State Ofpb. v. Avtar Singh
)*+,--.
!"#"
$/0/# )1,-,. 22(( ! 2$"
% & & ' &&
& ( 3# ,4, ! + 3 3 ,
%$ 2$"
2 22 (2%"+/ / $% ! + "
&"
!"
# $% ( "
" 0- 5)055 2 " +/ ( "
""
( $!"
6&!#62&
(!"
,# & $0 0 $%))*!" & $-7*787*-$%
&$ &4!
/& $$2 & !+ & &, )*-,
" $( & $ < ", 4 & # ,.
+/ &&!"62$" 1 .
"$% % #"
# 0 2 & $% 2$&!
! $, $ 5*5))*, 2&$ .
:;,.
($2 $("!/
($ .
$ 2$( &$%%
(,
"(/ & & 1" & %$# $ 2$"6 &&!" 1 .
4 $% 3
".
&!( 2$22/ / 2( , 22
$2 !# %$#, &$!
!# #, " %!
"!(
(
%$# $.
&$1/" $4
@!# , , , . $ '!" $ & 2$, "
9= A; .
#!( $! (/$ 2$( & $ $!
!
A$ +(:
,$ + $%.
& 9= A7;.
($"
"
" 2&$.
:;
($ .
2 / & " > ?2$ $%1 ((
!
,. # :-; $ " #$$ %,4
@!# ($ 1" 2$( &2 /2$&""$ 4 . &&!".
%$!"
" 2$22/&$2.
22 ""
$ 2$ - 2 $$ 2 .
& ((", .
. $ $$< 2 $$ 2 $% &$ $2 .$ "2" .
#(/ ! #
. ($ $ " 2$ &$%4
@!# , , , 2$22/&$22 "$1$< ($%( ".
1"
$# 1" &$2, .$ #2( $% - < & . 2 ",2
&<", " (".
( $%4
@!# 9>?;, 2&$ .
9>?; " # 9>?; #
& $2,.
+$!'!
(
"-< ,.
2 &<" $
" (/ (" ("2 &( (.!"$ "%$ $! #2(2 &(.( $ ( +$ $/%$ (/
2$&$#2( $$% 1
$,& (( .
2", " &&!"
& " !"& $-7*787*-$% &2( ""$
!
(/ "&(
#"
(
8 2$&! $ = " - - .
+ " "
"$&!# / / 1 "& # !
!" & $ A A,
&&!""
" ((
$,2( ""% ( #2( $, ""
"$(
/1 "& "%& B ( " 2&
( !"
, # 1 " !"
# "
"
0-5)055
" &&!"$ %$(($ $.
+$ $!"6 "2" .
" ! # $!
$ " #$%&$ $1/,.$= "3$
(/, 4
@!#
, , , . $ 2& &$2.
"(/ / 1" " (",.
($ $= " 2$&! $ %
(" $ +( &$ &
$% &!$"/ .
1
& +. %% $% $%%
( " $ ( #$/
!#+ $% #2(" .,"2$ ", " %$ (/ 2$ $% A # .
1 $ ((/$2 " #2("
"$&$
/2$22/ / " " !(" $! 2$
/ $% # 1 % #
2$ $% #2(
* &$ " $, ( "
( A$! (" 2$&!
(" $ +( !
( $ % 2$"6 &&!" +/$"
$ +("$ $!+ &&$"
(/ "
# ) C " &$!( &$"
"" ( "
( A$! " !
&&!"$& (
$!".
! " $6= $$%4
@!# , ,.
$% ( $ 2$&! $, "
$ # $% ( .
D" %% & $&
" .
&$1/ #! 1
+(/ + " #$/$%2 2&$.
:; # 9 :-;, +$ &$1/ .
, .
!%% $2$1&$1/ $ .
. $%%
( %!& . $ " $ #$ 1 $ % ((/ #2( &&!" 1 "& .
&$ " (
+(, +& $% / !
$ $% # /, &$!("$+"
& ""
" " "
&2 &/
$ $ .$ #2( +
$ A # .
, +, &( ( $ & A # 2$" #2( ( (( ".
2& # (, &
$%&!$"/#
"
&
2$&! ($ = "
"2" 2 $$ 2 , . $ " $ ((6.
