Darbara Singh v. State Of Punjab
"#
$%$&'()*%$&'( ++** ,$- & -.% +/ " 0(($ +$$**++$12%**3/(.-/'14 ! %$$$/( +$$$4 5 0(($(.-/'1(-*/%$+$/('4
$ 6$ & $$7/87$(++** 6$ 6.$($-9-*7//* 7 -.% ( +$ ++* /$/ ' ( .-/'1 8/$/$//
"
$/$/%2(*$/ //* & -/'7 ('$( &(%7 3($%2 ( ++** 3 8/$+-(%*-/$&5 ! // -/$'$'$-1+$1$*/+2 "
:; /-* +21 7 ( ++** -$($ -/$' $'$- 1+$1$2$ ( +$- 3 1 ( 1 '1/$ &'( 9$1. &'( <//= $/ ,**'
(+-$ 1/ & &3 &'(7 & 6-*+-$ !>
( 1 <?
=7 '1/$ &'( / ( ( $ 8$ 9-$ 3 1$$/ $%$ &'( -$1* &'( $/ ($(* 9(-$/$(*%-"
2$%@ /((%$($;;*3
$%$&'(-/%($8$9-$ *'3((($ 9$1. &'( / ( - /($ &'(7 $+ *+( 1'7 $1 ($ $ ( ( ( ( %% -+ %2 ($ (-%/73((-$%$&'(($(*9(-$/$/$ 1@(1-/$/ 38$7(21@3(((/'( (+73((3-/$(-$/3$&(% ($$7%- A 5 :#
67(*'3((($/ /($&'(3((+ (%$($;;*3 *'3((- /($&'(3$/' -/((+$($73($(($9$1.&'(3 /((+$/$1@$%$&'(-/$//B-$ (3(2('8%'(/-'($ (13(*7$%$&'( '2//$+@'-+$3/$8$73((3*2'$3( (17'8%*3(*/((($ /(3(( /(-%$($3/((+'(1$7(%$($;; *3*/32$1(+ ($$7(*'3((-$18/ (($9$1.&'(.-$//8*+*7 ('$( &(%($1$;2*7%-(($//(11 ( %-(17<?
:"=3( *&$ $'$ $+7 <?
:!=3*/'/( 1/2-/$&5 !CA D ($$7&&3&'(E(8'' $73 (8*+*7 ('$(&(%73($(//%/29$1.&'( 3*2'(1$-$2/+$+$/B-$+$? 6 &+;
1$1 ?1 -*/ % /-/ ( /27 & &3 &'( $/+-'9$.&'(@$(//%/23( +* -$$ / +$+$/ $-'( +* ? -$- ++*?
7+;1$1?1(//%/29$1.
&'(3/-/!
35"
7$%$&'(E -/3$$/ -$'$$'7-/-$//*-$ 1<?
=((((/@+*/$3/$8$ -/$((*(((+ +-$--(17-/ ' $8$/ $3 /$8$ / 3( %*/7 3(( 3 @ + 8/ $8$2 11 ?
9 1+* $2 $1*7$+$-/$&"
5$ 3*/'(+$ ++** +$87+$$1/$'8/$+$ ( $&F%$$27(/'$(<?
G=7(+$-( ?1/12"
3 0;"$ 9-*1&'(**76/* $78*+*7 ('$(&(%+$8/(+1$1$+$ ?
/+/(+%*2(.-$2(+$// 3($3/$8$%$-*/- ($3;?17 0;"$ 9-*1&'(**/(3+3(3(1%2(+* (1+1$1?1/(($3%*3<.-$2= (*/(( /((/(($-*(@/ (1$$('/-+--$'($ 0(*++$'(3;%?7 0;!'1/$&'(E -($ 7($$/$*$8$ ($;?17( /((($3(8'(3($3$&'(7(2(/ $/ ( (+ $ ( .-$2 3 */ ( ($ %2 ( -/7(*'3( /($&'(11/*2$/((+73(( (*2(-$ /((//7$3$&'(3 (*/' $3 /$8$ ( (/7 3( (2 $/ ( (+ $ ( -$$7(2%1%-2+$8/'(($
0;5 /($&'(-$1*&'(*/+/( 1$1(%/+/%2 0;!'1/$&'( ($;
?17(/(((--//5:A(-$ $1((-'1/$&'(,**' (+-$ -*9$1. &'(1($(-/(/*@3((($ ($$7( -*@/(11+2(1($(*9(-$/ /(( (@3*/'$'$/'(%''88$9-$%2(-/ +$$(/2-$$$(((/8/8**'- ( $ /( -/ /9$1.
&'((/'$++*/ 3((($/((23$*@'3((($$1*32 ** ( $1' $-1 ++$' ( +$- 8/ 3$ +- ( -/ ( 1 $$// -/$ & 5"5 $ // ( +$- **' / +*//*1+* (/7(*?1/(&'(7 F1%$/$ 0;"7 $. &'( 0;!7 $./$ &'( 0;5 / 63&'(0;A $''($-'((8/$$/7*$/$*-$ 8/ / / ( -/;++**7 1/ %87 3($B-/(1(($'*8**/-/$&A D $(-$7*$/-*$(++**($'-/ (/+/3(%.
# -/( ++$%-//'( (-7 3($(8$+-(%*-/$&5 ! -%*7%-%/%%8$ +-(%*-/$&5 A
($'-1 (/+/3(%./(-'((+*-$$ ($-'($%* 0;!'1/$&'(7-($ 7( '$**2 / ( ($ +$ 3 +$ ( + $ 2 1+*2 -$/3$ $ $( 3 +$ ( + ( $; ?17 ( /1/ ( ( (+7 3($ ( -$$ (/ @ +*($-'($7%-%/2+/(+*-$$( 1 */((($(/*@3($%$&'($%- 8 1- *2 %$(-$$ &-(1 0;! / $$%$/%2 0;5 /($&'(73((/(($$ ( (+ ($-'($7 %- +$ 3 ( 1 ($$7 ;.
' /+/ 3 % 1/ % /-%(+$-8$ &1*$*27 ( $'-1( ( 1 $8$2 $3 /$8$ $1 ( (+ ( ++**7 /+/ 3 ( % ./'3(-1$ ($8$23+ $3 /$8$ $1 ( *$ (+ ( ++** +-$- ( /*-$ 1<?
= (/%/-%/*2$($( /+/ ( % ?1/7 3( -( +$8/ %2 ( 8'' $
> (*/((($9$1.&'(<//=
!
"
#
$
%
&
'
(
)
)
(*/ ((//9$1.&'( (
#
%
% *
+, 9$1.&'(<//=3 /((+$/$1@$%$&'(-/$//B-$ (3(2('8%'(/-'($ ((1(8/+/( -% *
)
* !
3((@+*(/-$$7(( +7(++***/($3/$8$/%%/(( (// &-(-//%*33(-2+$;1//1/3(- 2-'/((// ($$7**3(
?+A&5
(/ */7
#
*
)
!
(
!
% *
)
!
+./!"
+. !" "
#
+.!"
+./!!"0
+./ !!"(
,1. ...2
<6
=
"# < F = ,1*