High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8842/2015disposed of

Hdfc Bank Ltd & ORS v. Harwant Singh & ORS

2016-07-22Mr. Justice Arun Monga12 pages

"# $%&'

( ) "*+#,(-&./"0#12 ##2 32& "24"#5610#12 7,#

! ! "#

2#% -2",11//"2(52,$"#4#1 -23"/1"5"1(,$"#(

2#17##2 -2-"'"*-"#1&2(,$"#(

227,# 88888 ! "#

17##21"*,#19&2,$# #1&2# &,22#$

: #1##&# ," 2##6;", #1 .7&6, 2,2 ,"#, ! <=&2 ;

>?( 412/' #1 "77$"# #127,#;7"#

2 #"*6 "$# "6"# #1 7##2;"*1"/"4,",#1"*1"/,2$#,# 2"#1".&###1=## @ ))A<426'2$2,,"@

#12,2?(22&'$.7&#," (>@(!

!;)

,7#,4#1 #1"*#11"7 ","4" 2##6;",#12,2 <=&2 ;

? #1 ". ,"#( 412/' #1 "77$"# ,"#,

> ! ,/'#17##2 24#1,2"4" #1".&#( ,7#,&,272###1&2#(1"/,., -2",11//"2("2,52 &"#,/' -23"/1" 5"1 ,$"#( "77"26 /1" #1 7##2 &/.##1"##17##2;"*1","22"772"$1,#1&2#, !) !$1"66#12,2,"#, ! !

", !(412/'#1#2"&2#("$&###&#,"##1 #"$ #127,#;7"#

(1",,2$#,#1"*#2"#1 1"2 7"#

!1#2"&2##$,#1 "$##1"#27,#;

"24"#5614""$;1"22##1=##

:B'"2,&# #1 ##"",."&26 @: B'"2,1#2",4".2#6"6, 4#1#1"*(41$14",&,2#15

5$#(

2"&.

( ( (C;","".&# ( >() (! C;2.",,7#, 4#1#1"*(41$14" &,=$"

#22"6#1&##",6 ,&1"77$"#4" ,/'/#1#1$;1"22(("2".

561","/2561 22" #1".&#1$". #1#12 "77$"#1"/"4,""#2.."&23;";#1$".

#1$##627,#(#1#2"&2#,2$#,#1"*#2"#1

& ".&#B&"## @ ))A1"2(&# #1##"".&#'6 ,7#,4#1#1"*#11"7 #1 "64#1#2#&7# #1,"# 2"(&/9$## &216#172"/,#1&.

!((C;",,.#'/, :!((C;1"

2.#, ,2$#$".#/7",#12,2,"#, >

(142( ! !(#1#2"&2#(#1"77$"#.,/'"24"#561 2 #"*6"$#"#1"*1",#$.7,4#1#12,2(2,2, 2 "##"$1.# #1 7272#' 1 &2#( , 2,2 ,"#, >> !( ,7, !) !"

#2#$6#1"26&.# #1$& 2#1"*4#126"2,##11"2 7"#

"24"#561#$42&,##17"2#2 266$# #1"##$*7 #1"*$&,/,"#1"*4" $&226#1,"."6$1"2646##1$"2",$&#,'42( #1 &2# 1", 6 /2#' # #1 "* # #1 #$* # 7("##12*",$# #17"#

",#1".&#( 2$,(4&,/,7#,&$1."2",.,"#1",/ ,;";#1&27&".&#(( D#1#1"

2.#, ,2$#(#127##4",7, &2#12&/.##1"##1"*1",#"6""772"$1#1 &2#, ) !) !"2,2,"#,:> !

$&,#//2&61###1#$ #1&2#(412/'#1"*4"

,2$#, # "22"6C, #1 $1B& #1 "##"$1, ".&#

(>@(!

