Darshan Singh & ORS. v. State Of Punjab
!
" #$
%
!
& '( (
(
!
"
#
$%
& '
(
%
)*
% '
#
)
#
&
+,-.
( /012 .
.+2 30"2
+,-.
1( /012 .
/ 033
44444 !) %* #
% + ,-
+ .)
% + /////
/ 033(/(
!" #"$ % & '( & )** * + *
*
* * %!,
- .
/
- .0**
** 1 $- . **
** 1 $ * %!2- .3**
** 1 4- .
* & **
* * 1 4 - . * %!2 - .3 ** 5
** 1 4- .
*
& **
* * 1 4- . * %!2- .3**
* * 1 4 - .
* & - **
** 1 4 * %!2- ."** & * $4
*%262"7
*
+ ** *
5-
$ &
*
' * %!, - . ** *
** 1 $- . &
5"6 8) *" ** *
** 1 $ * %!2 - . &
5" 6 8) * *"** *
6&
** 1 4- . &
5"$ 8) *
* & ***
5-
6&
** 1 4 * %!2- . &
5"$ 8) *"** *
5-
6&
** 1 4- . &
5" $ 8) *
* & ** *
5-
6&
** 1 4 * %!2- . &
5"$ 8) *" **
*
5-
6 &
** 1 4- . &
5"$ 8) *
* & - " ***
5-
6&
* * 1 4 * %!2- . &
5"$ 8) *"** *
5-
6&
** $4
*%262 &
5"$ 8) *" +**+ *9 * * " -* )+ +*
) * ' %.'(
*
-
+
+
:*
+
* * 1 481$#81$!81$18%!,8%!2- .* $4
*" ) )
**
* *";
** * &
*9
*& +
) *" ;
+ "" !" #"$ % " *
+ * 8
*9
*" * * * < ** <* % *
*
:
"
0 1 % *# %
2*
3435,335 % %
0 6
% ( ( 7 8 0 6 (#0 #
7 8 0 %
0 % % #
(( 7 8 9
0
# * :;5-%
6 #
(( 7 8 9
!!.3<
* #
%0 % *
% 8
=
#
*
6(#0 - >
*
!, % "35?@
@
0 # % A78A 0 %#
0
* %% <=)!.?
> % #
6(#0 * >
# # 0
8 $ ( '
# 9
6 (#0 (( 7 8 9
- % # 3:35,335 !3!5 0
%0 % 3435,335 # B A
A C6 (
0 B9
C % # # -
# #
%% :33 * ";5D%
% ( % # 8 % # # E % #
!,
0
5 % #
% % # % #
% %
# % 0
#
% 0 1
0 0 # 8 % % # %
0 %
#
% . # 2 0
0 #
# %
0 , #
% # % #
% 6 # # %
# % # ## % 7 %
#
. # 2 0
*@ # %
# % ( % . #
% ( (
##
## %* # * 0
( % # %
#* #
# * D
# $% >
8 % D 0 % 6 # %
6 0 ( # 0
9
*D 9 % 0 @
# %
(( 8 9
0 %
% 0 7 %
0 1 #
# % %* * # )
0
%
8 #
%
% * %
0 6 (#0 %
% % # <=
%96 # <= ?, 0
6 ( % # # % #
%0 % > 7 0 2
* 0 # 8
* 0 @% % =%
* 0 #
>
6
> 6 (#0 %
% # %
% #% * # A(A %#
0
*%% <=)!.?9-% *
!, % *
.!5 0 % = # 0 0 # %
.
* # # * # A(A 0
%% <=)!.?(-# # %
> % #
# 0
*%% <=)!.?8
# <=)!?D % # # )6(#0
87D
7 8
%
0 # #
* # A78A0 # # * # % A78A 0 % # 0
* %% <=)!.?' 7 * # # # 87
>!335,335 *
# 6(#0 %
!, ,.&5-%#%
# A(A # 0
%% <=)!.?$ >!!35,335
% % # >,,35,335 6(#0 * 8>6
0%
9
# * 0% 8> 6
>!.35,335 8 <=
% # # 0% -*# - %% # %
% 0 %# 0
%% <=)!5?8 (
* 6
> 0% # 0
0
%% <=)!5?D
0% 6
> # # 0
%% <=)!5?' % # # 7 * # # 87
> !"35,335 # 0% 6
> #
7 7 8( D 0 % %
7 6
> 7
<=!5?$( !, * # A8A#
%* <=)!5?$?!
<=)!5?$?, # 0
*%% <=)!5? > !435,335 8 <=
6
> # # # %% # 8 # ,535,335- %% #
% %
% % > ,"35,335
%
0 .!5 0 # 0# %
6 #
% <=)!5?-
.!5 # # # 0
%0
# AA %# 0
%% <= )!5?-?! > ,"35,335
8 % 0 #
.!5 0
# 0 # %
-
% <=)!5?) 6 # %
,&35,335 8 *
#
% # #%
# A A #
0
%% <=)!5?)?!
