High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2698/2020allowed

Huawei Telecommunications (India) Company Private Limited v. Union Of India And Others

2020-03-06Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan11 pages

"#$!%&'(! ' ) # *% !

"# !

"#$# %&'&() %*%+(+,*)-.#&(-%/01*)&2-)3 %-'3*4#-(5,**(/%6-'3%&6+7*%./01*)&'

%)3&8&)-)-(&% %*9&(/&%6'3-.#&(-%#)*(/-(5+('&, %)3& %&0&(+& +,--.

/ #0+/ 3& 2%-) 8&)-)-( -' -,&/ '&&:-(5 ;+*'3-(5 %/&% /*)&/

8*''&/+(/&%#&1)-(< )3&(17&*=1). > % '3%).!)3&1)!?2-)33,/-(5%& +(/ %)3&*''&''7&()@&*%' AB *(/ B +%)3&%/-%&1)-(-''+53)))3&%&'8(/&()')%& +(/)3&*7+() /+&))3&8&)-)-(&% 3&'3%)-''+&*%-'-(5-'*')23&)3&%%& +(/1*(4&2-)33&,/ +(/&% #&1)-( < 2-)3+) )3& 1(/-)-(' 7&()-(&/ )3&%&-( 4&-(5

+, -,,&/C #&1)-(<-';+)&/4&,2 123+ %&0&%@*''&''7&()@&*%177&(1-(5(%* )&% )3&')/*@ 8%-,. A.23&%&%& *(@*7+() 4&17&'/+&))3&*''&''&&+(/&%)3&8%0-'-(' '+4B '&1)-(>? '&1)-(<D*(/)3&''&''-(5

-1&%-'

8-(-(.3*0-(5%&5*%/))3& *1))3*)*()-1&3*'4&&( -''+&/+(/&%'+4B'&1)-(>? '&1)-(<D-(%&'8&1) '+13 %&)+%(.)3*))3&5%*() )3&%& +(/-',-:&,@)*/0&%'&,@*

&1) )3&%&0&(+&.3&7*@. %%&*'(')4&%&1%/&/-(2%-)-(5 *(/ 2-)3 )3& 8%&0-+' *88%0*, )3& %-(1-8*, 77-''-(&% % 77-''-(&%. *' )3& 1*'& 7*@ 4&. 2-)33,/)3&%& +(/+8))3&/*)&(23-13)3&*''&''7&()-' 7*/&E 3&'&1)-(*88,-&'))3&*''&''7&()@&*%177&(1-(5(% * )&%)3&')/*@ 8%-,. AF)3&%& +(//+&+(/&%#&1)-(<D>?1*(4& 2-)33&,/)-,,*''&''7&()-'7*/&- B>-?)3&%&-'*()-1&+(/&%#&1)-(<D >?F>--?)3&''&''-(5

-1&%-' )3&8-(-()3*)%&0&(+&2+,/4& */0&%'&,@*

&1)&/-(1*'& 5%*() +(/F>---?)3&''&''-(5

-1&%3*'

)5&)8%&0-+'*88%0*, )3&%-(1-8*,77-''-(&%%77-''-(&%F *(/>-0?)3&%&*'('*%&)4&%&1%/&/-(2%-)-(5 (1*'&'23&%&)3&*40&'*-/1(/-)-('*%& +, -,,&/.#&1)-( <&782&%'2-)33,/-(5 +(/3&13&1:7&13*(-'7-'-(4+-,)-( )3&8%0-'-(-& %%&*'(')4&%&1%/&/-(2%-)-(53-'&('+%&')3*) 8-(-( )3&''&''-(5

-1&%-'4*'&/('7&7*)&%-*, 3&%&,&0*()1,*+'&' &=)%*1)'&=8,*-(-(5%&,&0*()8%0-'-('

-(*(1& -,, A*%&%&8%/+1&/4&,2 G4 %5 ! 5 4

3&8%0-'-(' '+4B'&1)-(> ? '&1)-(<D8%0-/& )3*))3&8%1&''-(5 *%&)+%('3*,,()4&(&1&''*%@.23&%&* ()-1&3*'4&&(-''+&/))3&*''&''&&+(/&%'+4B'&1)-(>?

