← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/595/2010dismissed

Darshan Singh & ORS. v. State Of Punjab

2015-09-23Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron31 pages

 

   !

" #$

%   

 !

  & '( (

(

   

               

    !

"   

#   

$% 

   &   ' 



(    

   %  



)*

% '  

   

          

   #  

    



)

    

   

          

  

  #  

    

&

+,-.

( /012 .

.+2 30"2

+,-.

1( /012 .

/  033

44444 !)    %* #





% + ,- 

  

+ .)  

%        + /////

/  033(/(     

          

     

     

      

       

   

  

         !" #"$ % &    '( &  )**  * + *

*   

* * %!,

-  .

/

 - .0** 



** 1 $- .    **



** 1 $ * %!2- .3**  



** 1 4- .

*    &       **



*  *  1 4 - .    *  %!2 - .3 **    5 



** 1 4- .

* 

  &     **



* * 1 4- . * %!2- .3**

 



*  *  1 4 - .

 *    &   -       **



** 1 4  * %!2- ."**     & * $4

*%262"7  

*

+   **  *   

 5-

 $ &

 

*

'  *  %!, - .  **      *  

    



** 1 $- . &  

 5"6 8)     *"        ** *     



** 1 $   *  %!2 - .    &  

 5" 6 8) *     *"**   * 

6&

   



** 1 4- . & 

5"$ 8)  *

*    &       *** 

5-

6&



** 1 4 * %!2- . & 

5"$ 8)  *"**    * 

5-

6&



** 1 4- .    &  

 5" $ 8)     *

 *    &        ** * 

5-

6&



** 1 4  * %!2- . & 

5"$ 8)  *" ** 

     *   

 5-

 6 &

 

** 1 4- . & 

5"$ 8)   *

 *     &   -      "       *** 

5-

6&



* * 1 4 * %!2- . & 

5"$ 8)   *"**   * 

5-

6&



** $4

*%262 & 

5"$ 8)  *" +**+    *9     * *     " -* )+    +*  



)  * ' %.'(   

    *  

  -   

         

     +     

 +         

      :*    

       

+ 



* * 1 481$#81$!81$18%!,8%!2- .* $4

 *"    ) )

  **

 * *";

 ** *  &

 *9 



 

*& +   

  ) *" ;     

  +  "" !" #"$ % "               *    

            + * 8   

 

      *9 

      *"     * * *     < ** <*         %      *

*

:

"

  0  1    % *#  %

  2*

     3435,335     %     %    

0          6   



     %     (       (   7  8    0  6 (#0    #      



7 8   0  %

 

   

 0                   % %  #

((  7   8   9

  0  

 #    * :;5-%    



      6           # 

 ((  7   8   9

 !!.3<  

     * #      

 %0   %  * 

 

   % 8        

    =        

 

 

     

         # 

* 

6(#0  - >  

      *   



 

 !,     %        "35?@  

@

0 #  % A78A 0  %#

0 

     

 

* %%  <=)!.?

 > %  # 



6(#0  *  > 

   

   # # 0 

   8  $ (   '

# 9

  6 (#0      ((    7     8   9

 -  %        #  3:35,335 !3!5 0     

     

%0  %      3435,335  #     B  A

A C6      (      

 0       B9

C %     #   #       -  

# #

%% :33  *   ";5D%

      %  (       %  #    8      %  #    #      E  %  #

  !,     

         0

5 % #   

   %     % #       %  # 

    %     %

#   %          0 

  #

   



     %   0  1

 0 0  #  8       %   % #   %

     0   % 

#

   %     .    #  2 0 

0  #

# %  

  0    ,   #

% #   %  #      

       %       6      #             #        %  

#  %     #          ##            %     7 %  

#  

.   # 2 0    

 *@  #       %    

   #   %    (   %    .   # 

%    (  (  

##  

##       %*    # *         0

       (       % #     %

     #* #  

#  *     D

#  $%   >         

8        %     D       0     %  6  #  %

   

6 0 (  # 0

9

*D  9 %      0       @

   # %

 ((       8    9

0      %

    %         0  7 %   



 0  1    #   

 # %       %* * #        )   

0   

  % 

  

        8      #       

           %      

          

 %    *       %     



0    6 (#0     %    

%   %     #  <= 

   %96   # <= ?, 0    

           6        (       % # #  % #  



 %0  %  >    7      0   2       

* 0    #        8          

* 0        @% %  =% 

   

* 0    #

  >    

 6 

 >   6 (#0         %  

 

        %       # %  

     % #%  *  #  A(A %#

0 

   



*%% <=)!.?9-% * 

 !,  % *

 .!5  0 % =   #   0  0  #      %  

 .

