← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1502/2013dismissed

Kamaljit @ Jugnu v. State Of Punjab

2022-09-19Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat17 pages

  

        

   

 !"#$  ! %!& !"$$  

  



 

'"  ()'

 * *

*+ ,

  ()'

 * **,+ ! "#$   %& '( )*  +,& - & ."

//// *

*+ ,

 -   *    +   !&  +  *!*    ' +( 123 2403&6

)47 2400903 2402& (  &*(('+(*(( &+()(*! 1 !+*(( )))(+*" (+342)*   '&*!*(+!  1 2403&* + !(( &(  %,* *+):( (;<*('+(

..!& *!/!& 0! !.1%2/ 342   !

+%+%) +)

 04&4449=;+ 1    * <  ))#% )  )+    )*  !

+! +%+%)* %*

 *  ('+(  "(%  !!+'  )%  *  ' +(  ) ('+(+;<& &"(%!!+' )%*(> *1+*(;<;<&"(%+% *+%"#*   6'+(+!  6&  #  *  "(%      ++ *!+*+")*+6  





 * ?

-(  .+!*   #  #&! 08#& 11,+!1 1+*%@ +!@,&  !&

+ A  *  )+ # +  1+*  (( %.+  +!*  ! 4B 4C 2400& (  .+!*   #  #* (%*+*,(*& &!+1*1, ("+*'+!* + *% A+)*-* +!*+ ((*+%%"+*"*+*1#+! 1+(* )) *)&*+)*(* )*+% @**(  (* ( &* ! --

04  4B 4C 2400" 44

 1+*

 1& +&1*+(*+:*+"+

&1+* !    %++!  ) *+      02 4C 2400& +  -*  +!* )) %:*+"+ ")*+(& &*( * "*(( ! * ( 1+(4C 4C 2400D "*1)+ & &*+%"+*1,1+(* ))&  &*(%,1**+* "%  "#%.+ +!* !1** (( *+  " #%1* * "+)*+%:*+"+ &)% :*+"+ @0?9 1 !+ "100 4C  02 4C

 &+(#1 !+&1*(+' +4C 34

 & &+(1!+ (+ (( %.++!*1 02 4C

 3*  

 * -+! +!+& ((  %.+  +!*  ! +( *** (%%+ % ) .+!*   #

#4C 4C 2400+%1*+(*+(( +*+* )'+!"1& &** "+ *  " #+*  .++!*%& &**(+)+(,1 !)*+ ( (*)&* *+(#1:(+' !+ + +!*@+& &+ *(1*  " #1(( "#*+% *++(& 1 !&  &  " #1:(' & &*%1,++ "#*+( 1+ +)+ "#)*)* ( > :*+"+

1 & &*  " #1)%% :%++& &*%1( ( "#*  ) (  4C 2400&(( + *%1*** %  * (  .+!*   #  # *1*'+!" + *++ 1+*" 1+) )%*&1*+(*1 +(& & 1+**)*'+!+!))+(&  &1,++'+ %%:*+"+

!*+ )*() (((:*+"+  1  *1+!

(*)* ( 1,++'+ %%:*+"+

 -+!+'+!+& @=03,*'++!**  +( * 4C 4C 2400&** #((   ( !*" 44

 + +

C&  6#& + 0?

4C 2400& (( )) * +(%:*+"+ 6*))( *** ,(( * !!'+ 1*+(*** (%%+ %   )  .  +!*    #   #  +      C   ()*+ +(%:*+"+ 6& !!1('

# )%* +( ('+ %%:*+"+  !*,(* :*+"+ -)* !!1 !*+:*+"+

) *()('#) !!1 -+!*+'+!+& * !!&*(*) (  %)" + + 1+((+("# #++1 **"'+ +(1+ 1+*"  )  (%+  )  +'+!+  "# *  +'+!+! ))+((( &+* ;<&*++ ))+%+'  (+0736

&")* 6%%+ ! ((

'')



 * *))( (+342 61:(+'# +""#*6)+&*)&* (%%+6 '+    2?

