High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1939/2004allowed

Lakhbir Singh & ORS. v. State Of Punjab

2026-03-30Mr. Justice Surya Partap Singh16 pages

!" #$ $

% ! &!' !( $ $

)"* +)$

!"!#$!%&'()!

*( "!++,,!

-,!' !!"%+ &'()!

!,%.!/ 00000 ,$ 1 &.&#2 (*)(') (!&(&(* )%/( "&!

& 34563557% " ,!& && (!, ( &#% 2 ! ",& " !))&8!++,,! "9#, !&)(') & "2##'&(* "!/(':

2 (&2+#&.&#2 (*)(') (!&(&(* )%

!++!,"!/+*& 3 :",,% "*!) 2##*(2)(&! % *( )(22((*(**)+"!/,& ) (;56%;3<%;37%;3;%;7(* &!!,=(&% (133&!

&15541444$!,(&#&(,) ( ="""! ! > " #!& ( !/(':2 (& " ' #!

( $! )(&) &!&!,, "!))&%"!* /#*& (!!++,,!

(, %!2& "$)(') &!&?:

-. /01-''& ! '02 !

!0!'0 &! 1!-"/ #"

;56= #(( 2+(2 *( ' !!& (+! !* (*3%555@:!&&*!, (* +! 2 (* * ( &#( * "*( "2( "?

;3<= #(( 2+(2 *( " !!& (+! !* (*1555@:!&&*!, (* +! 2 (* * ( &#( * "*( $(2( "?

;3<!&$ ";7= #(( 2+(2 *( " !!& (+! !* (*1555@:!&&*!, (* +! 2 (* * ( &#( * "*( $(2( "?

;3;!&$ ") (;7= #(( 2+(2 *( A2( "!&(* 3!&& ;56!&$ ") (;7= #(( 2+(2 *( ' !!& (+! !* (*3%555@:!&&*!, (* +! 2 (* * ( &#( * "*( "2( "?

;3<!&$ ") (;7= *( " !!& (+!

! * (* 1555@: !& &*!, (*+! 2 (** ( &#(* "*( $( 2( "?

;3<= *( " ! !& ( +! !*(*1555@:!& &*!, (*+! 2 (** ( &#(* "*( $( 2( " ;37= *(( ! (* ;3;!&$ ") (;7= *( A2( " (* ; !//!

;56!&$ ") (;7= *( ' ! !& ( +! !*(*3555@:!& &*!, "(* ( &#( * "*( "2( "?

;3<!&$ ") (;7= *( " !!& (+!

! * (* 1555@: !& &*!, "(* ( &#( * "*( $(2( "?

;3<!&$ ") (;7= *( " !!& (+!

! * (* 1555@: !& &*!, "(* ( &#(

* "*( $(2( "?

;37!&$ ") (;7= *( ! (*?

;3;= *( A2( " (* ; *, & "(* ")!)!2 (/#!

" !) (* B !#!, ! C !#,D% "!* /# *& ( ! )(2+,!! @.&(, $! &/ "!/(':!2&)(2+,!!

(56541444!

!/( E ;5 %"$!

#( ")( *( (* "&(( (*"((2!&"/( "B!&" "!2D$! !-#/!

"+)(2+,!!

"B!-"/ #"C!-"!D!&B!&&D%/( "!2&$ " !& B !//!D2+ "!&&)!2+)(2+,!! B!-"/ #"C!-"!D A"( & ( !)"!,( ( ")(2+,!! !)(2+,!! D/( "B!&" "!2D"!&,(+&$ " "&!#"

(*B!-"/ #"C!-"!D))(&# ( )(2+,!! "!* " !,, " ,!)"& ! !!, +( "2 !& *,) &2, +,.("+("&)+ ((*.$!#' / ")(2+,!! !&?:

! ++,,! B !//!D)!#"

"(,&(*"2& ($")""*,, &($!+ *( (*""(!&**&!/!(( "#"

- / B!-"/ #"C!-"!D & (*,) . $ " "",+ (*(""!&!&%(& (&*&"2,*%$" "!&"#"

