← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/195/2004allowed

Surender v. State Of Haryana

2015-08-21Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal15 pages

   

      

  !"#! " !

$%!&$% ""'

%() *) !!!!!++,,  -

%).  !!! + *  !

$%! $% ""'

/ !!!!!++,,  -

%).  !!!! + * 

0



     



   

  

 

      !"

####         ! "#

$%  &'%(!)* +  # %  )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

  /

$%&

 '' (' ) *

+ %,-*

.//0 ) * *.%-*

.//0  1  1       ('   /2 /% .//0    /, /% .//0  

 3

 4  "

1   1 5 '

) *

+ %,-*

.//0 $.& 6 ' ('    

   "



   '' "

7/0*

8)  '' .

" "



 -//9* 

0,:* 8) 8   "'  "

    '' '

     $7& + 7/.

 ./ %% %,,:

 0,:* 7/0*

8)  

 ;5  ' )



<*%

./ %% %,,:

)

  

      !    

(   "  

= + '

 "

'

 " !  

' 



 /> /- %,,> 

 ;  !  ' !    5 '   $0&  '    '

 '' *       

  "



'

1  <   '    

'

1 ?"

   * @   '5   !  '

 .////9*  ' 1  *       ' 

 $-& )'   1 %/ "   

'    *     '**  **  3 3 1    1   ' @  ; 1

 

(  A %, %% %,,: 1  ' 5  15  

  '5 '

 A "

    %,9./ %% %,,: ;

 **   '        ' ''1       )'

 **  '**

 3 3 1   5

   1     1 '9 <   "

BC 

'  $>&    "

  

 1'  ;





9 ;



'

( <9 ;

 

 0,:* 7/0*

8)  " "

  1

 0,:* 7/0*

8)   "

 ' 

$2&  C' 1 ) 

 <*%

(

9 )

 <*.

' ; <9 )

 <*7 )1 8 

<*0 !)

' )

<*- 6

 <*>

' =

<*2 3'

 <*:

1

  8   <*, = ' ( <*%/ 1  ' BC  39.

? '

 

7%7 )  ) ?"

 '  

  '    ' 1   BC =*% =*.

$:& )

 <*% ' 1 

  '

 /> /- %,,> 1   5 1 '

  5  ;

 

(  **    ' '   '"

 1" "

 '  ( '"

 1 ''

 

 .////9*   ' '   1 1       '  '

!    1 '   ' 

 )' D ;

   

 ''1 '   

( ' 1 %/ "  



  '   1 '    *  1  ' ''1 '  '  *;1 

( 1

  A %, %% %,,: ** 

 ' 

 5

15 ''

  '

  5 '

 

'"

 '  1

 ''

 A "

    %,9./ %% %,,:

;

 '  1 

)'     1 

  ''



 

"   !





 %- /> %,,:

 '  !  "

 BC *%   BC %9  ' !     1"

   

"

1    '" '  "

BC 

  $,&

( <*.

1 ; <*7 '      "



 '

  1    '

1 ' '   "

 D

 1   1 '

   *

 C' ?     ' BC ) =

   

   + "



 .////  1   "

' "

 8  *C' "

 <*% )

  '

   '   

)

  /- /2 .//% )1 8 

  <*0  %% /% %,,,         BC B   <*% )

  1  $%/& 6

*<*>   1"

   ''

C' 1  =

' =*<*2  

%27 )  ) !) 3'

   <*:

 ./ %% %,,:   !)  

;5 

1

    "

  5 /: /% %,,,    "

1  )1

'  '

C'    "

1

'   

'    BC 4   "

'    

1 8

1







<*,  '  

BC 

 '

' BC 9%  

      BC  !  ' 

%>% )  ) !   1"

 ''

C' 

!     )   

 BC *%    BC %9 .. %% %,,:

'  BC *.

