High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/757/2010allowed

Sushila Devi v. State Of Punjab

2017-01-24Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Lok Adalat Bench - 117 pages

!"#" $%%&'(!)*!"# +',-. / 0 1,', +00 '23 /

,%0 !"#" 7-%%0- / 0, 1,', +00 '23 /

,%0 7& 897

+ 7 897

+ + 7 !"

# $$%%

& '#() (% %*(& + ,,,, + 7* -' #'&( ./0$$ '$0"'/' %

$$ %+ '.'/' %$$ %

'% +1

!' '/' % $$ % '% +1

#' )(/ 2 ( %%##/# !'.+

"!'" +1 # ( '' % ' 3( . 4 #"5 "(/

7 "8 ( 9#'

$( !' &( ./ " %%0 .$0 $'% +0$:%% +$0

: '.('/$'/%' $ 1 ' ;' (% #(#( .'.( '/$'/'</#

#' : '.('/$'/%' $ 1 ' ;' (% #(#( .'.( '/$'/'</# )(/ 2 ( : '.('/$'/%' $ 1 ' ;' (% #(#( .'.( '/$'/'</# 7# ""( "!'"$ 1# #' $$ %+ ""$ #'/$(. &( ./#'"!'"' "+ '

#1+ "=(' #"# . / .

'#/ '%1 "#"

$$"('!'

# "/$% ' &'! ) $'% ; % #' /# ) $'% . 1 .'"(%(' +1 !"

' ; !'%% . 9 '

''" 9#'

$( ("'%% 0 '

. #' / " 0'# '.# :;

9> %'" '9 '

0# %.0'# $%'"$ 1# "/ " "/$% ' &'! ) $'% ?%"'"'1 >'" 9 '

0#'% ("# "/$% ' %.0'## 8 # $ 8 +# 0 .'.#%'" '% . $.

'./( #' !

' # '1 : # ' / ?< &'! ) $'%

# # 0 .'"(%( % % # / ('. +( @ 8'%% '# !'%% . '

) % #'9 !%'''( - "#% # /# ( ' 9 '

0### 8$ '+# '1 4 '!A'# 5%8 #'$$1 ' ("# $ 7# ' 0 ' '. ' # 9 !%'

%.0'##' /'%1 #( +'. #"

.'"(%( %% #"/$% ' !'%% . '

) % ># ' 1 0# ' ' +'. # "

% '%% ##0' "##'/#9 !%'+(# ' "/

"#'/7##$" 0 '% !'%% . '

) % 0# # ( "#$$ %1'. # / ' # '% # + 1 ' 0 % %1'. ' # '% 0'# '"8%'#''.## 7#0 %'.

(/ 8 ( #'"8 ' $$ # /+ 1# /( #'/+1 .(% '0'## #%$'.("#%'8+&" " '. / ?< "/$% ' &'! ) $'% ?%"'"'1 >'" 9 '

: '.# 9> 4#' :!'.

'. >'";:>5 $( #' / ?< ; +%0 # / %'"

'#(.#" +% # ( '.##+ '0#'"#/ % 6: ?< ; 0 " %'" ' 9 '

( # '. ( :B.#)(/ 7# # $%'" $ 1 ""/$ ' +1 # "/$% ' "

/ # $% " ""(" 0# # :!'.

'. >'" $$ (.#'$% #$% "'"' ?<C;0'#

@ ""/ .' %9"

' ('=($" '.0'#.

#( ( % # ' $$ $'# .

?<C;9(// '.$'<$ $#. $# #$7#'.$'<$%' '.$'/+% %'=(/ 8D% % (/E7#:!'.

'.>'"(+"'+

$$%'"

'?< # + 1 '$($ .'. $// < /' ' " (" # 9 8 ' $' /$1 %'=( +% / 8 D% % (/E % 4+0%5 $$ '.$ "% !' //?<* +1 0'>0 %%" ''./$ $

;

0 % 8'$'!' //?<9>$ '

'"8%0'F !' //?<3$//< /' ' # + 1 0 # ! &'! ) $'% (# )(/

'"'$?<C;%## " 0#'"## + $ (" +#:!'.

'.>'"+19 (8# ! '.# $// < /' ' 0 8 ' $' "! ' $ "% # 8'$'!' //?<*> ""(

!' )(/ 2 (

#' 0 ' #' "

7#' "(/ ''/ ' //?<)?<G ?< $"'!%10$$ 7#' $ % "#0" (" //'# $"?< ?<> ?<0$$ ""( !' ('.#"('.