!2"

"#"

!2 ) B!-"/ #"C!-"D*,) &)(&/,($( "#"

"!& & B!&&D*,) & "/,($$ "!&.&,* ,#

B!-"/ #"C!-"!D*,) &*(/,($$ " ( ""!&!&$""!&",* "!& (!'"2,* "**&.(""!& * B!&&D*,) &/,($$ " "",+(*(",* - " B!&&D#!' !( " /,($ $ " !& .&",* *(( # B !//!D-)-&"2 " B!-"/ #"C!-"!D*,) &/,($( ",* &(* ""+ 7 " )! (* " +() ( " !/(':2 (& 2 (*)(2+,!! $!)(&&(15541444%$" ")(2+,!!

$!!&2

&"(+ !,"!/(':2 (& 2 $!&, &(& / % -"$& #"%!&( "/!(*!/(':2 (& 2

*(2!,(* ")!$!,(&#&!& "' #!

($!)(&) & )(2+, ((*' #!

(% "*!,+( & ) (16;==$! *,&!#! !,, "!++,,! ))(&#, !,, "!++,,! *!)&

!, !& " $ )"!#:" & / " ,!& !, =( *( )(22((*+"!/,& ) (;56%;3<%;37%;3;%;7(*=" !/(':2 (& !,, 2!

, ),2!

& ()(') ((*!,, " !++,,! F !& < "!/)( &&/ ,!&)(,*( "!++,,! ! ((*.&#2 "!/)(22

&/ ",!& !,=( $","(,&# #, !&)(') #!,, "!++,,! *( ")(22((*!/(':

2 (&(**)))(&# (,!&)(,*( "!++,,! * "*!)

!&))2 !)+ !# ( )!$(,&"!'/+(+, !!, G&/ ",!& !,=( "$!(+(/, (*)(&#!

*&#(*)(') (!#! "!++,,! ))(&# (,!&)(,*(

" !++,,! " '&) !&&)& / " +() ( $! &*) % ,!/,!&*,,(*)( !&) (%!& "*(% "!2$!( #((& (#" (2 " !&!&*A&*(+('#!)"!#)2!,)! 6 ",!&)(,*( "!++,,! "!* ")( &

2, ( "/!(*+2+ (!&!2+ (% ",!& !,=(

"!(/'& "+() ($!))*,&)"!##"/& ))(&# (,!&)(,*( "!++,,! !,, "&*))%$")"

$**) !&#!'(#" (& "+() ( ( ,!/,!& &(/ *,%"!'/#(&/ ",!& !,=( !&%2, %( "/! (*)(.) !&2 "*&#(*)(') ("!/)(&& E "!!,(/!#&/ ,!&)(,*( "!++,,!

)! ",!& !,=( "!#(& "*!) "$!!

&,! (* "&! +( # "2!

( "+(,)!& "&,! $! *!

!,%+! ),!, '$(* "*!) ""(+ !, "+(,)(**)!,"!& ' & " )(2+,!! ( 54541444% $"( $! &),!& ( / * *( 2 / *& (#' 2 ",!&)(,*( "!++,,! "!!,(+( &( !&& ( (!/('% ",!& !,=( "!!,( *!,& (!++)!

"$!(&+& )((/(!

((* ". **&/ ")(2+,!! %(2)"(' "/( "!&2( "(* )(2+,!! %$"($+(.) &! :$ (* "()))%&&(

)(2*($!& (++( "+() ()!$ "#!& ()& > "

#!& (!/('% ",!&)(,*( "!++,,! "!)( &&

/( "(*)(2+,!! !2, B!&" "!2D"!( &)/& "& !,(*

")& %),&# "$!+((*(**)&/ "!!,! %!& 2( "&&( +*(&+( ( !, 4 "!!,(/!#&/ ,!&)(,*( "!++,,!

!&& ( (!/('%!( ",!+( "+! (* "+() #!#) $!