2400&(%%+ *()+&*6 )* + !& +  )



 * )+ +!+%)(+(&(*! (+342) * 6"(%)% &!+*(( & &1*+(**  !+#& &(+% +     )  *  (+  (&  *  (+ :%+  +:  1+  )  (%+  )  ( +!  )  * ++  )  *  (+  1+&  *     ++ + !& + 1( +!& (+303)* 6

&  "  *+&  *  ((  (+%  )  +%+(+&   &   +(( A1'&'+ (+ )(1 ( "# *(( )((+)*+&&"(% 

 ;<&"#* + !& +&*(   %,*)' +()('+(+& &% *(> *1+*(;<;<&&* * '** *      )  

*)  

 

3 )) * (+!)*('+(= *(  1+*'+!")*+6&**' +((*! ")*+6 '">*  + ++" !%+(++)'+ ((  * '** * ) *

*) *** &* (*! ")*+6&**. !%&(*! ")*+6&+ 1%+ &  1#+)(



'*)*3  *  0!& .21 / !45 0/0 ! .+6

@=03  +  *+  :%++=+=(*+)  *  (*  *   4C 4C 2400&"0 342 44

 &1*** !   6#& +

C)+!*+!*(*(*+ )%*"&* *+))&*1"** (  .+!*

 # ! A+ +)+ *(( &1*1*+ 6 A*(+  ***,* 1+*"*) *%& &*)11 *"(,+ )*  1) '+!*(*+ *+(+'( .+!*   # +(* "#*+%"1,+!1 +  !& &+( ** "!+!*+1, )%*+%&**  ** ( 1,1*+% '&**  **%!**) .+!*   #& &1

7 ,1*+%'+4C 4C )1,+!&+( *+    +!  "*  *  (( &   &  (  !*&  *  1 +)% ** ( 1,+ "#(( ! A*" '#%*+(+*+)*+:%++=+=(*+)*+( ***(( & & ( !*&*&**  "+)** ( * "%  "#*(( *!*&+ *+ :%++=+=(*+)&** %*+(#  >*+  +!* ( & &(( !*4C 4C *& *!*  *  *    %     ( +  (*+!  *+&  *  "*  * (( & & ( 1'+#,1*+%&"# +   :(+!  (  :%++  "+!  % &    *+%&      * ))+((#)*"' ++&" @=03%+ (* +* "'  *&+()*"')(&*++%#+" +! ( +"++# 0?

'&  *!*  *  1    )*  +!  ( :%++% *+%&"#*++%#*** '  +%&*1'+"*'+&" '*+ !!+"(%(%# + "#*+% *&*+ (*'+%&1**1"**(( & & ( !** (>+)* '*!*&* *  %++%#  +!  )%  *+  '+  %  (   + 1++!&+%(*& +*+( +!*+*** *, *   *'(1+*"**((  * ( &#*+%,+!*"'(*+!+*+:%++=+=(*+) A1'&*"'+!"+%'%*+ '+#(  %+1++!&*+%++% ' 1**1+*)(%&  +*+:%++=+=(*+)

8 "  *+  '+"++#    *  '  (&    *  '  ! 1*91**"*1*(( & &* ( !*1* *    %+  *  *&    *  "'  %++% +%'%% "# @=03+*+:%++=+=(*+)&'*+ '+#(  %+1++!&"'+# *'# +!+)+(( 0C (>(&*!* @=03&*(+*" "'*1,+*(((&"**(( & & * ( 1!*+*'+(++#)*+&1*)% *+()*(( &*" #)* ( 1('   *   +  

'    * ) *

 *' 

* 0B -+!*()*('+())+!+(( #& *% +!  +(%1*+(*:*+"+ 6+ +!  *  (  )  *  +(  %    :( *+)

*  1+*  1*+(*  6**  *  *  %   * (  .+!*+ #* ,(( * 6** )(+! +&**  1 + +  #* *),+((  * !+1'+*!)

