High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/266/2011disposed of

Sarabjeet Singh v. Intelligence Officer, Dir. Of Revenue, Ldh.

2015-08-14Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh43 pages

!" #!

% #&&%#!

' ()*

# % +"$%#!

' ()*

) ,-) .. . . ,-) . !

" !#

$ %&'((%#')**

$ %&+,-%#')** ! .

$ %&'((%#')**

$ %&+,-%#')** /// . . . / " $ .

&%'((%# ')** 1

2 3

$ .

&%+,-% # ')** 1 4

25 6 % 3 2 3 # .

*))*')**

*')*')** 1 7

$ 4

2 $ &%'((%# ')**

$ &%+,-%#')**3

'* &

1 *8,-25&6% 3

9,8%$

$ 25$6% 3: " ;

'- .*8-825. 6% 3" ! 4

. . " 1 1 *-))))<%2

. . 1

'* & : . . 1 1 '))))<% 0" 1

. . = .

9,8%$ $ # 1

1"1$ .

&%'((%# ')**

'* &

9,8%$ $> "

1 "1 $ .

& %+,-%# ')** ;

. ? &,8 '-)9'))+2@=A*'<3" 1 4

'B'-',

'8& 9,8%$$ '- .

*B- $.*8('25$.6% 3 ? " . 1

7 25 6 % 3 # 4

C . D

1 . 1 5! @.6 $ & 4%8$%,'8) 4

0 "

2 $ %&'((% #')**

$ %&+,-%#')**3

D ;

" 1

0 1" 4

1 " 88B)))<% 288B *)))<% 3 +8') D

" 506. #C

5&,))6 " .1 . C 9(

. . D

1 .

*)))))<%2 13" " C .

(+&: C

. 1 .1 "

" ; .1 7

E E % D :

"10 " 7

&" 7

0 7

2 3

2506F 3 "

. 7

D 1.

.. 0 D 1

.. ".

9'& '*)9'))+

" 1 ..

0 " . E 0 "

6 .

. D

1 .

.. "

1 . 0 ". . 1

. " .1 . 0

"; .

D : 1 .

'*'B'-',

'8 &

9,8%$$ '- .

*B- $." G. . 4

. *(*)'))+ $

%.% 7

0 . ? " ".

" 1

D 5 6

D " "

-) & 1

1 C

; "

0 1

" 5 6" 1 4

*-)*-<%" .D1 . D

. . &

1 *(-<%"

. D1 . D A " DC "

1 *)))))<% "

5 6

1 D " " 1"

. C .D 506

" =

D D "

D " # D"" " 1"

D " ;

D "

. "

" H& D 0 "

D "

,B9)D

+8')D

. D " . C

" = D"

" . 50 6$. 1D D <

. " .D

57II6 <

D88B

1 *)))<% " =.

1 "

D " .D 5&,))6 "

D.D . 1

" ".1. C

" ; 1

D 1 .

.. .

. D

; 1

*)))))<% . " . ..

&" 0 . " "

. "

+8')D " '-+9)))<% " D " " C 0 D

1 88B)))<%

" 9(

" C

$. " .

$."!

1 ?

6 *B)9*888

)()(*8+)

** $. 1 0 5! @.6

B)))))<% "

. C

" C

" . .

& .

(+ &

$. '*)9'))+: . .

. 1 C

: "

. . :"

. E &" .

1 !< 7 @= . 23 4 . "

" .

" . G "

G "

D "D

1 .. : "

1 "

" . . 1 . .D

D : 1 . . " . = " 1 .17

" ; .

. .

D 1 .

.. 7

= . 1

D 1 .. 7

. .

. . 1 1

. 27

;

. . 0 7 1 *88+ "

3 "

0:" .0 7 *88+ "; 1 $. .7

" .

. . "

. .

" 7

. .1 "

. .: "

1 D 1

. .

*8)9'))+ . .

. .

D 1 .

.. . E '))9'))+ 0 1 "

" = : 1

B'-D . "

" 1. .

0 . " "

. D

D E E % D:

"11)( B).

1)( B).

. . . :"D " D

=D ." D ". "

D ."

. ')))))<%

" D " "

" ."" 1D

" .

