High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8309/2014dismissed

M/S Convenience Enterprises Pvt Ltd v. M/S Ozo Media Estate Ltd & ORS

2015-01-08Mr. Justice J.C. Verma6 pages

! "

!#$% &%'()(*+#*,#-. /

-%)%*$+

2-( 32(4 #'2#-/ &1'#$%/ -$2%5%$($(*%-

-#4+ 2%5%$($(*%-54#(*$(

()#66-(%1%& -&%-&#$%&

5#))%&7.$2%48%-',-$82%-%7.#554('#$(*,*&%--&%-9,4% :

$2%54#(*$8#)&();())%& .8#. #;%*&;%*$(*$2% 54#(*$/$2%54#(*$(

/5%$($(*%-2%-%(*/2#&),62$-%'1%-. #*#&&($(*#4 #;,*$ /00/0:/0<= 2%-(6(*#4),($5-% %--%&7.$2%54#(*$(

)%%3)#&%'-%% -%'1%-.*4.

/0=

,*)%4 -$2%5%$($(*%-2#)'4#(;%&$2#$%1%*$2,62$2% 5(*$)*82('2#;%*&;%*$(*$2%54#(*$()),62$/8%-%#4-%#&.(*$2% 3*84%&6% $2% 5%$($(*%-54#(*$(

#*& 8%-% &,4. '*)(&%-%& 82(4% #--(1(*6#$$2%#;,*$ -82('2$2%&%'-%%8#)-(6(*#44.),62$/%1%*$2%* $2%#;%*&;%*$),62$(*$2%54#(*$',4&*$2#1%7%%*-%>%'$%&#)$2%)#;% ()#448#74%%1%*#$$2%#55%44#$%)$#6%7,$$-%))2()'4#(;/',*)%4 $2%5%$($(*%-2#);#&%-% %-%*'%$$2% 448(*6>,&6;%*$)+

-,*?,;#-9) #*$)2#(*

*4(*%

#-7#*) (*62 #$-#9),-5-%%$ (*62

#-&#-#-( #'2#* (*629)#>- #- 2#>#* (*62#*& #*$2%- :0

)28#*( 66#-8#49) 2#*$(@#4 @94@ 0 ;-(3 (*62 #*& #*$2%- 9) ;($#72 (*62 #*& $2%-) = = < =

< ?#-#.#*# (44#(9) #-#;%)28#-#* (44#(/ < :; #-3#)29),3%)2?,;#- = = =

,-(*&%- (*629)(-;#4 (*62 = = =

2%-%()*&()5,$%#7,$$2%4#84#(&&8*(*$2%)%#,$2-($(%) #*&$2%-%'#**$7%#*. ,$$2% #'$) $2%'#)%(*2#*&#-%A,($%&(

%-%*$ $()#4)*%'%))#-.$-% %-$$2%-4%/$%*-#*&$%;5%-#;%*$ #) #4) '*&,'$ $2% 5%$($(*%-54#(*$(

(* 5-)%',$(*6 $2% ),($

554('#$(* -#;%*&;%*$$2%-%(*8#) (4%&*

/-%54.$82('2 8#)5-% %--%&7.$2%55)($%'*$%)$(*65#-$.*

$ $2() )$#6%/ ($ () $ 7% &%$%-;(*%& #) $ 82%$2%- $2% #554('#$(*;1%&7.$2%5%$($(*%-54#(*$(

$2%54#(*$() 6%*,(*%#*&7*# (&%B$()#4)$7%)%%*#)$82%$2%-$2()#;%*&;%*$ ),62$$7%(*$-&,'%&(*$2%54#(*$#&1#*'%)$2%'#,)% >,)$('%-&% %#$) $2%)#;%(--%)5%'$(1% ;%-($) $2%#;%*&;%*$)),62$(*$2%54#(*$B < %'-& 5-'%%&(*6) $2%),($54#'%&*$2%5#5%-73 ),

('(%*$4. -%1%#4) $2#$ $2% 5%$($(*%-54#(*$(

2#& 7%%* $#3(*6 $2% 5-'%%&(*6) 1%-. '#),#44. #*& 2#& *%1%- 5-%))%& 2() #554('#$(* #;%*&;%*$ $2%54#(*$ (4%&*

#*&'*$(*,%&5-'-#)$(*#$(*6 $2%;#$$%- %-%4.7%'#,)%$2%&% %*&#*$)2#1%*$ (4%&$2%8-($$%* )$#$%;%*$ 82('28#)&%4#.%&#55#-%*$4.&,%$$2%'*&,'$ 5%$($(*%-54#(*$(

(*5-)%',$(*6($)'#,)%(*$2%),($/()*$#6-,*&$ #448$2%#554('#$(*82('2#55#-%*$4.8#);#&%;%-%4.$&%4#.#*&&(4#$% $2% 5-'%%&(*6) (* $2% ),($ #& $2% 5%$($(*%-54#(*$(