C "1*+(***:(+',1 ! (!* %(' *++(

  (   +!  )  *  "'  :(  +! +(  %&   %   "# * ('+(   * +(  ))+( '  *  *  *  ()  *+  % +!  *  (  1+*   & "+ *(* *+&**+ #+ ('#)%*()*+*+ +!+&*'()+ *+ +!1:(+'#,1*+% *"'+!  +( %+" +%+(+()+)(+%"#*('+(

9 *+())+(1*(  +&&+ +*('#) "+!% *!*('#%%:*+"+  *&% '+ +#  1*  +    "  +!    *  +!  +( %)*('+(1*+(*:*+"+ 6&++! * "+!*&**+*"# + *:+()*++! *&&*'* + '&+( ;<&*:*+"+ 6+" ()+&&"'+#1* +*+"#(+2C)* +'+ ((&0572&(+# 1* ;<&+ *('#)*"+! % *++(&*+())+(&*!*('#%% :*+"+  +!+)+(#&1**('#)  1%  *!*('#%%&1*+(*:*+"+ ++!

 &"+ 1* *('#)  *!*%%:*+"+ &*" '    "          !+  ('#  *)&  * (%+'))()*"' +(+&+*&*'+ ('#) *(+%1*+()*('+(*+'+!+! ))+(& "'+# ((  *+% + *  (%%++ ) *(*! ))( '&**!*("++% * *#)&"(%"#! "#*(+ *!



3             *  

 :+#;: *&'+ %%:*+"+ @=0?9&*(( %  +!  +(% (+27)*'+ ((& (1*):( *+) E*()"1 1+& +( %  1  %   "#  ((  %.+  +  ! +!+'+!+&4C 4C 2400& .+!*+

 #+ #)-*+!*+ ) 6#& +1%  "#%+%((

$ +"1   " #)+  .+!* 1"+ "#%"# +!!+!***'( +  *  %  &  "  1*+(*    *'  *  :(+' ,1 !    (  !  *  %  ('    %# %(+ )*(( %,+!*"'+!  +( % (+27)* +'+ ((&")* +())+(&1+*) +!*+>* (*'+!* :(+',1 !)*'(1*** "+ *  " #)* ( #&*+'+!+!))+((( & % >*"-+'++!+& +&1*+(* :*+"+ @0?9 ++! &)*!+!%++:*%*   " #  )  *  (    (>(&  *  "  -+'++ !+& +&   + +!*@+& +"*+  '++*+)*' *  " #)* ( 1:*% +*() + +!*@+& +"*+ &

+& &1,++'+ ('#%%:*+"+

*"''+ # 1%%;<& )+%#((*(( +*(%%++)*(*! ))( !* '+!* "'+)("(%!'+ )%*)(%*+** ('+(*"# + *++!&((+:*+"+ @=0?9& *"#'*+  +"+ 1***' ** +('#)*')(*1!+ 

#&* +(' )(;<+"((  (( *+%1+**(+%'    * +

'''

  

3 

   * *(( &' "# @=0?96&1  4C *&' "#%%:*+"+

&"(% 1 02 4C 2400&(1*):( *+)&* *

 +())+(+1*** "+ *" #)* (

.+!*   # ">#&)%*+"++& + +)+ "#*(( &*" #) (  .+!*   # 1:*% )%*'"+( *"'1 +* () + +!*@+& +"*+ & + *'# )(%)*" #)* ( "+!"+ &+""'+# )(+')*"++"+!:(+'#,1*('+( *)&+)* *+())+(*"++&1*)* (  +  :*%+&    ,    +)(&  *  *  *  ) (%%++!*% ) ( * ,+"#+&*( )%1*+"(%:*% *&* +(' )(;<& "(%( *+()*(( +(:*+"+

+ +!  (%"#* +"*+ & +& &1*1*+ +!+*1+": @=0B&*'*() :*+"+

*&* +('#9:*%+)*" #)* ( )%*+1*+1"+ & &1*+(*1") ;<&*(:(+'#1+*+*,1 !)*('+(& ++)(&**"' +(' )(&*+()* ('+(    ("+!  *  "'  %%;<&  "+    +! ("+* ++) @=03 E

*()"1 1+&(( %.++!"'+ 1*+++(( #&+ (( (1+**+ +(%& *+( #  6#

C"1 +&+ *()*+ + +!* +"*+ & +    *  (  #+!  '(  +  )  )  * (( %1*  " #) (  . +!*+  #1(( "#*+%)*+%   *+()(( & 1 !   " #1:(' & +(+ 1 "*)*+  )  (,      *  (*&  (%%+  1+*  *   ! 1  1  )  -  " #  1  ,  +  +( +'+ %%+()'+ (