! &+& $ %#"/((+!/ %$!( A!2&!& ' "$!+((*(**)$( +(&)&/*( ",!& !,=( +,!&)(,*( "!++,,! "!/('&)&&*))

"+() ('&)"!'/#(&/ ",!& !,=( %!&

"*(% " 2+#& .&#2 (* )(') ( !& (& (* ) &' (/ !& 15 ",!& )(,"!)( (' & "!/(':2 (& !#2 ",!& )(,"!)( && )!( +(+!++)!

((*'&)!& ",'! ,!$%!#"

)(),("! /&!$/ ",!& !,=( +,!& )(, " !

)!!*,,+((*)!%$" ")"!#!#! "!++,,! "!'/ +('&/ (& ""!&($(*!,,!(!/,&(/ ))(&# (,!& )(,!' !&!

!,'((* " ( "!&/ :( / +() (/*( ",!& !,=( %(2)"(' "$!(**(

()!

! :$ !))( &+ "*!) *!2, 22/(* )(2+,!! %"/( "!&2( "%$+ " 11 ",!& )(,"!* ")( && /*( ,!& !, =( ( (, " $! ! ,!/, :$ !))( % )(2+#(* 2( (*.&@)(2+,!! %/ !,( "++( ' 2&)!, '&)% !& " !/(':2 (& '&) ,* $!

**) !&#((&(#" (&)"!# "/&(* "+() ($ "

#!& ()"!#*!2&!#! "!++,,! >",),!2# "( )(+(*&,#)!& *) "2+#&.&#2 % "!/ )( &&/ ,!& )(, !++!,&'(&(*2 !&&'&2!, 13 ")(&"!/+&)!*,, 1; +!,(*)(&"($ )!%(& ( +(' )! "+() ("!&A!2&'$ "& !,(* !/(':2 (&$ !!&?:

>:1 !&" "!2% " :$ >:3

!#!,!% ".& >:;

"!2 >:7 !!/.

>:F -"$& #"

>:< (+!! >:6 !#&" #" ,, 17 "&()2 ! '&) "+() ("!&+,!)&()(& !&+('& "!2%/ 2!-#$ "A"/ % "(* ")!% " +,!(*+,!)(*()))!& "2&)(:,#!,+( 1F (& ( +(' !,,#!

( !#! " !++,,! " *

$ A!2&/ "+() ($!B!&" "!2D$!A!2&! >:1($'% "$ /(A%""!&( #' "& !,(* )& ">:12+, &+(& (56541444!

!/( 5E ;5 % $""$! !-#/!

"% "!++,,! B!-"/ #"C!-"!D%!2&$ "

%B!&&D%!2&$ "!&B !//!D2+ "!&&)!2 ( "

"(!&(!'!,B!-"/ #"C!-"!DA"( & ()!

)""(,&B !#!, !D!&-,,"2%/)! "/( "(*B !#!,!D"!&,(+&$ "" &!#"

))(&# (>:1"+)(. $!*,) &/ !++,,! ( "+((*B !#!,!D+>:1 "2( "B!2,!

'D"!&!,(!'&( "+( !&$ & ")& >")(:

A!2& ">:1"!&!&2

& ( "!2&! %(56541444%" /( "B "!"!2D"!&,(+&$ "B!!2.

!D "&!#"

(*B!-"/ #" C !-"!D ($'% $ " #!& ( # !

( (* )! !#!

"!"!2D " >:1 "!& +,!&& #(!) ))(&# ( >:1 ( 56541444! +(,) (**)!, "!& ( ' & ""(2$ "#!& ( H !#! B "!"!2D 1< "A $ A!2&/ +() ($!B !#!,!D%

")(2+,!! @.&"2,*">:3"!&+(&)&%/ !&,!#% ( !,2( & )!, ( " 2 2!&/ "2/*( "+(,)8A9 ($'% "H)(*' $")"*(,&&( "+( !

2(* ()))$!!

&/ &** , %)(2+!( (" 2 /*(

"+(,)%)"!!* A"( ( ( !)"!,( "* !!, $! ,!)"&/ B!-"/ #"C!-"!D$ " "",+(*!&$"" ! & (!$! "$!+"&/ B !"/!D& ($")""*,,&($" !/(':2 (&+! (*A!2!

