High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1532/2013disposed of

Lallu @ Lal Mohan v. State Of Haryana

2015-02-24Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri11 pages

! "

# $%&% '()

* +,* - . '

** /# # 0 '

/ ( - 1&.. 23 1"24 $ # &5%$+& +% #. '# - '2.% /%'6." 22%#% ' 24 $ # ' " 0 ' #.& '2'#

8.#. #& #. $ &5 0 9 32# &#.1+265'#:

7 92# #. #& '

7 8.#.#.1+265'#&.

+29 #2%'

#.%6&#:

. &'# %& 2%$#2 6 %'&# #. 1+265'# $ ' 2 #2 '2 2 &'#'$2 #2

3.90 '#* +,* - . '. &9'.26+%#0 '2$ '4%$#2 '2&'#'$2 &

+'2(

'2/$#% ' . $ '4%$# %& &'#'$2 #

+'26 % %5%& '5'# '2 # 0 %' "; '2 %'

2 +# 05'# %'" #

+#. +'26

&%5 %5%& '5'# % 2 ' 0 %0" #. ' $ & %& #. # '

# 9 +#< - -+= '2 >&%'$ 2$ &27 3 & +'2 5+22 %' .%& &%2'#% ?+ # %' &#+2 5" /+# ' /%'6. ' 8&#'2 @ #%= %' #.

%$ /# #% ' / .' " +6 ' 5 %' '# A % -+'2 #2# #. %$#. #.3 &&%2'# &#+2 5 /+# '/%'6. '2-+= '23 & & %4%'6#. '63%#.

.%& 3% /.+='%" 2 +6.# 9 #. .%& 3% '2

%6%' 0 &%2'# @% 6 .

. #

%$ /# #% '

* . '"%&#%$# &+"/# #.. #%&6 ..0. 29' %'6 9 +3 = 5 &# B5 '#.&. #% '&3 &# %'29#3'#.$ +%/5#/.+='% '2-+= '2 & '#* +,* - . '3 &&# 0%'63%#./.+='% '2 -+= '2 '2 '#3 & 3 #. #/.+='%3 &9%'6 6%4'%# #5'#90..+&9 '2 '2" &&+$.".. 2 55%##2#.5+2 .%&C%1 C>&%&#C&.+&9 '273%#.

& C & $ 5 %' '#" $$+&2 2 3 0 5 #. & # #$ 55%##%'6#.5+2 +%'6#.#% &# 6"$. 63 & 52 6 %'&# #. '# $ 55%&&% ' '$+'2/$#% ' ' ) ) # 3.%$. . 22 '

# 6+%#0 '2 $ %52#% . 'D 5%'2 )3%#'&&&%' $$+&23 &D 5%'2+'2/$#% ' 34"'

3%#'&&%'2'$3 &D 5%'2 * '2 #% +26 3.% $%'6 % '$ + '

#&#%5 '0 '3%#'&&&2%&9%42#.2'$ 4&% '".2#. '#6+%#0 $ 55%&&% ' '$ +'2/$#% ' '2$ '4%$#2 '2&'#'$2.%5 #.+'2 %'6 66%42 &&%'6 & %21+265'# ' '2 2 &'#'$"#. '#%&9 #.%& +# . 3 & %6%' 0%290-/+'2 &3 " 24 $ # 9+# '

' . 2 +# %'

'$ #. '# /%'$ '# 3 & %' $+&# 20" #.%& +# %'#2 - 1&. . 23 1"

24 $ # &5%$+&+% 8. 4. 2- 1&.. 23 1"24 $ # & 5%$+&+% '2- '2.%/%'6."22%#% ' 24 $ #

) ' " 0 ' 9&%2&+&%'6#.$ 2 * '2#% +26. & &&2#.1+265'# ' '2 2 &'#'$3.% $%'6% '$+ '

#&#%5 '0 8 A %-+'2 "$ 5 %' '# #.%&$ &"

%&$ & #%4 2$ &2 &3 & $$+&2& ' $ &2-+= '23 &5 %2# /.+='%"3.

