High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/331/2012dismissed

Ranjinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2024-05-29Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill,Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat24 pages

"#$#%& '( )( * +#%!

, -#%./ #

233

,$1$ -

1%+ 2 $3%!

))

4+#

-#%./ 233

,$1$ -

1%+

2 $3%!

& 78 ( - 5 - 88 78 ( - (-( -9: , $ &

!" #$!%&" (-( -9:;

( '&%()

"*) (% )))%(&%()

+ ", -% ) ", "

"% .* +#%!

, -#%./ #

4+#

-#%./

1%!

, - "

#%$ -

# %( !, %" /01 ',, 2 ' ,

3 !- ' , +4* ' ) 356 !- , 14* 7 ) 350 !- , 14* 7 ) 36 !- , 14* 7 ) +#%!

-#%./

1%!

, - "

#%$ -

# %( !, %" /01 %

( ' , 8 2 8,

%" %%

, '9 ( "

))",: ! ( )"

%" .* ;', ),

8 -

!") ' ) ) ( ) )4 %)%((

*!2< & (=<%4!

( -(!>2% ( ) < & ( 4 < ( : ( # , )% , % ((4 )% "%

)%(( ( **,, % !2)%(( 2%

) *!2< % ,()

-( # %)" ',"

)(

) %(() - ' % " (!<5*9*//+ ( , () ( ' , ) * $' 8:(,%% % ? )

( $) %,

) , " %( ()

(( %( "(

) )) ,"

%()

! !!)%(( () (( % ( , ( < " ( %2( : & (3304!! & ( %2" ( (( (:-

%) +4'':- (64+:-(&( /4$:- 1634>#::-%2" ( /4+/:- "& ( +-41:- < & ( 14 1:- ( ( 364 ' :- " ( 03+4:- % ! 3 04$!:- < ( 334!'>-* %2 (/411-%2 (04+00:- "( 4 &-$% )( 3//4>#:- @ (345 6-.# "((/451- (/46 -%2 (/46 -)( 1435-)(6411-( (/4+01- A" ( 14++ - <( ( 14+53- 2

%) /431 - ! ( 1634 -"

! )& ( 0 4 - >2" ( 614+ 6 -

* < (3+34 '-& %) 145++ ( $B C% " (!< *9*55 * ",- /4:!$B ' " ($?* 6* 0/3 ",->2 (354 '$ <%" (!<**/01 ",:-: "&( 64 , "

)

(% %( 2 2 - ' % 2

% :(,&%% )( ) * $'8)( ' &( ( 8( , ) ( % D ,)) , ,8(%%)) , 2 2 2 ))), < " ( ( ,( 2' $B % ), %2( ( ,($

<% 2"% (( C% 2 % ( ) ), , " % ' 2( )& (=<%4! (-

-( ! >2 # )

:/6+$ +% ( ! )" ) ( % )< &(4< ( * 1: ( $ $ !: ( # )

) ),, ) : ! (! 8 -

!" ) ) (% ))

7 ) ( ( 2( ) %",% ,% ) 2 ' % " ( !<5*9*//+

, ( " ,%,%

<%,%" ( ((,%

,% $D

( ,% ),% %

( 8 " 2 ,, )?"(% % 2' %

)(D

8*)) % , ( )) ' A% & (!!#! 8 -

!" ) )" )2( ) %4 %) ( ) ( ( )% (

)",)&%"

( ","% ,& , E ,

F ) , %%

(4 &(

$ 1%) ") ,& , % () %, & , ))&! ( !!#!8-!") ( ($B )2( % A% , %)4 ( %()

)& (!!#! 8 -

!") )% ))

7 "

,% %

< " ,%,% ' " ( !<5*9*//+ % % ,

% %",% ,

( % "

,%,% ' <%,% ( ( ,%(,%

, (D

( ),% %

(8"" 2",? ,%@%%% % ' 8#!) )) "%% % (% ))' #!" % ' B % " (!<5*9*//+ ' ( 4 " % % % 2

) ( 4 " 2, "2

2, 2 , 2

2( D ) "

7 12 ( ) 2) 2 GGB

())( ((2)%"

( ) ) 1( ) 7

)2 , 2

) ) 2) 2* * <GGB*GGB< )("% 2

((//4//( ) 2 ) 2(

(() 2 GGB' ") "% 2 )

), :#!

= ) , !

(

9 ) */ '

)( ((//4//( ) 2 GGB) ((1( )) * * < *GGB *GGB< :4 () 2 ,))?())#!

