← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/506/2011dismissed

Sukhjinder Singh v. Narcotics Control Bureau, Chandigarh

2018-08-24Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri20 pages



        



 !

"#

$%&% & '()*+ "

, ' "-*

.%%//00" 1,!(!

,  !

 ", (,(2 *"

-,* ..!/ "

" 

 

 *"

3""

.%%//00" 1,!(!

,  !

 ", (,(2 *"

-,* ..!/ "

"   

0+ "

, ' "-*

.%%//00" 1,!(!

,  !

 ", (,(2 *"

-,* ..!/ "

" 5# "670 5,%(!  % %*( *, "670 5,%(!  3(0 / ' "-* 

        

   !!

"#$%$&'($%$)' "#$%$&)&$%$)'  

    !!

"#$%$&)$%$)' %%*+    

$,"  

 

 

     



   

   

  

  

) 3(0 / ' "-*2 % -  ++ .+

/  !!  

"+ !   !

     "#$%$&'($%$)'  "#$%$&)$%$)'   "#$%$&)&$%$)'  !   - *0.   *      !. *     !.  % *  1 2

- 34/     34/  

  .+

  

  )56)'  

 66)' 

-!  1

* !"

"   /

$ !!

/  

   *

 )"     /   *

 7    ,  %   -   

*



57& 

8,%*

9

   # :+  +

)-   #  !0  !

       #: -    ;

  '))''<  ) 

=   2+  :

!!

      ,  "

!   

"  > !3  

8,"9 

+

?@)7A

  

/ 

! ,  

!

  0   - !0 !- +0  !8= 

  *

 B6$BB "   ))6'  */

! - !    

 + 3$'<$$ 67'B      +  /      

  /            !/  2+ * 

," /

 :

      

   +      0   !!

      :

      4 ?@6+

 * 

,"    + +  C

!

:

!!

   C  #+  :

!!

   C  * 

% #.

2+* - #+ 2+* - !/ 

* -

! = 2+/

     /

    *

  B6$BB  "    ,  

  *

  B6

=0+"  :D! 

!! 2!  /  . 

/



   + 

  !/ 

5'' + ,0/ !   *

 B6$BB " 

/  *

& "  :



'6' +,  !

    /!0  /

  *

 B6$BB  +

 */ C -

! + +  !        *

 B6$BB !/ /      

  ,  !

+      

.   0    

    +  ,4  !  ," +

+   -  

/

++  !-   

 !   D

     /

*0.  )(-    

-  / 

 !.  &6-     

= ,<5

E  ,6  *     *   ,   /      !

*+! %



F ,  !

!  

- 1

-34/  66-  34/  

,  ," +

!  

- !!

 -/   /

   4  ?G6   

   *

&'  ,%*  

 ?@)B    )(  /        +  /   /  !

/

-  

/

=0+"  :D!

/  

   

 C4

 

    ," += 2+!

  

   

/ /  ! -

  

  / 

  /  0  0  !

!/  !-    .   / 

!. /

*

 

  /   !  - 

/    +  0  0  

/   +,  !1 2

-:

!   

/     D

!. 



!

 H=  H + /   -++ 

"     !!  *!

    # 6&  !0      -    +  "      !     +    ,  !    # B'  !0 C

! :

!!

  



= 2+

:

  0 +!!D

-

+ !+!!

    

 

/   

0  

/    H=  H   

/  /     +   0!+ 

!/   

+   0!+     

/   0

 

 -$ +$ 4 + +?@B / /  -



 

/

 

+    !  0      

   ," +! /   

      

 /

 !

   ,"  

  = ,7'

*

) "     !  -

/ !

 ," :

 ,"

!!   

/   0    / +0 - !!   !-  

/   

  



         !-          /  +@  +  !-/ + !

&+   /   0  + 

& +  +@     +!! !-    

!     + /    /   

!   /

     

!  + 

  ;

!

  



8,#":"*",#F3#?3$'(9/  @        + !   !   

 / 0  !-  !

  !   

 +0

!       /      !

 /  @    0  + !/  !- !  

!

