High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/44/2012allowed

Upkar Hans @ Vicky v. State Of Punjab

2018-10-30Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"!# $ %%%& '

"& ( )''& *(+, %%%& &'

+!-.(/ 01(# $ %%%& '

"& ( )''& *(+, %%%& &'

&& 02! %%%& '

"& ( )''& *(+, %%%& &'

!"#$#%&'&()**+

) ,-

* .** ,-

* .*.* * &&'3 %4%)%5(56- #'& %)'/5(56- #'&

'5&& '!

% %.

!5)!758 6- #'&

'5&& '!

% %2( /&&')!756- #'&

'5&& '!

% % ( !'' 6- #'&/!#(( !& !

% %9%*%)% ,!6!'! - #'&2&& 6 *(+,% ::::

*.* /* "!&'5!+(7/&'68& &' ! & '5 && & !%&% ! &,$ ! "!# $6

! &,$+!-.(/ 01(# $

! &,$&& 02!6 ##(&685 8& & '

!& # -!#'& ,$ '5& ( ' & & !'! )&! ;(7&6 5! (

'5&

&#&(& )&#'! 9*6 85& &'5&!

# ##(&)($8#<(!''&6 -!&!/(7& +(7/&''& %

-!& & '5&!-& $'&6 '5&$ !"!# $6+!-.(/ 01(# $&&

02!8& &&'&#& 83

#(%#0($#1.#%"&( .#("#(%#2!1$#$ )&#'! 9* 9/ ! /&'

&' $

!& % =6

> &#5 ! & ( ''5& 6' ( '5& (&

!7 ( !/ ! /&'

& ! '8 $& % 45&##(&# -!#'685 && ',&

&'5!

( '6 $'5''5&!

& ,&##&'&6'5&!/(7&+(7/&'

'5&!

# -!#'! & &'&#&,&&'!&'5&$,& #<(!''& '5&#5 7&

/&7!''5&/% !& $ ''&6 '5& #' '5& #& & '5& &#('! '

$ &'5' '5&!'& -&!7!75'

%?%

6 & & $# ( &/& $2( /! )!75/ +!'.( 8 /( & &''5&!

&!&#&!'5& & & 2( (8 4!,, )5!,6 5! ( &-& '!# &8& &' &

/'5&!

5 (&% % '/ .( 8!

& 5!& )!75 !-!7 ! '5&!

&!75, ( 5 !

/&'5&# / !' ,!

)!758

!7 !2( (8 4!,,)5!6 5! (

%?%

! '5&/ !7 ,!

)!75!'( 7 '5!''&/&' &# & 8!'5 )9 )( 58!& )!75

/ * !#& )''! & 4 86

5! ( 6 85 7 8!'5 '5& !#&

!#! 7&''!7 !

/'! &7 !7'5&!#!&'5 &#5&'5& '%'5& ,! ''&/&' # / !' ,!

)!756

/ @98

&# &%45&!-&'!7'! !'5!#&'

#&%&)( !&

.(/ 6(!#! //!! & 6 &!&' *( 5!

6 5! (

# '#'&'5& !#&!

/&'5'(!5.(/ 6 0 "!# $6 +!- .(/ 0 )($6 && )($ 5 #5& 5!/ # &!7 '5&!

!- -&/&' ! '5& !#!&'% ##(&(!5.(/ 6 0"!# $6+!-.(/ && 8& &

&'&!'5!#&% %%

?6##(&+!-.(/ 01(# $85! &! !#&#(' $5(

&!# ( &''&/&'!( (#& '5& 7 ' &# -& &7 # &'

/5! &!&'! 5 (&6 85!#58' &!' !#& &! % ##(& 0"!# $ /&''&/&'

(& )&#'! '5&A-!&#&#'' '5& !#&!( (#& '5& 7 '7 !7 &# -& &

/ /!

5!5!5 (&685!#5 8&!B&,$'5& !#&685& & %=%

?##(&(!5 .(/ 57 ' &# -& & &/ '

#$# &11A'& ,& !7 C %* ?

?685!#58' &!' &! ,$'5& !#& '$% %=%

?##(&(!5.(/ 0&5 /&''&/&'(& )&#'! '5&A-!&#&#',&

&'5& 9-&'!7'!7

!#& 7 ' &# -& & ' 78!'5'5 && ('& !7 & /!'!

'8 ('& !7 '5& & /!'! &685!#58& &&!B&,$'5& !#&% '& # / &'! !-&'!7'! '5&

/ !'!&6 #5 7!'##(&(!5.(/ 6 0"!# $6 +!-.(/ && 8 & & ! &!'5& ( '% '&

= # //!'/&' #&&!76 '5& #& 8 !7& ' !'! )&! ;(7&6 5! ( 685

/ #5 7&

&#& (& )&#'! D9*7!''5&##(&6' 85!#56'5&$ && '7(! '$# !/&'

! % ( !7'5& #&&!7(!5.(/ 8 (' ,& +(-&! & 5& 8

8 & ' ;(-&! & ;('!#& 6

5! (

,&!7'

!&+(-&! &%)( &/&' $#5 8

! &7!'##(&)($.(/ '5&/&&#5 7&

'5&

&#&(& )&#'! 6D9*8

/&##(& 6+!-.(/ 6)($.(/ && % ( !7 '5& # ( & !' &-!&#&6 '5& &#('! &E/!&/$&-&'&&8!'&&!%&%*F /)!756 (75'/6*F *8.(/ 6*F 578'1 6*F %;8!& )!756*F=)( !& .(/ 6*F'/.( 6*F "!+$)!756*F? +.(/ 6*FD /6*F

)9 4 &/)!756*F

.( 8')!756*F

)!756*F

&5.(/ 6*F )9! .(/ 6*F )9! 5 '6 *F = C!

