High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/447/2007disposed of

Vinod Kumar Sharma v. State Of Punjab

2022-07-27Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"#$%$ &'(( )$& "*+, -.

/(0011

)-%+%

! +&2 /( %0 &"&

' 45 ( ((

! "#$%& ! '%!

! )* "#(+#,- ....

((6( 7( / " (""&! "!!

-*! !0

"!"% ( "% 1# 2% $" 3 % &%&("%%'!"

(# !)"%4*

* # &&"56 7%8 ! 9

8'%!

%''&&!"%99 #999#9 # 989#:06,#"!3"!

,%("&!

!"%+

#3 &%$"&! '% %''&&!"%9 6, "!*%'!

% ! :

# 3 !&!%%"%%"* "%*!'%

"%%'8 !% '"%'8#

; "'

(!%'

*!%''"!%%'!

"%%"* "%*!'% "% %'9*%!

5(" "$!

-*!%' "&%$"&!"%

%%'!&# !;

% !

"%!3 %''"("!

! ()"% ! 9

#& ('"( !

&&3 *"!!'%( " &%$ %' '" 3 !

6 !* %' % ! 0

* "" !&%'!

&&3 "!

&%'

(7%3!

&%* '%'"

" 9 "'(!

!#'

&!%'!

& !

%&!"%!%

!#% 9

8 %!9 *#&%* ( !<

*, ( 3% " /3(( !%3"!

7 %&"(#+

3 %! !*%!%%%*"! ! %= /

$" !!

&&)"%4* """&&(* %'

&%(%& *"'%!%'%%%'!

*%!%%%*>!

&%* (

"*!

%'%&%*"!

#3 !

! "&%'&(%!

%'(&%(% ,7 %& %'!

&%* ( !"!%! ( ! "*!!

&%* ( !*

!%' "*('>!

'!#!

& "-"%'

&%'!

&%* ( !3"!

2?6

"* (*!

$"3%%

( !

& !'%*

" %("!

3%%>!

&%* ( ! " ( *# 3 !! &! $ ( % '%*!

$"&""! !

" "$ (!

&&('!!

( &% ""&&(!

(%3"!

"*!

3 %%'%''& !

,7>!

"-3

!% % "!

(#3 3 *"& ((! ! *"&%( (( @ *"/ &% %'A%'&%* ( !;"- ! 9

!!%!

,%("&!

!"%+

'%*3 6* "

3!!%"$"(2% "!

&%!

!*!%'"- <

*, (B@,6<

*, ( ! "%*!(%3&

9 !

!*! !C !%!

%("&!

!"%#%!

"%'3 # '%* (56'%!

%''&&!"%99 #989 :06,3 &%/ "$!" !"%"!

& !

!/ 6$!" !" ''"& !%% "!% %"%(%%!

" "!%'!

"-<

*, (2 3!!%!

( &%'"&"! % "! ( !

%' %!& ( & %!%

2& (%%!

" !

'%*!

%! !%% !

!"!% %("& %"%/ &&3 !"

% 9

8D "(""!% !#!

&&''

"&(%!

!*!!

!&%& (!

,7%'( &%(% 2?6"!

"&"! "3 #%(

3 3%(!!

% !"&(&%$/ " &%'!

"&(%!

!*!# (!

%("& !!%!

"&(% ( & %!!

!3% !"&(&%$#3 3!

"!% %("& %"% % "! ( %'!

( &%'&%$3 / !

!*!%'

3"! 3 &% '! !

" "!% %"% *"& ( %&*! "&(" !

* !

%!# %''& &!"%999 9 6,3 '! &%* (!"% %' "$!" !"% %!

'%* ("!"#

(( "!!

&&3 '"("!

%!%'

( <"$""% (1"&"

( "! !#+

!"%%'&

(( "!

%!%'( <"$""% ( 1"&"

( "! !# +

# (" &% " %'

%&*!(" %!

"!%!

&&'%'&%! %$" &!"% ,/ '""!

%''&&!"% 999 9 6, @&("$(!"

%!%'"%# ( <"$""% (1"&"

( "! !#+

&%**"!!!

!%!

%!%'( "%1#2% $"% ! E8

8 '%* 3 "! 3 !! !% !

%! %' ( "!"% ("%1#2% 0

&" !%'& "!

%!#( "!"% ("% 1 %&#5 !/ %!66#2% #%$"!

! "*

&"&

'%%''&&!"%99 #999#9 :06,3 "&(% "! &&# 3 &

! &&%"(# !% # ( %!"(! &( "*!"

( <"!

&%%'"!$"&#!