((
&&!", " . $ 2$"!&"
2 $$ 2 $% & &$2 ($ .
1 A$! #$/#
"!
! < 5 2# , .
! "
" ( "
(A$! &$## "
1 $ "
& 2$&! $ 1 "& $ &$ &!
"!# , +/!(
# &
$% ! &.
2 /" #2!
" !"
#+ " " 2$"6 &&!"
+&$1 &"
"& &&$"
&.
( .
, ( " &$!( %$ $ 2$" !22$"
#2!
" !
!"
#.
&$"" (.
.((6 $"
""$$ ((%$ %& 1 .$% %$(($.
6
(/, %
(! $% 2$ &! $ $ = "2" " ! # , . $ .
"# "(/2 #$ $% "&$1/,& $! "$!+ $ %
$% 1
$ $ 2( ! =2( $.
$%%"%$.
$("
#$/ &$"(/ " #$ #2$ ( (/, 4
@!# , . $ 2& 2$ $& $% 1 , .
" 22 $% #2 2( .
& " $!, .
$ " .
#$ #
( .
, $6 $% ((/!"# & $% 2$&! $
"(/, .
& $ & 2$&! 1 "&
"(
$% #2(:
( %% $% " A$ +( $< 9 :0; &$"" .$ #2($%-< & ."2 $ " "( $ A # , %% $% A$ :; " 2$$% A # (=
(% " $(/ $ #2( .
"2$ " !&
&$ &/, 2 ( "&$!(,!&< $$$% ( <1 "& (/, 2$ $% A # !"
$ (
1% ,$2 #2(&$
"
$ 2$22/ " & &
& 1 "& !( $! 2& $% &$ ", 2$&! $ & $$"
&$(( 2" 0 .
, %$,!+# " ($% 2$".
%!((/ ! "
" 22 ("1"$+"
# " : 1 "( "&$!( %$ 2 "2!" 1 "&$ &$" $!, #!+$+1 1" 2$&! $!" & &,. 2! # " ! #2$ &2$&"!
! ( % !
", A$! '!
"$ "$2 &!2!($!
0
22$ & &$#2(
& .
# $/ '!
#
1 "& - 2& , %$(($.
% # 6 9; +,)* )% ()%+- )./ / % +!!+!
( $!
2$&! $&
".$ "2".
#(/
" ! # , .
= "
( +& & .
1 =2(
" 1
% 2$&! 22 ""
/ #
! $ (, / . '!
" $ + +$!
$ +$=
" &$%$" &$6= $ (/ 4
@!# ,
, . $ 2( /" & ( $( !21 &$1/ 2$& , .
.
(" %$# .
+$= $6= &
$!" & $% 2$ &! $ 9; !! " # $!% &' ()* *1.+!
&&$"
$ %% 9= ;$% " A$ +($< 9 :0 0;, .$ #2( 2 &( $% - <
& . "2$ " "( ""$1$A$ :;%$+
<$ A # (= $.1, A$ +( :;
;
%% 9= ; " "2$ "$(/$ #2( $%% & $% A # (= 2$$% A # (= 9= ;
;
($&$" & 2$%$(/$ #2( 1
& #
(,$ &( ( !
!"# / $%
$% &!$"/ " &
$ +(2$ $ /$% #2
9; +")% 2+3+* 4).+1 -% 3$ &!&
((/, A #
? 2$ 9= ;
; $ ((/ /%$!" #2(&$
"$2$22/ "1!2$ %! (/ / , !(#
"
1 & & &1 "&
($ +( &$ " !$% #2(, %$!"
$$% 2$&! $& &!#+( 8 (
$% % &$, ( "
( A$!
(/ / &$&(!""
2$&! $ %
(" $ 2$ $1 & +/$" $ "$!+
( .
$ + " $ & & , +! $ !+ 1 "% &
1 "& B #2!
" !"
# $%
( , %$, .((6 $", +
" $ %
22&
$ $% 1 "&, " !%% %$# $ 21 /.
%& 22 ( * &&$"
(/, 22
( % (" +/ $% ! + ""
# " /0/# )1, 2
3 ,-,.
2& (3