' ( '"%( / # # # 8$ "" %

4$'" "%#5 +%( "%( ( # #

+ "#4"##

$ 50#'"#"(% +."! +1#/ + $% "5 # (+0%% / 7# :> (" ' 0''. # '"%( / ?<C ; 0#'"# 0 #(/+ / 8 +1 ""(

!' +1 % 1 " +% ($' ) ( 9 (80' '.# 7# ""(

!'0#'%'$%'""( 1.#

"! /# $% " $"'' ' # / 0#'"# 0 "! ' $ "% % 0'# %#:> #0 'F !' //?<C ;?7#:!'.

'.>'"$$ (.#'$% #$% " "!19" /0' ('.#"( '!'.

'#:>.'$% $% "'"' $$ ?<C;* "'! $?<6/:$"*( '$ '.# 6'.'?<$9 %"'! $?<H/#'" '" 6'. ' ( ( #'%% ( > "/$%' '!'.

' # / %'' "# %% .

' # ""( 0 $$ '% '#(:%% =

.' 9#'

$( > $ ' "# %% ' # ( :%% =

.' "$' "(/%' ($#'0($$%' # ""( " $!' ( "' 7# ' '. # " ( "': ' <"%('!%1 '

+%+1 ( '% :%% =

.' "//' #"

# ( % ' 3( . 9#'

$( / 0# ' 0 ( # '' % ' 3( . "(/ 7 "8 ( 9#'

$( / 8'. "' ' "# . " (

"'#: '

% 0 / .

' %%##

""( 0#'"##1$% .('%1 "% '/ '

%7#"

#'< !' "$"(' ('.#"(!' "$"('$"(' < /' /("# 0' $ '%+%0 C

*(/' '.# '"

%>'"'!'%9$' % 9#'

$( C

9 (8# ! '.# C

&'!) $'% C

:$"*( '$ '.# 4.

' (/+

C 5 C@

9 #' &' '.# C

:'8 /&' '.# C

+% (8# ! '.# C

:*!' )(/ C

+%9 ')'# CI

$ 8)(/ # 0 C

: '.# C *(/' '.# '"

%>'"'!'%9$' % 9#'

$( 0# @ %.0'# > *& "'('. " # " (" $// < /' ' # + 1 ' $ # # $ $%'" '/ ' # 8 $% "

J $//< /' '# +" (" @ @ 7# $ '/ ' $%'" ' # %%. %1 ' ( .(% ' "8 9 # # '. /' 0

$ ' %% ( %'/+J # 0 +% '. / # /(# 45 7#0 +0'#+% "8%'.

(/ 8"/0' #' + "8#"8>'0

+!##1' "

'% . #+ "8'0 &( +%0## '%'J# #'.# % %' # "8 # %'.

( / 8 0 %'.#%1 .'. 00 / # #1' "

'% . ($ ' + "%' / ' /("% 0 '.(% ! # # .'. ($0 + "80 > '"''0 .%''.0#' ( %1'./("% '(0""#1/ 45 (%'$%+0'#+% "8 + '0$# ' "8!

1'./ "/<"/ 45 7#0 0%%'.@"/< "/$#% ' +' % .' +0'# +% "8 ' "%( (+

"&("'!

%# /# .0 $ #.

0# %#1<"$#"(/0#'"# # !'.#1 "% 9 # # "

( # ' #' "

$#1<'

( .(% '"80#'"#0 ('"'"

( #'# ' 1"( ( 9$! "$1#$//$ ?< '

. /#0'. '&(' ?<; C 9 (8# ! '.# 0# @ 0#'%

$ %'" '9 '

0 //+#$%'"$ 1 # +1 :;

9> '.# $ # "

1'. ( '=( $" '. # :!'.

'. >'" # # ! # + 1 " #'/ > (&' '.# %. 0'#

$$%'"

' ?< #1 # . # $// < /' ' " (" # + 1 # $ (" # "%# " +:>0#'"## +'F +1#'/!' //?< C &'! ) $'% "/$% ' $ $ $"('1 .

'.'./''. #' + 1 # !'.+( '#'% '.# ##' / 8'. / # $%'" ?< 9 # # # . " '#' /# '0 % ( +1#'/ '# +%%'.#'/# #0 8 ;

/ ( # #'

""( /'/# +' '. '9 !%''( '#'% 90!# ' # #' # +!'''.#9 !%''# +" '9 # # ' # ! 1 ($'"' # 0' ' 0 # !'. '%%'"' % ' 0'# #' # =( (+%'" "( # 0'0 ($$'.#(##0 "% #'%0'

(+%'""(0 %%0 $(=('#'/'#/ " < /' '0#'# ' # !'. '#' / ?<? # #' 0 +1 #'/ ' 9 !%' ' # +" ' # #0 (+'.# #0 # !'.'%%'"'% ' 0'# !' 0; ' # # $(%% ($ ' 9 (# ' # !'. #$%'"# ## % #'