/    !/ 2+ * 

"  ,3$'<$$67'B + / !

0

 



+/    ;

+!  !

/ !

@   

+,

  *

(<,%* 

?@5 ?@ ?@6/    

  

+

/  

 !-       !  

/ 

;+    !  

!. *   !

! /   !     ;+ !   *0.   !

! /   !

      !  

1 2

-/

!

  

   :

+      

   1  2

-   /

/  

-?@ ! :

+   

4   *

&<,%*



* 

,"

 ?@6&  / /   -+    =  2+

:

  ! / C *  %  #.

2+

* -/

 

!.  *0. *   + ))''<    /

/

  *0/

* /  

     +

?@67     65           

+  ?@B'  /

(    / /  -  

/

/ !! ! 2 2 . 2 , . 2 1 0 2 

/  !

0 C != !

*

( " +  ! @+

   +  ! @+

 -/      



))''<! /     -   + !

/  

"#"F , /% ! :

!!

 C #+  

  ?G)5

+ !   !/    H=  /    

 

-!+  6)(I   + !





+ !

 

 " 

/       *

) / 7

*

)<$ )5,%*

/   - !   !

-   

  

 @+ E=0+ "  E) C #+  :

!!

    E6  



" + !?@+ EB= 2+ :

!!

      



!  E  @+   *

66""

*0. *   





! 

+     !!/ 

$ !" "#     "

  $ %&'

  



(") 

 

* + , ,+ ,, "    $



--"

%&'

  # "

$ #  

 '* .

" $   *      $

 

%&'/ # 

< $%&'

  

#     

   

  0& /    $       

 

  

  

.**1& #

 



 

 $    

          $ %&'

   #  

  0  $2    #  



% ") 



 3     #

     #  %   #  4 =      

  !.    *   /!   -   





 !    $ !" "#                  *  "         

 

 %&'   /         $   /    # $%&'/

   #

%&'

    $ %&'

  ,,  , ,+ (" .

   $

 

 --% "/

*$*  

 

 

%&'' -5  0   -    *  /     6  *   0           3          



78/&0* 

&0   #      

    

 

** 1& #    

 

  

 $ 



 

$ 

 %&'   

* *1& (  $** &  $ #

 $ 



 % "

  3 ( 

  *  *    $      

    &

 



 $



  $ " 

# #         

  / 

0 (

 5 895 %&'59/ 

"(    

           0 :  0  &     

   "

#

   

#     #   

$" 

 

7*/ ;

'   

       4 

1 2

-!

  



  



 !    $ " "#     5 # 

 

$"  $

  * <+/  %&'  $ 



$       $<,, % =>==++<+<, >? 

%&'  

 @ 



$ %&'

*  & %&'

 

   $  $



.    # #   $



$

   #  .3  %&'

  '*$*  A    %&'

 

 $

 $   

 #

#         "#    

) <+

% 9*(/   B39C

$

 #  "##

   $     

 ,+            #            

 $   " 3   /  

 B3 &"#         

 

    

 4 :

 

  

  @+  %E       * 

%E)*0/

*  %E6#+2 ,  

    :



"  %EB*+ +. 2%!!

%E&2! * "-  !  



E   !  

!   !!

!  *

'



!  !

 !!-   !  C #+ :

!!

 E) / !! = 2+ :

!!

 EB + 

+

 

/ + !

      =0+" E  

/

= !

    



  .   !   -

  -/

  

 +



- C #+ = 2+ :

!!

 F  

!   !!

  +

!- 

/

/

=0+"  :D! 

0/

," 

 -/    

!+ -  +:

 

   -/ !!  !-

    *



B6$BB "  /     /

 !  !! 2 !*  "  /  + 

+  C:

"  :

 /-  !  - !!  //

=0+ " :D!   

/  " 

! - 

.     - B& +F  

! !

 

  =0+"   0     0  

 / /  /  

  ," !

  /

  E    / + 

 

        !!- /  /

  @+  ! +  

  =0+" E   *

(< ,%*

 

  

 

+

/      !!

+

=0+" /!! @+  !  