%&!"%@ *"

* "@3"! !

"((%3 ,D<

*, (&%* ( !;"- %$"3"!

&&%!%'!

"&"! %!

3" %!!

%&!"%!%% * !"

&! ,D -4* #1B(! %!!%!

%&!"%!% ,D9<+"

#"& ''"&#3 %

*"&% ( (( @ *" !

&%* ( !;"- % 9

8 % "!

"-"%$ "*%!

%%'"-# %$"

"A "*"!

! B@, "&!%"

* %3"!

!%'"-" B@,; ,D< ("4* #!

"%(%"& (( @ *""-<

*, (% 9

8 '%' &!%'!

('!'%!

(%%' ((&% %"!%"-7%2 %$@ %! B@,+# *B@,+;!%B@,+;8 ,D86* " #"& %*%! 6#3 %

"%!!

"$!" !"%"!

%"!

! ,D0+ < #, %!%

#3 %

8 %' !

( & %' %&&& % " !

! &! %$" !

%!%

"* (%3"!

!"$ : D"!

%&!"%$"&%!&%&( E !

!*!%'!

&&3 &%&!"%99 ,# " 3 (( !

"&"*"

!" &"&*!

& " "

%&!"%$"&3 !!% "*! "!

(( !"% &%!"!

""%&!

(("$%($"!

* !!%''

&!!

"-3 &!"!

"3"'3

$" "(("&"!( !"%3"!

"* !%!

"(( &!"$"!"%' "3"'#

*"!3"!

$ ( % %* %3 %3"!

3 %*

*"!& "-"!% "* &%(%!"!"'&

* "*3%( &&"%!( $"&"'& A !"

(%!

'%*( !'%((%3" %"!'% !*"

!"%"!

'! " *!#( !"

(%!&%$"&! !& && *!"% %$#3 ('! "* "$

'"(!

! (

0 9 6

$ ( &%('%!

!F && &%$"&!#( ($%& !+ ('%!

!%',- " %"!

% !

&% 6 !

" & &%* ( !;"- <

* , ( 3 "(

" ,D

'(( %!!

%&!"%!%3"!

!%!

&&)"%4*

$" (! "*#!"!%! ( !

"* !

"'("&!""-" % "'

&3"!

2?623 &%@ *" !(!

('%'!

&&! !& !% " &%(%!

!!% * !"

( %"!/ % '& $"% 3"' %' !

&%* ( !;"- 3

$" "(("&"!

( !"%3"!

$ "% % &%* (

"&"%!

&&3 %%'& % '!

$" (! %* %3 %#

&& &( "!

!6%%!'"& @ (

!"%!%&%$"&" ( "(7% %

$"''*(!" ("-"% $"!

!("

&#%%'

"-""$%" !3%((!!

&! "( !%&%!

' "!%&%*"%&! %"!

& / &&%!"$ !

&%* ( !" "&%'"& 8 ,D -4* 1B (!

% %%!&( "*!%

$ "&"!! &%%% !!

%&!"%!%!

!"!

83 !3(( %!89 *#!

&%* ( !<

*, (3

$""-"% " % (%% %%="'%* "'% > !

*, (

!%( "*!

"-"

& !% "*)"%4* #!

(%3"!

%* 7

"- !% !

% "!

( 2" !!"*%"3"!

!%!

&!( !"!%!

"%%% '!

"&"! C"!($ !/ "$%($*!%'!

&&"!

" !

%$'%*!

&!!

!%!%( " &"'"& (( *"

56! '!" !!

%("&#3 3 "!% !

'' "&(%!

!*!&!"% %'!

B$"& &!

%! !

,7 %' ( &%(% (%% !

" 2?6&%$'%* " %"%#3

"=!

%("&%''"&5%*!

!*!%',D86* " #3 %

"%!!

"$!" !"%#"!&%*%!!

"$!" !"%

"%!" '

" "* !"

(* / 6$!" !" ''"&

%*%!"$!%"$%($!

&&"!

3%( !% %

"! "*!%& "&%$"&!"%/ 3 ''"&"!$"& &%((&!"!

"$!" !"%'%!

! %!

! !%'

&!"

(/ *"& ($"&"!

(&%%% ! %&( $"& 0 ,D9<+"

#"& ''"&#3 %

*"&% ( (( @ *" !

"- % 9

8 ! "$"( 2% "!

(# +

%$!

'%((%3""-"% " % !" !# $ %&# & '(

$ & ) &

& )

& + $,

%%&- $ .&#

/0&!& -" - $ .&1 $

(

& + $,

: 23 * 2 !# $

& &

& + $,

!"-7% 3 &( "* ( !"* %'@ *"

!"% 3 %'%"-"7%!%93

(!'%"-7%2'!

