Prem Singh & ANR v. State Of Punjab






    
 

    

  




 





!          


 

   
 "  #"$%!&$  ( # )*+

$ ,(& 

- ." *$ ,( #

(!/!

&  #"!

$(*& 0* !
!  1 

- .* 2!345 ## )4&$/&"!+6
#$$!)( +& ( *  

 



8(   

       ,   (          

9 :

&!

$  
 - :

&65(  $  4!, & 4(&'( (!,( 

(, ' ! (6 ! $ 

&&

;

:<"
&( *    5 =!   (,  '  !  $  

   '

(  $   :   (  <"
 # (!,( , ' 9 :

&( 

 6(( &! , * 6  !

((   * !*&

;&&


!  5*  &( ! ,  ,!

*  5 

8(  6 !5,,

*( *      &  &     ( (   01  0!

1&    6

 !

( *&(!( 5  ! , (  

6  
!

 



8( , (  !  *6

><'( ( ?@"2   & (

&      ( ( ><   ' , ( &#)A4,$ ,($"B&"C9&*  ( ' !5$"B " $ "( !B( ! ,( 

9&( '!5 " $ "( !$ 5% ' ,*(  , ( $ " $ "( !C( 6!

*  ,(&( '* ,  

5*"
5&"( !   &( ! < 
'( !

) ( ,(   ) , ,('

8(

  ,! B

*&( '

'( $ 6! (!

, ( &( ( " $ C( 6!

* ,  ,( * 

*( " $ &( ', ,( , 8 (,&( ' 655!,$ )(

&, 6! 5  ,(  (  &'( ( (

(

! ,(( * +!

( 65% ((  *

((

&'('

 , ( < 
( ! ,((**  *! (

(('(  65 ( %  5( 

 ( 5* 6  ( *$<<=6 $ ,(      (       (  *         *) ,  (



 & ( * ( ( 6 '( ( *><'  $<<



 =!







( 65,!  * * @*  $<

 !,( (  ! 8( ! '

 $ (   '

  B*

(

 , &(, ( ! ' 
!( <= #,   



 : $   '

@! 5 6 65( 
! $  &(! **    :

&(  $!6  4! #,  &"( !&**  !   6 
!$  



  8(  !   @*     *5    :  '

    & !6 5&  ( !6    !      !       ( !  !  &(   4!,  ' 

,! $ 


"
&'(

&( !

  && 

 < &(  ! @*    

   



  8(  $  (  &(

 6

 !

( 5(  6

,

* 5( ! % !6* (( 5(6

 ! 65"C9 4,$ ,(%'

& ( !5    ' ,&(         ( 6 (5    6!     (  ! & (!& (



 ( !

 !6 5
!  &&!  ( ! 65"C9 9
 5&(  $ ! (,!

(&(   ( , 6  
! '

* && ' 6 ,

 '

(&65( 
! 



  

 8( * *

 

?@"
8( ! 5( 65(

(  '!  

9%'

& ?@"
( ! 6!( *  %'

&( 65(  /!

$ ,(6

65"C*( )   (, ( (  8(  ! 



9&(  &(!,(( 65(

 &6 ! ! 5 

9&'( &(   

6 ,   &/!

$ ,(&(  !

*( 

D 6(   *!(    "C&  * (   )   (, (    (   

5 ,  ( *   

9  # &    (      

@ , &(/!

$ ,(   '( (6

! (( ! 5&*  

9!)'

&   ( 65 &/!

$ ,(&'(( 6

65 "C&*( (, ((  65 

9&65(  6( "C
 5&( 65!)'

6 !! 5  

9& 6  *5!   (

 /!

$ ,(8( * *

(6

 65"C "C ( 

,

(  6@( 

&(( *) ,! 5(

    (       &  (   6  ,  (   (  (



@ +!







    





   

      ! 

  "   

 

  ! 

  "   

 

#  $ >!( * &  (  (    

  (  ( **  '  '

* *6 6 %'

&"C *) 5

6!( !    &6!' (

( 
( ?@*  -

&

,( *((  

 *6

, ( 
(  ?@*    &  6!  5   ( 5   &   *) ,  (

( 8(!&(   4!, '

 "!6 " ! &((

( 
( ?@*  & 

&( !   &6 5

*  6 ! ? ( '

&(



( 
( ?@* '! 5& (  ! (    (  (      (      '   )   65   , %'

& "C (  @*  &(*  !,, & ( ( !   *  ,& !,&

& )  5'

6 ,  ! (*  (( !,&

& )  5(  !6 , &!(( (( * ( 

# &( (
!=!

-

'( (6 @ (

 &(* '

( 6

( 
( ?@* &* (    @*  &( '!5 

(( !


 '!(  +!5&'( ((   *(  , ( **6 '

 5 & &!6 
%&'

  

(

(  



  

 % 

  

 

 

)  *+   

   

 



,$  < &  6 ! ( 6

( 
( ?@*  &* (   (  &6 ( *&( ( !   ' !( (  +!5! 65( *   


 

  

 
 

      
  
   

  
  !"#

! !  * 2!345 6

, ! !  , &( *  ,! ! &'( ( ?@"C 9;<&  
 

-

  

&&



, ('( 6 @ (

 
 

   

  +     

 

 

(    -!    ./0  12 3

.-2 45 6-6% %

-8 9 - 7 ( -
+

( 

7  :

 4   :

-  %   0-    .