/   

  !  /     !  :



/

.   )''

+   -/

 '6' +    

- ," !

  @ +  ))''<  

!.  *0.  

      F    

!       !!

 *0.    *    !.    

  !

   /  0  +  

 /      +  1+ !  / / !!  !- 

," :



   

  

  

/



  

  'A))''< !. *   *0. $

/   0  +  !

!-

!

 #  *0. 

     

2+. 2,#: *

<

"  '))''<= /   0  +

 :

   6'' + -  /      

/     ! 0   C  #+    +

      

$ @+

*0. /   - .-/  / 

*+ 

+

!. =/ 2! "- 

%E& // 

!



 /  

 B))''<  )' +  +   !

 !+. 2    " !   !*

1  "     /  

 /   

       1!

* 

   +  !

 !/   6''

+

/  -   !  !

 C +

  !

) "!!   = !

*

6) "    +

   D

+. 2  !

    ! !!-  / !!/ 

 / 

-

  &B& + / !!/  +   . J

 *0. /   /  !  +   !-=  !



!  /   0  +*

< '))''<   

:

-   !

," /   !--= 2+ !/  2+  

*. =  ! 0 

/      . *0. = /   .

 !  +

 0!

= !

      ! / 

+!  

/    .-  *0.  *+ /  

"+ 

% 0   "+ 

% 0/   " !    F#!.  / /  / +  ! !!- @+  ))''<  !!/    .

$  & 

>3? 

 



    

 & 

=3C #

 



     

 & 

 

 

 

3        ,   . + !    . )  6(  

*0. /    !!/  .

$  & 

  



        #

 ) 

 

6

 (

 

 $

  

 #$

 #     #

  

 

         !   . ) ( :

. /   + !   :

. /

!! 



+.

 !/  

0    !/   !  /   / !- 

    +  !  @+    1  2

-   / !!/  .

$  & 

 3 # 

  

 (

3 # 

 

 (

3      #

  

 3    :

. /   + !    /  )B  F#

 ?@%$ %$"  .   

/

*0. / !-    /!  ,"

-      .    /   )     6(  

       

))''<E  / 

 '))''< '6'+   / 

 .  / !+ -C #+ = 2+

:

!!

 :

 /

+

:

!!

     D 

  ! 

*0. * /    !- 

 .

   

++  !-   

        /  

  + !-  !.    *      1

-/  !

    .    /  

 ! *0.  *

*0. /

B

   !+ -," !

!!  

/  

      /

 +  .

/!  4   

+

+   ," !

 *

(<,%*

  !!  !

!-   

    !

/   

 D   

/   

+

    *

(<,%*

:

 !   .

+

/

/ / /!! @+ /   

!. *    

*0.    K 

       /

 /   /

      *

 B6$BB *0. /

   

  !. /

           

     

   *     *   ,

 /      !  *+!  %



 F  /      

(&0+ +"  ,/  

+

   %E6  #+  2  ,   

   :



*

6B "  / 

*0.   :



*

< "  ," !

 +    - *0. :

 / *0.   :

 

     ) 

+



  -," !

 -    ) +

/    -.

/

 

/  

 '6'

+

& 

  @+    %E /

        '))''<  

*0.  /

 +  -   !

/ !  + *0. 

        



   *0.    *   /  !

    ! + /!0 :

 ''A&++  =  

/     ! 0   E!    - 0/-!.  /   + *0/

* %E) / !

 

+  

!

 /

  +  'A))''<

+ *0. / /   + =   /    

! 0   :



$ @+

 

," !

+ ))''< 56' + / / += / !   0  

 +. 2%!! %EB/ !. 

+  *0. 

  *0. *  +  "      2 .

2    :

 *

< "  '))''< = !

*+!  +     !!   -  

+  !!  /

    + ! / ($< 

  

 +   = /   . 

/ !  +   !- -/   ! *0. *   



   +

0   

 

 + 0/-   !!

!  . / !! -

!

 + *  !

! E  ,5B5&)''< ! 

+. 2

3    *   

  

#   *0/

*  +         / 

(    ! 0    =   !. / !

0

/--  +!   *0.

