High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/487/2010disposed of

Satnam Singh v. State Of Punjab

2016-01-06Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal,Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina13 pages

!"#$#%&'&()* *

'' (( )) * !"#"

' "( + ) +, ---- +, -

$! " , -!* +.

/ ! + 0 /1 -!!+ (+ #/ + 0 / (( )) -! !"

+ !

/ ++ ) + 0 . !)/$#%&/ ! "( + --- . "(( ) "& ) +&3

%#+ 0 0 + !+ ! " 0 + +("" +&3 ) ! + ++ ) "" "4#+ / !"!1 ! &3 (( )) "

& 0 0 + 0 (#"

&) #+ ! 0 5 6+ $ ) + 76$78 !"

! #!+ ! )%

"& " 0 + #+ !

) (!"

9& "+ "/(3 ":/;

#"+++ #) /#+ !

#! !

#"(!"

!"< " =6><$ ;1"!

" ! + " ?

()

$@/&!

! + 0 " +)%

00 !+

()/ 1" ! "+ -

)) A! $#!/ $ )0 6")&+/ "!0 !"!+1"!# (! )B+!3A + &!

!"+ "" !/1

1 ! ))!! + ! )B+!3

1""

+ # 1/ 1"+ &#" "" ") ++ !

31)7- !7 (( ))1"(#!0 " ++ !!

!1 + B (3 () ?

()

C #)+3 0+ / ::& #,5 (/)%

+ 0 " + 0" /&!

! ()/1"

1!+" 31)7- !7 !+ + 3!

(( )) 6 / ! 31)7- !7/

(( ))) 1 1 ! & 3" "&!

! /

(( ))1"

)+ 7B!(7 " ++1"!" " ()?

()

$@+ "&!

!#!+ !%

$@1 ! )"

1!+" 31)7- !7+1 ! B 1)B6 / %+ ! ?#! 1

" & < + )"

00 ( + C ! # +0!3+ "

(( ))+ """

0 ""

# / 31 1!+" C !"+ / "+ 00#" +/& 31""+ !

(( ))2 "+& 31 !B + "

( )& #+" !0 A !" +7))B!7 00

)++ 0 ) ""

+ 0 " + !+ + 36 /

(( ))/1

)+ 7B!(7 "!

+/)0 +7B!(7 &) 1 )%

/&!

! ())%

))+ 1 #++&)

+"! +

D !

%#!3 1")0 +2

()/ "&!

#!+ !%

+)"

%+ !?#!!" + )!C ! 00#" +) +!

"( 2 3!! + 0) +

+ +.#!# B A "()/ !"!1 ! ! +#+ !! 2)) ) +

! ( !/ ( + 0 !1" C $!()

6/ 6 !

/$ )0 $ ".#!&< !/ !"!/ () +

" ! 0 !+ +1 1" !++00 ( +"0 !! 0 6 $!()

/ 6 !

/ $ )0 $ " .#!&< !/ !"! $@ ! 0 !+ + ( )0 (!

0 + " 0 ::/ ) 1 !( )0 0)"1 ! (! " 2 ( B!-+0 0 1 (!

)) +0 0B ! 1"! 0 + ! )%

/! "+

A!(#!/ 31)7- !71"+ +%#! +0 + .#!#

B A "()/ !"! 6$!()

) 1 " ( "! 0 +

"()+ & +1! ( !

+ 0 !2 + 0 ! ( + %#! +1"# B " ?

()

$@/1

1" 3 1 ""+(! "

"()/ ((!

0 + 6$!()

"" ! 0 !+ +1 1"

! + + " + " $#%& !+ & !! 0/1 1" " +&3 6$!()

()/ 0 #+ ! 0 5;56$1"+ # 2

" 1"" ( )0 "

"&) %+ !?#!

"! 0" 2 0" #& !1""B + & ! + !

"! 0" !! 0 ( + 0 !7" ( /0 1 #)+& B " 0 1" & 0 +2 !

)

"B + & ! +

1! ) "" 6$!()

) 1 "

( "1 ! &#"3 " 2 1! 1"! 0 + ( )0 " + =61"!

" ! + &"" " 6$!()

$@0 +#0 + "

0" A $@ 1 .#!# B A "() ::+ "#& + (()0 0 0 ! + + 0 ! " ( !+ + %#! +)%

2 ( 1" + 0)! +# B " 2 $@ 1

"() 5:: 2 %#! +1" + 0)! +# B " &3 + 0 !"6 / %#! +)%

+ +-+A "()/ !"! 6$!()

1 -+A "()/ !"! ::+"

( + 0 ! + 0 ! ( + %#! + +"# ! +" ! #"&!%#!31

#)+! "#) "+ 2 (()0 " +&3 " B (

+ 0 !" .#!# B A "()+-+A "()1 !