 5   "

'' BC 

  "

'' BC 

$%%&

'  = ' (   <*%/  ./ %% %,,:

  = 

   ''

C'  1"

 1 )1 ; 



'

 ?  ("

'5  1"

  ''

C'    '

C'    )'

BC' BC 3      '     ''

  ''

C'  BC 39% 1  =  C'  1 .0   ''

C'  D  9BC 39.

$%.& 

   9

 '  5    " ' BC %*   

1  ' ' 

 1"

 ' ?

    "  '   '

'   '  '    

 "

' 1    '   9

 ' 

 ' ('    $%7&   ' 1     

$%0&   1  

 0,:* 7/0*

8) 8



0,:*

     1(  "

  ''

 <    1

7/0*

8)   1  

 *



< 

 (    '

'F



    "  '



 '  1 1( '   "

1     1  



  "

 ' '   ' $%-& 

 

9

   "

   

 

D   1'   ''

  1 (   8  ' ' 1   1( "

 "

 '      ' ? 

    D

 1  +00123  1

320/')-  & &4   

 

 6671,3  1

389/13 ! 4  

 " )  1'    

7/0*

8)

%%7*

8 B      D $%>& 

 

  





   BC %1

    8 A .. %% %,,:

   %- /> %,,:

  <*%  1     

 BC %   "

 1 "

'

   1  !      BC .

   "

'' BC 

  1  C'** <*%    

   1  "

C  ' "

  '   ./ %% %,,:



BC %   

 C %- /> %,,:

 1 ' "

  C   BC %9   

 %> /> %,,:

 

     '

'  1  C1     C $%2&  

  678:9 -   &;-! )%<

4

 " ! -  "" <

1' ' C1 '     C ?      BC *% 1   C +  1 '    '     BC *%1  "

 '



 1 

  8 A   <*, 

 C'**  5 

 BC *%    BC *%9 '   "

'' BC 

+ 1  8 A C "

 BC *% '



  *C'  ' 

 '

1 $%:& = ' (  '    ("

'5  1"

   '     ''

 ' <*.

<*7      ' 1  1  "

'       ' 1 <  '  



 



       1  

' <*% ' 1 <*.

<*7

  ' 

 

  C

' ' $%,&  



 

    +00,1- 3+,6/      " )  4

 )% -)( )% 

    1 '    ' ' 1  ' 1  

  ' '       1  /- /2 .//% $./&  



    

 +00123  1

39,/   &  )4  (%-  )% ) 1'  @@ @@     ' C  '  1 

'     

 0,:* 7/0*

8)  1( '  "

 '    "

' " ' 1   '   C  1  '

 

'     ' '    

0,:* 

7/0*

8) <  1

0,:* 

7/0*

8)    "

 ' 1    1 ' 

%%7*

8 B  

'      1   ' 1 1(  "

 '     "

'  

'       '

7/0*

8) 8       1( '  "

 '    "

'   1 ' 1      '  "

$.%& B  '

   BC *%

 '   

 7////9* 

'   

 



 

     **   '

' A  BC *%      '   D



 

      5  !

 '    **    '

1  5     "

  1        "

    ' " %,,> <  '    "1"@ ' )' ' ' 

( '

   

  "

15

7/0*

8) )'   %% /, %,,- 

   !     1  BC *% BC  $..& A  



 

    +0:6/ ) - /=    " ) 1'   ' ' 5    "    "

C   

  '    ''   '

%%7*

B  '  "

'  1  $.7& 4 '    " 1  1 '

   



    "

C    ' ' 1        ' <*% " '  '

     '  "

 '1    '  '

 "   

1 '"

<*%  BC *%   ' D  

'1

 C  BC *% 1  ' '     BC *%  "

 '



 ** '

 



 

  '5  "

"

C   '    ?  '     ' 1  

 * 

$.0& )'     ' '5       ' ('   /2 /% .//0    /, /% .//0  1"

  



 D 

 

'

 +"

D 

  .% ./%-

20 % 3