)' #!" & ( =<%< &(% : ( )(

)

#% (%

) " ) 2 )) % % (% ))

#!)' #!" )% ,2( ' B

%" (!<5*9*//+ % % ( )(

) ' ' (%) 2 , )) ? ( )) ",#! ), % < " (#! )

% & (=<%4! (< &(4 < ("% %, ) %) 2( " 1 2 ( ) %& ( =<% < & ( " ))

% 1/5 01#! 2(12 ( ) % ,) ' %A "( ( %(:- 1634>#: (

> %)" "):(

" ) %( ) "%, (4*: ! ( ! 8 -

!%&") # ) 8 :(, &% % ? ) ( !% ) 3 1 !

!8> -E'' 8.) " (! % "" ( ( (" ( %( ) )( :- "( %8 ( ( (, 9 "( % #%,

( :(

%( :- <2 (4>#:- )" ) %( - 1 6+ !

H + ( 9 %% (%' 2%

8) (

(% 2( )

% (% ( %4

( ))

% # %(!, %" /01

I#!J 3564350436 43 !-, (% , ) 3 #% ( % % 7) 6 < " (7)!?* :

() %

):% )

)9 *7) ) ",: (' ),: ( )% ,,

(' )

"%0. 1 )#!!

8 -

) "% ( ? ) %2( ) ( ) ' ( , ( + ))"

/. %

A%& ( , , ( (

: %) ( ' " (!<*59*//+ D", %) , 8%

%)" !<*59*//+" (% ) 1 ' % 7) :

( 8 -

!%&") !?*:

) % )) 9 E7! 1 (( ))) ,"

%()

! !!)%(( () ( , ) ( < " ( %2 ( : & ( & (

, ' 2 % ;:(,%H ? )$) ", %

(% : 7 ( D% *7)) 8 % %&" "",)#% ( % ( " (%#% (( %)"

7 (

, ')

(%)" %)" ( %)" "#>* B<*16" (( < " (

# (9 ( ( ( : ) % (,,

(: ##) "

,))%!

! ! (

! !: ( %(( ( ), ",

! :

, %( :(,' % 7)!?*+:-%2" (

E7!?+4 ) '

% 7) !?*3 & ( #! "( (D

% ( D% "

)

: %

) % ' % 7) !?*1# %) % #'8

: : "

( !<*59*//+ !(( %" (E(5 9500-<:9+01

5 ( ) ) %) & :

: %)" %

7' ) % "

( ' % 7)!?*5) %) ')!((" ( ( !<*59* //+ (

#'8 $% % '

% 7)!?*6(

' : ( ( #>* B<*16 ",) /+/ (

9 /00+/! F) ( : %, 9 , -'

- 5 % %)

% , % + +- !- )(%)& (

", 341,

(

,("((% ""

2 )

,< &(

' - (

)' -

, ) %

) ( ' , ) %"

) 6 > %

) , (% 9 ( % % ) ( "' ) , 3 #! ))) , A% " % (

A% "%

!?*: ( ) : ) , % ) ( ,

) % ) , 3

#! , 0 8 % ) , %"))", %

( %

) 2 (,

, 2

) %"

3+ #! % , ) ,

3 #!

)!?*: ! (

,)) , ) ) ! !)%(( () ( , % ,'% %

3+ #!) )

3 #! ) / ? " (%))", %

, % 3 , D%

% D 3+ D%

" %" .* ?* ( @ ,

,A;

,"/;

$ #B1,

,, $

@# /1

@ ,,

/,#$

#%K

% 2, "

) 7 %) %

( , ) -

$ ) %( ) , ) ) "

",( ", - $ ) ,%

% 2, "

% %( 7 , ) $ )) "

",( $ ) "

) 2 ( )(",, 2 (, %( , %"

% " )) ,%) ), )) %

(

, A% , ,%) ),

(

,A% , "

% % - B 2 ,"% (

* , ), " % %**

,%"% (,

2, ) ," % ,L

D% %( %"

) % )% % , ,) , " " "

% ,%) " ), )) ,

(

,A% , "

% % - B L

, ) " )),

% .

)% % )% % %( , %"

%"( % , ) % %

"7 ",

" 2 %"* .

