High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8270/2017allowed

Smt. Seema @ Savita Devi v. Surender Singh Chauhan And Others

2019-04-30Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan8 pages

! " #$%$ & '

() * + ,$ ,$ $$ & - . &" $&/0 0 .0 0 % %1 2'

34 2

5 4 % &' 2 "$6 $&7 ",

2 .& $" $&/07 ", 7 !

0 1 $$ & % 2 .* 87 ", 2 -$, 9 $&/8 7 ", 7 !

&" :::::::

5 47 ;4<

0 1 % & 1 $$ & $% "$ # "

$&% 0 " "

" 7 %% " =6 0 ""$$ 8 $%$# ."/ 7 ../ * ;!

7 0 11 88 .<7

>$&/ 0 8 !$8 " =6 %1

&" 7 !$8 " =6 0 * $&% 0 " " ?(7 1 %% " =6 0 $,$8 ."/ ;.&$ $,$%$ &<7 ../ * ;!

7 0 8 #$ 8< & ? 0 1 $$ & > % 8 # "

! ,$88 / %%

$6 0%$8 &" $%$# ../ * ;!

%0 7 0 ,$88 / < & .867 ?

&" &

#0 88 &/ " 0 1 $$ & @% 8 #$ & 0 ./0 >$ 1 $$ & !$8 "

= !

0$% . = $&/ A B)? C

D .#0 1 $$ % "$%*$%% " =6 0$% . ? =6 1 %%$&/ ! 0 !

>$&/ " ' 0 1$* 6 /$ , &# $% " $& 0 1 % & >$ 1 $$ & $% / "$&/ 0 8$/$=$8$6 ! %1 &" &

B E ,$ + * ,$7 !

0 1 &#0 $& 0 / & 8 8 #$ &%7 >0$#0 > 0 8"

& 0 &.

67 ? $& ,$88 / %%

$6 0%$8 &" $%$# ./

0 1 $$ & 0 8 & $, * "6 ! 8 #$ &" 0 $,$8 . 0 % = & & $!$ "

% 8 #$ 8

& %.#0 %$.

&7 > ! $& & $& 0 1 $$ &" 8 / &

$8 0 % $"

8 & $, * "67 $& ## "

&# >$0 8 >

2 ( $%*$%% "D

0 ! 7 & ? %1

&" !$8 "

& 8 #$ & = !

0 8 #$ 8 & = $&/ 1.

$# 7 0 1 $$ & "

= !

0 8 #$ &" !$8 "

& .&" " .8 % 9$&/ F #$ ! %1

&" @% 1 $$ & 0 / .&"

8% 0 & 0

% G.$ " .&" #$

F #7 ))( ;!

7 0 #< %.#0 1 $$ " & = & 1 % 886 1 % & " =6

&" 0 1 $$ & @% ## 1 " =6 0 8 #$

& 0 / .&" 0

&" 0 " & 1 % 886 1 % & "

0 $ 8 #$ & %1

&" 1 ! "

$&% 0

% $"

" 1 %% " =6 0 8 #$ 8 >0$#0 > > " $% $& 0 #9/ .&"

! 0 % !

#% 0 0 1 % & 1 $$ % = & !$8 " & " # .&% 8 !

0 1 $$ & %.=*$% 0 0 1 $$ & > % 8 # "

! 0 ,$88 & ? .#0 8 #$ % #0 88 &/ " !

0 !$% $* =6 %1 &" &

0 ./0 >$ 1 $$ & !$8 " =6 0$* = !

0$% . $& 0 !$% > 9 ! .867 ? % "$%*$%% "

& ?

& 0 / .&"

#0 88 &/ 0 1 $$ & @% 8 #$ & 0 * "6 $8 &" &

!$8 0 ! 7 & ? %1

&" !$8 "

#0 88 &/ 0 $& 0 1 $$ & @% 8 #$

$% %.=*$ " 0 0 1 $ " 1 %#$= " .&" #$ # !$8 & 8 #$ #0 88 &/ 0 8 #$ &#0 8$9 0 & > % 0$6 "

&" %$&# 0 8 #$ " = & !$8 " =6 %1

&" ! , %$H * &0%7 0 % * > % 8$ = F # "

& 0 / .&"

& $,$%$ & &#0 F."/* & ! 0$% . $& C

D7 ?;(< ;$,$8< ?

% #$ " $& %.11 & " # .&% 8 !

0 1 $$ & !.0 %.=*$ " 0 %$&#

&" "$" & 1 % 886 1 % & 0 8 #$ & = !

