← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/476/2010dismissed

Lal And ANR. v. State Of Haryana

2015-09-21Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron15 pages

 



     

 !

"

 #$% &'   (($$  )'* +',   

( - '  .'++'&/-0/'&(($$  .' 1&*'//', /'&'( - 2+

 +' 34*45&$   (($$ )'* +',   

( - '  . 366'7$/-0/'&(($$  .' 1&*'//', /'&'( - 2+ 8   

  !

       

    9&&' (''$$(('3,:$$7-&1*-63 ;

:'''-& (''' ;  <9&&'&1*-63 &*$-:'('- &6;    !

" &'-'&$$-('3  -7(($  =>?2  ('''-:,#$ - 4+&3:&*/:&  +&:1*4#@3 7$$ "?"2  ('''-:,+' 3 4*45&$ A& /-'-6 &1*-63  0

 -- ?

  -'-' -- >

 (-:,&$'

- -- $+ *-6/$7$/7&':,$$&(($$ 7' 0- '& (* &:$* <!? -=?   - - * -'6'0', 6'33  - &'-'  &('* 7 3  &3 A0 7+*' -'3-+ 3A*3'/+ 3($7$ ? B >  &'3 C@BD/A0-&&73''-*'3 &:5 )$$667 (*'+&3&'(' $&3,'-," B >  &0$+&-&&$(7&$7' 6$$17$$', 7&&'3&'+3 3&7'/7&'&':'&' 40+ 6& 7$( 6 :- &*''3 -&'&' 3'5&7$( 6 &'+&-&:*  ./&&'- '*$ 7&&&75*( -7&7,* 6(' /'3-7&/7'  - 6 '&'&,'-60 6: 6&37& - &' -&3 &*&'7&,7*$-:5$$-&,'30-$$ &''

3 7$$&'3&' -3*$-&'&&3 &-$5 7, " E2'3&$3'&+&*'&'-&& 3/'F 

G'3&':'&' -&'7$&'-&''/ $$&3'5 6$$&'

3  -&' 7,+&-& '3 6*-/& -&'3&'7& - &':'&' - &'7'*7&3&3(  -(' &-60 : 6 7& -$5 7,&''$$, 6 &'37&&3 +& *'&' - & &, 7' *'  *3:'H $$ ' ,* 6  - 7' (5 6 0$$6 $ 6*6  +& $ - & 7 ('  7' 7' 6 * -'7' -0 $, -&& - ,&3

&:*& 3 /'*IC@ D7 &$+ ''6' 

<

 

'('*I/  C@

D* ="> -<B  7 $-6- &3-, &''/+ 3A*3'0-&( -('('-'*6&  ($  C@ <D   $ 5    (  :$-  - '& 0- '0',33@$$$-+*53+ 6&/ 6'' @('/ 7&$-& (' '3&( -& --0'&3+ 3 A*3'' 0' 6 ('$-('$ 70'/ & @-,> B >/ 40+ 6&/ :'&'A0J3($ /**3:-& 1*'* --*' 6& *''  +-'1* 6($/$&*'* *& '3 /+ .&& & -/ ++'1  6'/ $& '6'-  ??B -- > B > C@?D  ' 3($ 6  I* ('- 6 C@"D/ + .&& & -   & -- :-, ' ( 3'3 @3   0- (($ @<&''/+ <!"/<!?%=?  7'--- &   7  !

>/*-&54($ -*-+'

37'''-  <<" >&,-$-&' 0$03  & ('   & & *- 7' ''-  - -*' 6  ''6 *'- -$*' 3  @  - @=   = !

> '(0$, :'+0)'/ +/$7$ '(&' 0$03  & 33 '3 &(' 7$$'6'- 6 $3  17$$',*'* *&3 /:&&*-6-3'-& ($  *''  0- 33 @    (' & -$*' 3 / *-&5$-&($(',+&  -6'0'-6$- 5$ '3&1&*66/7&&75  ( 0-33@<+3$'$,/ ('&-$*'3 /*-+' 3$$-&($(',

= &1&*66 0- $ ,/+&  -6'0'-6$-'( - (' 6$-5* -$/7&&7'$5  ( 0-'0',33 @" *- #$  -  / 7' ''-      <<" 

>  = !

> '3 & -/ * 1: *' 6  ''6  

" !