*)))))<%

" D

. 7

. *)))))<%".. 7

. . . 1D 7

" D 1 *)))))<% . .

. . . =

" " 5! I 6 "

"D 1

"1D D

D 1

. .

. "

" 1

""D

" . . :

" .

0 4

% E0 ** )). "

0 1"D : 1

" 7

$ 4

1 )+)*')), %

'* & 9,8%$ $

'- . .

% " . )+)'')),

'))9'))+*) 9-. E0 0# "

+8') " 1 . "

5! @.6$&4%8$%,'8)

1..

'*&> . .

" D2 3

88BD "

1..

9,8%$$>1 . .

" .D 506 (B-..

" (

.D5&,))6" ".1. C

'-" 1.

1..

'- . 0 "

= . . "

. =.

G. 4

2A*3> D .

$ @= $.. 0= @ 4

2A'3> .

!D $.:. 2AB3> " G.4 0=. $ @= &" 2A93>

1 IH &" 2A-3>

IH&" 2A(3>!D E $ @= &" 2A+3>G

I &" 2A,3>7$

2A83>

IH&" 2A*)3> . $

: 4

2A**3>:$G

1 G

2A*'3

$. . 2A*B3

" 1 . 1

4! DA"

" .

" . B*B $ $ .

25$$6% 3

. " . 1 . : "

D 1 .

" . " . " . .1 E

" " D 1 . *9)B'))* " 2H3

? &')-'))*

B)+ $ 0

.1E.

" . ?

" D 1 0 "

. D

. . . : 1 1 . :" " 4

. " 1 "

" "

. 1" :. $

. 2A*3

.2A%*3? & ,8 '-)9'))+2@=A*'<3" 1

'*'B'-',

'8& 9,8%$$

'- .!

2A*3

D " . . "

? .

& ( ? 2@= A*'<3 . . . 0 "

0 " . 2!

% A*3 )+*)'))+ .

)'**'))+: .. 0 ? " 1:E.

2A'3 " =.

= .

1!<E! 4 .

" 1

" 0 .

= " 1 D 1 " 1 = 0" . "

D 1 $.. $.<

" *9)B'))* ? &')-'))*

B)+$" ')& <E.#

& :

1 . "

" @= A'<* .1E.

"1 0 ? "@=A'<' "

2A'3 $ & . "

" . 1. "

: ? &'B8 '))* G A :2A'3

2 % . 3 :

.1 G. E $.. $.

1 .

1 . ! G.E" '))9

" !D !D

!D". 7

$ 4

'*&

9,8%$$ :" " ;

'- ." ! 4

. . " 1 1

*-))))<% 2

. . 1

'* & : " . . 1 1

'))))<%2 0" 1

. . =.

9,8%$ $ # " 1

$ .

& %'((%# ')**> "

;

. $ .

& %+,-%# ')**

'+ . + .

$ .

'- . ! $

" ! #

% $ &%'((% # ')** . %. " 9' & .

. 1 " 1

. "

" 1 1

IH&" 2A*)3*) )). '))9'))+0 " .

. " . 9' & " 0

$ .

G. 2A*3

1 " >

. "

1 . "

1%" > . 7 % " " " =.

. " " 1=1 1 1 1.

. " 1

IH &" 2A*)3 G. 4

2A*3 . 1 "1 '))8

G. 4

2A*3

D .

$ @= $.. 0= @ 4

2A'3

B**$$ 1 . 1

IH&" 2A*)3 1 " . . 0 .

7 4

'))9'))+ " . " . 4

'))9'))+

= " . " " 1"

" 7 4

. . D . 2A'3

0 .

F ."

. " " 4

" '- D . .

$ " "

" .

. 1 .

" "=.

" .1

D" =.

1 0

" 1 2

3" .

%. -'% & . "

" =.

! .

. 1 0 1 $

. 1. . . " 1 & 1 ;

. 1 ! . . ;

. "

'+ .

+ .0 $ .

'- .:

'+ . A

. '))9'))+ 15@.! 6$ "

+8') D " 1% =

. . D

88B)))<% D

1 "

7 . 'B)9'))+

? &,8 '-)9'))+2@=A*'<3" 1 4

0 ? :"

. $

%.% 7

& 4

'*'B '-',

'8& " 9,8%$$ '- .