" .

-1  3-     

!

  5(-7 (  



 



7:



 

  #

  ; :

0

:

-2 <

-7:

3 -( = 

 

   

 #

  7 :

2

( <

-7:3 

#   3 7 (

:  %

(( 

5 73=>4=  .



#

 7:

!

 5(- (



#

((

   , 



( .





 

 

 ,  

  # 

 (

( 



,

 





(  

=?; :



   +

(  7:



#



 

  : 

%  7 %

-7



  

(

:

  



   

    % @  ?=    

$ 
 

  



  $!"$

! !  " *$ ,(6

, !! 

, &( *  ,! ! &'( (?@"C 9;E&

      
  

  -

  

& &  

  , '( 6 @ (

 
 

   !

+     

 

 

(    - 7 :

4 :

-% 0- 

.

"  .

-  7:  @ (  %   -  1    3-           !

    5(-  7 (  - 
+ 

(    .0  2 3

.-%  3( - 

4  5 6-6% 7%

-8

9 -7 (  







  

 #

  ; :

0

:

-2 <

-7:3 -(  = 

 

 

 #

   :

2 <

-7:3 -#  3 7 (

:  %

(( 

5 73

"
=>4=

 

(

0   .



#

 

!

 5(-7 (- 

#

((

  

 , 



( .





 

(  

 ,  

  # 

(

( 



,

 



( 

(  

=?; :



   +

( 

0   

# 

 

    

    :   %     7  %

-7



  

( :

  



   

   % @   ?=    

$

8( !  * !

 !5    6(  (       5  (   (

  

,! 8(!&'( 5 65 5( @

 ,!   '(   ( 5 65   ( 

 & (  & !*  5 6 * 

# &  (!,(    ( !,   +!,* &    *  !

$   - :

&(  5( $6   & 6!( '( 6  (!,(?@"C %& !! (

,! ! 0!

1&! ! !5 (  ><6  ,- 

9& , " $ # ( &  %(  !&8(!&(   ,!

&* 65( 0!

1&



5 ,! ! & & 

6  ,!

65( *(  &! !

 , !5 ( 65$  ( <  ?  8(     6

,  (&        (

  

  ,! ! 01&(  ><6  ,-



9& , " $ # ( &  %(  !&( ! ,(!,(?@"C %&(  !   5(  $

#
  6  ,   ,    -"  % :

:&    (  , ,    8(  &!* 5 * 56  ( 6 '* * !!5(  * *6  ( (0!

1&  5 $&* (!,( *?@"C ;% *      5 )65   **  ( (,  



   

: ! !   , (!,(  5* *?@"E&  , ,  & *(  6) ! ,

(  $$!6 5(!,(* ** ?@"&(

!

6  *'

'

 ( $  , ,  -"  % :

:&'( )  $!6 5&(   (

!

(  

(  &&6  '

( 6  ,  D4$D8(

*0!

1&6  (!,(* *?@"E*(  & ( 6) 

?@"&'

 (!,(* *?@"&  (  $!6 5&6 *6  >$E F (



 *  &&*( ,& ?@*  &

((  &* !

& (!,(* *?@"E&( *

5*( ,'

(( (

6)! !

&6  *(   0!

18(!&(

  (  (

 &6 * 65  &&!, 5 ,& 

&(

( >$E&'( (?@"  # & % 
6 2!'

 $ ,('(* (  ,! ?@"E&'

 ( &( ! ! ( @*   (

  (   ?@"B&

$
'(

&( 

(   ( 

?@"E8(!,( ' ! @*  &6!  @!

5!,, 6 ( *& 5((

 &* *(  (!,(?@"E( '

* *(  &6!'

* * * (   ((  <( 6 

@!

5!,, 6 ,* % 
6 2!'

 $ ,(&  @( 
!&*) ! ((  ' 6   (

 8(!&(  5 ,! !  * 656(( &( (!,(01=!

,

5 , 
   $"

 8(!,(4,$ ,((

! &&(  , (  &6!(!6 5

!

&'(  ( 

* 
!&  5



* 5( ! (  %'

& (!,((   (

&( 6 (5  ! ( ! &(!*56 ( 6  (!,(*55 ** 

5 ,-

&( 5()5  6

,* ( 65"C94,$ ,(&5   
!& ,

  ( 5 !

  (   ,!    !    (

5!

 ( (  5(  &6  
! 5 6   , 5!

( >$E&'( (?@"  $ 5 ?@" ( &(

 * (

*  &! 6! 

* 65( ?@

 &((  5!,

 *(  6

,  ( (

!

&6 


*  (    &  '(   (  *  '    (       $ 5&'(  (6

! ((  ( !

*(  '* '( '   &6!'( '* ** ( $8(! &, 5 , 6  ?@"

 

 < &( !,    &&(  ( (  &6 

5  &&

 &!

 (( 65(   4!,  & ! *5,

  5&6! 5,* 

 && 

 (  < &( *  

&&( *  *  <( !  6 &( !

( &  !

 (( *6 ! 6 @ ! 65(

  4!,  &(!,(( ('

('

,** ' =!( *
 

5& 5&6 '

(  ('&6!5   @

5(

  ( 

,



9  6 '('

( 

 

  !%&'!&!!

 

()*+,)   
)+()+-,.+/0123#-+/,42+5$ +,#4 %!! & ' ( )*