+ ! + + 0 !! 0 ( ( + 0 !/ 6$!()

1 ( )0 " 1 ! AC ! 0 !+ +

0 #+ ! 0 56$2 " 1"++ + &""

( &3 + 0 !2

#" " 00#" +( !"

"1 !

!+ +/&# 30 #)+ & !0 +2 ( )0 (!3 +" #(0 0B

( "2 ( 1?

1 ! " 0! ! 1"! 0 + 00#" + (( ))/#!+ !

#"0 0E# +1 ! (! " &)!

+2 ( 2 ( )0 (!31 "+()0 +!! " +

+#!+ !

+ !! " "><$4+><$?! "( 0 )3

" ()><$F ()0 !! "1"(! (! +$ !"

)" !0 "><$-+>< $ 1 ! (! (! +6 1")"

" ! ) " 00#" +

!!! "

#! " /

(( ))+

+"0) "#! " :::!

!+ 0 ) 7B!(71

+0 + 0 2 7B!(7 +& 0 0 ) + &)!

+ !2 ( +% &!+ +!2 7B!(71"

#+ ! !""/1 #)+ ! 0 ! +&3) + ( )0 (!3 "+()0 "0) "#! " ><$$1"! 0 !+ +1 1"" + &3

(( ))+ " +&3A.#!1+ !

+ "&) )%

(( ))) + ( )0 (!3 +"0) " +()0 +

! 0 ! +7B!(7!

!""2 "+7B!(71"B ( "" "" + ><$G ()><$ ()0 ! 0 !3 7B!(71"(! (! + "B 0 >< $ 7B!(71")"

(! (! +2 " " 1 "" "1 !

! 0 !+ + !0 () " 0" /( )0 ! ( ! 0 ))1") + #! ) ! +4#+0)- "! " )""/ !"! : 2 ) ! +- "! / 1 0 #+ ! 0 5 6$ & )) +/ + !+ ! + + / + 0" #! "" / !"! !!)2 ) ! + ++ ) "" "4#+ / !"!/

0" 1""" +/+

!+ !+ +5/ #+ (!0 0" ! 0 (#"

&) #+ ! 0 5;56$1"+ # " 00#" +/

(( ))")"

#!+ !

#/ #)+

!+ !?#!2 31 ! 0 !

+00 !+ )3

#! !) 0" / %#! + )%

+ + / !& #1 3 !"+ ! " 00#!! 0 !+ )3/"#(() !3( )0 ! ( !1") +)) ""

0 #+ ! 0 5;5 6$ 2 00#" + 1 ! 00 !+ )3 !

+ 0 #+ ! 0 5;56$2 (!

" 0# / !+ ! "&)"

"0" / < +"3" 1 "" "9& "+ "/ + ! ++ 0# " + 0 2 "

(( ))1"! 0 !+ + !" 0 55 + !) $!

0 +#! 7!$7 !"

!+ + 0 (( ! " 1"

(# 6 "+ 0 / " + 1" 0 + +& )" )3()0 + 0"

)) + 00#!! 0 !

B()0 6 + 0 /AA!()

@1" < + A &!

" !

5 + + !

" ! + ( )0 " 6")&+ 0 #+ ! 0 5;56$2 "+=61"

" ! + " ?!"

?#!"

F#& 32

"+=61" < & +">< @; A )"

" !0

" ! +( )0 " 6")&+ ! 0 #+ ! 0 " 55;5;5 6$ 2 "+ =6 1" !

" ! +

" #!%?#!"

$!F) (3 "+=61"

< & + " >< @; A 1" 0!

< + &3 $#&)0 $!

" 0# ! ) ! + ++ ) "" "4#+ "+ ! + + 0 + !) ! 0 !++ )+ (( ))

#)3 0 #+ ! 0 56$ #!+ ! )%

2 !00#" +/ )3/#!+ !

#/ #) + !+ !?#!1 ! 0E# + !

(( )) "& " 0 + ) (!"

9& "+ "/(3 ":/;

++ #) /#+ !

#! !!

#"(!"

"< "2 "+ !+ ! 0 0 +" 0 """) + "

(( ) -!* +.