(::)"*(*>:3$!&** *(2 ( :( / "2/*( "+(,)%$" "!/(':2 (&' "!& !-+,!)'&)"((,(# "* "A!2!

(::)"*% >:3&+(& "$!.&/ B !"/!D$ "-)-!,(%!& " /( " B!&" "!2D !& 2( " B!2,!D"!& !'& !

" +( % $"( )!2&*(",+%!& "!* % "!!,! *,&*(2 "+( ))(&#

( >:3 " 2 $! )(&& " "(+ !, / " +(,) ( 15541444($'%$")(:A!2& ">:3"!&&+(& "$! ( !$!$" "! )2!,)!$!*,&!#! "/( "B "!"!2D *(-&!++# "&!#"

(*!++,,! (1:D!-"/ #"C!-"!D( ( ))(&# (>:3"$!( !$!(* "*!) !' #!

($! )(&) &% )!%/ "+(,)%(( ($'% $!!&2

&/ >:3 ""(%$" ")& "!& !-+,!)%$! !

")-, +(+,!

&!!%!& !

2(*()))% "$!( ,#"

% !& !* ".%"$!)()( 16 "* ")(:A!2!

(% ">:3"!&!&2

& " "($!!&.(# ""((* "!++,,! %!& "!2') %

"$"((*B!(&"!2D!&B"(!,D )))(&# (>:

2(*)& % "$!H &!-! ")& "!& !-+,!)!

E:E ;5 %!& !,, "!++,,! "!& &""( "(#"2! #!

%!&!

+( (* 2*$+("!&+!& "(#" " " >:3* " & "& !)/ $ "+,!)(*()))!& /!

"((2%$""/( "$! !-#/!

"$!<:6* $!!,( &/

")(2+,!! ""!&( **&! . ("*!)%)" ( !/&(2%!& "$!+($")"$!&*(*,) #.% $!( "($ ("2%*(& *)!

(% "=( ))(&# ( >:1% "+(,)"!&' &"2% ""(+ !,%(56541444%5E541444 !&54541444%/ "&&( # " 2 )(&&($'%""! && "## ( "*& (#'! 2 ( "+(,)/)! "$! & (#' 2 !* 2 #$ "" "(&!& 1E " A $ A!2& / " +() ( B" !2D

!* 2!$!(, !*(2!,$ %$"("!&+('& ")!,& +,!(*

"+,!)(*()))%!A 14 >:7 /+) (B !!/.

#"D% ((%$!!*(2!,$ % $"( "!& &+(& " +) " !++,,! $ ! & ( 3<111444%!& &# ")((*' #!

( "!))&B!&&D"!&

(,& ""!& "($ " "(!&&/"($'%!+ >:7 ")(' (*!/(':2 (&"!&' !-+,!) 35 " ' #!

# **) (* " )! $! A!2& / +() ( ! >:F% $"(% (/'(, % ++( & " +() ( )! / +(&)# !)" ' % $")" "!& !- +,!) &# " )( (* ' #!

( ($'% " >:F &+(& " "!& 2 .&@)(2+,!! ""(+ !,(5E541444!&54541444%/ (

"( $( ())!(% " .&@)(2+,!! && ( # " 2

)(&&%!& & "$(,&#' " 2 !* 2 #" B(&!&D 31 "2&)!,(**)%$"()(&) & "2&)(:,#!,A!2!

( (*.&$!A!2&!>:6 $!&+(&/ ">:6 !

2 (*2&)(:,#!,A!2!

(14.$*(&( "+((*.&% !&2( (* ".$)&$(&)!&/ "!+&#&$!+( ">:6"!&+('& "2&)(:,#!,+( (* ")(2+,!! !A1 ($'")(:A!2!