>/:&&3*'-('-$*'3 @ = -  "'(0$,-3 6&' 0$03 $ 67&&'2*- & ('      (*'*   &' -$*' 3 / *- #$  -  $-3'-&($0-33@?%>'(0$,

> !

>/*-#$$6'0'- ('&*35 - (' 6$-'(/7&&7'5  ( 0-33@ +3$'$,/ *-   $ 6 '0'- 7 6$- ' 6 '3 & 1&*66/ 1 + 6&6'/& -/7&&7'5  ( 0-33@

3($  ', 06 /'('* >< '  7$-6 &(' (($$ 7$$&54($ 3,: -& *- 3$,& 1*$-  :''-/&7-$'-('$3- -'0-'-'--

B  ('0  / & ('*  @3 - & 7   '3$ *'7$$92+ 3A*3' -92<+0)'/7& -(-7&'6'-& 06 ''-*:,&3&('* @3 -92"A0/&*&'  H92+3 3&7'/3&' A0 J 3($   - 92? ' -'/ :'&'  A0 J 3($  & ('*  & $ @3 - 92B ' +'0&  - /  ''/ '  .- / +-'1* 6 ($/ 7 $&/ 7&  -*- & (3'3 @3     &-- :-,    4 0 + 6&  (' '3 ('0 6 ( 3'3 '(' @=/ 92B ' +'0&

"  - ( -&&-&7' ':'$-36-*:$* ' -0'-*( &&-:,&'(', -&$$& 1*'7' 3'3 *' -& 1*',*- &-7* *-& & '- ',*' *' ' $* ('* 0- /&3 $$& *- 7' ''-- * -' +  << '   &  '3  6 '*3 ((' 66 &3 &('* 0- 7'(* &3&,- -&('*  -($--$3($  &' - / & *-  -'- '- (,  1*-63  -- B > B C@D '6 6&'*6&&0-  ''-/&$'

-'$ *' &1*-63 -- ?

 '*'

- - 6&&('* & :$('0:, - ,' :$-*:&&(' (($$ 7$$  &5 4 ($ &- 33- $*'5 6 &* '(  - -, 7& 3*'-' 40+ 6& &'- $&*&3($ 

& @-, >

 /*-&54($3 6-('3 &*-,&'7& &7: 65 & *' 7,'3 ' $ & -  $7$ ' &' 6   & I* *3    &''/&'$ *' $, -&'3 6*-&(' (($$ /3  - &'-' -- >

  ' & *'/ $'

- * $ ' & (($$  &0 0&3 $, '6*- &   92" A0 J 3($   - 92

3&7'/7&'-&0 &*-/:* &*-7'

5 7  -&3*'' 3-2 6&:*  ./&''/ & 0-  & &, &0 - - & *-    :$  92? ' -'/ :'&'  92" A0   & 7   & *'' /

?

 &''/ & 3 ,   '$0   -'3 /   7&&' & (($$  7' &  / 7& 7'  0$0-   & 33     +$$ *'&'/   '6*- & 92" A0 7  5 7    ,  & *-/&''/&7&- -$$&(($$  $'-& (($$  7' - - :, 92" A0   *'  $,/ &''/   & :    ,  -   ('-/ & 3 ,  92" A0 J 3($  &'$:$ -'*7'&,7 $'6*- &'0',17$$','$(*'* &-$*'3 & (($$  &'$:$ *'/&17$$','$''- ', 7'  - *$- : ($ - :, &('*    , 3  +$$ *'&'/  -( -  7  & :  @3 - :, & ('*   ('0 & '0', *& 17$$', '$   '6*- && 7(    ':*-  & (($$  ' & / 7&& ' 6 '$$, 0$:$/ &''/&('*  :-*( '$:$ -6 0-  #$,/'6*-&'  * <!?

- * $ ' & ('  - 7& &'  6 &'*6&& '''-'*$$,('*$&''- &7 & & ('*  & 30-   (($  '  -* 6 -   ('-  *- &5 4 ($  - +' 3 4 * 70'/0-&'3 --  !