# % 0% 8
6
> D @.3@ ,,4, # *
% # # 0
*%%
#
- 9$ # > %
#
0 % ,# % # 7 9 %@
!;467 .3,?.3&?!;:67
,& %
# @
# *
*
% % * # *
7
% % 3:!,,335
!;4 67 .3,?!;:67 .3&?!;: 67 ,& %
% )! % #
# %%
0
.!: 77 !43!,33"
!;4 67 .3,?!;: 67 .3&?!;: 67 ,& % # % 353&,33"
#
* % 0
9$<= %
.!.77# # *
% - 0 0 1
* "33 # AA
0 # %".3
:33 ".3 ( 6 8 % % 0 B C% # !,
*# 0 0 %
* 0 % %8
%
# %
#
% * 8 %#
%
% * @ * 8 2
%**8# 2
*#
% !535,33! *
D
0 % *- % *
*
# # 8
% # 0*
0 8
8 ) %
% 96 ,!5
.""?."4 .&"67
*!:&,8
# 8
# 8 % %** % %8 # 8#
*
8
%
*D
* 8#
2 * *
!&.B4C77
# * 7 8 * % %
0 D 8 )
( # # 7 7 D
B C
( % *
'
% * * * % %
6
*#
% 6 #
* 0 % 4F ".33?@ %
-
0 > * # %&,!
:;,8
%
#
%"33
!!33-* * %
0 % # 0*% %* %
*#*
0 8 # 8
% * @ 8 <=@ !, ., - *
% )
8 # *
% ) 6
3435,335 % * %% !!338
0' '# (
% @# B C0 ' # *
@.37@",!&
;33
- 00 (% # %
*
* # * # # % % ".3
&.3 ( # 7 %%
) 7 # D0 %
0
# ( # #
%%
%
62 *# * 0% 8>
0 2 * # (% 2
% #
* #*
=% (% )!
7 ), # E
). 7 *
%
0 <=H * I% # <=J#
6 @ > % * # 96 !", 3:35,335
.3,?.3&?.,;?.,.?!;4?!;:67
,5 ,& % # * % # %
6
8 ( # 96 !", 3:35,335
!;4?.,.?.,;?.,"?.."?!;:67
% #
*
.3& 67 ,& %
#
% ' @ @#
%
.3&?.,"?.,;?.,.?!;4?!;:67
,& % G % @
#
%
# % * 3;3",3!3 #*
#
#2
*
% @ % ' * &.03!%
# # * %-*# 3435,335 #
0 %
% 0 # #
% * * 7
D
0 > 2 .:, 3435,335 * % 0 6 (#0 #
0
%0 %
#
#
%0 % % # 3:35,335
*
#
% #
# % ".3
:33 *8 # 8
#
".3
3435,335 # * # ";5 &33 6 % # (% #
% # 8 % # 0 % # % % # !,
% # % % # % *D -
0
0 %
#
# 8 # #
5 % #
% 6 #* # % # % ( # % %
# % % % # ?
% ( # 0
% # %
# % D %
# -* % #
# #* #
#
#
* 7 % # 0 % * ' -
%
%
%
0
% %
- #
0
1
%% # %*%
%
0
%
% > %
6(#0 %
% # % 96# #%
@ *=% 7 8 0 3435,335 6 (#0
%
0 % # 0
%% 6 (#0
%
6
# #
# 0
* 0% 8>
0 8
0 6
> 0% - % #
0
* %% (
*+ # 0
%%
0 6
0 %# 0
* %% (
%0
3;@:";3# # 0
*%%
% # *#
* % ' @ @#
%
*# %% % ' *
*
-
% # % * * % ' % 6
# # %@
*# @
!;467 .,"?.,;?.,.?!;: .3&?!;:67 0
%
.!. 77 # # *
*
*#* # 0 6 % ( # # # ";5 # 8
# %
E
% #
#
0 %
0 6 % ( -*
0 -*B C
.3*-*
* *
%
% %
0 % * (
* %
.!. 77 6 8 %
% %
* -* %
*#* *=% ' )!
%% ( ), D ). % <=,,
<=,;
#
% %
7 %
%
% #* #
# @ %
% *% ' #2
*
% @ %
% ) %
% ** +
&" ; *** ( * &&
* * " = *
)** *" * *" *
9 "" *" &
&*
(
* &" -*
* &
><" ? $"%$"%22, &"""
. + /" + 0'( * &
><"@ %$" 6"$ % & " "'"" ' * '(
'( +
+
'( * 5
(
" .
& "" *"
+
" * +
* '( *" - * * + *
&
+ *"5 *
& . + /" + 0'( 4
><"
? * :
"% 1 2 / "" '( + 0
*
& %2,4" - & %2,4 & A* /><"
#0 &
+ * *
" - + +&
&.
&
*
( & *
* * * ( &
"* ** ( &
*&
* & ( &
A*
& " ;( * *( & * * * *
* . + /" + 0'('( *"
&" ; .
* '(+ ><"@ &
+ ** ( &
* *
><"*: *& . (
*
& *%2,4"B * 9 +*
*"9 * ( & &
+
A* ** * "; * * * **
(
* (
" ;( * * .