*'- $. . % " .

'* & 9,8%$ $

'- . 1 $ %

%. 9' & . 9' & "

. "

" 1 C

" " C

1 .

. D "

1 1

D "

1 1 "

& .. 1 . "

.. 1 ; 1 1 .

1 1 ; 1 "

$ & D 1

1 .1"

1 . 232 3% 2'3 9'& "

D "

1 . "

% 2*3

1%" 1 .. ;

. "

"D "

.. . 9'2'3&

IH &" 2A*)3 1

" & 4%8$%,'8) " " "

.. D" &" 4

0 " 0 # *) )) . : 2A*)3 "

@= :

IH&" 1 0 . 11

&" 2A*)3 " "

IH &" " . 1 %=.

2A*)3 . *) )). '))9'))+. "

"1 1 .

D ""

"D : 1 " : "

. .

D "

: D "

" 1

. . " 1 . . . .

@=" %=.

G. 4

2A*3

D .

$ @= $.. 0= @ 4

2A'3

IH &" 2A*)3 @=

1 5! @.6

& 4%8$%,'8) "

. . D &"

" 0 4

%&" E0 *) )). '))9'))+0 . " 1 1

2A*)3 7 % 1 # '))9'))+ 1

. .1 . D

0 " .D D . 2A'3

1 " .

D 1 '))9'))+)+ )). @= " " '))9'))+

" 7 &" % 1# . 1

D . 2A'3 . 1 '))9'))+

1 %. " 9' & $

" "1 1 '))8

%=.

G. 4

2A*3

D . 2A'3 1. G. 4

2A*3

%=.

" 1

7 %

G .2A'3 . "

. 1 ), )) . '))9'))+ 4 . "

. $

@= " 4

" G. 4

2A*3 . " . 1 ), )) . '))9'))+

. "

@= '))9'))+

.*8)) D . 2A'3 "

" 4

'))9'))+ " % =.

. $ "

. $ 7 . " .:

1 . "

. 1 . . 7 :" . " .. .:" 1 7 )+ )).

. . 7

. " . 1 . " ; 0 %=.

G. 2A*3

D . 2A'3

" %. 9'&# .

7 "

&1 . "

@= '))9'))+ . "

7 .1 1 # '))9'))+ "

. @=! D . 2A'3"D 1 " .

D 1 .. " 9'

" 1. 9'& $

" "

" 4

" '-D .. "

$ "

3 "

" .

. 1 .1 ; "

1 .

%&" E0 0# 0 "

. ;

"1. "

. "D 4

'-D ."1. "

0 1

@ "

1 .

.. .0 ."

. "

0 1 " ; . "

1 0

" . 4

2A*3 D E0 : "

" G . 2A'3

2A*B3

G .

:$ . $

0" " .1

D" 0 ; "

** B) . '))9'))+ : 2A*3 1

; "1

0 . G. 2A*31

1; 1

. 0 " D & 4

0 4

1 "

. 0 1

. "

" 1

2A*B3 " 5!D 6 $. .

@= !

@= !<* .

.. @=&"

. $"

" 0

. "

:$ 'B)9'))+

." $ $4&" 12@= 3 1

1G .2A'30 .."@=

5 6 "

0 $ $4 " "

"@=J

@=J<* .

5!D 6 $. : . 2AB3

5!D 6

0 1"

5!D 6 'B)9'))+

1 & &(<'))+

1 1"

@=!0 1 " . 7 ! * $ . : 2AB3

. 5!D 6 "

" @= () @= (+ 0 1 " . 1

< % 5!D 6 $. : . %=.

. "1

" "

1D 1 0 "

1 1"@= 1 )+)8'))+

. "

: D "

1 D 5!D 6

D 1 D 0 D &-

(

& * 9

. . . .0 " 5!D 6 5!D 6 . %=.

5!D 6 2AB3 " .

. .

. :" " . D

" . " 'B)9'))+ 2@= 3 " " 1 G . 2A'3 $ . @=.

$ $ 41&" .

H C+8') %"

'*)9'))+ .

