%#$%%'@2/'##1 %2 $#$ #2# $#1##1# $%% %

@%$ #*'%'6 '21 '%1 2%2#1$/

#1 @'1 '%1 2 6$%*%$2 '/#1%/ $#2%(2%#1 $#' $ 36 #1@71$17%(26'%2 #1 $$'$*#1%2$ 36%1 '2#1/ #2' 272

##2# 2 %

1 $#' $ 36 #1 /1 ##1 %#$ #1$$'%2*6$%*%#2%2'6%#/%12%#1 $#'

%$2

:+:

:?"13(/%%'2# 1271 12( ##1 %%%'21%212(3#1%# $$'%22'6%#/%12 #1#%# 6 C912 '% 1%%###2%$ %% #1% %# 716112( ##1%$2%%'21%%#2

(##(#1%%%'2#1 -13 1%$ 2#1#%$ -1322 #13

2##6 (##(#1 /$ $# * #1 *1( #%%%'21% 1%2##6 #1(1# #1 %2#%# 6#1% '#2 % # 26% # 2%$2#132$ (2($ 36 /1 ##1%#$ #1$$'%2

#%7%##2#1#$%/%2 $$'%##32$*#1 '#1% # $236$'# '%6# 6' #1%2#1H'#6 #1 32$22'$2/6#1 1%# /%$'#E2#1 '(16/ $$#(#1% #1%#$%*%262%$'%%2/ 3*#1 32$ 2 /6 #1 #1 %1 J%# %J 32$ % /% '#6 $2/ 2 % %#2% $ / #2 2$ 32$ (2(#1# 2#1 1 J/4' '#0'2(# #2%$4?")"1$% %@)% 8

*;!"

4+?*716(

' 0'2(#%* 5*( ( 3 $% %@ ;!"")= ?4B 2 $% % 3 5 * ($ 8* *.

;!"

=94 "B* 12#1##1D%# %G#1 6$ %# 671#1#(/#7#1 # # 71#1$$'%22#12$%27%#%3271#12$%2 % '222%% %#1# %%/#6 6% #1#1#1$$'%2 /(#1'#1 #1$/$ % %%/ #1%#$%*#1% 1266(#1#71#1$$'%27%J%#%J#11 '%2 #711%7 7%'22#11 '% %%'$1#1J%#%J32$ /$ % ##$ $$'%##32$#1%$%

1$$'%21% #22652

9 %7 22%%'#

0'%$'%27#1%12(27 #1 (

% %'$1*#1$$'%27%@$#2# $ '#7#1% @# (2( #12#1 1%7 #1%$ #@# $6/2# 3% %

%$# ": 232$$# )+!

4$# ":%#1#' @$# # ('%12%$# 232$$#* 71$12#%#1##1/'2

% #1% 71 %%#%#1 @%#$ %'$1 $# 4$# ":1232$$#* )+!2%%

7%&

C16 $#%%$67#1#15 72( 6% * #1/'2 3(#1# $#%' 1

0'2(# #2% $ '%*

$ 8*1$% %

'" - * #1 J/@ '#1%12#1# $#%%$6#1 5 72( 6% *#1/'2 3(#1# $#%' 12#1# #7 '2/ %%/ #1 # 3$# $#%#$'6 7#1#15 72( #1$$'%2 #7% '#112#1#1#4$#

":% ##22# 3#1 #%/'2# 3#1('#

#1$$'%2/6 2% /2 '/#*/'##1%$# 7 '26# $%% 71#1 1%%'$$22 3( $#% 71$1% / $$/27(2(@%#$ $# #1 $#%*'%%#1 $$'%2/63#' 1%%$5 72((2(%'$1 $#%* %6 @# 71$1(1#23#1$ '## 272 # $ 1'%# 7%12#1#%$# ": #132$$#%2%(2# #$# @$# $%%*71$1*#7 '2/ %%/ #1 #

%#/%1$# $#%71$1#$'67#1#15 72( #1 $$'%2

1 J/@ '#* #10'2(# #2% $ ( 1$% %/ % * 717 7%2 # 2#1#1 /2

#1# 1 2#1$$'%2%2 /#1#1 12( # #1$ '$1% 527%#1 #3 32 7#1#1$*'12$ 3$# $$'%271#1 /7% 0$#2*71% #(# 3% % %$# ": 232$$#

1 J/@ '#*$% #2%$:

2- 1$% %0"-

%% 71#2#$$$'%#$%71#1

22/ 2612/ '2#11 '% #1$$'%2 2#10'2(#

#1(1 '#3%($H'## $$'%2 13#@#$# $#20'2(#% 2'$2/ 7 #1%5 26 $& 6$,% %*B1( , ,%#

1()%* % * . ,%) ) ,

%* %*4 (8 . ) #%*9"( 1 8%* % ,%)"

*$ ,%) 1( %*,(%* %% ) .%*

% * ))% . 8 %**) %%*%*( %*#%) *%)* )% * % )*((# %,"

. * %*

),"% * ))",,))"

. 1(%* %)*((*,(

( %*C

12$%2*/(7 #1$$'%2213(22#11 '%

$$'%2#1 (

'#%136/'2 #1$$'%2#

@#1$$'%#$%'271$1#12$%27% '2221% '%#1 (

%%'# 0'%$'%27#1%1 2(27 %$671#1%$ #1$$'%2##1$

$$'$##1# #%% 2'6%#/%12 1$$'%213( 2 # 26@# #1%3%

# 2 '/##1##% $$'%271 7%% %/ $'%(2#1 -'#3

%'%1 # '2%$'%% %2/ 3*7 2#1##1$$'%## 32$2/6#1 7#1#12 %$# ": 32$$#% %' $## 2# 2#1 6 $#1##%#1$$'%2 -1371 12'221%7 -'#3 C2 # 26 #6

#1 2(%# #1% $#$$ 22/6#1# '#2#1%1/6 2 1% ##1%2#1%%1/62%%%2

"#$%&"'

1 C1#1%5(A% 2 %A

C1#1 #/ %A