High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1136/2013allowed

Nisha Singh & ANR v. State Of Punjab

2018-05-18Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri17 pages

!"!#$%&% '' (

))' *+' ' ( '

,$ -), ' -), ''.)

" $% '.)/ &' ( ( %$ )

* +( $ ! ,$!

$ -$.))+ ( +

/0 ( $ ! 1 (

2$ +( !$ 3 2!4 *51 3( ( 674 $ +) $( $ -$ .))(+ (#(( ))$

$( 8$+ &' 0 ( !( ( $ ( + ( ( 0 ( !(#

& ' 9 ($ ( *

! ;/!. 9( # !(#( !

) ( #(!. !(

( #( $+ (

90 -05 *) 9 # 9( < $

+ )( ) ( $ 9( < ##) ) ( + ( (# ( # (

=($!.09( # !( (( ( +( $ +$#() # ( + !.09( # !( #( # )+ "0> (() !( ,0 !( ( () #) #((

$ + .() #(9()!(/! - ) /" !(,+) ( )( (# % ( + # =(#((

( ( ) !. 9( # !( ( / <( + / !

)$ ( ,(( 0 ( !() ( ( ( ( "

? ; $ ( ( $ +! ;/!.09( # !( ( ( ? #($! ;/!.09( # !( 8$ "$ !( 2! ) ( ( ( ($( # !

2! ( ( )) ( 90 @0 5 )) (+ $)# $ #(( ++($A $( # )1 ) (# ) ( ) + ($A #(# $ * 1< ( ( # +

!.09( # !(#( )B9!C#(( $# ( D09()!( =(2! ( #(( ) B"!C ( ) # A )) EF , + ( # #+(2! -$8 EF E# ! ( #(( ) G.- EF G # # )) EF " -EF # $ !1( $ 0 !(#

)

,() EF )( # ( ,$ $ #( ( $ !1( (

$+(( $# A

$(( &:' =( ! $ % ( ( $ $$ $ F ) #09()!(8$ +( ( #(( (+ ( $ $$ ( $ ( #(

#((

$+( (! $(( ( ($# #(+ ( ) ( ,$ =( ! $ $( ( ( ( # )

+ ( + ) $) (

$ ()( $( &1' >A#(

+ + ( )( (,() EF )# % ($ ( # + + )

+ $ +#((

( ) # ) #( ) (

) # =(( ( ($#( +# % + ( () + 8$ + $ +) =( $ ( (

# % ($ +( # $((

#(( # $(#($( ($8$ + $( ) ( F $ $ # 2! "$ !( $$ ( ( $( ()) # % ( $ $( (

$ (# + (( #( # ( # ) # % ( $ # ) ))$

( # # ) )+ + ) + ( ) ) ( ,( $ $% + ( ,$ 2." - ,( 2"$% !!!

$,( ) $) -(,))# % ($ (# ( ( ( # ) & ' . ( ( ( ( ! $ !

$ ( () $ -$.)) + ( ((%$ )

&' > $ ( ( ( %$ )

* # $ %$ $)( (# 0) #((!1 H 1( #(

F ) ( +$( $ $ $ (#( # #(#$+ ($( # (

F ) ( ) $ ( $ + ( #09() !(#()( # $ () +# F ) ( A # ) $ (

( ( #$( +(

)+ +(

)(( =( +# )

$ ) # ((,() EF ) *

+ #( $(") )# #(($ ,G!>)# #(( +# ) # #( =( ( #

)$( ( # $ ( $ + =( # )

( )##((#(() ( ( $ + # ((+ ) $ $ $$#(+ + #( ( ) )

&5' !

" $% ( ()$ %$ ) (

(

(+ $() &*' D( ( $( ( $) (#( ( ($ (

)$$ 8$ ((

() & ' $ ( $8 *

+ ! ;/! ) ( ) 5

) $( ( $ 0 ( !( ( ( $ )(! ;/!.9( # !(2!"$!(# 8$ ( ( ( ) ( = !$)

90 @0 5

=($8 +) ( $A# ) #) ( )) $ ! 1/ /51( $(( (#(# ( ( # ( !(#( () #) #( +# ( +# $ +(! ;/!. $(( 9()!( ! - )# % # &' D0 !. 9( # !( .( ,. ! (

(# ! ; !) ( $5

#( (+ ##) #) ( $#()# ( #((() #) #( +#( + "> (() !( , !(( $ ( ) ) 9() !( ! - ) " !(,+) (#( ))( 9( < # % #( + $(