   )3        '

3



   *!*&++'*%#! ")*+6"#*  ()*('+(&*+(*%+')*(+%&* +*%! &&*"'*&*"'+,+*(*+ )(+(%+'+ ( (>+#'+ +#1* A1'&*"'!%+:%#)"& &+.( *   "(%  (%+  +  *  )(%&  *  *  %+'  +   (+  (      (+(%+  '+ (&  *!*   (%+'+ +,+*(*+)+(+%+#(+(%(&"+ %#"(%'&+)**+(+%+#+,&+*(*+ )+(+%+#(+(%(*(%#!!+')* +(+%+#+(++)*('+(+*(*! ))( +( *+6)++!*(*!

 ' +()('+(+&%    *  ('+(  "#  *    +   !&  *    *  + ((+&  &  "  )  %+!  1+*  (    "*  * (( & &* ( "+!!*& *+ %  +%% +  :+%+#    *  " #  )  *  (  "+! (' '&1** 1+!)%%;<&+ '"'+ &"+ *+(+'+;<++) *&    +"+  )  %+'  +)  #&  "# *  (+    * ('+(&#%+)#)+(*)&* '!&*()*('+(&!*' +() (>+&"( +()*(*!

' 

 *=%%+(%+ +:*+"+ 0& &   +  .+#  *  "#  -    "+&   ++  )&

 -%)+((+(& '% +(6!& +&  "#- -  @+ -   "++!+*1+ ":& @=7*'*+*+!*%& &*' *  :+(  *  )  *  +!  )  *  (=*    - -  @+

@=7+*+:%++=+=(*+)&*+)+ **+ %,+!#*" #)* ( & .+!*

 #&*+"'+!***+):( ( (+  1  +G  3  :  0  (%&  %(  & "+>#( 1+%) *(,) 1+ * (+ 1 +G2 C:0(%+ * & *+G# (    *  )  )  (,  +  + %4 2(%*))+.# ;0< 1%(  (+ 1 3:0(%+ *  %( 1*)+ )))(, ?(%+.#

2 ?

"1 1+**%!++G7:2 C(% 1)+ )"(,)(*++ 1    +!  )%  %+ +    !+! 1  # 1( "+># "1 1+**%!++G?

C:0 C(% 1+!*+ )"(,)(*++ 1HC 4(%*+!*)%+  1 ( "+># "1 1+**%!++GB:3(%1   "1  *  +!*  :+  1  "+># ( :+)+.#

?&C B *#1) %,+!( +!(+* (+'+" +!*(*('+#  :%++)!&(( +!* +.+  (+"  "'  1    1+* ()"244%)" +(* ('+# **!1+#( (+ 1 &+ * %+!0I2:C (%%( 1*):)( )+!*% 2?

A*( *+&**() %+) * ( 1*%*!& &*(,)*"' :( %%+.+&1*+(*"(%+)+ "#*+%" ))+(++* +#()( * *%&

 **+)+ **"" +)+%* "1*+.+  *1+%% +& &** +) +%"1 *& &%%1"1, *)& 1+*  @=03    +!  *  ( &   &  ((  !*   4C 4C 2400&*&* ++) @=7,+!"*"" +)+%+= *& &%%"+!1,& !!* @=03&*,**"*++! "**(( & &* ( !*4C 4C 2400&  1*+(*+""'+#1,+#"+!% * " #)* ( #&* ++) @=03(>+ ("+)%* ++) @=7 '&*"' %%+.+)(+')*+I"(%+!( *!

*I )* ! 1&*'+)*" #)* ( *&1**'+(+%+#1+*  !  1&   &  1*  '+  ('#  *)  "(%  ( *!* ('#%% :*+"+   *)&1* *() %+)* ( (+" "# @=7&++(+ %% +.+ "("*!** ! 1&*( *'+ #(' * !  +*   )  *  (    >&  ("+  **!*  + (>+  "#  %%  :*+"+    1**!*  "(% (' "+ ("++(>+ "#**#) &"(%"#!