>/&*-&--$ - ('( -  ('-('92"A0J3($ /&' 3&' 92 3&7'/ &' &' 3 '5&  - &' :'&'   4 0+ 6&C--D&0$'0- 1*'-*' 6& '0 6 6&  "E? B >  +*&   - ('0- :, & 3 , 92= 0

> &&/ '- A('/ 3 ($/ $7$/ 7& ('0- & 3- $6$ '('  ( 3 '5&/   4 0 + 6&  - 92" A0 J 3($ @ !/< %<'(0$,&& 1*'-92" A0 -92+3 3&7'/3&'A0J3($ /7&' & ,27 / &0 - - & *-   *'    &' '2 @3  /92"A0-&&($&-$$-&'':*K 3 &  - , & *- ('  ' &' ''  +& - - & *66 &&*-('  &*'&0 0'5-&' -&' &'3$,33:' & 6&"E? B > -$ &'17$$', 92"A0/7&03&(($$ /

'6&&' $ $$&*- -- -:,:&&,27 92 "A0 -92 3&7'/7&(' ('0-'3&3-$ - *''* - 6 '*3   $*- 6 &' 3    &  & -  :,&7 &*-  *'*  $& ('  (($$  7& & 33   '3 '   ' :, & ('* '&'-  7 (-:,&*- +$$ *'&'/   (*'*   &' -$*' 3  $$ & *-&06'0'-&17$$','$$$ 6 &'&''3& -$-($:,(  6*&30-'0', 33@</"/ % +*&'0',('77 -:,92?' -'/:'&' 92"A0J3($ /92 + 5'&-%92<+0 )'

&:*&6  -'$:$0- /&-   &*-:,& 1*'-,27   *''&''*$1 & -  ('- -'0','$&  &*-/ &('* :$ $*0$,('0&33 '3:,& (($$ :, - ,' :$-*:

B 9$-  - , 3' &'6*3 &'0', 17$$','$(*'* &-$*'3 &(($$   &'$:$ *'/&17$$','$''- ',7' -*$- :($ -:,&('*  ,3&'0',17$$','$ '3 & -$- ($ (*'*   & -$*' 3   $$ & *-2(($$ &-

:-*:- $,'&' &  -( - 7 &: @3 -/7& *&('0-:,92? ' -'/:'&'92"A0J3($ /92 + 5'&-% 92< + 0 )'/ &  06 6 '  & 3'  & *& 7 ' ''$0&03'&($$ * -'-&'3  6 ''$ '($$/& *' 3,'* L&'3 7&$$3'' -* *' '*$ -**'* ,/& *'3& $* &&3 ''$:$ -'*7'&,/&3 :3-:' 0 92   +  5 '&- % 92< + 0 )'/ 7   & '0',  17$$', '$   &' '2@3   -3- &   -( - (' 71 -&3'0',/:*&' & 6 ''-& &$7 7' 3$7'-&*-&,&- $$27$$ '  3, 6  & *-  $$, 3($ &3   & ('  

'3&3 &('* 7 /

:(-& *&17$$','$&0: ($ -&' & 6*66 7&,92?' -'/:'&'92"A0J3($ /92 + 5 '&- % 92< + 0 )' 2 &  06 6 ' 7*$- $$, 3($&*- +3$'$,/&7(   &(' 

' $ '0'- (*'*   & -$*' 3   & *-2

! (($$ 92"A0 &' $0' &-&&$ / 7& $- 1*'&' -&'3$,33:'/7''3-7& +*&7&'3 60 33-$,'&*''  -3*& :'&''&*-92B'+'0& - ( -&-&  40+ 6&7-*:$* '-0'-*( &&-:,&' (',&*/&7(   $,

:-&& '0',7$$,($ -*( &(($$  &- &*6&:$&&

 &*-  &:1*-63 @/7&':,&,&0: I*-   <<" > (*'* 7&&&(($$ 7'(('& -- & ('     ('*$  & 1*-63  @ &7 & & (' (($$ 7'$&*- &-&*-7'I*- '&' &&-$*'3 ' -3:$ 0-  - &'  3'$  '-   6 & '-:$,  & ('* 7 &I*$ &- '$0 &(' / 7&'&7 '-'  -&$$6 '6'- 633  '3'-' &*/7-  -&&' ,''' & - 6 ''--:,&$'

-'$ *'  0 6&(' (($$   '(&(','&(($$ '-*&  & ,'/$'

-* $'&(($$ '$,*( 0  & 1*-63  1& 6& *' ($+ 6&)+ 1&  D '$#  !? 9-  -&&(($$ ' $- , -*$6  &3'  ($+ 6&GC*('D/&' 660 :, & &&&' *:I* '3 $ -*&(($$ H&

  - :* ",'$- -&(($$ :*?