..D 5'65#'65$'65'65@'65?'6

5E'6 "

. C %"

D 1

2 3"

" ..2

. $

: "

" . =.

< 1 1 $ . @=.

$ $ 41&" ."= $ $ 7 ! 4

'B)9'))+

;". . .. 1

$ . @=.

6 2@= J3 "

. . " 2 1!

: 3 . " .. ..

." 1D .

@=J<* " G. 4 2A93 " "D

I '*)9'))+ 1

1 .2A93

. B8))))<%

. . .

0 " ?.

1 " . 5 6:

.. . 5 60

" . " C 0 . "

G "

(+& %=.

1 "

1 2A-3 '*)9'))+ . " G. 4 2A93

: . " G.42A93

IH&" 2A(3"=.

:2A(3

""D

I )8)-'))+ 1 2A(3 7"

K 7 :

0 . . 2A(3

(+&0 . 7"

" 2A(63 "

. "@=EE#"

K 1

" 2A(63 : . .2A(3

(+&0 . #

" 2A(63 "

. "@=:: 1 G. G " 2A(63 '')-'))+: . .2A(3

(+ &0 . 1 " 2A(63 "

. " @= 77 . " . . 1 " .D

$ "

1 . &" %=.

2A(3

0 1 ..

(+&0 .. " " 0 " 0 . " " 1

" " .

(+&

. :

. 0 . " :

1 1 7"

K7 . @=EE

5! @.6 & 48$%,'8) # 1 D " " E : #

K 1 . @=:: 7"

K7 "

1" . 1

1'))' " 7"

K 7 "D% :

. 'B)9'))+E"

1 "

: . " E"

.1#

" "

D6 !

&" E"

. 5! @.6 & 48$%,'8) " . G "

1 1 "

" 1 .

: 2#

K 13

K 7 E"

1 . 11

.. 1 .

1" 1 . 1 D .

1 '))))<% 1

D '))))<% *-)))<%" 1 .2#

K 13

K7 1"

-)))<% " 1E"

& . "

17"

K7 .

3 .

D " " . 0 " . 2#

K 13 1 7"

K 7 " 1

!< E ! 0 " .

D 7"

K 7 . 1 " D *)))))<%

" .

1. :?$# D

3 D

3 . 7"

K7 " 1

" 1"D "

4E:D 7"

K7 D D" . 17"

K7 .2#

K 137"

K7 " . 1

" .

DA " 1

. . .

" .

. D "

"0 1

1 . 1

0 1

1 . @=77 . 'B)9'))+E"

(+& D "G "

" 2 1 63

5! @.6 " & 48$%,'8) " 1

G "

. "

. 1'))9: . " D " 1 1 " D .2 1 3 " . " 1 . .G "

. :?$ # D G "

'))( : 2 1 3 " " "

2 %

3 0 5! @.6 " & 48$%,'8)" C 1 4

'))9'))+

" D

1 " . " 1

" D "

. . @= EE @= ::

@= 77 " "

" .G "

3 . "

. $

< =.

%=.

1 0

D" "

" . "

0 "

FG "

1 0 1 = .

1 ; !D E $ @= &" 2A+3 " "D

'*)9'))+:

D 5@.6

. "

G.0

(+&"

"= G

I &" 2A,3""D

I '*)9'))+ 1 "

" . 7 $

2A83" 4

B*)+'))+ 7

. "

*-)('))+2 )+)('))+32@=7732 @= GG3.

. 1 .

" '*)9'))+

+8')D " . . . 1 1 . .

?.5 6 B8))))<%

'-.." 0

; 1 7 $

2A83 " B*)+'))+ .

(+ &

*), $." . . . . 1$"

. "

$ 7 4

0 .

2A83"

$ 7 4

@=&& %=.

1 . "

. 1

$ 7 4

" 1 $ "

$ 7 4

1" "

" : D "

. . $ :

$ !

" .

.D . . : D "

1 $ 7

. . .

IH &" 2A*)3" IH&" '))9'))+: " & 48$%,'8) " " "

.. D" &" 4

0 " 0# *) )).: "

"@= :

IH&" 1 %=.

. *) )).. "

0 "1 1 .: . "

D ""

"D 1 .