'!@ %!' &!%'

'%!

(%('!"%' ((3 "-7%3 &( "$% ,D (" 4* # "& ( ''"&# "$"( 2% "!

(# +

% %!' &!"!&!3"!

!% "-7%%& "%'@ @ *"

!"%%'!

"-/ !%'

"-7%#3 3 '%!%"$% 3 % &( (!!

"!!"%%'!

&&3 !%& %'

&%* ( ! : D"!

!%!

&%!!"% "( &%('%

"%&%%% !"%!%!

!*!%'!

&%* ( !;"- "!"%! '!%( % "%(!!"*%# "%!'( '"!%'%!"$!%!

&&#6 *%!

"&("!% && !!

" *!%%% !"%" (%' & %!C"*!%'( 3/ %(!!"*%%' "-3"!&

"((" %#"'"!" "&%'"&6! #!

%("!

!*!%'!

&%* ( !3"!

!%!

"&"!"'% !%("

( 3%!

%' && !

&6%%! %!% "& !

* &%' &%%% !"%%%! ''&!!

E *"!%'!

%&!"%& E A &%('%!

"%*"& ($"&!%!

''&!!

!"-"'%%!

%%'!

&%* ( !;"-3 %!%("'/ '%#% %''&&!"%9 6,""&(%6 %!%' &

&%!!"%#

'!%-*!

! " # $

% & '()

*+,-./0

2%3$#6%%!'"*('" *!3"!

( &%('%!

!"!

! / %!"!%!

"!!"% %'!

!%'"- &! (("'("&!* %! &""$'

&!%"&%&(" !%3 !

& &!%'!

&( "!&%* 3"!

"*"& "'%'&!"%9 %%!6'"!!

%$%!

!"!!"%%'!

!3 !%& *%'$"&!"*#!

"( !* &%$"&!'%!

%''&&!"%9 6,# % !

$"&!"*;"! $"&!"* *" ! %!

$ '' $

& !& % "%/ &""'

&!%""!!"%%'!

&& 2'%*!

&%#"!&%*%!!

&&!"!%! ( ! &%* ( !;"- ""!"

(( 3"!

,7 3 !

&%* ( !*

!%' "*('#!

& "-"!% "*%

&3"!

3 %"2?6 %'!

$"'%!%"$%" !3"!

' &!%'!

% / !%'!

!"-&( (!!

"!!"%%'!

&&!% %'!

"- / '%#6%%!'" "(( ("! "( "!"!

-*! !

( !"

(%! "!" %

% " &"

!"%%'$"& &%&!"! !

!"% %'( 3 / %&!"%

&&'(( %$"!& "!!

&& %

%3 %' % ( %! 3 " !( &%$"&!'%!

%''&&!"%9 6, / !"

(%!

!&!

&&!%%'"$ %'"%%"* "%*! !% '"%'8#

; "

(!%' *!%''"# 3 '!

!&!%%"%% "* "%*!'% "%%'!

*%!

9 A &%('%!

&%!

!%3!

!" %! >

%!!

& %%( %"& "(> " %% %3% " "(3 "%( 3" %' !

*"(>

( % !%!

( "* "%*!%' #9*%!

'%# !&%'!

&&&!

(( #( !

!&%(

! !

&!% &!"'"& !#!

&&""$%($" %!

& "56 7%9 !E 8#&!"%98#9 9#8 E#8 0#96,# "!3"!

,%("&!

!"%+

/ '%# "

"! ( &"*"

%'"!"$!% "* 8 '! "!

"$ (&%!!"%#6'"!

!& %'"* "%*! !%!

! %(&!%%* @!!&%""!

&! &"&*!

&@ ( "( &%('%!

"&"!

( & %!

*%!

/ '%#!

"%%"* "%*!%''"$ !%!

!"&!%"%%"* "%*!'% / *%!%''"!%!

!%'8#

;"* %" !

& 0 D"!

& *%"'"& !"%"!

!& !#!

( !

" %%' &&%"( 7& "!"* !"%!!% "'1"&"

( "! !# 2% 3"!

"&!"%!% & 3 !"!*%'!

" -*! % !

! !

(( ! F &%$"&! " * !% % !

!& !% "*$"!

"-*! '!&!"!

"% %'"* "%*! ( % "*"!

"&!

* " (!

" %%'3"!

*%"'"& !"%# *"&(( % ("& !"%#"' #!

" %%' &&%"( ((

(( -$2 !

"; % G;7% !

( G;7%