/ )!756*F )9 &-)!75*F 9&#'

)( 58!& )!75% F!'5'5''5& &#('! &-!&#&' # &% )''&/&' ##(&8& & &# &(& )&#'! %*%%6!85!#5 '5&!# !/!'!7#!

#(/'#&& !7 7!' (#5 ##(& 8& & (' ' '5&/ ,(' '5&$ &!& '5& &7'! # '&!7'5''5&$8& &! #&'5,&& & $

!- -&!'5!#&% ##(&! ' &$&-!&#&!'5&!

& &#&% '& 5& !7 7(/&'6 & &'

! ( '# -!#'& &'&#&'5&##(& 0"!# $6+!-.(/ && .(/ /&'! & ( 6 85& & #<(!''&##(& )($.(/ 685!#5 & '##(& 6+!-.(/ && .(/ 77 !&-&'5&$5-& ! &'5& &&'& $!7'5''5&/&,&##&'&6'5&!/(7&+(7/&' '5&!

# -!#'! &'&#&,&&'!&'5&$,&#<(!''& '5& #5 7&

/&7!''5&/% F&5-&5& & &# (&

'5& '!&,&!& 7 !7'5 (75'5& &# 8& !'5''5&!/(7&+(7/&'

# -!#'! & &'&#&&,$'5&'

! ( ' & '

('!, & &, (' ,&&'!&

'5& 8!7 & 3 9'5' ,& &'!/!'5''5& &! &$&8!'&

'5& ##(

&#&'5&&'!

&#&!,&( #!

#(/''! &-!&#&% 45& 8 ! 8& &'' & '5' ! #& &' ( #!

#(/''! &-!&#&6 '5& '5& #5! '5& &-&' /(' ,& # / &'&!

$-!' ! !'5&#5!!/!!76'5&'5'

# ' &'

#& '5& &#('! ,&$ 5 8

& , & (,'% 9'5&!''#&6'5&/ '!/ ''8!'&

'5& &#('! 8*F=)( !& .(/ ,&

&85 /6'5&##(& 5 &7& $ /& &E'

+(!#! # &! % 8&-& 6 (#5

8!'&6/& $6*F=)( !& .(/ ! '' &'5& !& '5& &#('! '5& ''& '5' ! '5& $&

6 5& 8 (!#! //!! & (!#! //!''&&6 5! ( 5 8&-& 65& & ' 8(!5.(/ 6 0"!# $6 +!-.(/ 01(# $6&& 02!)($'5''5&$ &-& #/&' 5!/ # &&$7(! ',&

&5!/% &8 &# &5 '! &8!'&''5&!'#& '5&*(, !#* &#('

*(, !#* &#('

8& /!''&' ('<(&'! ' 5!/!'5&

/ # &E/!'! ,(' &7'5$# &E/!'! ,$'5& *(, !#* &#('

! &' 7&'$ & $

/5!/ ('5685!#5 /!75'5-&,&& - ( , &' '5& &#('! %45(*F=)( !&

.(/ '( '!7'5& &#('! '

$7!-&&-& &+ ''

'5& &#('! #&% &7 &-!&#&!'5&

/ &# -& $ '!# &

/ &! '5&##(&67!'5'&-!&#&# ',&' & !# !/!'!77!''5&##(&

'5& & '5''5& &!

'5!7' 5 8'5' '!# & &# -& &8& &! #',& 7!7'

'5&&#&&5,&&' &8$,$'5&##(&( !7'5& !#!&'% C &

/ '5& /! $ '5& &#&& $ #<(!'#&

!&'( &(' !&'!

$'5& '!# & &# -& &

/'5&##(&' ,&'5&/& &685!#55,&&' &8$

/'5&5 (& &#&&( !7'5&!#!&'%45&

&6(#5 '!# &# ',&' &' ,&' & '!# &'5& &#('! ,&!7 (, & ' # &#' '5 & '!# & 8!'5 '5& &#&&6 '5&

? &! '5& ,$ '5& ##(&6 &-& !

-&6 & '

# '!'('& $ !# !/!'!7 &-!&#& 7!' '5& ##(&% 45&

&/!!7 &-!&#& (#& ,$ '5& &#('! ! $

, '!-&'$&% *F /)!756 (75'/5+(' & &# & !'& '5& ' %%

?% *F *8 .(/ 5 5 8 !7 #& ,&!7 #<(!'&8!'5##(&(!5.(/ 0&55& !& % &8 &# &5 '! &8!'& ''5& !'#& !'! *(, !# * &#('

% *F 578' 1 5&& ' ,&

/ 8!'&685 5'&& &!&-!&#&5!