!;)

"&2 7"#

;"24"#561(#2. #1 2,2,"#, ! ! "$#("72#1$"$&"#1#"##"$1,4#1 #172&27##","4"#172#2" =&2 ;@(#1".&# "2#1"41"#1"/2,2,#/ 2$2, 2.#1"*",#1&2#("

#2#$6#1$##

#17"2#(,7, #1"

2.#,27##,2,2 ,"#, @> !,2$#6#1#2"$&2##7""2,2"$$2,"$ 4#1"4("

#266"772#&#' 1"26##1"*(&/9$## ,#2."# &##",6 ".&#( " "77"2#' 14 #1 $"$&"#1#2 22,#","4"#1,2$#$#",#1 2,2 ,"#, >> ! " #2. ."&2( #1 #2" &2# 4" 2#2", 2.,/&26#1".&###1",9&,$"# #1"$#&" ".&#"$$2,"$4#1"4 " &/.# #1"# "

#2 7"6 #1 2,2 ,"#, >> !( #1"*1",,7#,#1 ".&# B&"@ ))A1"2

"24"#561".&#6#

()() !C;"2 $#,#1$"$&"# , $1B& )@: ,"#, > ! 2 4"2, ,/&2.# 42( ,&26 #1 #226&.( #1 "77$"# ,$"#6 #1 "

2.#,".&#(#4""#"#,#1"##1"##"$1.#(2,2, /'#1#2"&2#(/2",",#1"*4&,2.##1"##"$1,

".&###1#2"&2###1."41(#17##2;"* 2.##,#1#2"##"$1,".&# (>@(!

!;)

/'." "

/"*2 $1B&C,2"

# ,"#, > !( /&# #1 #2" &2# ,, # ",9&,$"##1"77$"#"

2.#, &2#12&/.##1"#"

#27"6 #12,2,"#,

@> !(",$"#,"/(#1"*1", ,""77$"#,"#,

> ! 24#1,2"4" #1".&#,7#,&,272###1 &2# > !#172.#1"##1="$#".&#7"'"/ 4"'##/,#2.,#17,6&#&26#17,$' #1 &#(#1#2"&2#,7"2"#2,2,"#, !(,$,,#1 "77$"# #127,# 2#"*6"$#"6"##1"*"

21 # #1 ", "77$"# 41$1 4" ,7, ", #1 2,2 $1"6,#172#27## &2#12&/.##1"##1&2#1","2",'#12,2 ,"#, @> !(,2$#,#1#2"&2##,#2.#1&##",6 ".&#"72#1$"$&"#",#", 7,26&7&$1&( #1#2"&2#2,2,#1"##1".&# (>@(!

!;)

(41$11",# /,7&#,/'#1"*",(#12 2(,2$#,#1, ,"## 2"#1".&###1=## @ ))A<426'2$2,,"@ #12,2?,7#,4#1#1"*#11"7 #"24"# 5614#1"72, !,"'1#2"&2#"#$,#1"##1

' ".&#"2",'#,,7#,4#1#1&2#/2",# #1$2$&.#"$(#172#27##1"/ ,#1 62&,#1"##127",6 ",#1,2$# #1 "77$"#","' #17",6(#1".&#",#2.,/'#1 #2"$&2#1",/2.##,1",.4"'B&"#11"21 #2"&2#1"#7,2,&7#1$"$&"#1#(=&2 ;@ "##"$1, 4#1 #1 72# 2 7##( "$$2,6 # 41$1 #1 &##",6 ".&# "2 #1" 41"# 1" / #$, #1 .7&6,2,21&##7,61#2"&2#&61### 1"7",#12,2"##"#".&##,$26#1&# &2#12&/.

##1"#,&/#(#1&2##12,2 ,"#, >> ! 1", /2, #1"# #1 "* 1", "$*4,6, #1 ".&# 1"2 27,#"24"#561'6,7#,4#1#( /&##1B&"# $"# #11"2"."##2 ,7&#(41$11"# /=".,/'#1&2#",#12,21"/7", &2#12&/.##1"# #1#2"&2#(417"6#1 .7&6, 2,2( .2' 2, &7 #1 #"#.# "$$&#( ( ,$&.# 72,&$, /' 27,# 7# #1 7$ $ ,2$#6/'#1&2##6772#&#' 1"26##1"* ",72,&$,$&.

