Jand Singh v. State Of Punjab
!
"# $"%& '
()
$"%& '
, #-$.$ "/ ,+0123
4/
.",/
&$ ", $"%& $#&52#'
- , "#
&$ $# 6+, $"%& "#&52#'
- , ,& ", $"
&$4 & ++ #+ "2#'
- , ,& ", $"
()
4.4 "* $ &57 52##$,$ " #'
- ," 2 5"* 0 ,&. "#",
, ,
& . $# ,8 . & ' 0" #$-,# % $"., ,& *5#%+", - "'$-,$ " # ,# "## 09 ,& "# 5#%2
-$ 5,27 5,& 8&09,& ", --5.# & "# $"%& "# $"%&8- "'$-,# - ++$,,$"% " "-5"$.& 05"#
"3 ,& - ,$- 5%.: .9-& , $- 50., "-.-,2(13 ;&$" , +",$ "# . ,& -,<2 8& . = 6&8$"# $"%& 8 .
->5$,,# ,& .
",& ,,& .-5,$ "& . $#, '$,.- . % $"., &$+ 09 "# "9 .& # 8 .
" 0 # 50, ?$# # .","- ,&'"# ,20 ,&,& ",.8.","-#, 5"#%
$% 5.$+$.
"+", $ # 9 . "#, 9 $" . - -& "#$"# 5, 9+", $", 5"#% 5,&$% 5.
$+$.
"+", $ # @9 . -& ,& "-5"# "3
,&-, $92 .-5,$ "- .$.$6,&$./,& , "12
0$ $"%&-$'# .-,$" + ,$ ",& ,= 6&8$"# $"%&A= 6& "# & "# $"%&.
' $"%&$"#5%$",&05.$".. . 9 &5.6 " %.- &90$"% 9&5.6 +8 $ "#.59,& . +$"#$",-$,$. 5"* 0& ,# 920 ,& ,&+80$"%$"% 9 &5.6 09 ,5-6 0 $"% 6 %$., ,$ "
1
( 09 6$"%,&. +5"#,&0 %. B+ 5.+$.C&9 - +$"% +,& .$# 7 , 5 "#% $"%, 8 #.,& % 8 & ,&, .59 9&5.6"- .2 " 6 0 "#$ ,D$"0$#%D$",& & ,&$.
$#2 ,&9 - " 0 &"## # & "## $"#$"% ,&$. $" + ,$ $ 02
.",$" + ,$ ",
27 5,& ,& 5%& 5 " $"%&
5> E 8 ..",, ,& $-., ,$ " %$., ,$ ,&- . % $".,,& --5.#,& 5%&- "., 05+$, $"%&2 ",&0 .$. 8&$-&
+ E 8 .- ##4+ E 8 . #09
0$
$"%& - "#5-,$"%,&. -&8$,& 5, 0, $"$"%,&8 ",. "#.",,& . +, 5,,& 5%& "., 05'$"# $"%&
-&#,&. ,2 $2D$"0$#%D& ,&8& 50 -& " $"%& "%8$,& $- ,9 -&# "*$, $"%& .
" .& " $"%& 8 . * $"# $" ,& $"'.,$% ,$ ,&$.- ., 0 5,+2 ",5-60 $"%%$., ,$
1
(8 .."- +$"% +,&.$# 7 , 5 % '.$%" 8$,&,&& , -&, ., ,&,5-6&,5-6- +, & , *+ $"%&; --5.#<8 .#$'$"%,& . $#,5-6 "# & "#
$"%&; -5.#<8 ..$,,$"% ",&-
#$'. ,
#$.- .#&$.$#",$,9 , ,& --5.# "#, #,&+,& ,&8 .& '$"%.5.$-$ ",& ,,&98$"
....$ .
+- ", 0 "# .
$.#,&+ ,&$% $%&,
. -&09 F,,#$- 4 %$., , 8'2,& --5.# .#- "$#"-$",&
&$- ".",++ E "#E 8 #&. +8.$%"#09,& --5.#0.$#.8$,"... ",& #$-,$
".-, 50 -& " $"%&- "#5-,#. -& ,&,5-6 8&5 "(%5""90 %.- ", $"$"% 9&5.68- '# .,& . +89$"%5"#,&0 %. D+ 5.+$.D,&0 %.85" ## +,&,5-6 ".-, 50 -& " $"%&. ,,8 . +. 3 % +. -& + -& ,&- '#%5""90 %. 9&5.6 "
8$%&+",2,&+ $"#8 .8$%&#, 36$ % +.$" -&0 %,& +",$ "#. +. .8 .(%5""90 %.8- "',#$",
-. "#. #8$,&,&. 0 $"%$+..$ "D D "#,&. +8 , 6"$", $- ....$ "'$#++ E
+
( 8 . .