% ""%

( %, )

), % "% ( , , ) "%% (( % "

2, ) ( % %"*

( % " %

,*% , ))

% H

) ?*( @ ,

$ #B1,

,, $

#% 3164#"

, ))3), K D,%"

, %( , %"

% ")) (% %( %" , ) , "

% , %) " ), ))

% , %) ),

(

,A% , "

% % - B L

, ) " ))

% , %( , %"

%"% )"%

), ),H ( 7)A% % )% 3 #!% , 3+ #! % ,% ,

) %"

-%< :J"

% )-% ) -

1%+ C( 4!

-#%./;

''* - '') " 33+ #!

.* ;/ ' )

3+3 3 A%

( " 2(

< ) ( ( ))

" %( D% 3+ ,% % ( % 3+ )

% " , # %( !, %" %"

% )"% M

:N"

% )-%

.* M33+ )

%3) ,

,"% (, 3+ ) D% ),%"

D% ) % 3 " % % A% ) " ) ' % 3+ "% %"

, %"

)2(

A% ) ",

3 # %(!, %" ( "% % M + -A% ,2( ", :J"

% )-% " ,

, "

) %"

D% "

%)%"

3+ #!% " 3

) , (% ( &( % )

= : % (% (%",

%'% %")

1 8 %

%" ( &(& "%(%& % -A% , ( % ",

% 5 ? %"))", % ),

D% "

, ( & ( : % (% %"

4% %"

% 7 7)() % % , % E )

% "2 ,( %

%E %( , 2

)

)%(( )"

%%( ,) 6

) , (% )

1 #! % ' ))E7!+E7!3 "(", %" ",%) )) )" ", (

> ,(% % ""

2 0 8 % ) , (% , 2

) %'% ) , 1 #! > % %")

) %"

, ) 1 #! / < (, %(

(%)

%" )",:J"

% )-% +D , -#%./ 5$ -

,A ;

- =*< :J"

% )-%

# $ %%%&'

( && ) %%% *

+, "

- . -" '( .

/ $ %%& '

' ( %) %%*

*%, .

0 1 2 31 2

45067 $ %+

&, #$% &'( )

! ! * !)

&&',#

! #

&&&' - !

! - # # - ## #

##- ##

# ! &.' ! ! - ## ! - ##-# ## # -

.' / !

#- # -

# !!

- #

# # # # # .&' # !

! 0

- -

## .&&' ## # )

#-!

# ! ##

2# # ##

###- # ! !

- # # # !

( #

# & / /

# #

4!5-

# #- #

# #

# - !

3 4!5-

"#-* #- #-

* *! - 6)

7 +! #-

0 ! -

. 8

(1 &'

' ( ) -39 ( *) & & *

% 8 !

#-# # & "

# ! 1/(: ("

. -

%%%'

' ( +): %%% %& !"

# : %% %; "9

' ( +) &

#!!

# #- # # # #

# - - #!9 1' ! !!0 #

# - 8

: & (1

5 / ( $'

' ( *)-39 ( )

&, % 8 !

- #

- !-! # - #-

- ! 4! - # -

- -- #* !

# # ! ###

-! ) ! ; # -! !#!

!-# /- # - !

# *# &

# # -! # # -!

#* # *

# # # 88

8 99

## #- #- #

!!!#* !

' - -!8 % 8&

##!#- !

! -

( , 2

) ,

)

' 1 #!

" "

, % %" (%) ", %

(

)) ,

))E7! E7!"

( (( % )(D

( 8,

() (D

-A% , ( , %))&! (#!(D

) % !?*3&! (#! (()

,% ( %

))

), (D

( : )) E7!+E7!3"%, &!

(#!% %

' -A% , D% % !?*3&! (#! %

"% 1 #! ,

%") % A%

8 % %")

% )) )

' %7)!?*6((9 /00+/ ( ! F)(

( ' E% %)"

#>* B<*16: %% % %)" !<*5*9*//+' -A% , -% ( ,

% 35635036 3 !-

%( ( 7 % )12(

) % 2,

E %7)!?* < " ( !?*: ( !?*3&! (#! %) , "

)' 7 % "

% *7)

" "% )% " ",),) + E

, % (

", -% ? -%

, -9> )&% % " % , " ,)"

% ,"

E )% + +- !-

7 ,," , ", %% )

* % , ,) ( ) " , , /, ( )

9> !%&" -( ( 9> E7!G(

, * **GGB * %

) ) E 9> E7!G

%) % % % ,

12(

)

", 8 -

!%&")

)+ 2(

)& (=<%%, ) 3 "%-%

( ,)%(&%() %" ",)"( ,) -A% ,)%(&%() + ", -% ) % !( ,

5 - 88

(-( -9:

'( )( * )2 ? 2(4. @4 ? "