← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1387/2013dismissed

Ayodhya Parshad v. State Of Punjab

2022-12-13Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari12 pages

 

    

 





   

  !!""

#$   !

    

 

       %    & '

$( )* 

+ $ $   ,- 

$* 

./   $"

!!""

  )

, "

- 0* %$&

 

  3($/(

+!$/ 

4 5

* -   677

 8

*

  -  ,$/* .$( !

* !

/  9

 !$ ( 1" $ -  78*  * 

:%* )



 $!*

 ;

!!""

!

  / 



*



,$/ !

+!



$! * 1  

+! +

9""

*

( 

   



       !  

 "#$

%&    !    '  ! "

()    !     !     "#$

%&    !    '    * '

++    !     !     "#$

%&    !    '    * '





$!  1+

// 



 1  1+

// 

=$

(9   $! *

+! ( +*

($ "



$

( / 



!! $!  

 

  / 

+1 

>:

9( ( ?<%

 /*

( *



4

+!"

   -( /



+



!" *

/

$ ( " 

( 

 $/( 

/

@$/  (  &

1$

 @  

! $ *



1$



+*

+!"

 /

(  !  !"

9) A  $/(

/

1$

;5 @ 

")

@$/  1" /

@(@

% ( 

, /

1   /

+( ""

A9*

1$

9 + (

/ 



1$

!+*

+( ""

!"

@ /  ( & '$+

)

( & '$+ ( + +!"

+ /  /

(

-( % ( 

0!

" * 9( $ / (!

#( 3(

* 1 ( /

 ( & '$+ *

$"

( + A

$

 ( & '$+ 1 )  !!

@(@

% (

+ ""/ !$! 

 

+!"



>: /  

/ 

$    5 $ /

 /

*

: /





(  & '$+



!"

01 / ( =$

!

!!





   "

A!

! + +





4

 +!"

 /

 @

+ *

""

/ 

! 

 ++

 

 8 - 



 9 <"$ "@

1"

- *

($   ++



 5



 ( 

,$  / 

* .$( ++



-  

 7 + 

 

* $1=$ "@*

!$1"

"

 

"$

*



,$/ 9 ! / $ -  %* 9( *

!"  *

* +

" +!"

 A9*  

(

       



  $"

 !!""

 /$ $1+   

* +!$/ 

 $



/

/ +  !!



!!

  /+ 

/

/$

+!$/ 

=$ (

 

        "@*

 -

$"

/$



""/ 

9""

+ *

* 



1+ /  (*

             

    

     

4 3($/(

!! /

 1<

 

!

/ 

*

1+ +1 *

!! >:

9( ( ?<%

 / :

 ( 

$"

9""

)9

@(@

% ( *

  /

"

!+ 

1$

9 + (

/* 9(



"

!+  :



9( !

(!*



1$

8

!+*

 @*

@(@

% (   !+ *

*

( =$

!"

( & '$+ 

   -(

/

1$

@ 

""$ /

( " 1 $

 9  ( +

+!

@ A $

 / 9(

( "    -(

$

(

 ( & '$+ *

(  "

( +*

) @(@

%  *

*  @(@

% 

)

+!

@ A



$*

( & '$+ 

4

( /*

 (   +

  1"@

 "@ ! )*

1$

 /

/

 - 

$1=$

 /

/ (*

;

@ /*

)

( "

+!

""$ / ( +



1 $ *

( " 1+ 

!

++ ?< 9(

@

*

"

!< +

 / 1

/ (*



$ ""

@*

9""

1" (*

! =$

 /

/ ( 3( *



<!"

 / $// *

<

9(

 

/ 

" @ :

 

$*

($

9$" 1$

)

*

+$

*

$1&

 1 "

 1" +   *

)

+



+  ( +     

:

 $*

  "@ $  C

( /

<

 A9*

(

$// 

( 

( +  1 $"@

9 "

" /*

 ( 

+!" "@  

$

" !

   "@* <

( /*

<!

$*

 

( + >$ (+*

( *

 @(@

% (

$*

*

! 

( 

( / 9( 

!!

 "@ 1+

*

$

@ $// 

3( *

( "$

* 

$+ =$

$

/ (*

"

 +

*

!< +

@

( "

   

  :



(

( /

<

   (

)

+!

@ ?

( / +  $

*

(

$// 

 1 $"@

9

$ 1"

+

$"

"@* 9( 

 $ 1"





"$

(@

 /

/ (*

++

!< +

1+ / 

! !"

*  1+ $ " ( /"@

1" ( 3( *

$// *

 + 

@ "

+ 

( & '$+    

+!" "@ $!!

%B  :

 ( 

*

9(

1$

7

!+*



/ /

 ""

/ 01 / (*

%( #:::* > %  .$(



)

!

+

9)*

(

@*



$* 9(

! $"@ )9

( +*

* 9(+ 

* A

+!

 

1@

/ 58 @ *

*

( " @ /*

) /



@ /* $"

!"@ /

/ /



1@

($ >$

1$



!+* 9( $ /

($ 

!

+!" +

 /+ * ! )

(

( +*

$ A

($/(

) ( +*



$*

 

/ 

@ !"@ 3(

*

($/( 

)

$*

9(

( "

($

@

=$@*

!" 

+

 -$1=$ "@*

*

($*

 $1=$

4

+* 9( / /

%( #:::* > % 

9( ( 

&($// 

$ ( >

@*

(

!!" /

(

( A ! )

( " "@ /

(*

) 

$

( " 1" / A

$ (

9( ""@

(

1@*

9(

! $ 

+!