# ,,&. , ,5.8 .& "## ', "*$, $"%& H
= +8 . .
, 6"$", ....$ "'$# . $#++
5%&.$, " ,& - --5"- 8 . # . E 0 %. D+ 5.+$.D 8 .
, 6" $", $- ....$ " '$# ++ E
, ,+",. 8$,"...8- ##--5.# & "# $"%& "#*+
$"%&8 .,#--5.# .8 .,&- . ,98& "## ' , ".-, 50 -& " $"%&8& & "## ',&. +, ,&4 ,&
$- , ,$ "",&"E,# 92".-, 50 -& " $"%&,
6,&- . ,9 +,&4 ,& $- , ,$ " "# #5-#,&. + "% 8$,&,& --5.#0 ,& > 4 %$., ,27 5,& $"- +$ "-8$,& ,& '$.$ "3 ,&-,
$"#$"%$+ -$- . % $".,,& --5.#2,&98-& % .&,# "-5"$.& 05"# "3 ,&-,2, 8&$-&,&9 #$#"
, #%5$,905,- $+#,$ , , 6$"% ",$ .-5,$ " '$#"-2 ., ,+",. ,& --5.#5"# " 8- ##8&$",&9#"$# -& .-5,$ " % ,$ " $"% % $".,,&+ "# ##,&$$"" -"- &9 .
##,& ,,&9& '0" .9$+$- ,#$",&$.- ." ,&$#"-2,& --5.#E +$"#7 +*$,7 58$ *+ $"%& .
H "#?$* 975+ .
, 6 .& . H &$.?$* 975+ # .# 0 5,,&- .., $"$"%, = 6&8$"# $"%& --5.# ,& $"%0 ,&,&- 5". ,& ,$. "#5.$"%,& ",$'$#"- "- #2,& "#,$ 5#%- ##,&*5#%+", - "'$-,$ " % $".,0 ,&,& ",. "# ..# # .","- % $".,
,&+2 .+",$ "#$",& $ , ,&$.*5#%+", H& '& # "# 5". ,& ",. "# "# 5". ,& , , "#& '% ",& 5%&,&",$- # ,&$.- .
$., 2$,8 . %5#09 "# 5". ,& ",.
--5.#,& ,$" -,"
,&$"%8 .- '# +,& ....$ ,& --5.# "#,&9& '0" .9$+$- ,#$",&$.- . " -- 5", ,$ 8$,&,& $-
0$ $"%&8 ."
,.", ,,&. ,>5 ,
6 -0,8",& $- $-$ . "# & "# $"%& 5%&, & "#
$"%&8 .+ $# ,'$ %-& "12 & "# $"%&- +, +, &$.# 5%&, ,"$%&,,,& ,,$+2 $- ,98 .& #$"% " 6 "#,& ",$ $- ,98 .5"#,&$"5"- $>5 ,,& ,,$+2.
+ >5 ,
6 -0,8",& $- ,9 "#,& --5.# & "# $"%& & $- ,9% '0 ,$"%., & "# $"%& ",&+ ",$+2*+
$"%&8 . .
..$"%,& 5%&,& , -,$#, . ' & "# $"%& +,& $- $-$ . "#5"#,& .-$-5+., "-.2,& $- $-$ .
.
% '0 ,$"%., &$+ "#%$.,#,&$.- . .9 % $".,,&+ & 0 '- ",",$ "# 5". ,& ",.$.
,.5., $" 0 . - 5.,& --5.#E +$"#7 +*$,7 58$ $"%& . H8& # .#.
9,.5-& #"-& ."'0"
, 6"09,& --5.#$",&$., ,+",.5"# " .$#.
,& ,2 ,& - '9 ++ E 2 '$# 8&$-& ( 0 %. 9 &5.6 - '# +,& ....$ ,& --5.#28, 6"$", ....$ "2 8 . # 09
&$+. ".-, 50 -& " $"%&2 "# ,& $- $-$ 0.$#. "*$, $"%&50$-8$,"..& '.$%"#,&$.
