High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8620/2016allowed

Balbir Singh v. M/S Gainda Ram & Om Parkash & ORS

2020-01-16Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal7 pages

! "#

$# %&$ ' &(' &

! "# $ %

& ! "# $ ' ( )))) &(' &) *

&+ * $ "

+ ,#

# $$ $ - $ !

$$ . $ # .

$ ' /

. $

* + 0 # # #$ #

$ +#$ 1 , ! .

/.

2

/ "3 "4 5

64 1

"1 .78!

!7

6

1601 .

"3 ! : !!7 - 8 5-9

9!- ! !.

!" 4 ./ 110./! "1/. 9;.5-

./!.

!/

90 "18 / - !/ 110

<< 5-

./!6 -!

!")7.

!

9! 6 1 .

1 " 8 "0 "

. "

579 "1/

799 8/9 " "08 ""

.6

/ !!

1 5 - !

" 47. /9 "1 "!

!) " "

=7!

"0 ..

.5- -) 7"1

0 9!6 3.

1 " 47. "!

!> 2$ ' ($. # 3 . + ! $$$

# . ". $$ $## + +$. !# 4 $ $ #"+ $ $ # #

$ ' ( -. .

# 1 , + '7 . 1

" "1 8

.0 "=7"

" 5 - "!

?7

9 .

.

.0

87"

./!> 6+ -

1 ! "1 6 "3 /./.

.! .7"" "3 .8 !1 7"1

"

"1!

$@!

8 8 .2 !-

! 5"

. 1 .8 + -

1 ! "1 9! "!

.7

!

99- !"

5-

./

!-/ $@! .3 .

1 "3

"1

9"3 "3 7.3 !!)B 1 .2 !-)'7. "1 .(78 !"!'-

=- 4 "3 .!-/:

9 - - 9! !!7 1( - .-

""

15 5-

.8$@!

.3 .

1 "3 "1 7.3 !!) B 1 .2 !-

<;< '7. "1 .(78 .- !!7 ,>.8! . .8

"!

5-

./.

!"/. 9 "!

.1 "

.0!9 /

15 1+ -

./ !!

1/ . 1 8"

-!)

- 8!

9 "=7.

1 " . 1! 1 "

8"

-7"

C "1- .

"4 . 7!

-!/

9! "1 "

9905- " .

1.8- !

-- ""

15 !!7

9 - ! . - ! / 110 ./! !

!"

4 . "15-

.

!"/. 9;-

! "1 """ 4 5 -7.3 !!)B .2 !- "1'7. "1 .(78 /./.

.!@5"

.! .8$@! .3.

1 "3 "!

18 2 "31

A7!

!" /.

.

3 !

1. 8 "

9

'

!5 99 ! "=7.

!- 9!2 /

!8 . 3 "

9 !9 /! *( - .- !+ " /.8 !

/.

/ ,> .8! - ! . / 110 ./! 4 .67

.9 "3 . "3 8

.1 0

8..5 ".

7!

.

7." "1.

7!

9 8

+ -

9"35 -7.3

!!) B 1 .2 !- "1 '7. "1 . (78 . 5-

5"

.! .8$@! .3.

1 "3 """ 4 5 "!/

. '

(

984 9!

8/9

.

/9 -.

(

95- - !6 1 " 9 5 "1!

!4 1 6 "

"1" 6 "1 "37/"

" "08 ""

.- 18/9 5 ! 9 1 "9 7"

.69 =7!

3.

6 . 3 "

9.1 "

.0!9 /! .178 !.8 9 5797!

10/9

"

!8 9!

"1 637! 3.

7"1 /.

!!7.

=7!

!

- !!2 ".8 9 99 6 9 0

<C< + -

- !8 9.

?7

1 ! "1 9 8 "13 4

9!8 / 67 0- .

7!

9!.

7!

3 4 ".8

"

.1 "3 ./!

6 ;5- - 3 !91 -.73- 88 !! " "0 .3 .

1 "3 .7"" "3 .!-/

-.73-B 1 .2 !-)7.3 !! "1'7. "1 .(78 .67

- !- .

7!

"1- ) - !!7 3+* + -

!

.

"

"11

"1

9- !1

9 "3!5

9! "!

"!1"

" 0

.< ; "1;<C "1.

" 9!

.

.0 87"

7"117 60/ !! "3

.0 *6+ -

-73-

9 87"

17

"!

! "1.

.1 "3 ./!

"

1 " / D /9 "1 87"

160 ! " 9

"11 "

67

87"

6 .

1 60 /9 .8 ! "1.

.1 "3 ./!(- .

7"

!C))@< !6 "39 1 -+ -

4 !7 . /7./!

7.

"1=7. !1 " ! !C))@< 7.

8/ !C)@< !6 "3 A 1" > * $

# . # + $ ' ( 0+ + " # $ 5 6 . $ $ 7

# . $.

" 1

<D< ,05 0/.

//9

" //9 @/9

2!7.

/ .8 !! " /.

!7 .8!7

.1

")8

.0 "=7"

"5 -"!

?7

.

" !) !7 ..

.0 8"

0 !/ 8 "-

8 "!7

) !- 9.

10 9 15.

"17"

.9 8 "5- - !-

!73- 8"

01

!D)D)@< !;)D)@< /. " / 9 "1 ! ):)@< ! "

979

1 7/ :DD "1.

.1 "35- - !- 9.

A 1 7.

!

8/ ! )D@< 5) ! "

5 - "3 .

" /.

!7

/.

.8 60/9 !" " 901

"3! "

1 "3! " /.

!7 "1.8

"

! /.

//9

" !9

"

!6 "3!

7/60 5- - !" 8/9

1

.8 6 ! ! "

" !.

" !)5- -- 6!97

90" ""

"5 . 3- .

.0 "09 -73-

5 "18 /9 !9 6 967

5- " "

7.

!7 /9 ! 6 "3 - "3 8/9

90 "1 ".

!/"!

.9 .!7 )

9.

10 9 7"

.9 8) -7!) - ! 7.

8

"97! "

/.

//9

" !"

"

!9 5- -.

1"6 9 //9

" //9

!/.

"1 """

!

1 -.

0) 1 - 1 9 1 - ! 7"

8- .

) - ! 7.

1 !"

8 995

/.

//9

" !- 601 !8 !!

1> 7 # $ # " " $ * +$$ $## .+$

# !

. $ # " $$#"+

<< % + $ # 4 !

$!

# ! # $

# # . $

# * + $!# # .! + .#

+ * # $ 7 "8 ! 2"

# $ $ #+.

. +$$ $##

# + #$ #

#

$ $ *

+ # 4 #+! $$ #$+ 9

0. $ # " # #$,# 0 # ## #! #+.

. ! "

$$+$ " #

%."! $$# .#4# . $ $# $! . + # 4 $ # # #

$

<:< 9 $ # $ 4+. ## $ #"!

. 7 # $ $. $ +# # . .$ . 0 ". $ $! . # * $$ #+ $ $ * $! . #. ## #. .

. *&(' &+ ':

;'

(;(;

<