D )3& '*-/ '&1)-( 7&(/7&() ) )3& '*-/ '+4B'&1)-( 4%+53)4@-(*(1&1). 8%0-/&')3*)2-)3&

&1) %7 *''&''7&()@&*% AB .8%1&''-(5+(/&%'&1)-(<D>?-'

)4&/(&4& %&8*''-(5 *''&''7&()%/&% (%/&%)*//%&'')3&5%-&0*(1& /&,*@-(-''+*(1&

%& +(/ -( 5&(+-(& 1*'&' 23-13 *%& %+)-(&,@ '&,&1)&/ % '1%+)-(@*''&''7&().-)-'8%8'&/)3*)8%0-'-(' '&1)-( <D> ?'3*,,1&*'&)*88,@-(%&'8&1) %&)+%(' +%(-'3&/

%*''&''7&()@&*% AB *(/(2*%/' 2&0&%.)*//%&'')3&1(1&%( %&10&%@ %&0&(+&-( /+4) +,1*'&'.-)-'8%8'&/)-('&%)*(&2'&1)-(<) 8%0-/&)3*). %)3&%&)+%(' +%(-'3&/ %*''&''7&()@&*% 177&(1-(5(%* )&%')8%-,. A23&%&%& *(@ *7+()4&17&'/+&))3&*''&''&&+(/&%'&1)-(<D>?*(/ )3&''&''-(5

-1&%-' )3&8-(-()3*)5%*() +(/ 7*@*/0&%'&,@*

&1))3&%&10&%@ %&0&(+&.3&7*@. %)3& %&*'('%&1%/&/-(2%-)-(5*(/2-)3)3&8%&0-+'*88%0*,

)3&%-(1-8*,77-''-(&%%77-''-(&%.2-)33,/)3& %& +(/+8))3&/*)&(23-13)3&*''&''7&()-'7*/&E %7)3&1,*+'&'-)-'1,&*%)3*)*7&(/7&()-(#&1)-(<D> ?

*(/-('&%)-( #&1)-(<2*')0&%B17&)3&/&,*@ +(/23&%& )3&1*'&'2&%&%+)-(&,@'&,&1)&/ %'1%+)-(@2&0&%)3&-()&%&') %&0&(+&2*'8%)&1)&/-(/+4) +,1*'&'4@-('&%)-( #&1)-(<)3*) %& +(/1*(4&2-)33&,/23&%&)3&''&''-(5

-1&%-' )3&8-(-()3*) )3&'*7&7*@*/0&%'&,@*

&1))3&%&0&(+&

< ()3&8%&'&()1*'&. %7)3&-78+5(&/%/&%*(/)3&%&1%/.-) -'&0-/&())3*))3&%&-'(%&*'(%&1%/&/ %17-(5))3&1(1,+'-()3*) 5%*() +(/-',-:&,@)*/0&%'&,@*

&1))3&%&0&(+&.*''+13)3&%/&%-'

+('+')*-(*4,& 3& *1)'*%&)3*))3&8&)-)-(&%-'&(5*5&/-()3&4+'-(&''

7*(+ *1)+%-(5*(/)%*/-(5 )&,&17(&)2%:&;+-87&()3&%&)+%(' % )3&*''&''7&()@&*%' AB *(/ B 2&%& -,&//&1,*%-(5)*=*4,& -(17& 7%&)3*( A

1%%&'*(/

1%%&'.1,*-7-(5 %& +(/

< ..H. IB*(/ H.<H.D.

IB.%&'8&1)-0&,@ )&%0*%-+'()-1&'.

%&8,@ *(/ /-%&1)-( -( < . %& +(/ *' 8&% 177+(-1*)-(+(/&%#&1)-(<D>? %)3&*''&''7&()@&*% AB 2*'

H .