(8$(2!) (!("$!( ( (

#( .(0F ) D0 # ( ( ( ) ( )( !(# (A# (+ + ( $( !( ( !( # A# () ( ( ) #(( # ( ( +# ($ ( )(#( ) #( ( + # =( + #

% ( ( #(( #

% (

#(( # ($( =(%#(((+# # ( $ 1/ A)( =($)(%# ) (22-#((+ )(! D( !( +)( ( # ( (+ ($((+# + (

$ "> (() !( , !(( ( !( (

( ( $$($ $ (

( # ( + ( D 9()!()() ( $5

# # )( $

(# $1 /11+ (

))#()((

( ( $( ((

) (2! # $5 :1 ( ( (

* 1 ) ) ( !(# 5 1/5

) ( ( $ ( #( ( ( $( 2!() F ( ( +

( #(() $( )($8

($(,

!( $ $

( , !( ()( ) !(

) ( (+ (($ !( $

)$ (,( ( )

+$(($#(( $ ()

( # A ( (+(

A( !

(( #(() (

+(# )(! ,G!>)) *# ( +() # ( (# +) $(

$ ( (

( ( ( (2!( + ($( ( # 8$ (

$A )( +$# ) 8$ ( # ( $ > (( #( (

)( ( (( ( ( ( A ( A ( ( (2! (

A #) 2! -+))# $

+) $ #( + ) ( ( + )

% ( &' D0 , !((0F ) ,G!>)# #(() #(( + ! ;# F ) !

)# A - ( ()

+ ,

<$) )$( ))(F ) & ' D0 !. !( ($ , !(

( (

+ #( (

$ + $ #

> (()I> ((#/ !(/!

)$ (,( #()((

#( ( ( ( $ ( ( $ ( " > (() !( ( $ ( ( #( (

+)(# !(/ A !(/ !

)$ ( ,(

.(0F ) (

) # ( ( ( ) ( )( !(# ( A# + $(

) ( # ( +# ($( ( (2!(

( (

$* 1 (

( + $

( 2!(

$( ( + $

))) *,G!>)# # ( #(A# $( ) A((# +(.

;

($ #((($)90 -/5 * $ +#( #( (+ ) ( !

$+# )

+(.

;

#((# + +(.

;

($ (22-$)#$(($)# (22-(#(( ( $ ( ( $ ($ # 9() !(# A# ( + (# $

/ 1+ ( A##((D 9()!((

# +( =(2! ( ( $* 1 =( ) ( !(# +(2! $*

=(#((

( (

#((

$ +)( $(( 2! =( +# #( $

&:' D0 "> (() !(

(# !

) ( (

+( #(!. !( ,

!( !

9( # !( ( ) ( 90 -/5 *#((# + , %!( #( $+ # # $ )

+ $ !

9( # !( A ( ( #($ $ #() # # ( #( )# ( !( ( , !( ( (

+ ((#((

$ + ( #( $) (((#()( !( !( !

)$ (,(( (# ) + (A#()

+#() , !(( # > (()I> ((# !( !

)$ (,(( (+( +(

A . 0F ) ( ( ( $ #(((A((# 0$+( (

+( 90 -/5 *# $ +#(F ( #((+ )( $+ )

#((# + ( $ ()$( $ ( 22- $) 22- #(( # + ( .;0 9( # !( ($ #((( $)( )(# (22- =(+(

)( $

) ((

) +(! ;( ( # :

A ) $ ( $ #(! ;) () ( ( A#() (+ (

( !( /1A =( +# $)

) #( # ( ( $ ( ($ ( ( (2! ) ((#((

$ (( +(

+#( ) # ( $# + ( + #( .

;

# ( # #A( ( (

(($ !( ($ (($$) ( )((

%(($ !(( $ (# ) + ( !( (

#(( (+ #) ( (

) ! ) ( ( ( ( % + #%+)+ (($ !((

+# (A (( # A +)$ # ( ( # # #(( # ( ) ( ( + + # ( ( )(#) # ( )( #

) ( ( ! ( $ +( (# ( #( ( ($ ( ( ($#(( +# $ #( # $ (+ + =( #(A($8 (

($ (( ( )#

+)(

+$($ #( ( ) ($ (#)$()( + ) (($ ()#(( + ( ( =( +# #( ) A ( $ #(( )( + (($(# ((

( !(

+(,$() .# #$( (

!(#

((

#(($ &1' D05 "$ !( , 3-4 >$ ( (

( # 2! ) ( . ( 0F ) (

) ((

( ( $* 1 ( ( ( ## 5A))( + =( #( (

A ( $8 (

$ ( . # ( ( +# # +( ,$ (#(

% #% ( ($ ( )(#( =( + # (( ) + ))9 9( < ($( ( A# #( # A ($+( ( )F( +) A ()$ & ' D ( ( $) $ ( ) +( 5

$8 + ! ; ! ) ( *

# ) ( ( !( $A# ) #) )) $ !1/ /51( $( # ) ) ( ( !( #

( #( ( ( # #( + # ( + " > (() !( , !( $ + ( ! ;/!. 9( # !( ) +2!0"$!( ( ( ( * 1 ) ( :1