3 8 #$ 8 >0$#0 > *

6 G.$ * & .&" #$ #7 0 $ 1 $$ & > % 8$ = F # "

& 0 / .&"

%.11 0$% %.=*$%%$ F."/* & ! 0$% . $& C

!" #$

" D ;(< ;$,$8< ( > % #$ " & 0 0 0 &"7 8 & " # .&% 8 !

&" %.=*$ " 0 0 $%%.

" & = & 1 %% " =6 0 1 $$ & = !

0 8 #$ &" 0 !

7 %0 > % % 11 " ! * $%$&/ 0 % * = !

0$% . % !.0 %.=*$ " 0 0 $%%.

*$H " G. %$ &" !

&" 0 !

7 & 0$% / .&" 0 8 #$ & 1 ! " =6

&" # .8" 0 , & = & F # "

& !$8 " =6 0 & .&" " .8 & 0 $%%.

! 1 % &$&/ 0 8 #$ & 1 % 8867 $ > %.=*$ " 0 ! 0 # > % 1 # ". &" 0 !

7 , & $! %.#0 " & = & 1 % 886 1 % & "7 %.#0 " ! # > % #.

% 0 8" =6 0

&@=8 1 H . $& C

D ;< ;$,$8< ) 8% =6 0$% . $& C D7 ;< ;$,$8< () !

1 # "$&/% >$0 0 * 7 $ > .8" = 11 1$

! 0 # 0 % * "%

' C;< ! 0 , 8$"$6 &6 8 #$ * *= * *$$ I$8 $%0 ! * 0 $* -$# 0 $* &7 %$" & -$# %$" & !

*$$ I$8 $%0 " %1 #$, 86 $% = ./0 $& G. %$ &6 1 % & %$&/ 0 8 #$ =6 &6 1 % & G.

8$!$ "

0 8 #$

>0$#0 %.#0 G. %$ & 8 %7 %.#0 1 % & *

&6 $* >$0$& 0$6 "

! 0 "

! 0 " #8 ! %.8% &7 1 % & 0 #$,$8 # . 0 ,$&/ "$& 6 F.$%"$#$ & $& 0 >$0$& >0$#0 0 8 #$ % = & .8" 0 , = & 0 8"7 !

0 " *$&

! %.#0 G. %$ &D

4 % 1 0 G.

" 1 &7 $! 0 , 8$"$6 &6 8 #$

* *= * 7 *$$ I$8 $%0 * 7 0 $* -$# 0 $* &7 %$" & -$# %$" & *$$ I$8 $%0 " $% = ./0 $& G. %$ &6 1 % & # & %$&/ 0 8 #$ =6 &6 1 % & G.

8$!$ "

0 8 #$ >0$#0 %.#0 G. %$ 8 %7 %.#0 1 % & *

&6 $* >$0$& 0$6 "

! 0 "

! 0 " #8

! 0 %.8% ! 0 8 #$ &7 1 % & & 8 #$ 0 #$,$8 # . 0 ,$&/

"$& 6 F.$%"$#$ & $& 0 >$0$& >0$#0 0 8 #$ % = & .8" 0 = & 0 8"7 !

0 " *$& ! %.#0 G. %$

$% & "$%1. " 0

0 $* ! 1 % &

&" > & 1 % & = !

0 8 #$ 8

> , 7 $& ,$ > ! 0 8 > 8 $" "

>& =6 0

&@=8 1 H . $&

% # % ;%.1 <7 %.#0 *$%%$ & 0 $ 1 > .8" & $8 .$/0 F #$ ! 0 $ 1 $$

% # % ;%.1 < 0

&@=8 1 H .7 >0$8 $& 1 $&/ ! 0 #7 0 8" 0 % * = 1 # ". 8 % !.0 0 8" 0 " ! # $& & &1 % & ! 0 8 #$ & =6 0 8 #$ & > #. &" 0

"$%# $ & 0 " = & , % " $& 0 . 1 *$ 0 8 #$ & #. %.#0 " ! # =6 $&/ = !

0 . "

) 0 F."/* & $&

% # % ;%.1 <7 >0$#0 $% 8 , &7 $% 1 ".# " = 8 >' C) A !$&" %.=% &# $& 0 %.=*$%%$ &% * " =6 0 8 & " # .&% 8 !

11 88 & 0 1 & # $& " $& #$ & ?