*  #  # *   #    A(A   0 

   

%% <=)!.?(-#  #    %



>      %    #  

 # 0 

 



*%% <=)!.?8        

 #    <=)!?D  % # # )6(#0         

87D

   7  8     

   %

  0  # #

*  #  A78A0        # # * #  % A78A 0    % # 0 

     

 

* %% <=)!.?' 7   *  #    #     #  87   

 >!335,335       * 

      #   6(#0           % 

  !,   ,.&5-%#%  

  #  A(A # 0 

   

%% <=)!.?$ >!!35,335         

      %    % # >,,35,335 6(#0        * 8>6

0%    

  9  

   #   *  0%      8> 6

 >!.35,335 8   <= 

 

 %                   #   #    0% -*# -  %%  #  %   

   %         0  %# 0 

 

 %%  <=)!5?8 (  

  *        6 

>  0%  # 0 

    

 0

 %%  <=)!5?D      

     0%  6 

>  # #  0 

 

%% <=)!5?' % #  #   7   * #    #  87     

 > !"35,335  # 0%      6 

 >  #     

  7  7  8(  D 0   %  %  



  7  6 

>    7     

<=!5?$(   !,   * #  A8A#



 %*  <=)!5?$?! 

   

<=)!5?$?,   # 0

   



*%% <=)!5? > !435,335  8     <=  

   

6 

>  #    # #       %%  #            8    # ,535,335-  %%  #       

    %   %      

  %      % > ,"35,335         

 %

   0  .!5          0      #  0#    % 

  6  #    

 

  % <=)!5?-   



  .!5  # # # 0 

  %0   

   #  AA %# 0 

    

 %%  <= )!5?-?! > ,"35,335  

   8            %  0  # 

 .!5   0

        #    0 #     % 

  - 

   %   <=)!5?) 6  #      %

,&35,335  8        *

   



 # 

 % #  #%  

   #  A A #

0 

   

%% <=)!5?)?!   

   

 # % 0%    8

  

  6 

>  D  @.3@ ,,4,   # *    

 % #  #  0 

   



*%%    

#

   -    9$ #   > %



    

  #     

0   % ,#   %    #    7  9   %@         

!;467 .3,?.3&?!;:67  

,& % 

 # @

#  *



   *

 %   % *  #   *          

         7   

 %       %  3:!,,335      

 !;4 67 .3,?!;:67  .3&?!;: 67   ,&  %   

    % )!    %  #  

    # %%     

   

0   

 

.!: 77 !43!,33"                 

 !;4 67  .3,?!;: 67  .3&?!;: 67   ,&  %   #     % 353&,33"

 #        

   

  



   *  %     0    



       9$<=   %   

.!.77#  #  *   

 

    %      -  0    0  1     

  *   "33  #     AA



   

0   #    %".3 

 :33       ".3        (    6           8      %           %  0  B  C% # !, 



  *#  0   0   %    



  * 0     % %8



%     

#   % 

           # 

%   *  8  %# 

  %

          %    *      @           * 8           2

  %**8#       2

  *#

 

%     !535,33!   *   

   D

0    %   *- %   *    

*     

#  #     8    

 %  # 0*    

 

0        8  

       8       ) %        

   

      

%   96 ,!5 

.""?."4 .&"67 

*!:&,8

 

#  8

#       8 %        %** % %8 #     8#

 *

 

 8



  



  %

*D  

  *  8#      

 2 *  *  

!&.B4C77  

  #      *       7   8   * %        %   

0        D   8     ) 

 (       #  #     7   7  D

 B   C 

   (           % *  

'     

    % *     *  * %   %  

    6

*#

   %  6 # 

 *  0 %  4F     ".33?@    % 

    - 

          0   >  *        #    %&,!