H. HIB *(/ % )3& *''&''7&() @&*% B 2*'

AH. D. H.AIB( < -,&/4@)3&8&)-)-(&% % /-%&1)-()8%1&'')3&%&)+%('*(/'&&:-(5%& +(/.)3&%&'8(/&()' -,&/ 2%-))&(')*)&7&()*((&=-(5%/&%/*)&/ 2-)33,/-(5)3&%& +(/

%4)3)3&@&*%'3&8%&'&()8&)-)-(-' -,&/-78+5(-(5)3&%/&%

2-)33,/-(5 )2+,/4&%&,&0*())%&8%/+1&)3&-78+5(&/%/&%-()) G()3-'1*'&,&))&%/*)&/D *(/ 2*'

%&1&-0&/%&;+&')-(5&=8&/-)-+'8%1&''-(5 %&)+%(*(/ -''+& 'H<H% %)3& B *(/ '< DH% %)3& AB 3&%&;+&') %-''+&

%& )3&*''&''&&3*'4&&(8&%+'&/)-''&&()3*)-( 8*') &2@&*%'3+5&*//-)-(3*0&4&&(7*/&-(1,+/-(5 +82*%/*/9+')7&()'()3&-''+& )%*('

&%8%-1-(5,&*/-(5 ) %*-'-(5 3+5& /&7*(/ ( 178,&)-( '1%+)-(@

H *''&''7&()+I'<D>D? )3&1). )-' +%)3&%'&&( )3*)'1%+)-(@*''&''7&()8%1&&/-(5'-()3-'1*'& % BA. AB *(/ B *%&8%&'&(),@8&(/-(5*'( /*)&% BA%/&%+I' >D?3*'*,%&*/@4&&( %&1&-0&/ %7 )3& %*('

&% %-1-(5

-1&% 8%8'-(5 +82*%/ */9+')7&() % B . %& &%&(1& 3*'

*,%&*/@4&&(7*/&))3&#-(1&'-7-,*%-''+&'*%& -(0,0&/ -( *,, )3& )3%&& ' % 23-13 )3& '1%+)-(@ *''&''7&() *%& 8&(/-(5 *(/ )3&%&-' ,-:&,-3/ 3+5& /&7*(/4&-(5%*-'&/ %)3&'&@&*%'*'2&,, (0-&2 )3&*40& *1)'.)3&+(/&%'-5(&/-' 8-(-()3*)5%*() +(/ %)3& AB *(/ 4& %&178,&)-( '1%+)-(@*''&''7&()-',-:&,@) */0&%'&,@*

&1))3&1,,&1)-( %&0&(+&*'3+5&/&7*(/-'

,-:&,@)4&%*-'&/-( '1%+)-(@*''&''7&()'3&%& %&.-( *11%/*(1&2-)3)3&82&%'1( &%%&/+(/&%)3&8%0-'-('

'&1)-(<.)3&%& +(//+& %)3& AB *(/ B -'2-)33&,/)-,, -(*,-J*)-( '1%+)-(@*''&''7&() * )&%4)*-(-(5*88%0*, (!4,&% 77-''-(&%

(17&*=.+%5*(/*)&/ E 3&%&-'(/-'8+)&()3& *1))3*)()-1&'+(/&%#&1)-(<D>?

3*0&4&&(-''+&/ %)3&@&*%'-(;+&')-( "&*%(&/1+('&, %)3&8&)-)-(&%*%5+&/)3*))3&-78+5(&/ %/&%-'+('+')*-(*4,&*(/)3&%&*'('%&1%/&/-()3&%/&%/()'+88%) )3&8-(-()3*)5%*() +(/2+,/*/0&%'&,@*