5-%))%& ($)

#554('#$(* -#;%*&;%*$(*$2%54#(*$#*&2#&*$5-'-#)$(*#$%&$2% ;#$$%-/$2%-%8#)*-%#)* -$2%),($*$$2#1%5-6-%))%& ,-$2%- -;#44.#),($(*)$($,$%&*

:)2,4&*$2#1%'*$(*,%&#*& ;,)$2#1%7%%*&%'(&%&7.*8 : !%#4(*68($2$2%;#$$%- #;%*&;%*$ $2%54%#&(*6)/$2% *C74% ,5-%;% ,-$ (* %1#>%%$, ,(4&%-) !%1%45%-) 1 #-#.#*#)8#;. *)/

(1(4 : /&()',))(*6$2% %*$(-%*64()2#)8%44#)*&(#*4#88($2-%)5%'$$ #'$-)$7%$#3%*(*$ '*)(&%-#$(*82(4%&%#4(*68($2#554('#$(*) -#;%*&;%*$/(*5#-#<<$ : $2()>,&6;%*$/2%4&#),*&%-+

! !"

# $% & &'

# (& ) ) ('(* (%+' $( ,

, '( '+'

#' -& & %.#&

% $'

/' % %( )'

% -& ' %- # %

'0'

# &'

% 1% +')+' 234 &'

&' +')+' (%.#&

( +,'

5' 1%

, %,'

) '11'

5' )0.)

% %1 &' ('6 &'

&' ,,

% 1% +')+'

( $% 1 )'

% + 1 )'6 274 &' +')+' (&%. ) % .(' (.& , '0.) '

% &'

( )' -& & % $' %+,'( ') )'8.

' !

+( %1 +%'!9 2:4 '1.( # +')+' -%. ) 1 ') % 0.(

% ') % +.

, '

%9 2;4 &'

&' , %,%(') +')+' %(

% ! %

1.)+' ! &#'( &' .

' ) & '

%1 &'

('6 ) 24 ( #''

. '* &' %.

(&%. ) )' '

+')+' ( 1 1 '(& (.

% &' +')') +( -%. ) $' $

') $!

% % &' ) ' %1 ,,

% < &'('

' (%+' %1 &'

+,%

1 % ( -& & +! $'

/',

+ ) -& ' )'

# -

& ,,

% 1 ') .)'

= . ' 3 &'('

' % !

5' ) %

'>&.(

5' ? &' )' ( % % ,,

% +)' .)'

= . ' 3 ( 5'

! ('

%.( 0.) '>'

(' ) &' ( ) '>'

(' (&%. ) '5'

$' .)'

/' (. +'

@ ' % .)' %.

) (.(( % $! %$('

# &

-& ' )' ) # ,,

%( 1% +')+' ( &' %.

(

+.( %

'1.(' $% 1 )'* '#

+ '* &%'( ) ''(( ! +')+' ( ) (&%. ) '5'

+ 1 )'* -%

& '(( )A% ) (&%'( +')+' ( D2%*8%#554.$2%)%$%)$)$$2%5-%)%*$'#)%/($()'4%#-$2#$+ (#;%*&;%*$),62$ -()*%($2%--%A,(-%&*-5-5%- %

%'$(1%#&>,&('#$(* $2%'#)%E (($2%#554('#$(* -#;%*&;%*$/#)2#)#4-%#&.7%%*2%4&/$ ),

%--%5%$($(*/();%-%4.$&%4#.#*&&(4#$%$2%5-'%%&(*6) #*&();#4# (&%E ((( ( $2() #;%*&;%*$ () #448%&/ ($ 8,4& '#,)% )%-(,) 5-%>,&('%$$2%$2%-)(&%/82('2()*$';5%*)#74%(*$%-;) ;*%.E (1-% ,)(*6$2%#;%*&;%*$-(62$4.4%#&)$>,)$('%#*&#1(&) ;,4$(54('($. 4($(6#$(*E 1 5-5)%& #;%*&;%*$ '*)$($,$(*#44. #*& ,*&#;%*$#44.

'2#*6%)$2%*#$,-%#*&'2#-#'$%- $2%'#)%#*&#4)$#3%)(*$ '*)(&%-#$(* #'$)#*&'(-',;)$#*'%)82('22#&#4-%#&.7%%* $#3%*'#-% 7.$2%54#(*$(

#$$2%$(;% (*)$($,$(*6$2%'#)% 7.8#. -(6(*#454#(*$E#*& 1(%1%*82%*8%%F#;(*%$2%#;%*&;%*$),62$ -/($() #55#-%*$$2#$( # -%)2),($*$2%#;%*&%&'4#(;() (4%&/($ 8,4&7%7#--%&7.4(;($#$(**$2%&#$% #554('#$(*

(*'% $2% ;#$$%- - #;%*&;%*$ () )%-(,) *%/ * '*)(&%-#$(* $2%)%#)5%'$)/($()*$2(*67,$;#4# (&%#*&&()2*%)$ %F%-'()%7.$2%54#(*$(

*($(#44./ $2% ),($ 8#) - )%%3(*6 # &%'-%% -%'1%-.