%&2 +6.#

9 #.%' 3>& 7 A %-+'2 > 8 7 #.5 3&%2%'6 #&#+2 5.

+& '2+&2# 2 9 + = 8 A % -+'2 2 &2 #. # $$+&2 * + . 2 '# #.?+ # /.+='% '2 ##. ##%5-+= '23 & 0%'6%'#.

2##. ##%5/.+='%2%&$ &2#. # $$+&2 =%2 . .+&9 '2 3%#. C & C '2 # 55%##%'6 #. '$" . 2 3 0 5 #. & # $$ 2%'60".. 25 2$ 5 %'#D ;# #. %$

8 ) /5# /.+='% 3% 2$ &2 -+= '2 &

&+ #2#. '4&% '%'# # #. #&.3 &%4%'6 3%#...+&9 '2 '2$.%2'%'&#+2 5.

+&'#. #+ 2 0 % * + , * - . '=%2 . .+&9 '23%#.C '2 & C%'.%&?+ #.+&9 '2+&2#

9 #. '2.$.%2'?+'#0 #$ '&+5%'6%?+ '2#.& 53 &'

## #.%=%'6 .9 #."3.

%& '

3 '#9 #.%& +#'#.& 5'%6.# # 9 +#

-" . .+&9 '2 3 & =%2 90 $$+&2 3%#. C '2 & C '2"#. #" $$+&22 3 0 # 4%'6

C '2 & C ' #. & # 8 / '1 0 & &+ #2 #. '4&% '#. # '%'#4'%'6'%6.# ; "

.3 &%' 52#. #-+= '2. 2$%42%'1+%&3.%$.

3 $ +&2 90 * + , * - . ' ' $%# & %2 %' 5 #% '".+&.2# #.& # '2 +'2#. #-+= '2 3 &0%'6%'#.

2& 8"5+23 & 55%##2 90 #. '# & -+= '2 +&2 # 6%4 9 #%'6&# .%&&%&# '2.$.%2' '2 $$+&2$ +2'

# # ##.& 5 8 A

& 5 2#.&%5% 2 &%#% ' . 0 3%#'&& 4&% ' %& &+ #2 '2 #29052%$ 4%2'$903 0 &# #5'#

8/+2.%. +2. 0"3.

. 2$ '2+$#2#. &# #5D 5%' #% ' # 5#. ##. '$ & %&9 &2+ '#&#%5 '0 8B 5/%'6. '2 8) /+'2/%'6."/"3.

. 2%'4&#%6 #2#.5 ## 8< '%A+5 .

# 6 . 42#..

# 6 .&D& # 8 &.A+5 "2 #&5 '. 2 2#. &%# 'D ; 8E / #%&.A+5 '2 8

'&# 9 1 5 #. 5 3%#'&&& #.%&$ &"

. 2 #'22#.% %2 4%#& D 8E; '2

; +#& $+&# 20 $ & #0 8F '&# 9 %&.

. '2. 22%42&$% # #.%&$ &# ?

- 6%&# # '2 &'% %$ %$& 8 5

A+5 . 2 $ 5#2 #. %'4&#%6 #%'6 $2%'6& 3. & 8 '&$# '% A+5 . 2 2 %' # +'2 /$#% ' F # $ 5#% ' %'4&#%6 #% ' 6 %'&##. 2'% &+# 3 2%'#. &# #5'#+'2/$#% ' " $$+&2&%50#

= #. #. ##. '$ &%& & '2.. &9'

&0 %5%$ #2 %' #.%& $ & 3. & . %& %'' $'# 34"#. %''

$'$3 &'

#9%4290#.#% +26 '2" $$ 2%'60".3 &.26+%#0 '2$ '4%$#2 '2&'#'$2 #. '$+'2/$#% ' ##.#%5 6+5'#&"- 1&.. 23 1"

'25%$+&+% &'#%'6#. '##

=#. #. # #. ' $ & %& '

# 9%4 9 #

8 ) /5# /.+='% $ ''

# 9 %2 + ' & &. 3 & 2 &%'6 50 9$ +& #. 2 #. . .+&9 '2 . 2 # =' $ 8 A %-+'2 $ 5 %' '# #.%&$ &. 2 $.2 ##. $ $$+'$ ##.%'$%2'#. 2 # =' $ '2 & &+$." . 3 & ' # 9 # 2 & '0#.%'6 #. # 3.