I !''#9 !%'# +('! 1 %' #' ' # <"# . +( #' 0# ("

/#"(

#' C :$" *( $ '.# 6'. ' ?<$ 9#'

$( # @ "'$ %$#'" / ./%'"%/9#'

$(## "# # $% " ""(" # ' "# ' '% &'! ) $'% ' !'%% . '

) % # '$" " "'/ %. 0'# :>#"

/%1 : '.#%'" '9 '

# #0 #0 %%# '"%($" +# % +1# "(%$'J#< /' # / ( /'.$'+% 0'/ 8D% % (/E

/% % 4+0%5%1'.' #(+0%%/ # ## !%$ #'/$'0'## #%$(' +%$0 "'"% # /0'#'''

% !''. # :> / 8 # $ "% ' '"% # / '"6'.'( (#'%% (#(.#$"'

%/.9 ' # '"% %.0'##'$?<60# !:> (# "' C @9 #' &' '.# # #'!'. 6'. ' 7"#'"'

+1 '. ' 9 '"' #' " : '8 /&' '.# %'" ' '

#0#( #'9 G8#'3 :9#'

8 $"'/ '. $' '/$' ""( #'

'.# )(/ 2 ( !'7##0 '. +1 #'/ +1 #' 9 G8#' 3 : 9#'

0#'"#0# ! :'8 /&' '.#(#" 1

"' C

: '8 /&' '.# 0# @ 0 //+#$%'"$ 1# +1 : (8#0' '.# $ .

'.0# # 8$% "'#'$"# 19(# $ # ""( !' )(/

#' '.#0 +1#:> #'$"'/'. $' 0 8 9 $! !

'( "(/ "!

'"% C +% (8# ! '.# / %0'0# # 8 % $ "%/ 9*!' )(/ 8'.# /#'"6'.'( (#'%% ( # # # # (% /$'. 0'# # $ "% # 8$% "0# ' $ "%/ ' '#'"( 1 C

: *!' )(/ 0# @ 0 $ 9 %'" ' 9 '

0'# 0#/ :

'.## $' #"

$$1(0#'"### + '.$"''"$ "%!

'(=( '""'0'## '!'.

'#"

$ # /$'. %# 8 $% " ('.#$' ("#$ "%;

'"%/ ' '#'$" C +%9 ')'# #. $#%'"G' 9#'

$( # @ 0#'% # 0 $ %'" G' 9#'

$( '"'

% $#. $# # 1 # ' " : '.#%'" '9 '

## . #$% """("' !'%% . '

) % '#

'% &'!) $'% 0#' + 10 %1'. "%'"8 # $#. $# / ' .% 9 (# $ # !%$'.#.

'! $''.#$#. $### ! '< $#. $# .

'! : '.# 9 $! $#. $# ?<C;C;6 .

'!C;*C;G C I' $ 8)(/ # 0 '"#''/1' =('%!

# /'+'.$ (" 1" K

!""#$!% "& '

( ( )*$ +$ , - $ , . *$ )$ + / $ 0 / $ 1 1 '

( *$ ($ - / & , .$( 2$ ""& '

$ $

$ 1 1 .'

& L C : '.# :> #' "

$ .

'. # '!'.

' " (" +1 #'/ $!'. !

'( "(/ G '' %(+%'""($ (" $ 6'. ' ( ( ?<M 0'# # $"('!' "0 "% 7# / ""( 0 " ( "' '0#'"# %%#'"'/' '.!' " $$ '. .

' # ""( 0 $( #/ +( #1 ' # %%.

' " '.# #10'" # + %%1'!%! ' #'"

7# ""( ' % 1!' "' " # '. .(/ '

% ( "!'" " # ""( /' +!0#'"#%#/ ..'!

#1# !'% #$ $$ % C # ! # % "(% # $ ' +' .'.#(.##" 0' # #'/$(. &( ./' ( ' +%'"'(/!

'(''/'' '%%.

%'' : ' "

"'"(/ '

% !' " '" !' "#'"' ' !

'% +%G 0'0%%% # '("#

!( %'1#"# '!/(+"/$% '/!' % %'8 ' /''. # "!'"' ""( "

+ ( '

6(#//'!$% 1 '.''"

%'("#1$"

: #' "

'(!' %%'8'#"# ' /''./'. # !' " (" +1 # $"(' C *(/' '.#

% >'" 0 //+ # " 0#'"# # " (" $// < /' ' # + 1 "

'6/#' /'"

+ 8# '# ' ( ( % #+10 1 .(% '+(#"("'

%#'.+ ' 0## "

( ("# # '7#"% !' "' # .

#0'. '!%!/ ""( ' # '"' ' # /'.#'/1C 9 (8# ! '.## # &(.$//< /' '" (" # + 1 ''("'#:>9''/1'/% / %' ( /'. # / C &'! ) $'%

"/$% ' # $ .

