High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/220/2024disposed of

Varun Saini v. Pooja Saini And ORS

2024-05-18Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan22 pages

-1IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH Date of Decision: 18.05.2024 VARUN SAINI ......PETITIONER Vs.

POOJA SAINI AND OTHERS .........RESPONDENTS

CORAM:

HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN Present:- Mr. Amar Nath Saini, Advocate, for the petitioner (through video conferencing). ***** HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN J. (ORAL) 1.

! " #

$ %!$ !&"

) * !$ !

+ ,&

$( ( - . / (0 (#( !12 3 /0 #( 45 %

)

( ,& 6!, & ( ((

& ( " 7 /0#(

& 1!, & & & ((

8&! "

90 2 5&

" #

$ % $(

-2- /0#( ! ( "& " (

( " 1!, &

((

(

2 ,& 5 +( & ( (

- &

! ;&

"( !& (

& ( (

<=& ( (" >( ), ),1: , ! ?

$ # $ ! (

- /0 #( ( 84 #@ A "B+C $ C > A "$& A

6!A

D C

+ "

25 2

5 ( .>() 8 #/ $ "

265D 6! & /0#( ( 8&!& (( " ) ( ( ($( /0#( * & 8E #@ A

E ( 2 5

$( /0#( ( & (

( # ! $( 7 /0#(

-3- & ( *0 / #(

( -

& /0#( " ( " " ) *0 ( "

( " )

$( 7 /0#( !& ( &

*0 /0#( (

! &

$( 6:

F, @@@@ @@@@ @@@@ @@@@ GDH?#DI0*$*I+$J ;:

/0#( & )

@ !

& ( F, ;S( ( - / ( (#( !1 &

@ K (1)* "(

#( !

)

" (

(2) * )

( (

! (

( ( C

( ( (!

@ ( !

"( ! ( :!( 7!( !( !

(

"!(

-4- :

7 /0#( "

( I " ) "& "

( F ;7 # K $ & " " & (

" ) ! (

"!& ( < :

#( " ( ( "

$( F, ;

" ( ( " K 5 # ( ( !

( !" ( #( &

( &

"@ " !& & (

"@ & " !&

25 (,( 2 5 " ) & ! (& ( ( " ((

2 5 -

( ,( 2 5! )

( ( 67:# *

261 :'5 "

/&"

#( ! 7'

2: 7'

5! (

"! ( ( (

(

&$( 6:

& "

; ( " < ; & ( ( <.@( (&$( 6: !

(

-5-

* ( !

& /0#( ( ! ( (

8&!

& $( /0#( !&" "

(

( ,&

( ("

F & "( ! & (

& ( (

/0#( & $( !

! :! 7!! $(

/0#( ( (

)

$( 25 "

(

( " ( ( (( $(

/0#( ; < L : /0#( ! ( ( " & "

(

( ( (! ( "

( L$( 7 /0#( ! (! (

L$( /0#( ! " ( - $(

& ( "

( $(

(

& ((

-6- $( /0#(

& (( @

$( :! 7!!

"$( /0#( & ( "& "

( " ;( < & (

>" & " &

( ("

/0#( !

(

( & (( (

8E #@ A "B +C $ C > E ( 2 5 & ( ( /0#( ! $ I(

#( I( & (& " #( ! " /0#( & "& (

( (

F, ;

* ( ! " /0 #( & "& (

( (

* & ( &

( "C !(

(( &

" ( & "

* ($( 67:# *

&& " ( & ( &

-7- ( ( ((( ( ( ( "

! $( #( (!

& " ) ! (

" !&

( ( (

* ! &

" (

( & $ I(

#( !

&F M*+I/L *I+

0 #(( 776 > /(

#( 2 (C& ( ( "

L +

# . / (

- ? (

(

$ ( ( &

( " C !

(

" (( &

( ( *

& "

(

( &

"! & &

( ( " "

! ($( 67:# *

* " ( & ( &

( (

((( ( ( " ( -

-8- / (0 (> & (

$#H)H+I.I>%H $#+/H#$I+$ / ( ( "

#(( 776 > /(

#( 2 (C& L +

# . / (

- H/#-5 ? (

N**2 7:75 (

$ ( ( &

(

" C (

" (( &

@@@@@@@@@

* ! ! ( &C

& ( 6!