/) ! +" #" )/(( ! 1 -! !+ (+ # (( )) "0 + + /0/

(! " 0 3 1 "" "/ )3/ ?

()

$@ + #!+ !%

$@"

)3+ #&#)+" "&)"

+ 6"

"#& + & ! &!

!" )%

+ 0 " ++ 3 + ( " + #! (!

" 0# 2 ! + 0 /"

"#& +/")&) & !#) + # 0 "+ ! +0" "

<0)#+ + ! " "&)"

" 0# 0" 630" /"

"#& + !

0"+0!0#"0 " 0" 0 #+ ! 0 5$! 666$ "0& "+ & + #"

! 0+ + 00#!! + :: ++ + / ! 1 3 !" + ! "/ + ! 1"

+"0 !

"() > !1" /"" + 0"

#)+& 0 ! +&3><0 ( 0 56$"#0 "1" 0 + 0+ + 00#!! +"#++

+ !B 3#+# + !0 0!# ) ! 6 ! "( " / -! !"

+ !

/ ++ ) + 0 . !)/$#%&/) ! + 0 #" ) ""#& + 0" " (( ))"0) !)3+ #2 ) ! +!) #! "! 0 !+ +! + " (( )) !0 "+ ! )) + 0 + !)

! 0 !+2 " " )&) & ! ! +1 + %#+ + !+ ! ) ! +!) #!! )&) & "#" ++#( )+ @ #!

#)0 "+ ! "

) ! +0 #" ) (! "+1 !"""0

! 0 !+" 0" " ?

()

()$@+ "

!#!+ !%

$@"#(( ! (!

" 0# 0" F ! + " #" )(( ! (( )) "/

1 !/"#& + 1 ! /0/ (! " ()0 00#!! 0 "

(( )) + )%

( !0 0 9& "+ "/ "+1 "" "

0 ! ( !0 0 + " (!

!&))3!"

! )3

" 3 0 0 1 "" "6")"

"#& + ! " (! #"

3& 1 (! "A 1 !/1 ! 1 0"+ 0!0#"0 "+ !1 7B!(7&) 11")0 +/1 "

& ! +&3 +0) + 0 ! 0 !++ +

(( )) +)0 +7B!(7&) 1 + )%

2 ! ! / ) ! +" #" ) 1"

0 0 1 #)+ & #0 " 00 " 0+

00#!! + )) ! ( () + ! ( !

0 > 0" (!

" 0# " )%

1!+"

(( )) )) 0 31 1"+#

"&!

()

()$@ ) ! +" #" ) (( )) "0" 5$! 666$3& 0 "+ ! +6" & 0 +

" 0# 0" " )%

+ 0 " + +

1!+"

(( )) )) 0 3 1"+# "&!

()

+ +)3/ ! " (! #" 3& 1 1 "+ "

(( ))1"" + & 0!!3 7B!(7

" !"(! + " & &!

! 0 !+&3 (!

" 0# A 1 !/!

#! %#!3 "

& )0 + + )%

/1 "" ) &) 1/0& !! + (( )) + B

1) + %#!3 +1 #)+! "#) + )%

)

++ + 0#" "+ 2 "" ! "

! 1" (! !()

+1")%

+0 2 0"

(( ))1 #)+))1 ><0 ( 0 56$/1

! +"" )) 1", H

#)(&)

0+ " #!+ ! "

#(! + "#++

("" #( "#++ E#!! )+1

# + !

B #+# + !0 +0!# ) !##"#) !

6" !)"#0 0" "1 (!3 !"

0 " !"""#)I 6 !+ ! (()3+ B ><0 ( 0 56$/ #!! E#! "! & #))) +/ 0+ 00#!! + "#++

9 ! 1" (! + 9 01 ! "#) + 0+ 1"+ ("" 9+ + ! + B 3#+# + !0 0!# ) ! 2 ( ! "( 0" 0+ #" & "#++ + (! + + "+ "/ + !#" B 3#+# + !0 + 0!# ) ! 2 ><() ><0 ( " " "

!)"#0 0" "1 (!3 !" (!

0 "

!"""#)2 ! ! /" 0 ""!3

E# " "

! + (!

0 + !"""#)2 !1

0+ + 00#!! + 1" "#++

+ #(! + +9 & "+ "/"

!"0 )) 0 3"0 0 ! +/ !) <0 ( ! " " & &!