( ( ( ## 5A))( + , #(A($8 (

$ ( (

+# ($( #(D0 !.0 )!( (0 F ) ( (2!$ ( +

$(( A((# +(.;($ #(( ( 90 /5 * # $ +#( #( (+ )(! $+# )

+(.;#((# +(.;$($ (22-$)$($)# (22- (#(( ( $ (

0: ($ E # ) ( $ ( ( ( #9()!(#

1+ ( A##((((

+( =(#((

( ( #((

+ ) ( $ ( ( 2! ( +# #( $

&' ; (( ( D0 " > (() !(

#( ! ) ( ( #( !. !( , !(!.9( # !( ( )( 90 -/5 *#( ) 9 9( < <($ ## $)

+ ((()#(#

( !(# ( #(((# + ( , !(( (

+ ( ( #( $ ( ( ( #( ( !( !( !

)$ (,( ) +A#() $(

+#() !(( # > (()I> ((#/ !( !

)$ (,(

.(0F ) (

) (

$( 90 -/5 *#

$ +#(F( $( #((+(

)( $+# )

#((# +

( $ ()$($ (22-$) 22- # + .;09( # !( ( $ #(( ( $))(# (22- ( ( # A#() (+ (

( !( /1A 2!(

) (( #(((

$ ( +

+ #( ) =( D0 " > (() !( +

+( ((# ( ) ( ) F ) 00( (

) ((

!( (#> (()I > (($(0F ) (

) ( # A# () ( + ( ( (

( ($ !( ($ (($$) ) ($ !( (#) +(

!( (

#(( (+ # ) ( ( (

) ! ) (( ( (

( +#%+)+ (($ !( ( () ( D0)( ( A

3 *

) ( $ ( ! ( ($ #( ( + # &5' D0+#

D05"$ !(,3-4>$ ( 2!) ( )( +(.; $*

)( ()

( :1

D( ( D0 " > (() !(($ ( ($ $ *

( ( ()(2!(

)( ( ((

$ ( ( ($

(+# D052!())# *

#( +# )

D0(

($ +*

(

$ ( ($ (+ (

((8$() A ( (2! ( $ (2!D05()

()* 1 :1

=(+$#((

#( ((2!# (# D0 ( ( + $ ( + ( $ ( $ &*' D0 ((

!((( ((#((# #( (0F ) (

) ( ( #A#()(+ $( ( ( (

( ($ A# ( ($ ( )+ )) (

+$ $(( ( (

()()(,$(

+ D0 , !( $ $ + ( D(

( > (()I > (( ( (

( (#

D( D0 ( ( (

$ ($ D0 !.0 9( # !( D0 "> (() !( , !(( ( ( $$($ $

=( )

( D0#(

( ) A ($ ( ( /1

A (# +*

=($(+$(

#((+# $ ($ + & ' !(+ / !( ( ((+ $$ ( ( () #( ( + ( # # )( ) (

$+($ A(($+ ((+ $$ () # $ )(($

!(#((# 5

+ + ( )

( ($ A 2D0#(# (F ( $ ( ($ !(

(#( D0# ( + *

=( ( 8$ ( ( !( ( ( (( ( () &' ;) () #(( )( )

*/,G!> ) # ( ) ( D0 , !(#( ,G!>)#

#(() #( + ! ;# F ) )# A! # ( ()

#( ( *

# ( ,G!>)$)

*($ +(.; ( ($ ( #( ( ) ( # ) ( ($ ( + #( ( G

!> +( ( ) ($ +

( ) + $ (+ ( ) ) #(+( .( (

) + D0 , !( ( ,G!> ) #

#(() #(( + ! ;# F ) (# ( ()

+(( $ $( () A .((( ( (# ( #( (%$ ) +$$ &' + ( %$ )

* !7

!( 8$ (( ) () ( + 8$ + ( G

+ + 0 !($ () 0 1 0'.)1 %&% D(( A/ J/ D(( J/