" ( && ( ( &

( ( ((( ( ( ( "

> !

!C & F, @@@@@@@@@

5* @ M ( (M ( ( " !( ! ! (

"& " &&"

& (

5* & ( * &

!& "

-9- ( (" (!& ( "

)

5* & ) (

(

( ( ( " (

( ! &C ( " ( " ! (

& !

" " ( ( !

& ( (<

8E #@ A "B +C $ C > E ( 2 5( " /0#( (! & " ) !&

! ( (

* & "

& ( ( " ) /0#( ( ( ! @ ( /0#( ) & &

@ * & ( ( " ) (

/0#( (

8E #@ A "B +C $ C > E( 2 5 ( ( & ;( < ;(

<& (( /0 #( - $( /0#( ! & "8E #@

-10-

( & (( (

8&!& (( "

) ( ( ( $( #(

+ 6"8E #@ F, ;

(

*0 /0#( & ( $( 7 L$(

(

) "

( I ( "

) &!$( :!

( $( 7 /0 #( O ) ( & (

" (

(

& ( ( ) " & ( ( " ) $( /0#( ( ( ! @! ( ( !

" " (

(

& ( ! "

"( ( " ) & & $( /0#(

& ) (

-11-

( !

" ( ((

( " ) ( ) & &

@, * ! !(

C & ((

( #

! & (( " ) !$( ( ( ( <2 5

14.

/0#( ( & & ( ( $( ( $( /0#( (

( "8E #@

E( 2 8E #@ & &

$( !

: /0#(

8&!8E #@ ( $( !:! /0#(

+ (

& > $( 6':

( O (

& (

& & $( !

: /0#(

8E #@ (

$( /0#( !

& (& (" $ % ) /

) 2 5

( "

-12-

+ 8 &"

$( /0 #( (

(

" ) 8

E( 2 5!& (

$( /0#( & ("8E #@ + 7

F, ;

(

$( #( & (" $ % 8 /

PI F M * (! ! !

( " @

& / #( / ( "

( "@(

( :2 5 #( C / # !

" ( M(

M ( / #( /

# (

25 /

" &

" " ( I ( I ! (

!( 25

" &

) !& &

! ! & C& C& (

( 8&! ) &

$( #( (

-13- C (

( 8(!& ( (

) '2 5 / # (

" ( I (

( 62 5 /

'2 5

$( #( . ** #( !

$( (

( 25

!! ( ( O ( $( 72 5 &" ( N0

( O (&

( / #( !$( 72 5 (

N0 & "" (

!( 25

!! )

$( #( M * ( 8 &"

$( #( (

( * ( &! 8 &

$( #( & " ( ( ( <

* (

(

E ( 2 5

-14-

( 6: (

( (

$( 6: $( /0 #( & ( "(

E 2 8&! 8E #@ & ( (

/0#(

( ,> ( - / (0 ('! (

(

$( 25

& &" & C"

/0#( & " ( & (

" $( !

: /0 #( 8E #@

" ( #

% 265 $

*# E( 2 5! & "

8E #@ ) C ( O ( (! (& "

(( "

((! ) (

" C $( ( ( & * & ( " & & && , (

! "

C $( 6: 8E #@

( " A

E( 2 5 +

# E ( 2 5 & ! " & )

C( O ( ( (! (

-15- ! (C ) ! "

$( 6:

8&! ( ($( /0#( ( ! (!

( # E ( 2 5 & ( & ( $( /0#(

* (

$( : /0 #( ! ( "

( ( /0#(

8E #@ ( (

( /0 #(

E( 2 5 (

" $ % ) 8 /

E( 2

!8E .>( ) 8

(

#/ E 2 5 /0 #( & & & !

& ( F, ;2 5M- ( $( / #( ( ( # (

$( 6:

= 25-

) ! ( "! $ "& " $( 7 / #( =M

- (

"8E .>() 8

#/ E( 2 5

-16- /0 ( ( " (

/ #(

+ 6 F, ;6 8 ( "@

(

/ #( !& ( " (

/ #( (

F / #( (

) ( ( O ( (

! !