#7 ))( $% & > " =6 &% G. &$ 8 % #$ & & $8$&/ "$%*$%% 8 #$ & $$ &7 $! $ $% & 1 % & " =6 0 8 #$ & $$ & $& 1 % & 0 0 0 &"7 $& = 0 #$ & ! 0 1 % & ! 18 #

&" % #$ & ! 0 .&F = #7 & & 1 % & ! 0 8 #$ & $$ =6 0 8 #$ & $$ & =6 0$*% 8!J0 % 8! > .8" & $8 "$%*$%% 8 8 867 0 !

7 0

4 /$%8 . 0 " $& &" "

* 9 0 1 & $& #$ & ? 1 # ". 8 0 =6 * 9$&/ 0 " ! # $& & & 1 % & ! 0 8 #$ & $$ & =6 0 8 #$ & $$ & $& 1 % #. =8 "$%# $ % = & , % " $& 0 . 1 *$ 0 8 #$ $$ & #. 0 " ! # =6 $&/ = !

0 . "

7 $!

"$ # " =6 0 .D

, ,$ > > % !

> " =6 0$% . $& % # % ;%.1 < >0 $& $ > % 0 8"

5 C

* & $& / * & >$0 0 %.=*$%%$ ! 2 0.

% 0 &/.

! #$ & ?

! ))( # $% #8 *=$/.

.% ! 0 # $% #8 *=$/.

.%7 0 $% & & "

9 0 $"

0 1

$& 1 0 % * 0 #%7 $ 7 ))( # &" )B #7 &,$% / " 0 1 % & ! 0 1 $$ " !

" # &"$"

$& 1 % =.7 >0 %7

# "

% & &,$% / %.#0 *

6 G.$ * &

! 8 &" $& # % 7 0 8 #$ & $% !$8 " >$0 . 0 1 % &# & 0 $&7 0 " ! # $% #. &" $ "

% & $8 $& "$%*$%%

&" 0$% > % 0 1$&$ & H1 %% " =6 0

&3=8 .1 * . $& .& 1 " F."/* & #$ " %.1 >0$#0 "% 0.%' &'

(

" ) ( *# !" # + , # -./.012 0 23435

" (

" '# /663 + "5 "

" ( '# /61. (

'#/6630 7(

"'72 ' !

# 5 # 5 5 "

8 &

'9. (

# : 4; (

"'#

"##< 5

*# " # 5 "

# # = * "

/4; '5 # " (5

#""+

'## ('#/61.# ' (

"' '

# '

>" " " !

/4; '# /6635" : (#" ( *

#" 9/ ('

9. (

"'# ( " ( " ?

# # ,

/4; !

" (" ( "'

" ( " " # " =

& ,$ > , 7 0 8 #$ & 1 ! " =6 %1

&" # && .$/086 F # "

& 0 / .&" 0 0 % * > % & 1 % 1 % & " =6 0 * = !

0 8 #$ 8 %1 #$ 0 % ! # &%$"

& !$8 " =6 0 1 $$ & .&" " .8

0 %.=*$%%$ ! 8 & " # .&% 8 !

&" 0 $%%.

& $% *$H " G. %$ ! 8 &" !

&" 0 !

7 # && = / $&

0 % ! !$8$&/ & .&" " .8 7 $& 0 !

#% 0 1 % & # % 7 & "% = F # " 4 & " # .&% 8 !

&" & $0 "$%1. % 0 "

! 0 1 $$ & @% 8 #$ & & 0 "

! !$8$&/ ! 0 8 #$ & =6 %1

&" >0$#0 $% ! %$H * &0% ! %.#0 8 #$ & , & 0 >$ 1 $$ &7 !$8 " =6 %1

&" = !

0$% .7

#0 88 &/ 0 1 $$ & @% 8 #$ &7 >0$#0 > % & & $& " !

> & !! #$,

8 & $, * "67 > % !$8 " =6 0 * ! , !$, * &0% ! 0 1 $$ & @% 8 #$ & % 1 0 G.

" #$ ! 0 # & $% G.$ "

= !$8 " >$0$& 0$6 "

0 $% & 1 & .&" & ?;< ! 0 # & 0 " 8 ! !$8$&/ ! 0 8 #$ = 6 &" 0 1 %#$= " 1 $ ! 0$6 "

6% 0 8 > $% > 88 % 8 " 0 0 1 >

& " 8 6 # & = H #$% " =6 0 .J .0 $6 &86 $! 0 H$%% 1

, & 0 >$% 7 0 $% & 0>0$8 H18 & /$, & =6 %1

&" !

