High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1611/2009disposed of

Malkiat Chand And ORS. v. State Of Punjab

2015-09-08Bench- 47 pages

!"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #,

34 !

" # !

$ !%& '(&)* # +

, " + -

! "

# " ! #

(''( !

* *

+ 61#7 -8 $"# 0%-6#( 89:$, 9+( :1%:'*,$9+:#, "96# +- "#,1$9$1-+$-(#:.9%#900#..9+$-9%.-:"9+'%19,&'6#+1.#9$$"#$1*# 7"#+ "# :-**1$$#( $"# -::'%%#+:# -+ 55 "# 900.1:9$1-+ 1, 9..-7#(

::',#(9.;19$ "9+(9%.-:"9+'%19+( '%(9,'%1"96# :"9..#+)#($"#&'()#*#+$09,,#(/<$"#$%19. -'%$61(#7"1:"9::',#( 9.;19$ "9+( 79, :-+61:$#( '+(#% #:$1-+ 4= 7"1.# 9::',#( 9%.-:"9+'%19+( '%(9,'%17#%#:-+61:$#('+(#%#:$1-+4=%#9(71$" #:$1-+45 9+(7#%##9:",#+$#+:#($-'+(#%)- <#9%, 9+($-09< 981+#-8>#9:"9+(1+(#89'.$-809<*#+$-881+#$-'+(#%)-98'%$"#% 0#%1-(-8 8-%4*-+$",#9:"

$1,$"#:9,#-8$"#0%-,#:'$1-+$"9$!9)1% 9*7"- %#$1%#(8%-**1.1$9%<1+$"#<#9%@ 79,,#%61+)9,'&9%11+$"# ')9 9%1-8$"#61..9)# +459::',#(9.;19$ "9+(9+( '%(9, '%1$#9,#($"#)1%.,7"-7#%#)-1+)$-$"#8-%#,$$-#9,#$"#*,#.6#,9)1%

9*"9(-/&#:$#($-$"#,91($#9,1+) +559$9/-'$9*9..

$"#$"%##9::',#(9.-+)71$"-$"#%0#%,-+,:9*#0%#,#+$9$ ')99%1 ::',#(9.;19$ "9+(#A0%#,,#("1,1+$#+$1-+$-$#9:"9.#,,-+$-9)1%

9*#"961+)$9;#+-'$%1,"'.8%-*$"#%#.1)1-',0.9:#"1$!7"- 79,:9')"$"-.(-8/<9::',#(9%.-:"9+'%19+( '%(9,'%1 +# 1%9+&9+1+)"*9(#9+9$$#*0$$-%#,:'#!8%-*$"#9::',#(9+(1+ $"9$0%-:#,,"#9.,-%#:#16#(1+&'%1#,

4 = + 79,%#)1,$#%#(/9,#(-+$"#,$9$#*#+$,'88#%#(/<!4 '.,"9+ '*9%7"-1,$"#,-+-8!9)1% 9* ! % 1$9+&9.1 #A9*1+#( 1+&'%#( 1%9+&9+ 1+)" -+ 559$9/-'$ 9*9+(8-'+(9.9:#%9$#(7-'+(1+"1,-::101$9. %#)1-+9:-+$',1-+-+"1,%1)"$9%*9+(9,7#..1+)1+$"#.#8$"9+(.. $"#,#1+&'%1#,7#%#:#%$181#(/<"#%9,,1*0.#1++9$'%#!9.,-*#(1:- .#)9..<#A9*1+#(!9)1% 9*-+$"#,9*#(9<9$9/-'$9*9+( 8-'+(.9:#%9$#(7-'+(-+$"#.#8$09%1#$9.9%#9-8,:9.0$1,"#%-01+1-+ $"9$9/.'+$,1(#-8$"#7#90-+"9(/##+',#($-:9',#$"#1+&'%< @ ! % $ -.9.'$<#(1:9. 881:#% -**9+( -,01$9.!#,$#%+ -**9+( "9+(1*9+(1%#A9*1+#(9)1% 9*9+(8-'+( 0#+#$%9$1+) 7-'+( -+ "1, .#8$ $#*0-%9. %#)1-+ 7"- 79, 9(*1$$#( $-