2##6;", #1.7&6,2,2

( -2-"'"*-"#1&2("2,$&"77"26/1"

27,# &/.##1"#$#1"*1","2",'",.##,#1 1"2 27,# #142###"#.#(#124",# 72$, &2#12#1&#12,2&,2$1"67",' #1/" #1",.",#1&2#1","2",'#$,#1 "$# #12,2,"#,>> !/'#"*6#1", 72 2,2 & ) 126"#'",722#'#12,21".&# 2,2,#/2",$22$#",#12,7&###1". 12=$7"'.# #1".&#1"*&$"2'

,$"#6#1=7$&22,#1$# #6"##$(41$1 $"#/ "#,&7#127,#$#1"*1","2",' 2$,#1=$".&#/'6#1.2#6"6,7272#1 "*$"#4#11,#1=$".&# 221'.22"",( #1&(&26#1&2# 2"

2.6#1 ,6 1" 1"2, #1 "2, $& 2 #1 7"2# ", "772",#17"72/*

2#1"* /2#'(#172"#7"2# #12,2,"#, >> !7", !) !",2,2,"#, @> !

7", ) !) !2",#1&%;

!"#!$ %

& '( & !

)

,-#

)

+0 *

"1!'234%+!15

0 *

#& '6$7 "1!'

3 !

"1!'

234%+!15

234%+!85

#& '6$7 "1!' 9 "1!'

"1!'

/ 1.7&6,2,2,#2 $##1"77$"# ., 27$# ,2$#$#",#12,2,"#, @> !12 2"2#12 2$6#72&.2"&.#1"##1"*1", /6772#&#'#729$##$"27$# #1$"$&"# 1#<=&2 ;@?"##"$1,4#1#127##"#7"6 ) #"."##2 2$2,#1"#=&2 ; @ ) !)

!", ;@#172#27##"2,#$"",#1 #2"&2#1".2'2,&7#1$"$&"# 7"#

!# ""."##2 2$2,#1"#$,&26#17,$' #12 7##(#1".&#"2,2,/'#1#2"&2#1"/2", 4#1&#2,26 22 &, #1".&#,.#"77272"##,2$# #1#2"&2##,#2.#1&##",6".&#/'2 226##1 $"$&"#1#"

#2"

2,6772#&#'##1"*26"2,6#1 &##",6 ".&# B&" @ ))A 1"2 27,# "24"# 5611#2"&2#.#272#6#1/2"#6#1 2,2,"#,>> !4#126"2,##1"6,",.#142## #"#.#1",. #11"2(/&##&##",6".&# $" "',7&#4#126"2,##1$"$&"#&/.##,/'#1 7"2###1(#1&2#9,&7"/6"##=".#1 ".",#12"

#22,2 22" #1".&#",$"#/4"', "4"'4#1#1$"$&"# #17"2#'$"#1".&#2,2, #/2",(1"/2",( ,. # "77272"# # & ,2$# # #1 #2" &2# # ,$, #1 $#22' 2 ,#2."# #1 ".&# B&" #1 1"2 27,# "24"#561((@ ))A "$$2,"$4#1"4"

#262"#6 772#&#'##17"2###1$"#1".&#6#1 $"$&"#&/.##,/'#127,# &,#/$22$#(2,2

4&,/2B&2,#/7",(/&# #1$#2"2'(#1$"$&"# &,#/$22$#(#1#2"&2#1"7"""77272"#2,2 2 2 &, #1".&##", "6#17"2##*,$"#

#12 62"$ #12 #12&61 6 #1 2 2 ,7,# "77$"#2,2#$&##1$# #6"#",#.

7## #", ,7, #2. #1 "

2.#,,2$#

*+#'

,! "- ./01

"121.3/4 56./ 7 86

"121.3 .2/9 86