← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/1544/2013dismissed

Parminder Singh v. State Of Haryana

2017-08-09Mr. Justice S.J. Vazifdar,Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri16 pages



    

 

   !

"""""

  #$%

&!

'!

(!



 

  

 ) *



 

    

 """""

+,% +-. /0 ,!

12340 4!

!3!

,-- +-. /0 ,!

12340

,  3-5 3-2

$% 

          !"## $%!&    ' $   ##" $%!# 

          ##" $%!#    (   )  ***** ,  3-5 3-261!

 ,(         -   (   ,(   !.

%/ $%!&  0 

 

  1( 0 - 0   ( 

  

2   !"## $%!&3 (  &%$    4   2   54 53   

  $% %/ $%!&  (     -   !% %%%6- ( (    (   -

 , -   7( 

(    

 

        7(   



   0

 ' ##"   $%!#             0   289 $3  0 

 :4 ' !#/  !;

%"

$%!% -   (  &%#6&# 4     '   0  8         (< 7 

                       

     !""#          ##      #$# 

! ##    %   &$ !

"      "          #        !  "  !""#   ! #" ' #! 

"       (   ! )!   $     !

"!*      !    $   "           +" "#       !+,            "

 

#,!   

  

 

       -   -   +$  -

+ ,##! "  ! . /, 0!. ! $

 !  "

      "  !

!"     "   ! ( -1  - !

-23##,   

$#    " #                   # 

"

    !

 4      % &        ("

#

"    "  " 

5 !

"!

    !  ,      "

   ("

  $    #    "!!$#   , !    "   )      ,) ! "!" "  ","!   

 !$   #      6 (  

    -   !;

%/ $%!%  )4

 

 

(           (0    (  !;&      ( !/;& 2   = 

=3   

   :    ( 0 (

 &%#6&%$ 4 9 ( 0 0  (  

  -    (     %!

%/ $%!%



>  ( $"# (   0  

(

    ( 0 (  &%#6&# 4   (

-

    !# %/ $%!%  - 

   ( 

  >     !% !$ $%!%   (  

  (  &%$6&# 4  -

+     (  9 $! -

?-  2@!3 -        , 2   3



2@$3 0       ?( 2@&3 (     

 

2@/3        '

2@!%3  (,0 '    +- 0 

A 

(  2@!$3

  (,0 ' 

1    A( '  )(

2@!.3

, 2@!;3

  B +(  0   )(   2@!/3

(   :

  >0   (0  @        

0 1 

2@#3

       89 C

0  ' 2@"3

          

   0  !;

%"

$%!%

0    2@.3 -        - :

> ?  !C %.

$%!%

0  

2@;3 -           (

         -     :

>  (0 ?  !;

%"

$%!% D !.

%.

$%!%

4  ?( 2@C3

 (   9     0   ,                  -       

  89    4  B 4 



2@!&3     (  !;& 

 %C %C $%!%



  23 2@!#3      :4 289 !;3    89 !C  0 ' ?( 2@!"3     '  - -     -   , 0 4 6 B  ?(     :

>

 (0 

  9  4 -  2@!C3     -    - 4 6 B  ?(  (07(  !C %.

$%!%   - (  

      

(     !"

%%%6   0 

(  

 &% %;

$%!% 0   (

  (,0 '  A( '    

(   4   ?( 23 2@$%3

           (  !;# 

$&3 (

  289 #%3

 (   9    0       89 $$   

( 

 !C %"

$%!% -  (  (  289 !%3   ((       - (   289 !!  !$3  (     (    

( (  &!& 

-    - 

    0        

-  

 9 (

 &!& 

  (< E7# 7 "$# 7      #          "  (   """

 "! 

#,!"# #$    , 8!7   !

 

8

"!

  #   7    , 8!    #$   # !  $# !""  $  # , $! $! $!" ,8!,$   #"  "#! #   4/  7 9              $   #,!   "  :#!

#   6 4   

( 9 %" -     A ( 2 @!3 , ?(  (- 2 @$3  (

 2 @&3

(   ?

  1 2 @#3 F    ,(  2 @"3  '(  0 

4    

(  (    289 A3  

  

   , >  (         0   

    (    

(    (  &%$ 4 0(  7(   0 

 0  (0  

(              

(  -     (      (     0   

> (  

   (     (  -    

(  &%$ 4             0                ( 0 (  &%$ 4

4  (   (   

(  

(

        ( ' &!$

;

0  - 

     (  0(   -  0   (         0     0   -    (          > (     (   (    



(    ,(   0 

, 2@!;3G 0(      9 ,( 0G   -     0        (          9    ,(             0  

  89  289 $#  89 $"3 - 

 (     9    

(  

    (          (

  (   0          4    (       -     

 9 (  @ 289 !3  $$ !% $%%C  0 07( 7(         -     (        -  

  ?( 2@&3 -   -       (              ( 4    (        

-  

        7(     0   4  (   (     !"