  @

+  ))''<  -   



! ! !   ! + !-     /  



 

 - !    +

   ! +   )))''<

 - +  0 /+   

     

!

 -," !

"  -  !1!

! 6))''<    *0.  . 

   =      /  /     

 /  ! -     !



 

    !

 

+  ! !!- @+  B))''<   !

/  "- 2! *   ! 0  +        !

   

 :

 /

  !  ++

 

  :



$ @+

      !

    ))''<  )6'+ +  'A))''< *   

*0/

*          )6'A6''+*  !!  L    /

*0/

* / !! -   !

* 

  0 / ;:#,5))6&)''(/  

 

 

*0.   *

6B 6)& &'( B7 B5:"

! *  *+! .=/  +

;:# *

6'):"/  

 

   !. 

! * *+!  ;:#,(( )B)''<  !+ 

!

;:# :  



/ !!  



@+  +  !/  !. / 



<

K:

  *0.  1 2

-/  

/

  *0. / !-    

+

 *

(<,%*

 @ 

 +   /

0  +  *+! /  

(&0+ + "     / 

 !. /

0  + +  !

/   

 :

  /

/  



 /

 +    *

 B6$BB " 

," !

! 

  !  

/    -  -  -  

  -   ! /

 + /  ! /   

 



 

  - =/   !-   !  

/ !!  !- 

 / 

 !-/

 -/   0 ,"     !

  ! /  

    /    +*0.  !.       

! -  !

   /    0  +   !  /    +    !

     +

+

 

  

 / !   *0.  /    /

- 

D

!.   - /   ! 

 "

D

!- !.   *    

  F  

!   !!

  +

!- 

 4   *

B,%*

! E    /  * 

," !-

7  4    *

 4   ,   *

&,%*



   

  

    / 

70 H=  H  !0 !-   !

-," !

+     

  

 -

 / 0 ,"

 +  -

+  /  *

   !

/   0

   

/  

+  ! -   

- @+    !

 /  

     !+ -

    #   ! - - ! :

  H=  H F  

!   !!

    



 ," !

 -   



  - -   /  "/   ! 

  !  " . 2/  " . 2  

0     !    0  -

 E    /  +  

 !   " /

  ! 

   -  " . 2 /        



 !

  !! -     

 " . 2 !+    !   /

/ -!.  /-      F  

!   !!

     ++

 

/    !/  2+* 

/  @+      

-    

! -

+  

 !  :



  

 

 !  +  E    / ,"

/      

5

  !  /

 /  +  /      / !!/  +   $ @+ !/ 2+ * 

++ !

  -    - !!  ! 

F  

!   !!

  +

!- 

 # &''A$/    +1 2

- ! / )'

,,4  "

-# )''A$/    +*0.  # &''A$+!.    !/

 # B'

!0 : !/  

+ + - !    -   H=  H   !,"



!



        -+

 +   /-   

! - -+

     ! -   /       

 +!  F    

!      ,"    !

      ,"  !

  + /  /  /   *

&6  ,%*

# -        +   *

&B,%*

    !

1 2

-  

 

  /

  

   /  @+  :



1 2

-

-  :

   !

!- + ! =  



    

 / !

     !

- E    /    +    ," !

!-+ ! 1 2

-     

- D

1 2

- *0. 

 

)'

  !  :

 /    

/    /

 

 

  !.    *   !         -   !!

  ! 

 

! - !

+ !

 !        

  D

 E !

    !! ! - + -     - !"    -70 H=  + 

  *0.    *      1  2

-  

 !-  

  *

)" / *

7,%*

-

!"   !=/

     ! -  

-   

  /    +

    !

 

      

 

 +

# :+  +

)-   

*0.  1 2

-   #

:+  +

'-    /! 

 +

  "

D

!-  !D!.   "#$%$&)&$ %$)' !!/ =   !   /   D  -  

 !

D

*0.  1 2

-    "#$%$&'($%$)'     "#$%$&)$%$)'     +

  / +

8% %*( *, 9

83(0 / ' "-*9

( -

( -

$%&% & $  E   0 A  M

E  #  !

M