! 0 !+2 ! " "

! 1" 3& 1 1 "+ " 60/00 !+

" 0# 0" / ! 1"&#" ""+ ) "& 1 6"#0 "# /0 & "+ (( )) + 0#"

+ )%

2 ! ! /1 ! 1 0" 1 #)+&

1 #)+))1 ><0 ( 0 56$2 "" ! "

/ ! "

++ +) " !1 3 !"+ " 0+ + 00#!! ++ ! +& +"0 !

+ !

"() ! "

B / ""

0 $!

!/ (! = ! "0- +0 +2 <0 )

3/.

! - +0) )) / !"!

$@ " ( + 0#" + 0" 1"0 (! "" &!"! "#) "#&+#!) 0#" +&3 )+ ) +1 #++ "0!& + %#!3

/1 1""#0 !+!30 #!" #! 0#" + 6%#!3

"& +" )) 1", H 03"0"1 )) <:01"(! " !

(! ( !)!

+61"(!

% 0 (!

)3 "

! C 0 ! ""1 )) 1 )" +

"0!<01"(! " < + !

&0B !

!+ < + #( 0 ! ) (! )!

0#! + ! !

#+ "0!!B/"##! !B"1 !

(! " C+"" 0 ( ! !

( (! )&

1" (! " + #) "B#))1" + 0 "!

1 &0B)B 03"0"1 )) 1"(!

% 0

# C 0# / 3 )) 1"

+ !"(! )#+ "#! :000 "0 #2 ! &!

"1 )) 1"

+ " 03"0 "1 )) 1"

00#(3 % !( ! !

0 ! &!) "( ! +)"#!0 ) 0 ! &!) "( ! 1"

+ (! "" +! 00 # 0 (! "" 0#" +&303"0 "1 )) A ! (( 0(#" 3! & "+ 1"(! "

!) #" 2 1

&!1": "I ) ! +!) #! " )+ 0" & #!+ ! 1 !/ 0"+0!0#"0 "/1 ! 1 (! " "0" 0#)(&)

0+ # #!+ !2 0#" +

"& + & "#&+#!) /1 "00##) 0 ! &!

"())#+= "#&+#!)"(0 ! +%#!36(( !"

& ! ) )30 /&#" " +#!) " !3! 1 )) + + 2 %#!3& )++)%

"#! + !) "1 3 !"+ ! " ! 0+ +)"

0 + & +"0 !

"()/"E# + ! 1" (! (( )) #!+ ! )%

)

+ B

1) + + #)+& 0#" +&3)0 7B!(7&) 1 " + F ! + 0 #" ) ! " ) + + -! + ! ?#! !/ $$/ #( ! + / !) 4)/ !"!

( ! + (!"

#+ !

(( ))6 !" "++/ (( )) "#+ !

0#)(!"

#!3 !"/ ) "+1 3 ! +3""

:A " ! +! "" 3 !"/ "+

+3"A" )(!"

0)#+ ! "" "" 3 !"/ "

+ +3" :2 ! " !0" " (( )) ! ! / 0"+0!0#"0 "/1 #)+& %#"+ <( + +3 0 (( ))!

0 56$ 0 5$! 666$9& "+ "9 +3 " 0 (!"

!) ( ! + (!"

)! +3#+ !

&3 2

(( )) + 0#" + + )%

00 !+

() ?

()

$@ )) " &!

!" 1 ! !! +9 & "+ "/)%

+ 0 " +1"553 !" "+

00 !+ ( " ! ! ( ! 2 ! ! / 0" + 0!0#"0 "/ 1 #)+ & %#" + <( + 0 ( " "://;

#( " )0"(+&3 (( )) ) ) !" + 0 " +)%

!+ )3/ (( )"(!)3)) 1 ++ 0 (( )) ! 0 #+ ! 0 5 6$ + " 0 (!"

!) +)"

" 0 "" "+ A 1 !/ (( ))

"0 0 + 0 #+ !

0 5 $! 66 6$ + " 0 + ( ! + (!"

)! +3 #+ !

&3 9 & "+ "/ "

)) (3 0 ( " "://;

#( " )0 ) ) !" + 0 " +)%

))(31 1 "!

+ ! 0 ( 0 (3

!+ !2 "+ #"

))& + ( " + #! ) ! + 4#+0)- "! / !"!/1

))+"&#!" "

) ) !" + 0 " + )%

! +# !0 2

(( ))/ 1 +3 !0" /& " )& !3 ! 1 ---

@ & ! !! + ! ( ! !,J "