-**9+(-,01$9.-+559$9/-'$@ 0*"#,91(1+&'%<79, :#%$181#(9,)%1#6-',1++9$'%# !9)1% 9*79,8-'+('+,$9/.#$-)16#%9$1-+9.9+,7#%,9$ $"#$1*#7"#+"#79,#A9*1+#('$"#,0-;#9/-'$$"#9$$9:;.9'+:"#(/< $"#9::',#(9+($"#1+&'%1#,,',$91+#(/<"1* ! 9./1% 9*79, 9+-$"#%#<#71$+#,,7"-9.,-,'00-%$#($"#$#,$1*-+<-8!49+(! !? #,9%1+)"9+(!9"1+(#%1+)""96#1+6#,$1)9$#($"# :9,# !4 "9, :9$#)-%1:9..< ,0-;#+ 9/-'$ $"# *-$16# 8-% $"# -::'%%#+:#"#0%#61-',(9<-8$"#-::'%%#+:#!"9(-/&#:$#($-$"# 9:$-89::',#(1+$#9,1+)$"#)1%.,7"-0%-:##(#($-$"#8-%#,$9%#98-% #9,1+)$"#*,#.6#,6#+-$"#%71,#1$1,97#..,#$$.#(0-,1$1-+-8.97$"9$

5 7"#+9+#<#71$+#,,1,$"#%#$-#,$9/.1,"$"#:9,#-8$"#0%-,#:'$1-+$"# *-$16#8-%$"#-::'%%#+:#09.#,1+$-1+,1)+181:9+:# !49+(!

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

<1+ "1,0%#,#+:#$"#,$9$#*#+$-81%9+&9+1+)"79,%#:-%(#("#%#8-%#1$1, 8-'+($"9$1%9+&9+1+)"79,6#%<*':"%#.':$9+$8%-*$"#6#%</#)1++1+) $-0%-,#:'$#$"#9::',#(8-%$"#1+&'%1#,"#,',$91+#(1+$"#-::'%%#+:#$ 9+<%9$#1+$"#.1)"$-8#61(#+:#-8!49+(! 9+(1+$"#/9:;)%-'+(-8 $"#*#(1:9.#61(#+:#9691.9/.#-+%#:-%($"# -'%$:9++-$,1*0.<1)+-%# $"#9$$9:;.9'+:"#(/<$"#9::',#(+-$-+.<-+!/'$9.,--+1%9+&9+ 1+)" "# -:'.9% $#,$1*-+< "9, /##+ :-*0.#$#.< :-%%-/-%9$#( /< $"# *#(1:9.

#9%+#(:-'+,#.900#9%1+)8-%$"#900#..9+$,7-'.(,'/*1$$"9$ $"#%#79,9(#.9<1+.-()1+)$"#81%,$1+8-%*9$1-+%#0-%$9+($"9$,':"9

(#.9<(#9.,9(#9$"/.-7$-$"#:9,#-8$"#0%-,#:'$1-+ ?

$"-%-')".<0#%',#($"##61(#+:#-8!? #,9%1+)"

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

#9%+#(:-'+,#.900#9%1+)8-%$"#900#..9+$,0-1+$#(-'$$"9$ $"#%#79,,-*#(1,:%#09+:<1+$"#*#(1:9.#61(#+:# +9:9%#8'.9+9.<,1, -8#61(#+:#-8!9+(!1$1,8-'+($"9$!:9*#-'$71$"96#%,1-+ $"9$!,',$91+#(.9:#%9$#(7-'+(7"#%#9,!-+#A9*1+9$1-+-8 !:#%$181#($"9$$"#1+&'%<79,90#+#$%9$1+)7-'+( @ $*9</#9:9,#7"#%##1$"#%-8$"#,#$7--:$-%,"9(+-$ 0%-0#%.<#A9*1+#($"#7-'+(,'88#%#(/<!"#61:$1*(-#,+-$"96# 9+<:-+$%-.-6#%$"#-01+1-+/#1+)#A0%#,,#(/<$"#-:$-%,7"-#A9*1+#(

? "1*"#89:$%#*91+,$"9$%1,"'.79,',#(8-%:9',1+)1+&'%<-+$"#"#9( -8!!"#+$"#-:'.9%71$+#,,"9,,0-;#+:-)#+$.<$"9$%1,"'.79, ',#($-:9',#1+&'%<-+$"#"#9(-8!$"#:-+$%9(1:$1-+8-'+(1+$"# *#(1:9.#61(#+:#(-#,+-$)-$-$"#%--$-8$"#*9$$#% "#+-+#A9*1+9$1-+-81%9+&9+1+)"(-#,+-$:%#9$#9(#+$ 1+ $"# :9,# -8 $"# 0%-,#:'$1-+ 1+9,*':" 9, $"# -$"#% 71$+#,,#, "96# :-)#+$.<#,$9/.1,"#($"#:9,#-8$"#0%-,#:'$1-+

#9%+#( :-'+,#. 900#9%1+) 8-% $"# 900#..9+$, ,'/*1$$#( (#:1,1-+,-8$"1, -'%$1+

9+( !!"