0 " 8 6 $& !$8$&/ ! 0 $ 8 #$ A$0 / "

! " 8 6 $& 0 !$8$&/ ! %1

&" @% 8 #$ 9$&/ # .% & B ! 0 4$*$ & #7 )?

7 0 )?

#<7 $,$%$ & &#0 ! 0$% . $&

% # % ;%.1 < .0 $ $, 86 0 8" 0 0 1 ! #$ & B ! 0 )?

# > .8" &

0 !$8$&/ & .&" #$ ! 0 # / 10% ! 0 % $" F."/* & C A 1 # "

*$& 8 , & % .

6 1 &% # &# &$&/ 0 $%%. #$

$ F #7 ))( ;$& %0

7 C0 ))( #D< 1 ,$" % 0 $! 0 , 8$"$6 &6 8 #$ * *= * 7 &#07 *$$ I$8 $%0 &#0 # $% = ./0 $& G. %$ &6 1 % & # & %$&/ 0 8 #$ =6 &6 1 % & G.

8$!$ "

0 8 #$ >0$#0 %.#0 G. %$ & 8 %7 %.#0 1 % & *

&6 $* >$0$& "

! 0 " #8 ! 0 %.8% * 6 !$8 & 8 #$ & $& 0 #$,$8 # . ! # *1 & F.$%"$#$ ! 0 ))( # "% 0.%' C?;< ! 0 , 8$"$6 &6 8 #$ * *= * 7 *$$ I$8 $%0 ! * 7 0 $* -$# 0 $* &7 %$" & -$# %$" & *$$ I$8 $%0 " %1 #$, 86 $% = ./0 $& G. %$ =6 &6 1 % & # & %$&/ 0 8 #$ =6 &6 1 % & G.

8$!$ "

0 8 #$ >0$#0 %.#0 G. %$ & 8 %7 %.#0 1 % & *

&6 $* >$0$& 0$6 "

! 0 "

! 0 " #8 ! %.8% 8 #$ &7 1 % & 0 #$,$8 # . 0 ,$&/ "$& F.$%"$#$ & $& 0 >$0$& >0$#0 0 8 #$ % = & .8"

, = & 0 8"7 !

0 " *$& ! %.#0 G. %$ &D #$ & B ! 0 4$*$ & #7 )?

;0 $& ! ! "

% C0 #D< $% 1 ".# "

B H &%$ ! 1 %#$= " 1 $ " $& # $& # % %&6 &6

&7 0 0 & .&" &6 ! 0 1 " ! 0 $,$8 # ". 7 ) ;B ! )<7 * 6 =

"*$ "

! 0 1 %#$= " 1 $ " $! 0 11 88 0 $%!$ % 0 # . 0 0 0 " %.!!$#$ & # .% !

& 1 ! $&/ 0

* 9$&/ 0 & >$0$& %.#0 1 $ " H18 & 0 !

# 0 11 88 0 & * 6 *$%8 " =6

&6 " 7 1 #$% F."/* & ! 0 $/0 . $& %# $&$&/ *1.$&/ 0 1 %#$= " 1 $ " * 6 = %.!!$#$ & # .% >$0$& 0 * &$&/ ! 0$% #$ &D ) 18 $& "$&/ ! #$ & B ! 0 # %0 >% 0 $ 0 =$8$6

&86

8% &%7 0 0 & 0 &% * " .&" &6

! 0 1 ! " ! 0 ! $,$8 # ". 7 )

>0 1 ,$" % !

# ! " 8 6 $& 0 !$8$&/ ! 0 %.$% 0 %$*$8 G. %$ & # * .1 = !

0$% . $&

! &" 0$% . 0 8" 0 0 8 #$ & !$8 " .&" 0 ))( # ! 0 8 1% ! 0 % .

6 1 $ "

6% ! * 0 "

" #8 ! 0 %.8 %0 88 = = 6 &" 8$*$ &" 8$ "$%*$%% "D

& ,$ > , 7 0 ./0 %1

&" %.## "

& 0 $%%. >$0 / "

0 & & 1 % & & 1 % 886 = !

0 8 #$ 87 $ $% !

.&" 0 %.#0 8 #$ % 8$ = F # "

0 / .&"

! 0 % * 0 ,$&/ = & !$8 " = 6 &" 0 1 $ & % 1 %#$= "

.&" #$ ! 0 #

8 &% G. &867 ! % $&/ %$" 0 $*1./& "

" 7 0 1 % & 1 $$ $% > " $& 0 , *%

() K 5 4 L %0 *%0 A0 0 %1 9$&/J & "

% J

A0 0 1 ' % J