'. " ' +'. ' #' /$%1/ %.0'##' /'%1' '.'#9 !%'0# # !

0 % ' '. 9 $ # '" '# ( %.0'# #"

%'%% !'.#( #( '('#0' "##'/+( #0 '#9 !%' # #0#''% 0# + 1 '0 %1'.## !'.%'.

(/ 8 ( #' "8 ### $ #/ #$%'"9( # %' $"(' # # # / 1 ($$%/ 1 /#$%'"'0#'"### '"% # !'0;

@ '0 # !'.'%%'"'% '0'# #' # ## 8

#' !''#'9 !%'9 ' 180% ..

1 +( # !'. +'. <"# . +0 #' '

+( '! 1 $' # '"' 7# /'! 0#'"# # $"(' 0 +%'# +1 0 1 < /''. #' 0' . $! 7#(.# # # # ' # + %%'.#'/# #0 8 ;

/ (+(## ' 1# #0 1#'%'1+0 " ' ( #' #7# /#'0' #%$#$"('' !

"'.'"

/'.#'/1C :$"*( '$ '.# 6'.'?<$9#'

$(0## %' #'.$'/ # +% %'=( 0#'"# "/$ ' 0 ( %%1 0'# '.$' )(/ 2 (:'("# '"'/' '. !' "0#'"#0(% $'(0 '!%!/# ""( ' #'"' /'.'/1C I $ 8)(/ !'0 8 #' '/1 ("# # + ' . #0 # # (% 1 +( ## ""(

#' )(/ 2 ( 8'.%'=('#(+0%%/ "/$% ' 0# ""( !'0 ( +!'. #/# !'. &(.0 0'##:'#"

# $"('# # " 0 %''.# 8'.%'=(0'#

""( #' )(/ 2 (9 '+#' "(% + 8 # / '$( /'.# # ! 8 $% " +0 #/ (%0#'"# ""( "//' /( '(

# ' 0 ( +( ' # '% # %'=( +% # !'. '. $' #' # ! /("# '.''"

" 7# '/1 C I $ 8 )(/ . $'('%%'"% '+0 !' #' )(/ 7#'./'.## !+ ''## +! #' )(/

!' ' / "/$/''. $'' !' 8'.%'=(0'# #' )(/ )(/ 2 (( &(# # #0 '. +1# !'.&(.0 . +%'# 1'%%'"'% '+0 #' )(/

!'/$ '"(% %10##' "# +.%1 ' +1C #' &'!) $'% "/$% '

/C @9 #' &' '.#' '"%1 '"'/' '. .

' # ""( # '/1 C

: '8 /&' '.#0## $ '"'$ '#'!'.

'#"

C +% (8# ! '.# C

: *!' )(/ &(# $$ +#/ %0'.

'/1 C +% 9 ' )'# #. $# #' '/1 ' "+ '! (%1 C : '.# # &( "

' ( '!'.

' ' #' "

9 "% '/ # ! 1 $ % 80% ..

'.#'"' .

!'('. '"%( /

.'.

"! /#$'# / .##$"('"

/' %1#

6'" "'"G + 1 $' !

'% +%# '" '

1+% '$' '# " C : '.# /' ' #' " < /' ' # ("# %'8

'%1 !

'% +% ' # $ / 8 #0 $"'

%/ 8' ''"

'9 # # ' $"'

% / 8 ""'. # ""( 0'#

7#'"

+ ' # #'

0#'"#0 ."! +1

!'0 ( .(% '# " 6/ # $"(' 1 ' "/ ( # # .(% '0 0'#/'.$90!("# $0 "! /#$ +1C :

'.# 7# $"(' # '% "" # ""( 0'# # '"' ./'!#'"' "(% + +%'# : "(% + +%'# ' "'%1 #

0 ( .(% '# " +1# ""( %%# "% #""%('# !' %%'8 /''.'#$"('"

+ "'"(/ '

% !' " 7# $"(' # '% ' ' !( $! "# . .

' # ""( +1 # 0 +% (+ 7# '

% ( +1 /' $$ ' % !' " 0. '$ ' % 0 "

/ ( ""%(' # "# ."( "': +%'# .

' %% ## ""( +1 ## 0 +% (+0# ' 7# &( ./ "!'"' " $ +1 # '

%(# %. #''%'

+%+ ' +1

1 ""$ " $$ % '.# $$ % %%0 7# "!'"' " %%## ""( ' ' #1

"=(' #"# . / .

'#/7#1+ %'+1 '=(' 1'#"

;

+ 7< ; + 7< '(!)*!"# &# C##$ 8'.; B; C##$ +% B;