+ ><"
@ C 9 $6" 6"$ % * D" * * & *
)** ><"@ +
&
*
.
& 9 +)
* ><"@"**
*" *
& %2,4 * * (
*
* ** * & *&
**& "" *"
" ;
)** + * ** & " * * "%$
* & * &* * *
* &
"
&(
* & * & " ; &$+ "; ( * *
+ " * & *
* * &
&
(
*"**&"7
* * &
(
" >+
(
&
+ + && +
***&
& *" - < * & *
) ** *" *
& * *
* *2E "'" * ***( *#E!6 "'"; &* &
1
"B *
*"
#E1 "'" 2E1 "'"* * 9 *
* &
" ; *
*
)** +
& * *& F-5* & * * " 5* +&
$ & -+ B
* + ** &* * + "- * *
+ * & *
("G +) *+ * )** *"
&"
' -+& &'" '+ * F-5
* & "; ***(* #E!6 "' ," 6"$ 6F-5
*
><"
:8$% E%6"'"; &
1 * F-5"; & *
";& * * "** &
* * * *" '=5* &
F-5 * '=5 * **" - *
(
* +
,)2'&$ 6"H * **
*
* **
& F-5" -
(#0 -+
* *" *
9 :
" 12% ," 6"$ 6 *
9:
12$ ," 6"$ 6 *
*
*
* + '("7 * ><"
8%
><"
8%
><" 8%
- ><"
F8%
*
* *
"
"' *.
F ( "+& * +><"
= > *& ' *B
** + '(
( "
( * + & * ( * " * *& + *
) < * *
*">+ (
*** * * ( - * +
* + 9
*(" >+ G1 " *& < &
* "* * + * * & ("- +&
*
+ ** *& '=5" *
'=5"G * ( * * +
F-5":
& 1 * + "* & +
* & + *"H * ** * ( F-5 & & +
* + *
**";*
*
)** ** + ( "
" ' * .
F ( ( * * & &* ( *& F-5 * *3 +
&
*" B&
* * *** "; * * "
"' *.
F ( +& * * & *";* *
"; *& * &
" + * &*
"; * +
& "-*
* * *
* & "
" ' * .
F ( & **
* ( * * &" - < & *
)** G)$ '
+ '=5 +
";2 " - &:
"4 * $"6*@"46* 9&* < &
* &
( + ** + ";
)<
* ** " -
* * &*
** + < " ** *"* &
* ** "%$ " 1)! .
+ + & 1)!
" '=5
* +& &" < &
5 * "; + *
* )*
* & * & * " 5
& * * (
* ) * F-5 * & ** &
*" *
" ;
*
* ( +& * + " - *
&+ * *
*
*" * &
+
.
) *
& &" *
*
* && **
* &
&< *
* *" ;< &*
) ** 3 "%$
" ;
( * ** < & * * *( * * "
& &+
**&
& &"; * + & *" * *
-+ B
* % " 6"$ 6 *
**
&
*
***
6
* 3 "%$ ( * " ; + * * * ** "; "%$ * & & &
**& * +
";
*
) ** +
&
*" - & *
) ** .
+ * *9 " >+
* & *" -9 & * *"- 9 &
*" (% G%7 ), **"7 /G$0
+ 0
***">+ 0% / G%60 **
"7 /G$0 ><)
.
+
**
#E%6 "' ,E "'" * * * *
+ "
**
(
";
*
)** +
&
*" & * + * + *+ **
+
*** * "**
(
&&
*"-
+&** * "F
* **"-
*
+ *
** * * **** *+
* *
* * **
& &
*" (% BG%0 *
* ) < *
* 9 *
" * *
*
*** " * *& &"=""?+ ) + * & . " H * ** * * * *
* *& * ++ *+ * "1%6 - " - / G20 *
*&
*
*""'
/ G$0
*
*
- '=5><"
" >+ / G60 / G%%0 *
&
- "* *
*
***
">+ * 9 && ( / G%60 .
*
*
***" = ( +* & *
)** &*
* * * & *+ *3 +
&
*"; *+ + & / G60- / G20 / G%%0 & * ( " =& & *
) ** & &* * & + *
**"- *
+ * * + ** *" F
+ *"- * *** & (
( " ** * & *
"
*** & *
- " *
( " *
" * " *
" * * " * * & + & & & + "; *
( & &
* *
& *
& ( "
( * +";
* & +
'
&
+ "
& &"* *
* & * *
( ";
+ * *< *
*& *
*"* *
+ * + ) **" B < *" * * * & *"3 +* & ) )
3
+ * *"
( &(* * +& - * + & " <
* * + + +& %% ( " :
& +
* )* (#0 * * A * *( ** & * ( -
*
( "
($
* * " * * A *" * + I &
'
*( (
* "; + *
+& I&
&&* +
* & *
( & + &" 9
% % %
% 3;3",3!3 #
%
.+2 30"2
/ 033
/03. /03. %,.
,3!5