High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1459/2009dismissed

Krishan v. State Of Haryana

2017-09-15Mr. Justice Mahavir Singh Chauhan16 pages

! " # $ % & '"

( )*+,""

& , -).)# $ //// % 0 1 2"1, * +3

3) 0$ -"1) 45 6 ' "

7) # * 8 8*" 9: 8 ;% *$ 1 " , ,$)

+<" $,) "

" 1 1 ", , $ 2"1, "

" =6 " 3

, " ,1 3 0"

%& "1 >4,

01 71$ 1 ?"

" ", * # @ "; ,,)

+ % ,) 8 8 8 '1 ) "1 "1 ' 0

,* 8 ,,

A "1 )

8" ' 1 $) " 9:++ :;%8 1 % *1 ,

, *1) " 9 %8 "

) 08 ) 1" 9: 8

:;%8 ,1 ")8 1" $ , ; *) ">,%A

8$,% )%A

B )%A9"0 )%A"0 ; ! ", )%A# ' )%A:% >)%A# %A3% ,1 ; ,) " 99 %) " ,1*1 , 1" $ , A " 1$*) * 11

"1 * 1 "

) 6 "

* " 0*11 *0$ 2"1,* ) "

C0 )"0, %A3% , 1 )8) $ $ 1)8 ," ' 20$ "#"

, , >%A: %A6 , " *)8 "

1 * " * ' @ " 9: 8 ;%8,"1 0"0)8" 11 ,$

> C ) " "0, "" $0 ) "

1 $* * "

*0 0," " $ " 6 >)1 $ %A:) " $ " "0$1 8 8 '18 , ",) " "

), ' , 8806 ' 1 8 1 ) ,* 8 ,* " "

1 $

*1A * *1) "

" $D

0 0$ , *) %A

8$,% )& C ).##6 >, > 3

0 * 8 0 " "EF,>+ , ,>+ ,0 ' 0 $ 2"

0 '8 00 " "%A

B >," "0 *>" "

& * ) , >

0 0$ %A) # 8 , "

0$ >;80$ ,= 3

) 88$* 1 8 0"

8 '# ,0' 3

8 0$ "1 4,0 ,7

)8 ) '

0 ,* 8 18 "

, 8 "6 ) , ,0" , 8* 0 6 18 1

8 8 , @ " 1* G>%)8 0 1"

D , >

)"0$ " )1 ) )" "11

" " " 8 1 " " $%

' , * 0> , 8 #H0 "

!" #$ %!&%

'! ()$)# "47 3: ",1 $0 * " =; " ,"1 2"1, " 1 * $, ", ,

> 8 1

" * $ 0 1" , A , 8 ) , $ * * 8 ,' "H "0" 6 , "

", " 8" 0 8

1 " ,$"

)" 8 ,$

', *"

0$ "

; $"8, , ," ) 1

?" 0 ", 0$ '1*8 " 8 * ,8 " 88,'1 ,6 "

*%*+#,!

% &

- #"./012030 , * " 8 , ' " ,$ ;,$ %! & 4

./5.# 303 "

8 8 , * $,

1 " $) $ 01*"", & 1 "$

$ " 6 "

1 4 (%!)& -"'

./5.6076

8 8$ , )

8* ) " " $ ,$ 0 "

" ,

0 *) ,

,, $" ,)" , " '

, "

) '& 8 , > , D ; ) > *

* " , 6 , *

0 * #H0 >"

%!8#!*&% 4

!#96::3;573: " =6 08 , " 0 $ 0 G1

<& % "4=$.02 .1.; )8 ",,1" 1 2"

$)-"% 0 *I;

1" $" 8 ,, )$","0 ) >) $ $ " 0" *) 8 1 $

I ; $!'# %!) , %! &% 4 )$!# #$ %!

96:.2;..*>#

4*#% %355 #H0 "

0 *"

6 , $,8 8 " 8" * "* 8"02 1%A ) 8

, 1 ) , ", 18 0 * 1 ) 0$ 5( 6 8" " $ 0"02 % * )0" $ "* ) $, 6 G> 9;% 08 0$ 1 "

", 8 )8" 0"">" "

$ % ,$ 8$

" 1 $, ,8 8$ " ",1* 6 "

," >, *

" $ "," * ,8 0 ,, , >" "

, " " 11 ,$1

: 1) 8 ,$ ,' 2"1, "

8 8" " *8 8 *'5 $) *$$*?

)4%!& 4 $!= #$ %!@96::3;*>>.

1.1A)8 "

8 18 ,8 , ",) "

,1 #1 "

* 1 8""

*") "1 8 "; " =;8 , $ 0 " 10$ 0$ " G* $) ,, , $ " > ; ) , "

, * " H

*0 80$ #1 "

0 6 #1 "

* 1 8"" 6 $,8" *0 0 0" ,>;->>*" + )' 49%*>#;) "

1 $, 08 ,, , ,, ,) 81 , ,,,0018 , "

,, , 1 8 ,,1 8 8 ,, 6 ,, ,, 8 $) ,,

,,, 6 8 H,H ),") )0' $,16 > $8 * ?" ,,, , 01" ,,,) , , ,, & ,,) 80$$) "6 8 0' " 0,> 8

8 1 0, ) 8 ,"

11; "8 02 " 1 ,* 8 "11 % *1

11 , ,"

$ ,, ; 8 $ , , 8 ,*,8 ,, , % ,,

" 0 $ 8 ,, "

4811 8 1 .* ,;79 4 ,,$76 *1 08 ,

,,, 0 4G, " 7D

$) #'

