Atma Singh And ORS. v. Punjab State Civil Supplies Corp. Ltd. And ANR.





   
 

  



       

      ! ""!  "

 # $  

   % "

 "

 %& '()*+

#, -.#  /
00 &&&&    ' &($

 $

 "    ' "! $

 $

  "

 &&&&  )   "

 

!

!"" * !!

+   

 ,- 
 .

     "

   ,-  / )   

 

  "

    ,-
&&&& 


  !!  "       * 0  "   . * 

 

"  $+

  !*+   "!

* +1-1.     !

  

* 

   !!             *   * 

   

0"" "   

"    

 

1-1  ! !



     !  !!

. ""!  



&
&



 "!+   !

* "!

* 0  

 

 

  "  

 



  
 
 


 !
"##$
  
%&'( +         

  

*  

  * 1-1      "!

*  

  !!   !

    !



 . 

 + " !

 "!  

 

  



 $"" !

!

* "!

+  !!

+  

$

  "

!  !  !* "" !

$ + $       ! 



 

$(  2    "



 (+!! "

  

  *+   "" !



       

" *  "" !! 

.  !* !"

+

!!

  +

  )        

         "!

*  "   !+!

+*  "  

  

)
*3 "4,
 (  2

 .+  + 

" !    0   "!

*  * +

  !*   

" !*$ *  +      0   "

!* 

 
5/

      "" ! !

*  "!

* $ "" !! 

&/&   *  "

  6    



+  "* "  

 . 

  

!*.  "!

*   !!* "

   6    

  * "" !!   *



*   !    "

  " *  7 

 + !!    "  

8   



$  "!

*      0+   6  !!  "

$  "  "    

!  * 

 (+

    



 "   ! .   !*    *  "!

* 

"   !     . ! 

 !

 "   + !!0 "!! !  "    +    !*  "  

*"





 $ " !  +  " "  0*  .$

 $   +



  6 !*$  +!!   .       !* " "   

    "!

*   !      

 

 !

!!       (  !!*  

!   (  " 

0

0

     .           !+    "      

0   "

9 % !   (

     !!* +  !! " !

*



&:&

  *       "!

*   .    "  *   "" !! 

!!

+

 

 "  

  + " 

!*

 (  

     

  *      "" !  6 *       !6   +    "    / . 

 

 !

+   "     !00$