(% ">:6&+(& "$!(. (! '

!,+! (* "/(& !& . (7%$")"$!)!&/ /,

$!+(%)(,&"!'/!( )(2(*&&*!,,( "#(&

33 *!! "!/(':2 (&'&)!&&)&/ +() ( )()& ! /! +!, (* " !/(':2 (& '&) "($

*(,,($#! ",'! !+) %$")"&)(&!

(

)! :

4-52! :

* "*!) !,2!

A(* )!!!'!,!/,( )(& !- ()(&!

(% !+ ")&

"!&!,,#&, !-+,!)!

5E ;5 (56541444%/ *( # !

( (* " * 2 $! #' / )(2+,!! @.&(15541444!

!/( 5E ;5 , "(#"

"' #!

# **)"! & (#'!A+,!!

($ "

#!& (!/(':2 (&&,! %/ (A+,!!

()(2# *($!&*(2 "&(*)(2+,!! @.&!& "% "!/(':

2 (&&,! *!

!,*( "+() (> "#!& (!/('

"+)+,(*,!$,!&&($ ")!(*",!!,' (*!2, !&146; =F51%$" "!/(/'& I &,! ,(&## "* *(2!

(+( H (* , 2/,,"2 $")"!)!

(*!* "(#"

!))( (*&,! "+( ( (, # /* (* "!&'! !#(* +( ! &!# )+ (* " (&) ( (* )(,(& '(%A!##!

&!))( ()()() & ( !!, (* &,/!

(!&)(, ( % "*(% !, &,! ",(&##(* "* *(2!

(+( "(,&/ !

*!) (, A+,!&J !6-.2!-02 ! /5720!

)!% $! &/ ">:1 !

2 (* )& " 2( " !2, B!2,! 'D $! !,( + %/ "$!( A!2&&# ")((* !," !/(':2 (&*!, "!

" )&/, (* +() ( )!! ")(:A!2!

((*!/(':!2&'

!,$ )(,& "!'/ 2 !,! "# " -24& /80 32 0-24 /012!'2!0 :

")!(* "+() ( !

2(*)&

B!&" "!2D "/( "(*)(2+,!! $!+ "!2 "(!&$! !-# /!

"" & !) / $ " +,!) (* ()))!& "/!

"((2%! &/ ">:3%$!<:6* ($'% " /( " (* )(2+,!! B!&" "!2D $" !++!& "$ :/(A%!>:1%2! !& ! )(2+, ,) !/( "& !,$")" . $ *,) & "! /&(&+ "*!) !+>:1$"")!2( (*

"/!

"((2% "!))&$+ !

"+( *!) ">:

1+)*)!,, &+(& (. $!)!&( "+((* >:1 " +) "% " +() ( )!D &' ! /* *(2 2( (*>:1 ' 2!9!!0

-02 !

)!&# ")((*A!2!

( >:1 "!& !&2

& " "( $! !

& ! ")-, +(+,!

&!!%!& !

2(*)& 2/(*+( "!&/+!# "(#" " *( (* ""((* )(2+,!! ) " )& "!& !- +,!) ! ")-,

+(+,!

&!!% *!*(2/,'!/, ! (* "#"/(% ! # "#"/(#"(% (! +!/ $(,&(

"!'( )& ")& %$"14.$**&/ )(2+,!! "!/(':2 (&*!,'

)! ' 8-9 ! / //!'2 ! 09

)!((* "))!,!+) (/ !- ( )(&!

( "$!+((*(**)$")"$!!,,#&, &/ " !!,! B!-"/ #"C!-"!D!&B!&&D 8!++,,! "9$!( )('&/ "' #!

# **) &# ")((* !,( "!2$!+('&> "#!& ( !/('% " >:1 "!& +)*)!,, &+(& "$!+((* (**)$!( + "=( "*!,(*' #!

# #) ()('!& +(' " $!+((*(**)$ "( % A+,!!

(!*!) ($")")!

&(/ !/( ")&/, (*

"' #!

( ' +-9 2!2!

023-02 !

)!!( ",'! !+) (/ !- ( )(&!

( "' #!

