Subeg Singh v. State Of Punjab

 
  


 







 

 !"#$%"&'('#)*"+,- ,./0

12 -+"3')34

')%",')34 222
 ! !"#$-)6 + 222  
 *

 



 ,"(")!* #)"$#,!4" 77"88 )!(2 4,'+4'(4"9
4 -! 8 0(('(! )!%5#& !"")", 80-)6 +2


 !2 , 8*

"')3 33,'"5"%+.6-%3:")! )%#,%",% !"%

22

') "(('#)( 
("  #2 /  #$   ;2

/  ,'(')3  #-!  #$    #2/  % !"%  2/2

/0  -)%",  "&!'#)    #$  !4"   ,&#!'&  ,-3(   (.&4#!,#7'& -+(! )&"(&!0 0,"3'(!","% !#8'&"! !'#) % ,0 ,'%9#!0,")%","% +.!4"8" ,)"%!,' 8&#-,!+.<4'&4+#!4!4" &&-("% 77"88 )!(-+"3')34 )%  ')%",')34<","&#)5'&!"%$#,#$$")&"-)%","&!'#)#$!4"  ,&#!'&,-3( (.&4#!,#7'&-+(! )&"(&!0  )%(")!")&"%!4":!# -)%",3#$#,." ,( )%!#7 .$')"#$(2

=0')%"$ -8!#)":#,"

." ,0!4"7,"(")!!<# 77" 8(<","("7 , !"8.$'8"%+.!4"!<# 77"88 )!(2 " ,%>" ,)"%
#-)("8$#,!4"! !"2 #)" 77" ,($#,!4" 77"88 )!(2 !'(!4"& ("#$!4"7,#("&-!'#)!4 !#) 2/2

/0!4"7#8'&"

7 ,!.$,#:#8'&"! !'#) % , ,'%9#!4" %"%+. 8')34$#-)% !

+#-!2 20!4 !!<#7",(#)('2"20!4" 77"88 )!(<","&#:')3#)(&##!", $,#:!4"#77#('!"('%" )%<"," (9"%!#(!#724".(!#77"%!4"(&##!", )%, ) < .')!#!4"<4" !$'"8%(+-!!4".<","'%")!'$'"% ( ')%",')34 )%-+"3')342,#&"%-,"&#)!":78 !"%-)%","&!'#) #$!4"&!< ( $#88#<"% )%#)!4"7",(#) 8(" ,&47#77.4-(9<"'34')3 9'8#3, :( )%

3, :(< (("'?"%$,#:!4":#-!#$<4'&4 3, :(< ((")!$#, "@ :') !'#)24".<","7-!#)!,' 8 )%-8!': !"8.$#-)%3-'8!.+.!4"!,' 8 6-%3" )% ((-&4(")!")&"% &&#,%')38.2 4 5"7",-("%!4"':7-3)"%6-%3:")! )%#,%",& ,"$-88.2 $')%  !4 !  !4"  8" ,)"%  !,' 8  -%3"  4 (  %'(&-(("%  !4"  "5'%")&"  ,"3 ,%')3 ,"&#5",."!&2$')%!4 !!4"7,#&"%-,"4 (+"")&#,,"&!8.$#88#<"%!4 !< ( &#)!":78 !"%+.!4"8 < )%!4","< ()#$ -8!<4'&4&#-8%+"$#-)%#-!2 4"8" ,)"%!,' 86-%3"4 (: %"%'(&-(('#)(#$"5'%")&"-)%",7 ,  #$!4" 6-%3:")!<4'&4A-#!"4","-)%",* B
     

    

                         

 

   

                

          

      !"#  $%  &

     '        

               '  '            

     

  



          ('

 



 

               )*  

'

 

   

    

   

/   

      '           



         '              )+, 

  

   

 

 

     

           

  - 

  .     

  '              

   '



 



         

   

 /
*0+**0 



       

  +/0+**0

 

 

 ' 

                   

   .    1 &#)&-,<'!4!4"$')%')3#$!4"!,' 86-%3","&#,%"% +#5" )% !4-(4#8%!4 !!4"&#)5'&!'#)#$!4" 77"88 )!('(8"3 80&#,,"&! )%7,#7",2 4")"@!A-"(!'#)'( +#-!!4" < ,%#$(")!")&"2(7",!4" &-(!#%.&",!'$'& !"0 ')%",')344 ( 8," %.-)%",3#)"(")!")&"#$ ." ,( )% % .(<4"," (!4"#!4", &&-("%) :"8.-+"3')344 (-)%",3#)" /:#)!4( )%% .(24"7,#("&-!'#)& ("'!("8$(4#<(!4 !-+"3')34 < ( 7'88'#),'%", )%'!< ( ')%",')34<4#< (4#8%')3!4"&#)!, + )% )% 8(#%,'5')3!4"(&##!",2 4"  A- )!'!.  #$  7#77.  4-(9  !4 !  < (  ("'?"%  < (  #)8. 

9'8#3, :( )% 3, :(<4'&4'( %:'!!"%8.)#)&#::",&' 82 ):. #7')'#)0!4"A- )!'!.#$7#77.4-(9'(!##8#< )%!4" < ,%#$(")!")&" ( $#,"( '%':7#("%+.!4"!,' 86-%3"'(#) 5",.4'34",('%"2):.#7')'#)0

')%",')34+"')3!4"7,')&'7 8 &&-("%0<4#< (& ,,'",0 )%-+"3')34 +"')3!4"7'88'#),'%",0!4')9!4":'!'3 !')3&',&-:(! )&"%#"@'(!')!4" ')(! )!& ("$#,"@!")%')3!4"+")"$'!#$,"%-&!'#)#$(")!")&"#$+#!4!4"

77"88 )!(0:#,"(#<4")!4"')&'%")!4 %! 9")78 &"')!4"." ,

/ )% '!<'88+"<4#88.-)6-(!!#7-(4!4":')6 '8 3 ')2 )!4 !5'"<#$!4" : !!",0!4')9!4"$#88#<')3#,%",<#-8%(-+(",5"!4"')!","(!#$6-(!'&"* 

'
 

 )%




 ,"7 ,!8.

88#<"%C

'' 6-%3:")!  #$  &#)5'&!'#)  )%  #,%",  #$  (")!")&"  % !"%

22

'(&#)$',:"%C

'''4#<"5",0!4"6-%3:")! )%#,%",,"3 ,%')3(")!")&"'(("! ('%" )%:#%'$'"%!#!4""@!")!<4'&4!4" 77"88 )!(4 5" 8," %.-)%",3#)"2     D


 E "+,- ,./0

12  

"

 F4"!4",(7" 9')3=," (#)"% "(=# F4"!4",,"7#,! +8"

"(=#