&1))3&%&0&(+&&

+%)3&%*%5+&/)3*)*//-)-('7*/&-()3&8%&1&/-(5@&*%2&%&()'+')*-(&/

3&')*(/ )3&%&'8(/&()'-')3*)%&*'('*%&7&()-(&/-( )3&-78+5(&/%/&%

+%-(5)3&1+%'& 3&*%-(5.-)2*'8+)),&*%(&/1+('&, % )3&%&'8(/&()')3*)*8*%) %7)3& *1))3*))3&%&-',-:&,-3/ /&7*(/ 4&-(51%&*)&/.)3&%&-'(%&*'(%&1%/&/-()3&%/&%*')32)3&%& +(/ 2+,/*/0&%'&,@*

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

A 3+53)3&%&;+-%&7&()-')3*)%&*'(''3+,/4&7&()-(&/-( )3&%/&%@&)2&3&*%/%6%-(2*()#*3*@. %-(1-8*,77-''-(&%

(17&*=.3)*:8%&'&()-(1+%)*,(52-)3)3&%&1%/-(1,+/-(5)3& %&1%/ *88%0*,&'+47-)')3*)23-,&5%*()-(5*88%0*, 2-)33,/-(5 )3&%& +(/.-)-')3%+53,@'&&()3*)- )3&%&-'3-')%@ *//-)-('7*/&-( )3&&*%,-&%@&*%F23&)3&%)3&%&2+,/4&*'-7-,*%*//-)-(-()3-'@&*%%() *(/,*'),@)3&/&7*(/.- 1%&*)&/.-'3+5&%())-''+47-))&/)3*)*,,)3%&& *'8&1)'3*0&4&&(/+,@7&()-(&/-()3&-78+5(&/%/&% 3&*+)3%-)-&'23-,&-(0:-(5#&1)-(<,')'-53) )3*) 7&%&8&(/&(1@ )3&8%1&&/-(5'+(/&%#&1)-(<D>?-(-)'&, -'() &(+53)2-)33,/)3&%& +(/*/)3*)4&&()3&1*'&.)3&,*(5+*5&

8%0-'-( 2-)33,/-(5 2+,/ 3*0& 4&&( 1+13&/ /-

&%&(),@ 3& '&,&1)-( 1*'& %'1%+)-(@/&'()*+)7*)-1*,,@*7+()')2-)33,/-(5 +(/ & 3*0& 8&%+'&/ )3& %&1%/. ( %&*'(' *8*%) %7 (& 7&()-(&/-()3&%/&%*%&)3&%& 3&()& *88%0*, )3&%-(1-*, 77-''-(&%2*'*,'8&%+'&/4@+'.)3&(,@%&*'(7&()-(&/2*')3*) )3&%&2*'*(*7+()+)')*(/-(5 H1%%&'//*5*-('))3&8&)-)-(&%*(/

%)3&'*-/%&*'(.)3&%& +(/-'2-)33&,/"&*%(&/1+('&, %)3&8&)-)-(&% /-'8+)&/)3& *1)*(/'+47-))&/)3*))3&'*-//&7*(/2*''&)*'-/& &)3*) *'-)7*@.)3&8&(/&(1@ /&7*(/ H1%%&'1*(()4&*5%+(/ % 2-)33,/-(5*,7')%&

1%%&'.*'8&%#&1)-(<H.)3&/+& *7+()1+,/4&'&)

*5*-('))3&%& +(//+& ()3&*4'&(1& *(@7*)&%-*,*(/%&*'( % %7-(58-(-( )3*)%& +(/-',-:&,@)*/0&%'&,@*

&1))3&%&0&(+&2-)33,/-(51*(()4& '+')*-(&/

"&*%(&/1+('&, %)3&8&)-)-(&%%&,-&/+8(0*%-+'1-)*)-(' %&,*)-(5)#&1)-(<D> ?4+))3&'*7&2+,/3*0&(/-%&1)*88,-1*)-(-( )3&1*'&-(3*(/*')3&5%-&0*(1&-'*5*-(')%/&%+(/&%#&1)-(< 1) )2+,/4& +%)3&%8&%)-(&())()&3&%&)3*))3&%&-'(/-'8+)& %*-'&/4@)3&%&'8(/&()')3*)*'(/*)&%& +(/'*%&/+&))3&8&)-)-(&%*'

