High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11677/1995allowed

Gram Panchayat Mehngrowal v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2023-11-30Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari10 pages

!"# $%&$&%

!"!'"(

!"# %$&$&%

! )# *+ ) ,

*+ ) ,

"!#$% &'()!*+& ,( &!"())-&# &.&/)!*+& , !0 ,,

(&. !+!&"&345) .(#$( */ 666&++ !& &/572 ,2887).(#$(!9342:)&)6&!#$(//+ ++!) ( &++ " ( & /+& , ( &6 &+(&$& ++!),&"(6& +,( /&!) &(.&;&(!&!&! < =+;+)("(345)(6&6&! +,(! !/&!)#+&6&!,&*),( !+44,( !++! 5 &!",(6 "!345)*&/(& #+&6#&'! &! &!#$(+)/!&

, /!".(#$( &!(/&!)*4&4*)( *& !++! 0

(/&!+/,( *& !++! &/+!(&(6 "!3/&#/#&!)& 6&! &+!+)6&!#$(*/++!) ( (,-!+,(*/)&#+&6 +&!("( + &, + 25 (-&# //&" 66&!9"/&:+)28>2)("((6!"+ 28,28?> @

(,)(*!&$*",345(&# &!)#!(&&/#!6!&.(((! &!#$(/!&()!(/!&$*")(&6 #"#&! &!+,(*/++!/&/$) (*!&$&+$,(!+,(*/&/;! #"&"! > = & 6 ( (& &6 &+(&$& (&"&.&/) +(&//"! ( ! &! #$ ( /!& ()#,(("(,/"4225<742882 ( &! #+&6 !+!! <<7A<7<5 ( ++/!"

&&"& (,(*!+9 &:&3&+!(&,

" #

$ !

&'&% ! ( " #

" # &) &&

+ ( " #

+ , -

&) &&

. 33333 333333 33333B ? .*)#, +!"6&'&$!( &. &(6,(!+9 &:)!6! +&$3&+(&*66&!(&. ) #!!6!+&$!+).(((,&+,(&! +&)&6/&(,&+&(&!)&(#$&#/( !&.&!+&!6.((!+6&!(. 4225<742882

/ "0

0202!" A

( &6&+(&$&. ,

/&!6&">7><@'&&/2A6&/&*//&"(".&/! 6&875!&!<87A28@?)(&&, .& 6&!(&6,&6&+(&$& (& &/!*(&!

9 !0:) 3& &+(.&&(C! (&+(&$&/&! 8 &6 &+(&$& ,/! ! + ? , ( -&#//&"66&!9"/&:+)28>29(&,, (+&//!&(D+,28>2D: ("(&!!&.( 7>7828879342:)(//+++!(/!)(&(/&! ! *

/0 1 &!),, +/*& (,)(!!,(*+,( ! ++!&875.&&+!<87A28@?,&* ,( 4&6&+(&$&&(*.,(&#*!+ 27 ""*! &"& ( ! 93 42:) ( ! 0 ,/! & & &/ #, ( */ 6 669=:-&#)3+"( .,66

("(&!6&!(7A7<288@9345:)( & &/9 &:#+&6&//.! 22

(6&'",(&,!9345:)(&!+&! &( 4&6&+(&$&&!(&/!,/(& . #,( 2< = &&8,(. )(&#&*!(& & 2<50 &" *//&" (".&/ &( .& !(*+!#(#&,&*/!+ !&!<?7028>? (&!6&.&+!#$&6&+(&$&) &!) ( &6 .& -+! #$ ( & //+ ++! ("(&!6&!522<28A@

25 &'(&&&!(+/!" !0) ,/!&& &/(&"&#,(//+++!).(+(.& &//.!("(&!!&.<@7>28A>).(#$)(! &!#$(&//+&!&(#+&6&! 20 /"&""*!)(&6&+(&$& ,!&& &/ &"&(! &!#$(//+++!)(#,( /&! 66 9 &/: &/&!(& *) &/&!(& .*)(&!& &/#+&6!6!("(&!!&. 7@2<28AA 2@ /"!4&,!,6(&,)(&6&+(&$& ++!,/!* #&"5<7,28AA4A8#,( /&!&+&/669 &/:-&# ("(&! !&. ( 282<2887 93 4>:) ( &! * #+&6&++ !&!(! &!#$(66

&/&!(&*)&.//&)#$(//+.&!)&!)( ! &!#$(&//+&!)"&!"-+ ,6&2<50(#+&6! !9

5!"

! 2>

( !+!(&(. , /&!("(( !+44#$ +(&,6"&" "(($&2822&!2820)&+()(+&+*!!( *,+095:9:,(D+,28>2D) *.(, &3&+!(&, 2

3 "&# "# "4# "#

"&#

"# "# !

" #" $ % " # & ' ($ ) * 2? ,(+!(&( 6"&",($& 2A?2&!(&("(,6"&"9:./!(6#("( ( !+44($&2822&!2820)(*!. &&&/!!&!+((+ ,( /&! 2A ()( .!&! !#$( &! ( &6 & &/ +!! ( +/6 , .( (&!,&++/&,6& &/,-&6&#&!,( $&28>?4>A 28 &875.&&+!&+6,&/ +,28@5).((.&36 )#(.+"* 36 ,6*", (&+(&$& ()( +(&(+&,( !;&/$,&//.((&6# ,(36 6!+095:9:,(D+,28>2D 9 &: <7

*(-&6&#&! &"($&28A24A<&! 28?>4??&+!"(&." !&6"&"9:)( (3,((&9:(/&! "178

':/2

2!"

