High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8449/2014allowed

M/S Malibu Estate Pvt Ltd v. Subhram & ORS

2015-02-16Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath4 pages

" # $%&'%(!)* !+ ,-,'$&.'. ./.0 ..% 1%& "&$2%'3'0.2% 4 50. ,#6 7/, " 8"8 ,

%.# ,%&%'9'*0:'. %.25..% ,% 8&3'%* 0:'. % %50. !.

8"8 , *; %'< 2 5.. 0%:.0 '9'. .2 %0% 0'.0

039 .2 '55:'. 0 $( .2 5..%

%:&$$9.=:&.$'%9!/0'.0 ! ! ..0'"&$2%'3'0'.2%,-,'$&.'. ./.0 ;2%'

.% % %%0 . %. &.< '0 '.2% '0 $'%9 ! >0'.0>> ! ..0',-,'$&.'. . /.0 '0 '.2% "&$2%'3 '0 .2% ;2%' .% % %%0.:0&.< /'%0 :& % .2 5..% 2' &$3..0 .2'..2 %.&.*.25'.

&92.'0:'%'..2'. .2('%:62'%%'0:6=%5 !- .2

66 2'% '0 :35%0 ?2='. )* ?2'. )* %:.'9 !* ?' !

- ;6 < .&'.0 =.2 .2 %& .'. '9 '.25&%* 2 '0 .%:. &%9''5%@'3'$'0 %.2('% >6 =%* .2 =%.. .'.3.* .2 5..% 2' '90 .2'. . 2'0 5&%:2'0 .2 '0 '9 %:.'9 ! ?' !

-;6 <*!A;6<..''03'&%9 ?'''0) 3'%' . .2 B.. >- .2 2'% > ?'' + 3'%' .&'.0.2%&.'. '9 '.25&%*2'0 .%:. &%9' 0 ' 00 $'%9 '?' ! +! 0'.0)!

+ .2 :0 &.* .2 5'.

2' &92. ' 0:'%'..2'..2('%=%5 '0 '9 %:.'9!?'!A3&.2;!6!+<*'9%0. $ 0 $( .2 0 0'. .2% 0 '9%3. 0'.0 + .2 %. &.* .2 0: 99 $&. .2:0&.&2'.$ %'30 '% . &$3..0 $( '%0 :& % .2 5..%.2'..2 %.&.(.2'

0'.2'$ .0%0B'3'.66:2 $&..2=.2'. $:%6B'30/'%0:& %.25..%2' &$3..0.2'..205&.$.2.2&.=.2%9'%0

6>6 . .. % .2 5%5%.( 05&. '9 %:.'9 !*?'!

-;6 <.2 %.&.*.2%50. '%:'39!- .22'%.2%*=2%'*.2:0&.* .2 5..% :'39 .2 .% '0 . =&0 $ B50..:&$$.2.2&..2'.0: .2 &. $ %:%00 ' '0 :'* $( .2 .%' &%. '0 &.3'.( 09'%9'.=2.2%.25..% =% .25%5%.(05&.%.2%50. /'%0 :&

% .2 %50. 2' &$3..0.2'..2%%%%.2%0% .2&%. $=$:'&'.&% $.2.2&.'%0

%.$:'& .2 :0 &.* .2 5'.

'% :'39 5: : 5% %3':'= .% 2'%9 '%0 :& % .2 5'%. '0 B'39 .2 %:%0 .2 :'* '3 .2 :0%0 5.2'..2%0%5'0$(.2&%.$=5'..( %%&$:'&$.2 .2&.2'$ 0=.2' 9'5 .=3.225'%.'%:'39.2%..% .2 &. 5%5%.( %:.'9 !* ?' ! -;6 < =2:2 :' $ 0:00 :'* =2:2 .2 0: :&0$%:%00$(.2&%.$= ": .2 0: :' =&0 &.3'.( '

:..20:.2.2%:'*.2% %*.2%

6 5..'=0.2.2&.'%2%$(%0%0.$ :&$$0 .9.2% '0 .2 .%' &%. &%.2% 0%:.0 . ?5 .2 %. &.* 0 $( .2 %50.* ' .2 '0 :' '0 ' . %'3 '00.' & =.2 %9'%0 . 5'09 .2 :0 &. '0 '= .2 5'%. . '0 0:.2 %.&.'&2''%'0($ %'30 '0.25'%.'%'%'0('09.2%0:

$%&'%(!)* !+ ;

8"8 , < 8