:;,8  

 %  

#    

       %"33 

!!33-* * %       

0 % # 0*%           %*          % 

*#*   

 

0        8    #    8

 

      

 % *  @ 8 <=@      !,    .,  -  * 

    % ) 

    8 #   * 

       %     ) 6 

3435,335 %  *     %%         !!338

0' '#  (

      

% @# B  C0 '  # *  

 @.37@",!&  

        ;33 

   - 00   (%     #  %    

    *        

 *  #    *  # # %         % ".3 

 &.3  ( # 7 %%

   

) 7  # D0  %

    0 



#   ( #    #   

   %% 

%  

  62 *#                  * 0%    8>   

  0     2 * #    (%    2   

% #   

* #*    

    =%    (%      )!

 7      ),  #     E

   ). 7   *  

%

        0       <=H      *     I%  # <=J#    

 6    @      >  %       *  #    96  !", 3:35,335 

.3,?.3&?.,;?.,.?!;4?!;:67  

 ,5 ,& % # *    %           #             %

 6 

8  (   # 96 !", 3:35,335  

!;4?.,.?.,;?.,"?.."?!;:67  

   % #

 *        

 .3& 67   ,&  % 

 # 

     

   %  '   @ @#           

%   

.3&?.,"?.,;?.,.?!;4?!;:67  

,&  %   G    %      @ 

 #  

%  

#   % *  3;3",3!3 #*    

   #

 #2

*

% @   % '     *     &.03!%     

  # # * %-*#       3435,335 #

0      % 

%                  0     #  #   

 %    * *  7  

  D

0  >    2    .:,  3435,335 *       %       0  6 (#0    #        



     0        

         

%0  %

 # 

     # 

 %0   %      %      #  3:35,335   

* 

 #

 %      #   

   # % ".3

:33  *8 #   8  

#  



     

    ".3

3435,335 # *  #          ";5 &33 6  % #   (% # 

 %  #    8  %  #   0    % #   % % # !,     

    %  #     %  %  #   % *D -

        0

0          %    

  #

# 8      #  #   

5   %      # 

     %  6     #*   #      %    #   %  (    #      %  %   

       #    %  %  %  # ?

      %     (    #    0

%   # %   

#   %    D                %



#     -*  % #

    #  #*   #   

 # 

# 

   * 7 %    # 0 % *  '   -   

 % 

  %

  %   

   0 

 % %

- #

 0

 1      

%%  # %*%

  % 

0   

   %        

  % >    %

6(#0   %  

% #  % 96#    #%

@ *=%   7 8   0   3435,335  6 (#0          

           

 % 



     0    % # 0 

    

   %%  6 (#0             

 %

6

# #

    

 # 0

* 0%   8>   

  0 8            

        0     6 

 >  0%     - % #

0 

     

   

* %%  (  

 *+   # 0 

 

  %%

   0  6  

   

    

0  %# 0 

    

   

* %%    (   

 

%0      

 3;@:";3#  # 0 

 

 

*%%    

    

      %   #      *#

 *      % '   @ @#       

% 

  *# %%          % '        *  

 *  

-  

   % #   %   *  * % '     %  6 

        #   #      %@    

*# @  

 

!;467 .,"?.,;?.,.?!;: .3&?!;:67   0    



  %    

 .!. 77 #   #  *    

*  



          *#*    # 0   6   %       (     #    #    #      ";5   # 8    

#     %    

     E     

  % #

      # 



0 %    

    0     6       %       (    -* 

 0  -*B C  

     .3*-* 

 * *

   %       

  

     

        %   % 

0   % * (     



 

 

   

 *         %   

 .!. 77  6      8    %        

 

 

 % %

 

 

 *    -*   % 

    *#*    *=%    '  )!