. 2 $ +&2 #. 5+2 -+= '2 /%5% 0"#&#%5 '%& 8& '2 '

# '0. #. ' 34" #. '2 #% +26 . & $2 % '$ + ' #. & 5 3. & #. 4%2'$ %& 3.

0+'% 9 '2#.& 53 &9 &2 '. & 0

8.% 6+%'6 '#.& %'#&"- '2.%/%'6."

22%#% ' 24 $ #' " 0 ' "#

=#. #. #%# 3 & $ & 03%#'&& $$ +'# '2#.%&'

#.%'6#

2%&9%4#.#&#%5 '0 8 )/.+='%.4%$#%5 '2 2$ &2%'#.%&$ &%&'

'&9+#.+&9 '2 /5# /.+='% '2 C%1 C $$+&2 . %& '

2 +9# 9 +# %2'#%#0 #. $$+&2 #.53%4%'6%'#.& 5 ?+ #.5 %'%'63%#'&&&. 4 & &+ #2 '2 #2 #. ' $ & %' # # '2 #. %& '

#.%'6 # 2%&9%4 0 3%#'&& $$ +'# '2 52%$ 4%2'$ & 3 & 5 %'%'6 4%2'$ 90 3 0 %'4&#%6 #%'6 $2%'6& 8. 4$ '&%22#.%4 $ '#'#% '&. 4%'6 9' %&290 '2$ +'& #. #%& .5 &#%5 # '# %'#%'4 42%'#.%&$ &%& #. ##.#% #.$ &. 2# =' $9 '2 22%#% ' /&&% '&+26"+6 '##. ##%5"'

3 & %&2 #. # '# $$+&2 * + , * - . ' %& 1+4'% 34"&+9&?+'#0#. # 3 & %&29 #.%& +#2+%'6#. $2%'6& '2 22 #2 ) ) 3 & &&2 #.90 2%$#%'6 #. +4'% +&#%$ 2"+6 '# .

2%'?+%0 9 +##. 6 #. '# +&+ '# # #. & %2 2 2 #2 ) )"

+4'% +&#%$ 2" +6 ' .2 #. %'?+%0 '2

'$+22#. ##. '#3 &1+4'% '#.2 # 55%&&% ' #. '$$$ 2%'60"#. '#3 & 2$ 2 &+4'%%'$ '%$#3%#. 3 & 2 #.%& +#2 #2

. 5 %' %'# # 9 $ '&%22 3 & 3.#. '# $$+&2 ?+%2 # 9 #%2 # $ %'?+%0 9 +4'%+&#%$ 2 +6 ' #.%& +#3.% 2 %'63%#. $ '2$%2#.5 ##%'$ '# 4&0 /%5% 5 ##. 26 '9 'C9/+5 +#%'$ &

##$$ !

$! % &% $'

"> 7

/ < '2 'C9 #. /+5 +# +.2 #. $ ' 34"

$# %'2%$#% '&3%&&+2# #.#% - 6%&# #& 'C9/+5 +# & .2#. #3.%+.