 2C *!*  *  ((  "  +  +(+%+#  +% "+ *" + +(+%+#1)))(&"(% %+ *!* )(

087CC963  43 4B 2400&*

# (( A1'&' "#*)1*+(* :*+"+ J++! &**+(+':%++& +**+):( ++ <

* *  )



 ** 



?329240099 "9 +9:%&  48 4B 6 )( 

044&  029C92400&

9342 6&

 &6+'++& +

(II(+ =6**! "+ 1+*"

(I I(+ =+! "+ 1+*"

(I6I(+ =*)1+!:*+"+! "+ 1+*" $= +<=*+%, 6=0+*"# ++< %, 6=2+*"# +++<  1%, 6=3+*"#

* ) :'  E*:*+"+(+ +*(&  6 + 1+**%" 2B *!*&  +  *  1,  )  *  (+  (!# "+*+!&*(*! 1!+*('+(&*!**+! +*1+":)( +"1+ @=03&1** '+ # *('+(  ( !*+%% +#")* (((+*%+%% +:+%+#*((( '&*!**(+*""'* (*!*!*'+ # 1%%;<&"+ )%*% +( '+ (;< A1'&*)*:%++&%  *" + +%*(( &%#*' )* )+)#+!  ("+   * '+ ( ;<&  "(%  ( "#*(+ A1'&*"':( & % *" + +%*!+(( & *+)"+*+!**" +(+ *

 '+%*("!+!*" !)* ( (( *&*+((+'+#)++"#*!+ "**%" (+ *'+%"!+!* " !)* ( (( *"'+((+'+#) ++  %# *'"  '(%  #+) * +'+!+!  ))+( (( &* "%*!**++!*((+&) *'( &)%*)%+#%%")* ( (( &**#( *'"!1+**' " + +%&*!+(( &)*+%,+!* ""+(%+*) +#+*1,)* "'++ )+'+!+**"''((&* +  *  "'  +'+!+  +)+%+#  "(%+!  +   *+!*+!* "#*+6

*+%#&++ +!)* )*(( *+%(&%)*+% *&)*(+':%++*&*#"(% + "%")#"#+*&" ++ +  * % & * #) *  * * ' +%9%+"(%+! ++!  + *"'+ )+* #+* (*)*'%(* (*(( &+) +):%++ "+!% *%*(( *'+ *")+('+ (*6 )1 *)&+)*+# #*)*"+ (( &    %,    #    *  +%    *  ) :%++&++)*-+(;<)*(( &+! +"++#    *  !+  ((      *  *  :

7 ((   +!  *  *  +'+!+!  ))+(  (( *)& %+((*'( )%*)%+# %%")* ( )*+. (( &"+ *# %+)*1+* *+ ( *(!1+** " + '('+&*(( *&++ % )+ +(*-+( ) +(& ." 1 "(*1+++!+)*+'+!+!))+(+*)

."

*++!"+% &+*"'! & &1+* ! *' (*"+!% %#* (( 6>#& * !+# )*+ 6 +  +(   )*1+*(+((#)*+' +(*-+( )

+(& ."

6%+(>*"' +(+" " (%%+( * !+#)*+6&"+%*#"+"#* -+( ) +(& ."

 ++&*-+()* ."& +( **+*%:%++% * %+ (* *(( &"#*:1,+! *&*'*)#+% **+# ++!+ ++)*%+9+%*  (#)*+' +("*%

 ) *  )%*&((+***&"(% 1+"#* ('+(+!6&*+" 1 "#*+6 *)*"' +(+&+*&*+6  )+ #%++*& &+(+  +%++

8 )

 *

 6>#&  *    +  +%+  *  +%! ' +(  )  ('+(+&   &  *  (>  *1+*  (;< ;<&"(%+% *('+(=&"#* ('+(+!6&))+%  %++ 3?

*(#&+)#&" 1+*+(( (1+* 1&")*:+#)+ )+%++)*)++!)  *( ")*1+* 1  4*

*+ ,

   4**,+6    $$ ,'+!* +=/=  51>0!?;

1 ! "

 ; +=/=  5 /1@2 "

 ;