%!8#!*&

!#9)48!#'!)$;@96::3;573:A) "

" J 9;%) > 1 0* 01 ; ", ) >8 0" $ 1) ) 8

*6 0 $' 1", 8 ,,1 >" "

8 6 , 1 " 9" 0 " 9:;% 8 1 ,1 @" 9:;% 0 , " " 8 , >; 0 $>) 8" 0 1 8 "

9 % ) 01 *1 1

, , 8 6 , 1 , 18 0,2 *" * " 8 8 "$, , * , * *, , $) $ 1 $8" 0"1 "

99:;%6 "

8 0 1

J%* 0" @ ; ) "

8 01 " 9 818 49) 37=3;,$ 0 9;% G> 9 8 KG> L% "" >" "

$ M , G> "0* $ 1 8 *1 1 , , 8

6" 9;% G> ?" " $0, * *,+ > ; 8 " $ " 0 , , 1 8

,, ""

$,G* 1 , 18 0,2 *" * "8 8 " $,, *, * *,8" 0?""1

99:;%6 01 ?"0 ,, 1 $

*8 ""1$2"

$ 1

*1 $ , " 0 "0* , "1

* * $ 81 8 >" *$ *, 8"02>" " 8 "8 8" *" 2"

" * 0$ 8 >, D>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

6 8 = D) 1C>

$,=

"1 )

"1 D 9; " )8 9;%

?" , * ) ,$"

$, ,;*8 G> 9), *1 1 " *" 9:;%

3; 1 0*2"1,) $0 " 8 , " 00 $ $, *,1 8

6 "

" , * ) >,

" " 1 ", ) ,,

"0# " $ , # "

1 $0$ 1 )0"*0$" $"

101

6 ) ' 1 ,8

$ " ?" 1 6 8 $ , ' $ 2"

$" 0 0$ 02"

> 8" 2"$ 81 $ * 1 ") 0" $ 8" " "

;8 0"" 2"1, "

B=9 $;B= %& 4 - #"@6:.693;..0A)8 "

8 =: >>0"

8 , *,

,6 G* 8 $

*0"

0 , " ""0 $, 8 " 3 * ,"

* ,81 2"

$ * 6 ,1 "," * " * 2"

, 8 , A $ "

,"0 * " 18 * 8 ", 1 * 0$ ; "

' , * >) " 8 G*, ; " 407 8 ?" '

0 ; , "

, ,$

>,$ ' *8 ,$ "

?" , 6 "

* ?" "

,$ >," $ ", " > " " " 1 "

0* *" , 80 , "8 $; $ ", 1 > * 1 ,* $* * 1) "

" $ * 1

* A 8" "

' 0 * 8

9 1 * >) "

,"', > * "

* 1 " $) " $ "

;) 8" 0""" 8,,"8 $ 01 *, >" " , " *8 0 > 0$ 2"1, "

4 *)(B&*# ),!9.//3;6251 " 2"1, ( )$ #? (*& 4 96::/;.3 3/) 8 ,$0"" $> ; >;" "

)8,*, >" 11 8" " $ $, ,0$$, > , $ ", 1> 8," *,> ,) 8" 0 , $ 0" "

A 1 * >) "

," 8$ ', 18,8" "

'0$ $ 11,,

) $ '

0 ,$ " $ " " 1 , 00 $

") * > , ,$00 ,$ >;

0 1 $

0 ** , *,2" * $ 02"

* *,0 "* D 0, 2"1, "

4 !" #$ %!& %! @ 6::325.A

96 ") ",

) ' "8

,, ," "8 00 0$ , 8)

* ,) & 5( ; *$"0"

, " ,, 8 8 8 1D ; 0**) 1", " 0)" 9;% , ) 10"

> "?"* $ " " *1A ) " $8 8

"6 * " " *1) "

*, ) "8" * * "

" "; 1 1 , >) $)$)0 $1 6 )" 9: 8 ;%,,, 6 1 08 " 11 ,$8, $1 6 " 1 1 ; *,

) 8" *0",, $ ,1)" 0 ,, $" 11 ,$8,?" $ 1", 2 1 1",

0 ) 8 , > " *

0 ; " 2"

18 , 0 ,, )0" 0 " , >

;8,) ?", '2"

" '1 18$ * "& * )'1*8 ", ) , "0# " $ , 6 ) 1", #H0 "

, "

4 +% )(= -*#96:.0;67.8 18 *,)8 8"02 ) 0 *" =8 ,$*, >" * " , 1 8 '1

0 ,) "

" " $ ,$ *, >" " * "@"0)

,$ '1

0 ,0 $1" , " )" )8" $," 1" 2"

$6 >

) ")0'8 @ *, ,

*0"8 "

0 1 2"

8 ; "

" * ),$ '

0 ,,*8 "

* 6

0 ) > )?"8 *, " 8 ,

, 0$ " 8, ; 8" 0 1" 2"

$ 8, ,

8 00 *"

0 , " ) , , A $ " * 1 8,8 , >" , 0 *88 8 1 8 "0) 0 "N 6 0" '

0 "0D * 1 ) >8 $ 1 ,"

" "

8 6 "" "$

, , $0$ *, A 1 "

1 0$%A3% ,1 ) , 8 1" " * $0 $ "," *> "

" 8 "

1 , " , 5"

*8 1* >) "

0$%A3 $ " $ ; *8 0*) 1 $ , ,"12"1, 0$ "

9 ;

1* C!

#%> '

),D# %4) $E % D 4 C!

## >4#B"

% 4