,'6 & (' /&(($$ &0: * -6*$,33   * <!? -,7&3*'-'     * -' +  <!?   & 7 3(    -, -3*'-'&3*'-'- -* <  -$& @( &(* &3 '*$(:$&3--&'3(' 3 '$*$(:$&3- 3*  63*'-'/7&&$$* -' + < =&:,7&&&-&*-7&*&   * 6-&/7&&(* &:$'('-$& $ &  G:$ +*('3 *'    1*-63  '('-  +&,3 &')+ ''-& !">+ < * -&& $ 6'- '  -,'&0'3'(' &*$-:  '

-   & 33      & *' &$-& &'6 * -' + <!? &7 6'- CD&33 &-,/ - CD&33 &3*'-' 33 6&-,& *' * - & 0    0   & (($$  * -' +  <!?     * :$/&3*'-'&0 6: 33-/& * <  7*$-:3-*  3 $)+3 !?B+ =?=/& G:$ +*('3 *' &$- &   * -' +  <!?     $ & * &   * <  & *' &-1*-63 7  -' 6/7&&'&*- 0-'  * <!? /-& &*$-:7'--7&$-&'*$* <  & -&&*$-$$7* $' '&7 ' 60 6$' /:* *&'*$(($+ <!? 3,:



-&&-1*-63 760 (''-0$(3 (* &3 6' -&  ''''& *'&$-* -'

M= NNN 6 / 7 -  & 5 & & $'

- *-6  & $$&:- 6& *'  --  $, -7  &/ 0     7&'  ('  0-'& * <!? / -&'$' 0-  & & &3$ &- 33-  $-2:$-- 3*'-'  33 6&-,/ -&&*$- $$7 $'$,/& 07@('-73 (($,&7&'&'*$-:  -   - 6   7&& ('  33- & 3*'-'  - $$ & 33:'&6 6'&$- '*0$,6*$,& (* &:$ * <!? (' ($ * -'*&* 

: (($-    7&' &'  -' 0-  &  ('*$' *- 33-&3*'-'&3$/& - 6 &('  & '*3 /&'-'3-:,&6& *'3*:&$-:1*- -&(($-3-O ('*$&:0@'&7&&33:'&6 6 '  * <!? ' '*0$,6*$,&  #' 1*-63 '('-A$57')+&' C!!>D=+ =="/& G:$+*('3 *'&$-&'  * -' + <!?

 / , &-F333*'-' 33 6 -,G0', &-$:$:(* &-&'7&-&' 3(' 3 '$''6'*3(' 3 ''3/7&&3,@ -  ,'-/ (*'* 33 -,/33 3*'-'/$$&3(  /7&'('( 6 &33 & 3 -, 3, :  0- * -' +  <!?  / $&*6& &, 3, &0 ('(  &3*'-':, -&('(  -,   ','&('* :$&&' ,33    06- + <='33 :1 3($- + =!

 M>

<!?/ , &-M333*'-' 33 6-,O0', &-$:$:(* &- &'7&-&'3(' 3 '$''6'*3(' 3 ' '37&&3,@ - ,'- &('6'/ - (*'* /&33 -,333*'-'/$$ &3(  /7&'('( 6 &33 &3 -,3,: 0-* -'& /$&*6&&,3,&0

 ('(    & 3*'-' :, - &   ('(   -,  ',&&3*'-'&*$-&0: 7& &  3($ $$'3&37& &-,7($

-/

'   ', & &, &*$- &0 *$$, 5  ('  / ' :-/33  --&,3, &0: (' &  3*'-'/'3, &05 7 0 &3*'-'76 6 :/ ' &-    : / 33- *  &$ &, $$ 7$$ : $:$' & -(* &3 /('0--('  3*'-'- :, &33:'&6 6 &33 &-, B   ','&('*  *&:$& &'  , 33      06-   +  <= ' 33 :1  3($-   +  =!        & - 33- 3*'-' -*' 6 & 33   -, &  $  + <!?

7*$-('  0$($$&-&*--$-7&  ( $ '*3'   - &   7*$- : 33'$ & & &' - --  &' &    7& & ('  7& 33- 3*'-'O & '- 1*-63  &0 :  ' $,  -'- :, &  G:$+*('3 *' I&3-)+ C DB+ <  & *'&$-& 3*'-'&: $- - '('- & ('0   +  <!?    &    3*'-' (* &:$ * -' +  <    7$$ &0  : '-   & ('0     - * <!?