. $

: 4

2A**3

" : 4

'B)9'))+ 1G . 2A'3

" .$?$4&" :D . 1

'9)9'))+

. " @= JJ . @= JJ . .D 5'65#'65$'65'65@'65?'6

5E'6" .

. 1

1 .

."D %=.

D 1

D . ." $?$4: . .

. @=JJ" :

" D 1 41 "

. " . :

" D 1 . : 1: D

D :

:$ G

2A*'3

? & ,8 '-)9'))+

9,8%$ $ '- . '*'B'-',

'8&

*B- $.0 ? " 1 7 4

D$ ". : 1 ? "

"@= *'< "

" %=.

" ? B*)B')),0 .

"" " . 0 " 1$1"

. "

1 1 4

$. . 2A*B3 " 4

'))9'))+ 1

" . 2A*3> D .2A'3

D 0 # *) 9- . " 4

0 1

5! @.6 " & 48$%,'8) ** B)."

. "

: " $

.0 1 1

-)&" 1 . 2A*30 .

" "

" ; "

1"D 2A*B3" . "D .2A*3 'B)9'))+

.2A*B3 1

1 $. :

5!D 6. :2A*B3 .

5!D 6 :

1@=!

@=!<*"

1@=!" 1

% 5!D 6

. " 1 : ; % . $. . 0 1" 1 .

0 ." . " . :"%=.

. $

IH &" 2A*)3 " & 48$%,'8) " " "

.. D" &"

" 0# *) )) .0 . " "

2A*)30 . @=0 "

IH &"

1 $

%=.

G. 2A*3

D . 2A'3

B**$$" 1 . 1

2A*)3

'))9'))+ ; @= " " '))9'))+

" 7 . 1 0

. 7 1

. .1 . D

0 ".D D . 2A'3 1"

D 1

. '))9'))+

; 11 0

. ;

2A*)3 %=.

. *) )).. "

5! @.61

". "

IH &" 0 7 .1 1 # .

. '))9'))+ 2@= 3 .D 1 1# 7 D .2A'3 D . 2A'3 '))9'))+ . . 7 4

" " .

5! @.6 D " "

7 4

. .&" 0

2@= 3

D . 2A'3 ; " 1 .

D "

5! @.61

G. 2A*3

" .1

D " =.

" 1 .

1" .

0 . . -9 &

& .1.

1 ..

& 1 1 "

1 # $ . 12340

5 64/#!

7'7* '45 8* " "

." . "

C " 1 :" "

0 1 "

. "

" "

1 1" " D .1

. " "

1" .

B-&

" "

1 .

.. " . B- & . .

1 .

.. " 0 $ . = . . B-&

. " "

.= B-&

L . M . D "

.% 2'3 B-&

B- 1 "

= 1

1 0 1

1 .

. "

. . . 1

$ &%+,-%#')** 1 ! .

. .

'- . "

'+ .

+ . .

$ ;

'- ." ! B8 . !

1 1

B " ! + . ; . . ..

; 1>.

> 1 . .. 1 1 $ E .

. '+ .

.% 2'3 '+

1 . .. + " . . ."

1 "

.1=

. .

5 6 . . 1 5 .6

1 %

% D .

. ."

'2*32 3 ."

5 .6. .

. . .

. C

. .1" 1

1 = ;

1 %

% D .

. $ E . .1 1

C 1 .

" " " .D506(B-..

" =

.D5&,))6" ".1. C '-" 1 . " ..

'- . "

1 " "

. . '2*32 3 . "

. "

. " . .

. C

. .1&

.D506(B-..

.D 5&,))6"5 6."

" + .

; 1 .D .

'+ . .

. 1 $ ;

'- ." "

; . B8 91 43 .86'

::+*&. + "

'- .. . ;

B8 . "

! $

1 . .

1 .

1 :

. .

1 $

. . " 1 " .

. "

= . . 1 G

" B'%&"

. .. 1 " 1 $ "

. 1 . .

1 . :" . .

." 1 1 . . > 1 *-))))<%2

13 1 $

. . 1

'*&0 1

'))))<% 2 0" 1

1. =.

9,8%$$

. # 1 '. . . * '

* *9),')*-

. <. & % N