!-!'AE%*% *F %;8!& )!75 5 -!& '5& /&!# &-!&#&& !7'5'

%?%

85! & '&'!-! !' 6

5! ( 65&5# (#'& '/ '&/&E/!'! '5& & , $ / +!' .( % & ''& '5' 5& 5 ( & # '(! ?E=#/ 5& !75'#5&& % & ( '5& ''&'5' '5& /&'&65&5 # (#'& '/ '&/&E/!'! '5& &, $ 2( /! )!75% & ( '5& ''&'5' !7'( &/'& ! 8!'5 '8 #( '!& ( '5& (& 5 &# ( '

-& & $8 &&' '5&&, $ 2( /! )!75! , '5'5&#&65&''&'5'!5! !! '5&#(& &'58 5$E! (& ' '

7( '! 6 85!#5 8 '&/ '&/ (

!#!&'' #(&&'5!'5& ! $# ( & '( &%

D 45& '&'!/ $ *F= )( !& .(/ 5 ,&& !#(&, -&% *F '/ .( !-!7 ! &!75, ( 5 '5& &#&&+('''&'5'

%?%

', ('?>D3

%/%!'5& / !765&8&'' '5&5 (& '5&&#&& ('5', '5

'5&/8& & $!7&'5&5&8&'' 2( (8 )5!, !

/& ,!

)!75)&8 '5& ,!

)!75. /+!'

)!75#/&' '5&5 (& '5&&#&&!

/&'5&/''& '

'5& !#&% '&'!/ $! 5-!7/(#5 & &-#& '

&'& /!&'5&7(! ' '5&##(&% *F)9"!+$)!75685 8/&/,& '5& !#& '$5&&,$)9! .(/ ,&

&85 /##(&+!-.(/

0 1(# $6 0 "!# $ && 5 (

& !# ( &''&/&'7 ''5& '!# & &# -& && &!'5'

&7 % & ( '5& & &'5' %=%

?6##(&(!5 .(/ 0&55 (

&!# ( &''&/&'7 '

' &# -& &

/5! &!&'! 5 (&685!#5 5,&&' &!' &! % *F? +.(/ 6*5 ' 7 5& & & &7 !7 ' !7 5 ' 7 5

/'5& '

%?%

'5& & '&

5!7 -& (#55 ' 7 5' '5&9-&'!7'!7

!#& % *FD / *F

)9 4 &/ )!75 5&&' ,&/ & &

/ 8!'&&% *F

.( 8')!75''&'5'

%?%

', ('

3 >

%/%65&5 &#&!-&'& &5 !#/&7&, ('&'5

2( /! )!75/ +!'.( 5&8&'' '5&5 (& '5& &#&&6!&'!

!&'5&!

&, !&5!7&'5&!<(&'

& '% *F

)!75& & &7 !75! & '!7'5& /''& ' '5& !#&% *F &5.(/ 685 57 &' '5& #&

##(

&#&!# &#'! 8!'5!-&'!7'! '5&#&6!/! $ *F )9! .(/ 685 5#

!& ('!-&'!7'! !'5!

#& ' $6& &!'5' &7 % )!/! $6 '5& &/!!7 8!'&& &E/!& ,$ '5& &#('! & '5& !'!-#!7!'#&% 45&'

! ( '# & $ & !&

!# /!7' '5& # # (! '5'#5 7&7!'##(& 6+!-.(/

&& .(/ ' -&685& &!'8 ' ,!7 <(&'! /

& -& '

('5 ( & '5& &#('! '

$% /''& #'6'5& &#('! 5,&&((##& ( ! -!7!'

#5 7&7!''5&##(&,(''5&'

! ( ',$/! !

&-!&#& /!!'& &''! 8 8 7 $ #/& ' '5& # # (! '5& 8!&%45& &#('! 5,&&(, &' -&!'

#5 7&7!''5&##(&,&$ 5 8 & , & (,'% 45&'

! ( ',$/! ! '5&&-!&#&&

& ( $ /!!'& &''! 8#/&' '5&# # (! '5''5&#5 7& 7!' '5& ##(& ' -&6 85!#5 # # (! ! '

('!, &! !, &' ,&&'!&% 45&

&6 '5& & ! & ,&5

& '>##(&># -!#' &##&'&%45&!/(7&+(7/&'

# -!#'! & &'&#&(& & <('5&/

&( ''5& &&'!&%45&& 'G##(& ! "!# $6 +!- .(/ 0 1(# $ && 0 2! #<(!''& '5&#5 7&

85!#5'5&$5-&,&&5& 7(! '$ # -!#'&-!&'5&!/(7&+(7/&'% 45&& '>##(& !"!# $6+!- .(/ 01(# $&& 02!685 &''&' ,&! #(' $ &!

&#'&' ,& & &&

'58!'56!

' &<(!

&!$ '5& #&% C&#& $!

/'! ,&&'' '5&<( '& # #& &% ** *.*

**+ 1&3 F5&'5& & !7> & & 3 H&>C F5&'5& & ', & H&>C