 %% ( ), D ). % <=,,

<=,;

#    

           

 %   %  

  7     %

  %   

%      #*     #

#     @       %          



%    *% ' #2

*

% @  %

      

% )                 %   

 %     ** + 

       

  &" ; ***  ( *      &&    

   * *  " = * 

 )**     *" *       *"   *  

   9        ""      *"   &

     &* 

(   



* &" -*

* &

 ><" ? $"%$"%22, &"""

   . +  /" +  0'(  * &

  ><"@  %$" 6"$ %  & " "'"" '    * '(    

               '(        +   



  +   

   

 '(     *    5        

     (    

          



   " .

  & ""      *"    

    +   



  "   * +  

  *   '(   *" -   *    *  +     *        

    & 

   

 +    *"5    *    

&  . +  /" +  0'(  4

  ><"

?    * :

"% 1  2 / "" '(         +        0     

  *   

    &   %2,4" -  & %2,4  &    A* /><"

#0   &   

 +   *     *     

   

" -   +   +&

 &.

 & 

    

 *

 (     &   *      



*  * *  (  &

"*  **  (  &

*&

    *       & (   &   

   A* 

 &   " ;(    *    *(  & *   * *      *    

*       . +  /" +  0'('(   *"     

     &" ; .



      * '(+   ><"@ & 

     +   **  (  & 

* *

><"*: *& . ( 

    * 

   & *%2,4"B * 9  +*  

  *"9   *   (   &  & 

 +  

   A* ** *   ";   *   *    * **  

(   

       

  *   (

   " ;(     *     *    .

 +  ><"

@   C 9   $6" 6"$ %  *  D"  * *     &  * 

  )**     ><"@  +

 &

*

    

 .

   &   9  +)   

*   ><"@"** 



    *"  *      

    &   %2,4        *        *   (

         *    

*     ** *           &     *& 

  **& ""  *"

 " ; 



 )**   +    *  ** &         "    * *               "%$  

                      

    *   & *  &*  *    *   



*  & 

   "

  &( 

*  &          *   &  " ; &$+  "; (     *        * 

 +  "  * &  *

     *      *   &  

   & 

             (

   

    *"**&"7  

      *  *   &      

 

   



   

 (   

  " >+  

  (

       & 

 +    + &&  +

  ***& 

 &    *" -  < *  &  * 

  ) **  *"  *

    & *  *     

    * *2E  "'" *  ***( *#E!6 "'";    &*   & 

   

1    

 

"B *

  *" 

 #E1  "'" 2E1  "'"* *  9   *

    *   &     

 " ;  * 

  * 

  )** +

&   * *&   F-5*  &   *    * " 5* +&

 $  &  -+    B

*   + **  &*  *  + "- *       *       

  +    *   & * 

   

 ("G  +) *+ *     )**  *"

 &"

 ' -+& &'" '+ * F-5

 * & ";  ***(* #E!6 "'  ," 6"$ 6F-5

 *  

 ><"

:8$% E%6"'"; &

 1   *   F-5"; &     *

";&   * * "**   &

 *            *     *     *"   '=5*   &

 F-5 *             '=5   * **" - *     

      (  

  *  +   

,)2'&$ 6"H * **       

*

 * ** 

&   F-5" -     

 (#0    -+  

*   *"      * 

 9 :

" 12%  ," 6"$ 6 *

   9:

12$ ," 6"$ 6  *

      *

* 

 * +    '("7  * ><"

8%

 ><"

8%

     ><" 8%

 -     ><"

F8%

          

  *

*        *  

     "

"' *.

  F ( "+&  * +><"

=  > *& ' *B

** +   '(   

(  "  

(    * +  & *  (  *  " * *&  +   * 

    

 ) <  *  *

*">+     ( 

  ***   *           * (   -     * +      

  * +         9 

        *(" >+ G1 "    *&  <               &   

   * "* *  +  * * &     ("-  +&

*

+        ** *&   '=5"                  * 

'=5"G  *    ( * *     +



  F-5":

 &  1  * +    "*  & + 

*  & +    *"H * ** *   (   F-5      & & + 

    *   +     * 

**";* 

* 

 )**   ** +  (  "

" ' * .

     F (          (   *     *  &  &* (  *& F-5     * *3    +

 &

*" B&    

        * * *** ";           * *   "

"' *.