8&%177+(-1*)-( 8%1&''-(5 %&)+%(+(/&%#&1)-(<D>? &'8(/&()'3*0&()/-'8+)&/)3*)-()3&%&)+%( -,&/4@)3& 8&)-)-(&% %)3&*''&''7&()@&*% B .)3&))*,-(17&/&1,*%&/-'

7%&)3*( HH 1%%&'*(/%& 7%&)3*( D1%%&'3*'4&&( 1,*-7&/)1*(()4&,')'-53) )3*))3&%&0&(+&-'()-(*8'-)-() /&(@)3*))3&8&)-)-(&%-'%+((-(5-)'4+'-(&''.)3&%&)+%('4&-(5 -,&/*%&

*,7')7%&)3*(

1%%&'.)3&%&*%&(*%%&*%' )*=%&,*)-(5)*(@ *''&''7&()@&*%*(/)3&%& +(/-'4&-(51,*-7&/&0&%@@&*%3&%&-'( *,,&5*)-()3*))3&)*=-'()4&-(58*-/%)3&%&-'*(@-%%&5+,*%-)@-( -,-(5 )3&%&)+%(' 3&/&1-'-( 74*@-53+%)-(%-)&)-)-(<H K, #(!'% &!! !6 7 /&1-/&/ ( < -' %&,-&/ +8( ) 1()&(/ )3*) 23&%& %&;+-%&7&()' #&1)-(<*%&() +, -,,&/.)3&&=&%1-'& 82&%-'4*/ -(,*23&8&%*)-(*,8*%*5%*83 )3&9+/57&()-';+)&/4&,2 G('-/&%-(5)3&'&*'8&1)' )3&7*))&%.2&/() -(/)3*) )3& &=&%1-'& 82&%' 4@ )3& ''&''-(5

-1&% +, -,,'

%&;+-%&7&() #&1)-(< )3&1)&3*0&.(/+4).

*4+))3&&=-')&(1& )3&82&%'& -(/)3*))3&&=&%1-'&

)3&82&%'2+,/()4&9+')- -&/-()3& *1)' )3&1*'&(

)3&%&'+,).)3&%/&%'-78+5(&/-(4)3)3&8&)-)-('*%&'&) *'-/&&'+,)*(),@.)3&%&'8(/&()''3*,,%&,&*'&%& 8&)-)-(&%*%-'-(5+) )3&%&)+%( -,&/ %)3&*''&''7&() @&*% AB *(/)3&8%1&'')3&%& +(/&%#&1)-(<D>?

)3&1)4@)3&''&''-(5

-1&%3-''3*,,4&/(&*,(5 2-)3')*)+)%@-()&%&')2-)3-(*8&%-/ )3%&&2&&:' %7)3& /*)& %&1&-8) 18@ )3-'%/&%E

)3 '-/&' %&,-&/ +8( /&1-'-( &,3- -53 +%) -( >? A

D K% (4 ' (! '% !! #!7.

/&1-/&/(< &,-*(1& )3&8&)-)-(&%-')3*)%/&%+(/&%#&1)-( <2*''&)*'-/&*'(%&*'('2&%&7&()-(&/*')23@%& +(/-',-:&,@ )*/0&%'&,@*

&1))3&%&0&(+&3&%&0&(+&1()&(/')3*))3&%/&%2*''&) *'-/&*(/)3&7*))&%2*'%&7-))&/4*1:)/&1-/&)3&-''+&* %&'3 3&1()&()-( )3&%&'8(/&()')%&7-))3&7*))&%4*1:-'

() +(/2%)3*11&8)*(1&*'-()3&8%&'&()1*'&.)3&%&*%&(%&*'('&0&( -()3&%&1%/)'+88%))3& -(/-(5)3*)%& +(/2+,/*/0&%'&,@*