# **) ")(,,) & /,((& !! "*(2 " +( ()(,,) & "),( "(* .& $")" )(,& "!' ++( & " 2&)!, '&) / "($#) "),( ")(+(&# ( ".)(&& " !/(':2 (& ,!+ ( " +! (* ' #!

# **)!,(,'! %+! ),!, '$(*( " &*)) )!

' &:0-: &0.2'-4 2!' :

)! ,'! (( !+2&)(:

,#!,+( A1%+('&/ >:6%!& 2( (* !

# &() (%A!2&!>:5<% "*!) $!*(&( ""!&(*

")(2+,!! !&*( ++(# $!+*(2&%/

"&() ($"("!&)(&) &&(,(#)!,A!2!

($!(

A!2&%!& "&(,(#)!,+( ( "A:! +( $(

+('&!))(&!)$ ",!$ ' /!'

2 !

$(#"/((* ")(2+,!! "!'/A!2&! >:1!&>:3%!2, (#&!!& #"( "(*

"2"!'&+(& " "!&( "!&(*! )")&

"#"/("((&(56541444 A !&'0 /01' .94-2!-!0 :

" ! ' +)*) !,,#!

( !& ( "$ !,( +('&/ "&*)$ "$!!,,#!

(!#!

")(2+,!! D*!2, )(2+,!! D/( ""!&,(+& $ " "&!#"

(*((* "!))&%/ !' !# 2! ">:38)(2+,!! 9&# ")((*")(:

A!2!

("!-+ , !/( "!/(':2 (&!,,#!

( !

"" & (+,!&#(!)$")( &$ ",!

& H ( A 4 / 023-02!33!'571242!

;2!3'02 ! < " )!%((* ",'! !+) (/ !- ( )(&!

( ((* ")"!#*!2&!#!

!++,,! $!%*( ")(22((*(**)& ) (;56 =($' 2( (*>:6"($ ((* .**&/ ")(2+,!! $!('

!,+! (*"/(& )!++() ('( "!!,! % $((*$"(2 $!2&$ ""!+&#&$!+("!&*,) &.(

"+((*)(2+,!! / &&( )!! . (! '

!,+! (* "/(& %)"!!/&(2%)" ("!&%)!

' (#&(/ $ "#!& ( !&(* "+() (

"$!! ( (-,, ")(2+,!! 3; " )2,!

' **) (* !,, " !/(':2 (& *!) (% )(.( , %,!& (!)(),( )!% "!&(/ $ "

#!& ( ")&/, (* " ( :( / "+() ( , % " !&(/ $ "#!& ( "2/(*!))&%$"($'(,'& )(22((*(**)$")"/ ! &/ &,! %)(&, % " &(/ $ "#!& ( "$!+($")"$!& ")(22((* )2% "&, % "!&*)) "' #!

()(&) &/ ' #!

# **)%!&*( ", % ",!)-(*&+& )((/(!

( 37 '$(*!/('%!!(!/,&(/ )(++&+!#! +() ( ( !& $! "& (* "+() ( (&+, "!/(':

2 (&+)())2 !)%$")"$(&# ( %/ +() (2!/, *!,& (&(( 3F '$(*!/(':2 (&(/'!

(% "/ (/'&

" +() ( $! ( ))*, ( +(' )"!# !#! !++,,! / (& ""!&($(*!,,!(!/,&(/ %!& "!++,,! !

,&*( "/* (*&(/

3< ! H, ( !/(':2 (& (/'!

(% "/ (/'& !((*.&#2 "!/)(22

&/ ,!& !,=(

$","(,&# "!++,,! #, *( ")(22((*(**)+"!/, & ) (;56%;3<%;37%;3;%;7(*&!!,=(&*!) #'*!) !

(%/ #'# "/* (*&(/ !.&#2 (*!)H

!, "(,&"!'/ &/ ",!& !,=( "%/ !))+ # + !++!, "2+#&.&#2 (*)(') (!&(&(* )! "/ 0- 2!&!++,,! !"/ -'=&200 > ?

$ $

% >" "+!-#@!(& K@ ( >" "+( !/, K@ (