2%'6#. 1+265'# $ ' '2 3 2%'6+'%&.5'#"$ &

%!( )*

&% $'

" >)7

>7 < $ ' 9 32" 3.%$. 0& 2 3' #. # % ' %& +.2" #. 5 ## $ ' 9 $2 9 +4'%+&#%$ 2 3 2%'6&+%# 9+'%&.5'## 3 & & %22 3'#. #% $$+&2%&$ '4%$#2 '0#. C+'%&.5'#&C '

# 6 # #. ' #.

& &#+ #2 90 #. +4'%+&#%$$#" <EB +6.## 9 3 22# .%5 '#.%6.# 9 4 3 %22 3'90 'C9#. /+5 +#G $#& #.%&$ &G4%2'$ 4 % 9 '%

< '2 3.% $ '&%2%'6 #. &+95%&&% '& %&2 90 '2 +'& #. #%&"3 #.$ '&%224%3#. # #% +26. 2 &&2#.1+265'# $ '2 #2

9 &2 '03%#'&&& $$ +'#"3.%$.%&2+0 &+ #2 '2 $ #2 90 52%$ 4%2'$ '2 %'4&#%6 #% '2 '90 %$ %$% &.%&'

& '#

2%&9%4#.#&#%5 '0 8 )/5#/.+='% &3 & #&#%5 '0 8 A % -+'2 $ 5 %' '# %' #.%& $ & &$% 03.'#.2'$4&% '%&1+&# 2'% / 5%'2&&+ # '2$ #% ' 5#&#%5 '%&

'2 8"3.

4%&%#2#.& #%552% #0 ##. %'$%2'# * '2#% +#. &%6.#0.2#. '# 6+%#0 $ 55%&&% ' '$+'2/$#% ' '2 '4%$#2.%5#.+'2 '2 6 %'&#1+265'# ' %& 3%#.

+# '0 5%# '2 #. & 5 &# '2& 2%&5%&&2 . %& 9& +#0 '

9 #. # &+$. '#9%'61+4'%$ ''

#9 %&2 #.%&##%5 2+%'6 6+5'#& %&# 4' %' #. &$ '2 9 'C9#./+5 +#/+$. 33 & %2 2 3' 90 'C9 +# %' $ & %!( )*

&% $'

,%)- . 'C9/+5 +# . 2 & 9&42%'$ & &/0 !

&% $'

1!" >)7 >%5%' 7 #. # % $$+&2 . 2 55%##2#. '$5 #. ' 0 & 6 "#.3 & '

%'#5%##%'6#.5 ##9 $=# #.+4'%+&#%$ +#

3$ 5%'6# #. %'# &'#'$"% '0"# 9 3 22# #. '#" '2#% +26. 2&'#'$2 #. '## +'26 %%5%& '5'# '2 0 %' ";.%&'

2%&+##. ##.& %2&'#'$$ ''

# 9 3 22# #. '#"3.

. & 209'.2#

91+4'%%'$ '%$#3%#. 3& 4%&% '& /$#% '

#.+4'%+&#%$> '2 #$#% ' .%2'7 $#"#. '#3.

%&1+4'%%'$ '%$#3%#. 3 $ '9 3 22#. 3%'6&'#'$( HDDDDDDDDD >675 = ' 22%$#%'6#.1+4'% # 9 &'# # &$% .

5 % 2 #.0 & DDD DDD DDDI ' #.$ & %' . '2" #. '# . & 20 &'# % 2 9 +# #3 0 & 3.% 5 %'%'6 %'

$+&# 20 '&%2%'6 #.4 '# $# &"#.%'#&# 1+&#%$3 +295#&+%# 90%#. '#%& 22#

5 %'%'&$% .

5 % 2 0 & '2B '#.& '2 0%' "; '2%'$ &. %&#

5 =#. 05'# %'".&. . 4# &# 0%'&$% .

5 '

#.% 2 '5 '#..% 2 20 &'#90.%5%'$+&# 202+%'6%'?+%0"%'4&#%6 #% '"#% '2 #.%&$ &&. 9&# 6 %'&##.& %2 % 2 0 & '2B5 '#.& ' 4%3 #. 9 4" #. &'# %& $$ 2%'60 #0 $$#2. 6 %'&#1+265'# '2 #2 &# '2&2%&5%&&23. &#. 6 %'&# 2 &'#'$%&5 2%%2 & 9 4

, .

3# ) 45 /