&1))3& %&0&(+&*(/)3&()&-(*88%0*, -,&)3*))3&%&2*'/&7*(/ H1%%&'

8&(/-(53*'4&&( +(/()5/&(+53)2-)33,/)3&%& 7%& )3*(

1%%&'0&()3&

-1-*,'8%&'&()-(+%)2&%&()-(*8'-)-( )1-)&*(@7*)&%-*,%%&*'(2-)3%&5*%/)*/0&%'&*

&1) +(/( %&0&(+&.-)2+,/4&*(&=&%1-'&-( +)-,-)@)5-0&*()3&%88%)+(-)@ (0-&2 )3&*40&.2%-)8&)-)-(-'*,,2&/3&-78+5(&/ %/&%-';+*'3&/ 3&%&'8(/&()'*%&/-%&1)&/)-''+&%& +(/ %)3& *''&''7&()@&*% AB *(/ B *,(52-)3')*)+)%@-()&%&')(),*)&% )3*(2-)3-( +%2&&:' %7%&1&-8) 1&%)- -&/18@

& %&8*%)-(5.-)-'8&%)-(&())()&)3*)-()3&8%&'&()1*'& *(/*,' %7(+74&% 1*'&'.-)-'&0-/&())3*)8%1&/+%& %%& +(/*(/ 2-)33,/-(5 +(/-' )&(4&-(5+'&/*'/&,*@-(5)*1)-1' %0*%-+'

%&*'('-(1,+/-(52-(/2/%&''-(5 1,,&1)-( %&0&(+&3&7&)3/ */8)&/-'*'3%)'-53)&/0-'-(8*%) %73*%*''7&()))3&*''&''&&.-) %&'+,)'-(8*@-(5-()&%&')()3&/&,*@&/*7+() +(/8+))-(5 +%)3&% 4+%/&(()3&&=13&;+&%)1*(()4&,')'-53) )3*))%*/&*(/177&%1& -'*,- &4,/ )3&'@')&7.- )3&&=1&''*7+()/&8'-)&/*')*=-'() %& +(/&/))3&&()%&8%&(&+%I*''&''&&. -)3*' &

&1)()3&,-;+-/-)@*(/ 4+'-(&''3&%&1*(()4&'&1(/8-(-()3*))3&%&0&(+&1,,&1)-(*(/ '&1+%-(5)3&-()&%&') )3&%&0&(+&-' 5%&*)-78%)*(1&.*))3&'*7&)-7& )3&%&0&(+&-')4&1,,&1)&/,-:&*(*8-*%-')&=)%*1)'3(&@ %74&&3-0& 2-)3+)/&')%@-(5-)('-/&%-(5)3& *1)')3*)-('8-)& )3&%&4&-(5( 9+')- -*4,& %&*'( *' 8&% 8%0-'-(' )3& ')*)+)&. @&) )3& %& +(/ 2*'

2-)33&,/ %23-13)3&8&)-)-(&%2+,/4&&()-),&/)')*)+)%@-()&%&').2& /&&7-)*88%8%-*)&) +%)3&%1('-/&%- 1')''3+,/4&-78'&/()3&

-1&%>'? >-( )3&-% 8&%'(*, 1*8*1-)@? *(/ 1('&;+&(),@ -''+& ()-1& ) %6%-(2*()#*3*@.%-(1-8*,77-''-(&% (17&*=.3)*:*(/ % -8-( &,. ''-')*() 77-''-(&% (17& *=. -%1,& <>?.

+%+5%*7)'321*+'&23@)3-''3+,/()4&/(&*(/ %)3-',-7-)&/ 8+%8'&.*/9+%()3&7*))&%) < "&))3&74&'&%0&/)3%+53)3& 1+('&, "+,--.

/ #0+$"+/+8-+*#$ /)0-/)0- *%13 . I7:

3&)3&%'8&*:-(5I%&*'(&/

&'I 3&)3&%%&8%)*4,&

&'I