 (' ($5 F$6$ :, '(' G & *'&$-&$$7 6 M = & 6'- :&& /3@ /'$ -'   3*&   3($      M-,O * -' +  <!?

< '::',7&$* <  0  (' :,&3$ 33&  3*'-' */$'-, -/ '& ('0   +  <!?/ &    M-,O 3* : *($- 7&3*'-' &'7'-/& 6'- + < :3 6'$ ('  &   (* &:$ * -' +  <!?  

*$ $,/ & -   7& '6'-  & *3:'  ('  0$0- &33 &'3$6   (:$&& M-,O3, :('0-:*$$&  3*'-'*$-::$&-/$5 &('  ( ' :$ $,&$ 6*6&('0 /$'& &*'&5( 3 -& 6'- 7&&&$$ * '3 $ 7& &3 6&( $ &   $, $ && &'6-7&:*0 7&' &'3('0*-,-' ( $('0 &*- 3, &0 33- 3' &      ' 0      6'0' *'3, $$,:(* &-'$' '0 0'/&$7('3 -&'I* 6'- '- @@ @@ ?  &(' /7'('3'$, '

-7&   (* &:$* <!?  - &$'

0'   (* &:$ * -' +  <    &   * -' +  <!?    7 ('

 / -, :, 0 ' 3' (' /  -  /33 63*'-' -- & -, &*-&033-:&& /&,'$:$: (* &-7&-&'3(' 3 '$''6'*3(' 3 ''37&&3,@ - ,' -:$:$(,  7$$

-' +  <   / 7&0' 33 3*'-' &$$ : (* &-7&-&'3(' 3 '$ -&$$$:$:$ (, & 3*'-'&: @($ -* <   &:,7&&&-&*-- 7&&  * 6-&/3*'-'7$$$:3*'-'/$$  , &'*3  + -$,/&'-$, - *'&$,+ <  - 7& $$ &@( & ?

& 1 '- 6+ <!? -<  /$' & &    3*'-' & :  $-  -  '('-   & ('0 + <!?  &'7'-/& 3*'-' (* &:$ * -' +  <   -  - - * -' +  <  7$$

= &0:'- &('0  -* <!?   &'7'-/7&'('0 (&,$$,$- -3- ('   &' ('0 /  &$$ $$ 7&  & 3:  - (  (' ($ 5   M$6$  :,  '(' O 7&& '3$$,  (($- :7    @ 6 *  -  7$,  - $7 & @('  M3*'-'O ((' 6   +  <!? 7*$- &0  5

'$, 3: -(& 6'- + <   *'(  /&' (' , 3:6*,&('0  ' $'  - -3  ( ' (($    , &' (' ($  '(' @(&M6$- '*$ '* O'-& *',$ 6*66'33$$, -'3 $6$$, &'- ', -('3', 7&&(('  @7&*3 ' --  & ('0  '- $$0$,/ (* & 3' :, - 3:6*,&& 3*'-'/:,($ 6*6/ $*-- & * <!?7$$&0&3

 / 3 6 - 6'- ' 3($-* -'&('0  + <  O A( 6   07 & '- (' ($/ 7&'      *$(:$&3-3*  63*'-'(* &:$* <   33 6 -,/ & (* &3   -& ' 3(' 3  ' $  & '6'*3(' 3 ''3/7&&3,@  ,'(*$- * <!?  $, &/7&&$$7& + < =  ' 6 (- + <  7&'-&  --:*-   & ('  / 7  - & & (($$  &0 60 3'$ : 6  & --   4 0 + 6&/ & 3&' 92

3&7'/&&' 3'5& -&'92"A0J3($   $,&(($$ &05 $

 L /&,&0$ 33--, $$ 6 * -' + <!    &''/ & (($$  

:3(-(* &3 /7&&$& 3(' 3 '$/ &(($$ '6*$,'33 3*'-' -'-,(* &:$

" * <!&*/&3(' 3 '$& $,(* &3 / 7&& :60 * <!?    07  & :0/ 7  - & & $'

- '$ *' &  -'-& '0-  ''('(0'*'

 - 6&& ('* &*-- ('0 6&&'66 &(($$ & 1*-63    0   - '-'    ''-- :, & $'

- -- $ +  *-6 -  *' '3  , (  $$6$, ' ''6*$',  I* $,/&(' (($'-3- C. D  

 !

"  C   # D )3$