)

/0=87.8#. #;%*&;%*$/($()),62$$7%'*1%-$%& (*$#),($ -#&%'-%% --%'1%-. </:/< =

2% 5-5)%& #;%*&;%*$ () 5-(;#-(4.7#)%& * &',;%*$) &#$%& <#*& <82('28%-%*$*4.(*$2%3*84%&6% 54#(*$(

#$$2%$(;% $2%),($7,$2#&#4)7%%* (4%&7.($8($2$2%

54#(*$($)%4 2,)/&,4.'*)(&%-(*6$2%)%&',;%*$)/$2%54#(*$(

2#& '* (*%&($)'4#(;*4. --%'1%-.

/0=

2%-% () #7)4,$%4. * -%#)* -$2';(*6 #) $ 82#$ 2#) $-#*)5(-%&4#$%-$'4#(;#&&($(*#4#;,*$ /00/0:/0<=2%-%()* ),'2'#)%$2#$$2()54%#',4&*$7%$#3%*7.$2%5%$($(*%-=54#(*$(

%#-4(%- #$$2%$(;% (*)$($,$(* $2%),($&,%$);% -$,($,)-%#)*)2%),($ ()5%*&(*6 -$2%4#)$)%1%*.%#-) $()7%(*65,-),%&'#),#44. $2#) 7%';% # 4,F,-. 4($(6#$(* - $2% 5#-$(%) 2%-% () * '2#*6%

'(-',;)$#*'%)),55-$(*6$2%#;%*&;%*$(*$2%54#(*$ ;%*&;%*$),62$ (*$2%54#(*$()*%($2%-7*# (&%*-6%*,(*%*-%1%*2#)#*.%F54#*#$(* #)$82.$2%#;,*$*8),62$/2#&*$7%%*&%;#*&%&%#-4(%-82%*$2% &',;%*$) * 82('2 '4#(; - #&&($(*#4 #;,*$ () 7#)%& 8%-% &,4. '*)(&%-%&7.$2%54#(*$(

#$$2%$(;% $2% $2%-(6(*#4),($#*& $2%*$2%#;,*$ -%'1%-.8#)'* (*%&*4.$)

/0=

$2%#;%*&;%*$()#448%&/5-#'$('#44.$2()8,4&#;,*$$ ),7)$($,$(* $2%%#-4(%-54#(*$8($2$2%%*$(-%4.*%8*%/8($2*%8'#,)% #'$(*#*&*%8-%4(% ),62$ -7.$2%54#(*$(

2%-%()'4%#-#&;())(* $2%54#(*$(

(*'*)(&%-(*6$2%#;,*$ $2%7(44) <#*&

< #*& $2%* #--(1(*6 #$ #* #;,*$ )

/00= 82('2 #&;())(*()),62$$7%8($2&-#8*7.8#. $2()#;%*&;%*$8($2,$#*.

%F54#*#$(*--%#)*)5,$ -$2(*$2%#554('#$(* 54#(*$

2%#554('#$(*-#$2%-/()*$2(*67,$();(),)%- $2%5-'%)) $2%',-$ (*'%$2%),($2#)#4-%#&.7%%*'*)(&%-#74.&%4#.%&(*($) &()5)#4/$2%48%-',-$8,4&&%'(&%($8($2(*)(F;*$2)7.$#3(*6$2% 8-($$%*)$#$%;%*$ $2%&% %*&#*$)*-%'-&#*&$2%-%# $%-6(1(*6$2-%% 55-$,*($(%)$%#'2 $2%5#-$(%)$4%#&$2%(-%1(&%*'%

,-$))2,4&*$7%$#3%*'#),#44.7.$2%4($(6#*$)-%;1%

),'2(;5-%))(*$2#$$2%;#$$%-'#*7%&%4#.%&#*&&(4#$%&(*$2%',-$)#$ $2%8(44#*&8()2 $2%5#-$(%)/($()&(-%'$%&$2#$$2%$-(#4',-$8,4& #&2%-%$$2%$(;%4(;($#*&8,4&'*&,'$%1%*&#.$&#.5-'%%&(*6)(

,*&*%'%))#-.

< 2% -%1()(* 5%$($(* () &();())%& 8($2 ')$) 82('2 #-% A,#*$( (%&#$)0/ =