← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8449/2015dismissed

Ashok Kumar Talwar And ANR. v. Ranjit Talwar And ORS.

2017-11-07Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma10 pages



   

!"##$%&%'())  

        

  (* +, - -  

 

 !   "  

#

!

  

  !   " $%&





!   " $'  .           (         %)*)+*%, -.#  /(  0 $1# !

/



!  " -. 

%%' 2 '3 % %,%##(

 "  *&*&+*%,   

    *&*&+*%,4 5+  " -. ""

  $'  - ( 4"



6



.      " 2 &+  &" # "#   

.   6   "

-   1 -

.( ""

  " -." 

(  -    !( 

  ""   "%7&  

 

. "



  

(" $% +"

 " ( 2""  .! 

# -

!  -"      "       (    (

    4  "

   ("  .

0



" 

"  ( ""  "  "



 ""!  # -

 "   -    

 .

-( .(

 4"

1    ""  ."

  ( ( (  

 """  . (  # -



( 

." ""$%1    "

 - .# 1 - 

 # -

  ( 

." 

 ""$%   - 

 " ! """   2 &+  %## (  # -

" $'  (  

" 

-/ 

.!+*%&



 (  # -

1   

 (  

 -  "  +*.

 "

&+##-  (

 

    (    .-

-    (         # -

       "    # -

 (    ""   -   1 . !" $% +    ""  ( "# .

 #    .     # -

 "  

 .        .(

 

 ""$% " ( "

- (      # -

     ""  ( (  .   ( 

# -

"   . "

 -( .#  1    # -



    

   

      ( "        

 

 .1    -  " !6"  (  4"



1    # -



 (0 "

   .-((

( 1    # -

!    .

           -    (

  "       

 - 

  

 #     -       

   *&*&+*%,

 " -.

 ""! (" $&- (4 "

  ! 1"

  # -

  "                  -      (

-   ""  -" $& (4"

1



" -. ""   "  -."   "" "    0" $&  - " 4  0"   $%    +!   " !  "       (

 " 



#    ( ."     "  %)*)+*%,

"  

(-  ( 

 6 "    -   ""  #  (  . (

-"     "2 &+  1!+!, %, .  1

   ""  

 . !  !.  (  # -

  ( ""-

.     

." # -

/ 

.+*%&1    "" 

.(   "/



    -         "    !                 0     "" 

#    1 

- "-

   (

     

  "       .

""  

( "  2

&+ %,##        ""   

(      ""  ( -. 

!(  -.

.  

  

 

"  .

(  ! ""  "  -. 2 #  #."-    

  -     -

"  "                "  2  &+     %    %'  ##  .       "

 4 +     " 

" - 8

.

 1  (   .

 

.  ""    "        .       "       "

 " 9

 &   ""  " "  "     .

           .  -    "       (

1  (  ""   

" $&  ( ."   " "  (

 - 1 -   " ! ""    (  " $& ( 1  (   ( -"

(  " $& -   - - 

 ""  ."

#  (   ( (    # -

    "  1  (  ."  """  "        . "(

 "" $&  #  "



(.1

 ( 

""       

(          

.             :  

    

 ! " # $%  & &'# ( ( )&*

 &   + &*  

  &     

,(    *  -,  .  

 &  $/  % &   0 (- %$     ( * ,,  1 $!  %& 

 ( * ,234 2           -     -

"  "  

 - "2 &+ & .      "  - 

 "5  "  "2 &+ &

 ##!;

<"#      -     

.  ." 5  -"

5       ""  .

! . - 1  (  "    -

 -  (

 . 6   -  (  "

-.  .      -"

.

 

 (    

    

  (      4          -   .

              :!$ +  

 5   %  

5- 4#-

 1 -

.     "2 &+ %!&!'!=>3 

        

     

  

          

      



  

  

!    

 "  

 

#$  %

 " &  '() *+ '(),     

*, *,$  - &   .

*%,  /  

              

         

      

 0



 

##  

    /    

  

  *-,

*1,/2  

     

 

   

 

" 

 !

*3,   &   

      

      #     

       

#  #  



 



  

       



*(,4  

      

 #  

  

            

 

    #  

  # 

    # 

  

  

# "  

 #    



  5 6 2    





 !

1  "

!-  ""      "          "      !

  "2 &+## .  " -

.

  - & '  => 3  ( & . -  """

(  "  "  



. "  "    -

 

(        "    "   (

74"

 +   "-.

-

""  7 "  

#    """  1  ""   

.  # -

!  ! "  $&1 "   "" "

  ((

 4"

1  .

" "  "  ( ""

    .    -. ""

       # -

 (   .!

 "   "  

#

  (  (

1  "

   " $& (1

         $-!  

.        -"

"   - ""!

.

 

# 

  (



  " -. ""  -. 

""      ( (

"

      (

         !        -"

   -   

-( -.  

. 

-

"

"      -    - 1"" . 

        /#01#2).)   

34#"4#2 #!&'#56-7#!8%'9 #&6 34#"4#2 #72"!1:# #&6