     F (        +&  *   *   &    *";*  * 

        

       

"; *&  *  &      

" +    *    &* 

 ";        *  +      

 

&   "-*

* * *    

 *   &     "

" ' * .

   F (  & ** 

 *  (  *  *  &" -  <   & * 

  )**      G)$ '

  +  '=5  +    

  ";2      " - &:

"4 *  $"6*@"46*  9&*   < &   

* &

(  + **   +  ";

 )<

    

   * **    " -      

           * *   &*    

** +    < "              **      *"*  & 

    *  **             "%$  " 1)!        .

    + + &   1)! 

          "   '=5

          * +&   &"     <  &

 5 *     ";  + *  

* )*   

*  &    *   &  *   " 5         

         &   *    * (       

     *  ) *       F-5    *   & ** &

     *"  *      

            " ;

 *

 *  (     +& *     +  " -  *

&+ *    *

    *

  *"  *   &  

+     

     .

          

    ) *  

 &   &"  * 

   *

    

*  && **   

       *  &  

&<   *     

 * *" ;<  &* 

) **  3      "%$ 

" ; 

       (   * **   < & *   * *( * *  "    

&   &+ 

**&

&   &";     * +    &  *" * * 

-+   B

* % " 6"$ 6 * 

  ** 

  & 

*

***

 6 

* 3  "%$  (     *   " ;  + *   * * **         ";                "%$   * &  & &

**& * +

   ";  

* 

) ** +

&

*" -     &  * 

  ) ** .



+    * *9   " >+ 

    

  * &    *" -9 &  * *"- 9 &

  *"  (% G%7 ),     **"7 /G$0 

   +   0 

***">+ 0% / G%60      **



  "7 /G$0   ><)  

.

 

 +   

  

**

   #E%6 "'      ,E  "'"  * *     * *





+  "

  

**

 

(  

 ";  

* 

 )**     +

 &

*"     &  * + *  + *+      **

    +   

  ***    * "**

  (

 &&

 *"-    



   +&** * "F  



  

 * **"- 

* 

 +   *



**   *  *  ****     *+    

*  * 

 *     * **

& &

 *" (% BG%0  * 

 * ) <     * 

 

    *  9    *



  "        * *      

   *

*** "    * *&   &"=""?+  ) +     *  &    . " H  * **              * *    * *   

      *  *&      *   ++ *+    *      "1%6        -    " -     / G20 *

 *& 

       *   

  *""'

/ G$0

*        

     

 *

 -     '=5><"

" >+  / G60   / G%%0   * 

   &

   -   "* *



    *

*** 

 ">+  *   9 && (   / G%60   .

  *



      * 

***" = (     +* &  * 

)**      &*  

  * *  *         & *+ *3 +

&

*"; *+  +  & / G60-   / G20     / G%%0  &       *     (     " =&     &  * 

  ) ** &  &* *  &  + *

**"- * 

 + *   *    +    **     *" F 

        



   

 + *"-  *  ***   &   (

(   "   ** *   &       *

   "

  ***   &     *

 -    "      *      

(    "   *     

        "      *          "   *      

       

 "       *      *  "    *    *  & +  &  &  & + ";    * 

(  &  &     

  

*    *  

 & * 

    & (     "         

(  * +";    

*  &         +           

'

   & 

   + "    

&   &"*        *

*  &   *        *

(   "; 

 + *  *<    * 

   *&    *

 

 *"*    *   

  +  *    +     ) **" B   <    *"        * *       *   & *"3  +*   &    ) )

  3   

   + *           *"      

(      &(*              * +&   -          * + &     "       <        

*  * +  +        +&  %%  ( " :

 &   +   

  * )* (#0  *  * A  *       *(  ** &  *          (         -          

*        

(  "  

($    

*  * "  *  * A        *"  * +         I &

'

*( (

*   ";  + * 

   +&     I& 

 &&*      +    



*  & *

(  & +      &" 9      

      %       %      %

 

%      3;3",3!3  #          



 %   

.+2 30"2

/  033

/03. /03.  %,.

,3!5