(02 /1

(!'"

0202!"

(!'"

5!"

"0 <2 =&//$(./!#/!& /$(*!+)& 6&!#$(4225<742882)(,&+&(&! (

&+6 !(,&+6(&(!+)&)6&!(+& 9 &:.&;&/$(,&+&.+&!( << .*)(*+!.(+(#+6/!) ) #$(/&! */ 6669=:93+"( .,66:!+/(& +*,(+/&,+& ,( /&!&( +*/$& * &!

0 .)$($.!(.( ,( ++!).((&,($&2822&!2820) +!! 6"&"(&!/&!*4&4*( ! !+ , !0 (,)(.&++&,&$&// #"6&!&$,(&*"+/&)(!,, +&//$ + 095:9: , ( D+ , 28>2D * .(,&!3&+!(&#* <5

(&#"(&+( ! !+44 , !0)#+&6&"!"(&6"&"9: *(! !/&!#$(/&.,/.(,/&/$( &#* 6&,&+*!,&+)!!) 6&,&+)6&'(! ! /&!)#( /&!#.!#$( &+(&$& (#$+6",+,(D+,28>2D)(.&&$ +$,(#+6"*!(&6 &+(&$&++!) /( !0.&/!(#,+"&+, (&*" +/& 9 &: &&//$) ).( ( ,&+ , ( -&6&#&! 28@7)&!+!(!345)( (/&!..!#$( #$(+/*& +/6) !04 &/!*(&!.&!&#6&'"

+/*&(,)#! .(,6.(6( ! !+44 , ! 0 &+;! "( &

;

6"&"( <0

("(( !+44, !0) !/$&+;!("(&6"&"()( 28@7 /&/$ .( (#$ ! 0 ("( ( !+44).&) 6&,&+)/!#+6#.! .((#,+"&+,(&*"+/&9 &:)(!, , (,) +*,&$$#"6&!( *+!!+/&"(/&!# $( ,&+,( ! !+44, ! 0) #+6"/!#+6#.!(#,+"&+,( &*"+/&9 &:)(#$(/&!)(+/!#!6! #+6*!( <@

(&&6&$)(!6&!#$( */ 6 66)& &(&*#6&!#.((6&'"&$ ,+&$"&/"+&/&#/).(#$ !0)!!&#/$ *)(&( !+44.(6"&"9:*( /&! <>

( &!!+ *!+ , ( "&/"+&/ &#/ &(.&#66 &)&(#$&/ !0) &( +/! +/&6 (& (#$ ( (&! &+;! ,6 ( /&.,/ !+44)(&+;!"(&6"&"( /&!)#!+/!+/&6(&//!6 6&!,(6"&" 6$)(#$(++44,(6"&")( ) ($&/!&*&/! &!/&6"&"9: *(! !/&! <? (6)#&&//$(&#**) 6&,&+) (.&"()/&!*(/&!)(*"

(&6&+(&$&++!)(#$(&//+ ++!++!&(+/!-+(+/&6;&&&,( 6&)(("(&!6&!7>7828879342:) .(#$)6&.&!!#!(&6,(&6 &+(&$&++! <A

(&#"(&(&#*!9342: #"/&!#$(!+6&!345).(+(. +(&//"!#,( <8

(&&6&$)+(,&9 &: ++/!(&(6 "!!9345:)("(!+/&( ! !+44,( )#+6 &"!*&/!"(&6"&"*( /&!)#+ ((&&/(&#*#*!)(&.(&$"&/"+&/ &#/ &( #+6" &!!+! #, ( & //+ ++!)((/&! */ 666)+/!

.//++/!)(&(6"&".( !+44 , !0 (,),(&!&(6 "!! 93 45:) & &! #$ ( /&! */ 6 66++!)#/&#/#;&(!&!&! 57 (/)(/&",-+)6/$, .&,&!!+,(&#*"&/"+&/&#/)#,(& //+++!&((+/&6, !<&(+& #+/! (,)!6!,&!& &6&!( )(&(/*& !"&#/)#+6&!!+!#,( &//+++!),(#$((#,&#/(" (& !0)((++44,( +* !+44

, 52 =&,6&()(. &//.! (6 "!

!9345:;&(!&!&!&!(,(&, )6&!!(&//+++!).((&// !+( &&!!+(/*&"&/"+&/&#/)&!)(&// (&,"*& $( &$&!!+#&/ (*!+ 5<

(3+9:#!#+6 /!.( 36(&!(!+(6&!! #6&!#&, (&"&//&,,+! ++! 55 =+/&,!(&(#!"&!++/*!+)& 6&!(6&!! (&//"*).(( !0) /!&$!,6&#"6&!(,&*)(#$( *&(++!=(&#**)(/*&6 6&$ #+6 +& #, ( ($ ++!) # // ( 3426&$(/!,+ 50 +(6&+&/,(&#!+!!)()&//( !"& /+&9:),&$)&/&!9:! !,

<,,

<-+

= %$&$&% '&*"( 3

1>2"?@

@ !

01:7

@ !