) ++ &$.'9# -5+",$,. '.,&."-
0$ $"%& ,,&. ,'" ,&++ .2 .+",$ "# 0 '2& '0" # 09
&$+." -,2
0$ $"%&$.,&$"'.,$% ,$"% $- ,&$.- .
-$'#,&.-,$" + ,$ " % $".,,& --5.# "#& & #.",,& ,$" + ,$ ", &$..5$ $-.
0$ $"%& . H "#".-, 50 -& " $"%&28& 8 . ,,&' ",,$+ . H2 - ,% $- 9# .# 0 5,,&- "#5-, $"'.,$% ,$ ,&$.- .09
, "9,&$.2'",&., ,+",. H "# H - ".$.,", + ,$ $",.$".$$"%- "$#"-$",&+$"# ,&- 5,% #$"% %5$, ,& --5.# & , ,$,$ "20 ,&,&8$,"...& '59 .5 ,#,& .-5,$ "- . .., 5, 0 ''"#5$"%,&- 5. - ..E +$" ,$ H "# H2"
.5%%.,$ "& .0"%$'", ,& .-5,$ "8$,"...,& ,
0$ $"%&8 ."
,.", ,,&. , ,& ,&& #"
,-$'#,&.-,$" + ,$ #$#"
, 9 "9" 6 ,,& . , H$,&,&$. '8&+$"%'$#"- ",&$2,&."-
0$ $"%& ,,&" 6 2$2. ,$.., 0$.&# ",&$ , 8 . "E, %5# 09 "# 5". ,& ",.
--5.# ,& , ,& .-, $" + ,$ " 8 . %#9 -$'# % $"., = 6&8$"# $"%&A= 6& $"%& "# & "# $"%&H&",&8 ."
.-,$" + ,$ " % $".,*+ $"%&2,& 2- +$ "- "G
,&-,8 ."
,+ #09,& .-5,$ "&$. %5+",$. % $"#'
$#
"9 - &.-,$" + ,$ "-$'#09,&
8 . % $"., = 6&8$"# $"%& "# "# $"%&
0$ $"%&% '$" + ,$ % #$"%.-,$" + ,$ ",
27 5,& ..5-&8& ,'.-,
$" + ,$ "8 .-$'#09&$+2#5$" + ,$ "8 .%$'"% #$"%,& , 09,&
, &$..5$ $- $-.,$. 8 9."
,"-.. 9,& ,,& - . .& 5# -# .,$-,9 $" -- # "- 8$,& ,& .-, $" + ,$ -$'# ,&8$.$,8$"
,.5., $"".
+- ..2'" ,-$, .-,$" + ,$ "2"
- '9$.-,#..5-&2 ,&.$+ .
,& ,.-,$" + ,$ "8 ."
, % $".,*+ $"%&2,& 2 '$.$
"G ,&-, "
,- +$#8$,&2$."
,,&,"
"G ,&-, = .,92% #$"%.","-2$,8 . %5#09 "# 5". ,& ",.
--5.#,& , ", & "# $"%&$. " # %#.
"2 .5$"% +& , ,, -6 5$"%,&- 5. ,$ 2&.5#,8
.$ 5.& , , -6.I&& .$'-&$#"I&$.8$$. . 0# $##" "# .5$"% + 9.$. &8$ *+ $"%&$. 6$#"9 ,$", $"%&&$+.$. " #+ "*+ $"%&& . # 5%&, "# .
" & .,
6 ,,&+..5-&2.
+"$",'$80, 6"% #$"% .","- 6$"%$", - ".$# ,$ ",& . $#- ",",$ "# 5". ,& ",.
--5.#28 ,&- ".$##'$8,& ,,& "#. *5.,$-8 5#0+,$"- .,&.","- 0 ,&,& ", --5.#$.#5-# +9 ., 9 .8& .,&.","- $" .& + $",&. +
$. ## -- #$"%9
,& .
". - ## 0 '2 $"#$"% "
+$, $" ,&. .2+ $", $"$"%*5#%+", - "'$-,$ "# ,# "# # .","- '"# ,28$,&,&+ #$$- ,$ " .$"#$- ,# 0 '2,&. +
#$.+$..#