#$% &' (' $- ,$%#+)$"#+ "1, 9%)'*#+$ $"9$ )%1#6-', 1+&'%<9..#)#(.<,',$91+#(/<!79,+-$#,$9/.1,"#( #:$1-+4=-8$"# 7-'.(/#9$$%9:$#(#6#+18+-1+&'%<"9, /##+,',$91+#(/<$"#61:$1*'$1+$"#1+,$9+$:9,#$"#,#9$-81+&'%<9+( $"#7#90-+',#(:.#9%.<#,$9/.1,"$"9$9+9$$#*0$$-:-**1$*'%(#%79, *9(#/<,$ 9::',#(71$"$"#91(-8+( 9+(4%( 9::',#( '%$"#%$"# #61(#+:#-8!7-'.(#,$9/.1,"$"9$1+&'%<8-'+(-+$"#0#%,-+-8! 79,)%1#6-',1++9$'%#"#%#8-%#$"#9/-6#(#:1,1-+,7-'.(+-$900.<$- $"#89:$,9+(:1%:'*,$9+:#,-8$"1,:9,# 4 00#..9+$-9%.-:"9+'%179,(#:.9%#(9,*1+-%9,0#%$"# -%(#%09,,#(/<$"1, -'%$1+

4@?549*979%#-8$"#.#)9.

0-,1$1-+$"9$'+(#%,':":1%:'*,$9+:#,"#,"9../#%#8#%%#($-$"#'6#+1.# ',$1:# -9%( :-+:#%+#( 8-% 09,,1+) $"# ,#+$#+:#'$ :-+,1(#%1+) $"# 0#:'.19%89:$,$"9$"#79,:-+61:$#(9.-+)71$"$"#9('.$9::',#(9+("9,

= 9.,-'+(#%)-+#*-+$",9+(@(9<,-81*0%1,-+*#+$(-+-$0%-0-,#$- ,#+($"#:9,#$-$"#'6#+1.#',$1:#-9%(:-+:#%+#(8-%09,,1+),'1$9/.# ,#+$#+:# -+81%*1+)$"#:-+61:$1-+%#:-%(#(/<$"#$%19. -'%$9,9)91+,$ 9::',#(9%.-:"9+'%1"#1,,#+$#+:#($-$"#0#%1-(9.%#9(<'+(#%)-+#/< "1* 5

-*1+)$-$"#,#+$#+:#1*0-,#(-+900#..9+$9.;19$ "9+( 9+( '%(9,'%181+($"9$$"#<"9('+(#%)-+#$"#-%(#9.-8$%19.8-%9/-'$ .-+)<#9%,::',#( '%(9,'%1"9(&',$:9')"$"-.(-8$"#61:$1*+ 61#7-8$"#9/-6#0#:'.19%:1%:'*,$9+:#,9::',#(900#..9+$9.;19$ "9+( 1,,#+$#+:#($-'+(#%)-5<#9%, 1+,$#9(-8 <#9%, 9+(9::',#( 900#..9+$ '%(9,'%11,,#+$#+:#($-'+(#%)-<#9%, 1+,$#9(-8 <#9%,

"#81+#9*-'+$979%(#(9+($"#(#89'.$,#+$#+:#1*0-,#(/<$"#$%19.

-'%$9,9)91+,$9..$"#$"%##9::',#(900#..9+$,,$9+(,',$91+#(

"#9::',#(900#..9+$,9.;19$ "9+(9+( '%(9,'%19%#-+ /91."#1%/91./-+(,,$9+(:9+:#..#("#<,"9..,'%%#+(#%71$"1+ (9<, 8%-* $"# (9$# -8 $"1, &'()#*#+$ /#8-%# $"# "1#8 '(1:19. 9)1,$%9$# -"9.17"-,"9..,#+($"#*$-&91.$-'+(#%)-$"#%#*91+1+)09%$-8$"# ,#+$#+:# 8$"#<891.$-,'%%#+(#%$"#.#9%+#( "1#8'(1:19.9)1,$%9$# -"9.1,"9..$9;#:-#%:16#,$#0,$-,#:'%#$"1#%0%#,#+:#9+(,#+($-&91.$- '+(#%)-$"#%#*91+1+)09%$-8$"#,#+$#+:# ?

"#900#9.1,(1,0-,#(-89::-%(1+).< #0$#*/#%

'.9$1 "#