$( '2 5 / !'! "

& " (

$( 25

! (

! (( O ( $(

72 5

&" ( N0

( O (! &

( / #(

$ (

(( "(!$( /

#( @" ) M (M @ ( . 0**

/ !

$( '

$( 6 / #( & ) ( ( " ( !&

-17-

( & "

(

)

"! ) "( "$( 2 5 #( (( $( !

O ! $( :! ( @( " ) / #(

) & "

( " ( NN*N

( &

(

0*** <

* & #/ E ( 2 5

! & ( 8E $ A "B+C $ C > E ( 2 5!

/0#( !& (( "

) ( * " (

( ( ( $( /0#( (

( #(! & "8E .>( #/ E( 2 5! (

$( /0#( ! ) ( "

(

( /0#( * + !8E #@

/0#(

" (

"8E #@

-18-

2 5!

$( /0#( ! ( & F, ;

# & ( M(

( M! $ !

A .

$ 8 "

51$

1 !

& & F M# (

( ((! ( " (

( "& (! (

(( !

2 (! 2

5 ( C&

$ !

( ( & &

( ( M #

$( / #(

" ( * ( ! " $ A

! !

$( / #( ! ( "$(

& (

, !

( +( ( ( ( ( ( (& ( " 0*** !" "

! ( ( ( (

$( / #( (

( !

8E .>(( : /0#( & (( ( ) & ( : / #( # &

-19- &C ! (

( &

1 * view of the above, the argument raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner are not having much force.

& C /

2 5& (& "8E #@

E ( 2 5 & "

8E .>( #/ E( 2 &

$( 6:

( ( *0 / #(

" 84 . >( + ! F, ; - ! ! (

( *0 / #( ! ) @( (

( $( :, #(

"! & & + # 0C !%

! ! ) @( $( / #( !

# ! & &

&" $ $ A

! !

$( 6:

(

! &

! !

$( 6:

( *0 /

#( <

( 8E 8 > "+ >(! + C

-20- 0"

& E( 2 5!& ( "

!& ( "8E ) 8 #/ E ( 2 5

& 8E .>( ( (( $( : / #( ( 8 $( 6:

" ( ! ( "8E #@ $"

/ E ( 2 5& (

( ( " (

! ( "&

" (

6: ( ( (

$( ! &

I+ DL$*I+

* &

( ! & ((

F, 5 8E #@ A "B+C $ C > E ( 2 5 $( ( !

&!& (( " ) " ( ($( /0#(

58E #@ A

E( 2 5

$( /0#( & (

(

8E.>() 8 #/ E2 5 ( *0 / #( ( ( " C $( 6:

8E.>(

-21- ) 8

(

"8E #@ A " B +C $ C > E A

E ( 2 5 &

"8E .>( > "

/ ") Q E( 2

5 I $( $( 7 /0#( & ( *0 / #(

( 25

& $( /0#( " ( " " ) *0 (

( " )

( !

( 7 /0#( !& ( & *0 /0 #( (

! (!

$( 6:

! ( &

" 8E #@ A "B+C $ C > E A

E 2 5 ( 8E .>( ) 8 #/ E2

(( "

$( 6:

& "

" &

8&!

-225.

In view of the facts and circumstances of the present case, the order passed by the Judicial Magistrate was only granting interim maintenance and the impugned order passed by the Additional Sessions Judge in an appeal was only granting interim monetary relief of 5,000/- per month towards rent for alternate accommodation to the complainant-respondent, as such, no such order has been passed which is criminal in nature. 6.

In view of the ratio of the said decision, dated 30.11.2023, given by this Bench ),),1: , ! ?

$ #$ !

(

( "84 #@ $ C

& $

I A ''

* ( "

( ( ( ! ( (

& ( &

$( 7 /0#(

! & ( 84 #@

A "B+C $ C > 4 A

E( 2

* & !

8&!

"! & 9.

Pending miscellaneous application (s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.

May 18, 2024 (HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN) nitin JUDGE Whether Speaking Yes Whether reportable Yes