$    

  ? /+

""@ 

 "@ !)

%B *

 ( 

 $

+!

  $"*

!"@ $

 /

" @

  /*

  $"

!! $// 

%B * 9( " !$

( +

<

 1 $"@  /

!)

%B *

D

  (  $"

"@* 

%B *

!*

9



/ ( 9(

 

$+

1



/ !!

++

!< +

( " 1+ / 

"$

  +$

( "

    

  

 ! 5 - 



%B5* 

!!

 "@ $

! +1"" (+

(  ! $"@

+ 9  9(

(  ! 

 ( 





    "@* 9(

(  ! 





+!"

 1

 +!"

 

@  /

 /

( 

  ! "@

 

"@

1"

!

1+ 

%B5

1$

1

 /

/ (

1/



/

/ 

1+ / "@

1" (  "

 

# 8 !

+ +

( & '$+ * $  

%B

"/ ++1





%B !  (*  $ ( / ?<%B;

1  !

 /

$

(

++1

 

?<%B;

"

$ !@

( & '$+  7 (

!*

$

( & '$+ * 9 /

(+( /

()*

$"

$( &$   / 

 1 "$+



/  9( ( 9

+ +*

$

 

$

  @ $

$ "

+ + &$ 

%B*

( 

 







     

 

     



 

  



 

 

  

! 

   "

   

 !

  #$$

%$$ 

        

  "





  

   

       !

   &$$   #$$    ' 

      

  





( 

 

       

) *+ 





      

 

   , 

"    

 

  

! 

 

 

   

  "



   

)$$  !

   -







 

. 

 

     





 ,  

  

/      

 

 

)+  0

     

  

  %B

 ( 

) /

!

(+ ?< + *

9(+

9 1

$+*

( " * 

!"@ $

+!

$! " " " !

"*



1"  &  % - /( 6



( /

(  =$

!+

C

1+ /



" " !

"* !) =$

( ! /

)

!  *

$ " ?<%B;* =$

$

+ 

( & '$+ * $!

+( /

()*

$"

$( &$@

/ 

 1 1 "$+



/  3( *

!! 

"@

+ 

( "

$ /

$

$( &$ 

 1 "$+

9( ( $"

"@ $"

( "D +       

         

            

$  A9*

+  "/ /  !

 /

$*

($/(

 /  "* =$

( / $ /

( * =$

 *

! 

!

$*

$"

!   =$

!

1"

! + / <$ $ @

$ ( /

 

( *

1$

&$@  /

 1  *

$"$+

* 1+ /

+  ! 

/ 

$ 4  $"



( 

/$*

  * <

( /

9(

 $

( "

1$

87 @ 

/

$"

(

! 1 "

&$ 

/ ;! 



$

(

/$

9(

.

$* 

!

  =$

1   &$@

$ ! 

/ * $"

"@

/$



 + C

+  ( "

 

     % 

 

A9*

$1+   &  

&

$1+   1+

$

$+*

$1+    *

+  "/ !

$*

!

 1

  

<( 1

) 1

(

 1"   

( / $! *

!$! "@

( 

@

 

@

!

 1 $"@

( / $ /

<

%B

 

<$"!

@ 9 /(



@* 

( /

 

. !!

 !

+  1"  *

*

$+ /"@*



!

$+

!

1"

! + <$ $*

( " A9*

1

$+!

*  1+ +!" "@ + (

($/(

 !  

(+ ?< +  * !

9( ( ?<%E

 /* 9( *

+  /



$

+!

$! " " !

"* +$(

*

9 1

) /

!  

-!+

C

( 

-!+

C



" " !

"*

($ 1/

*

1"/

$*



1+ /

  *

 

(

 / 

(  )



"$  ?<%E* 

 / "$ 

(+

 

$

  

-!+

C  

1"/

( +*

$ / "" *



*

 *  -!+

C

( /

(



-!+

C

  "@

$

9 1

( " $"

)

$

 

$*

1"@

!

(+ ?< + *

 -!+

C

$

9 1

*



@ /"@ ( "*



-!+

C

+ 

9 1



$! "

$

+! 

(+ ?< +  *   1 $"@ "

$ 1 

+ /

"$ * 1+

$*

$+

 (  ! /

9(

*

1" C /

$ A9*

( /

%B *

 ( 

+  $1$

=$

@*

!! 

( + $"



=$

( / $! 

  $"*

1"@

$+* 1/

*

!)

$ $" $"

"@*



(  

-!+

C

  "@



9 1

*

(+ ?< +  *

1"/ /

$

+ 

+ 1"



+!" 

! 

$+

"@ $"

1" C /

( +*

$"

+

 /

(  <  *

/ 

( "

 

: =$*

+!$/ 



*

=$

(9 

 *

1+ *

* +!* 



,$/ * 

$

/ ! @*

1$

/ +  !!

* 

!!

   : =$*

( +

!! "*

*

 +  :

"*

($!

 *

+! ( + $

<$



,$/ *

(9  9 / ++

  ( +  !! @*

  9*

"@

<! @

! 

" +

" /

!! "

  

9

(9 ( "

 

#   $&$ '

"   # ()*+,)    )+()+-,.+/01234-+/,52+6  +,45 )+()+--+.5-(/7*+ +,45