%%%6 0 

 

(      

(    -G 0(  ( - ( (  "% %%%6 - 

-  0     

   0   0(    (  0 H  (  "% %%%6   (  !"

%%%6  

'

(

   (  -   (( -

    !"

%%%6    

(    6     (   0          0 ( 0   ?( 2@&3 B       (   (           (     (0        (         (  



      (  &%$ 4

   ((     

   

2@$3  0( !<%%      



  !.6!;

%"

$%!%   , 2   3   G 0(                     (   #<%%      (        

( 

-  (

   ( -       



2@$3         

   0    (    -   0     ( 

 -    289 $3          - (         ?( 2@&3 -            - (  (0       

0  (

  ?( 2@&3 - -            G 0(   (   0 (   -    (  (   (  ,(     

&

 (       0 (23   0  ?- 

2@!3 -          ,

 0     

2@$3  

    - 0   

(  -  (  

(  ,      

  

(  -  (     

( -     (  0            

( 0(   0,  

7(    @!

  (      0 "% %%%6   ?( 2@&3 -    (0        0( (    (       ( - ( (  9

0    2@.3              (    

(        (07(      :

 >0 ?  !C %.

$%!%

 

2@/3    - -   (   (   -    89 !%  0

 

 $% %"

$%!!          (   289 !!  89 !$3   -                 ' 2@!%3  A 

(  2@!$3

  

      (,0 '        !"

%%%6  !"

%"

$%!%    

(    0 

2@$3 )(   2@!/3 (   :

>  (0



 

(0   89 &C   - 6 (   

    , 4   ?( 2 3 2@$%3 -  4  B         7(  (

 !;# 

 -       !C %"

$%!% -       0 - (    !!  !$  ((    (  289 !%3  0  

 -  (      (   

B6C3          ( (0   ((    -        7(    (  (  !;#



  0   0   4  B       0 -         -    (  0 - H (  (      - 0(      

0              

 4 -  0       ,( - 0    0 4       0  (    (

  (<

, 2@!;3   B +(  0

  - , (     9 289 $!3     0     !;

%"

$%!%  0( #<&%  

 - 0(

    -         ,( 0 (0   0       9    ( - ,(< ;

 "5"4< #"

"#$$ "  -"  #

"





"6 4         (      - (  -  #I$          - (

0   0(     -      

  89        ( ;7!$ #!"  #!   "4< 9  "

"  !  #    #"! =! *$,$ #!# "$ "##: 86  ( 0- ,(    - - - (   

  89 -        89 $#  89 $"

 (   89 $#      -               89 0 !  #            (< >: ?

-     #  $" #

   

  ;@!  @  $8   ;/"  4  ;

    (! "? 9  "  :      

 "#$ #6 :(  (   89 $"    (  89 !

 89 .            (<

 

>: ?

- 2$#,  # ,  #!  A"     #!! 9

  2$#,  #    #! " $  8  2$#,  # , "  #! 8 4 2$#,  #  !#! $   $#, #   $ 8

 2$#,  # $#"##, # % & 8 B 2$#,  # $#"  #! / (! "? - 9  " : .-AB     

 "#$ -   9   "    :  . 

 4  A    $    " !! $6     

  89 

   -        (   - (  E  ,(   7(J (

9

      -     ,(  ( ' !%    7(     -  9   ,(                     0  -  

 - 

-  (    -  -       -   (6  (      0-   0  -

 -     (

    0  ,(  0 0 (   (  

 

     0,  -      (   (  0    0,  -      

 ,(                0 0 (  ((    0(         6   -  -       ((  0  -   0  ,( 0( (    E     ,( ( 0 0 0   ,(J 4  (   0   -   ,(   0  

     0,  -       9   E7(J - 

     7(      0 

 (  0   -  (             (  -      -          0 (    -

 (  ,( #I$

     (

    -   ,( (   (       (   (( 9   

  89     

, 2@!;3   

  (      - E  ,(   7(J   ,( ( 0 0 0           0, -       -    (  

0 (  (        ( 0  (    

         

(    ,(   7( '-    7(       - 

 (   ,(           0 9 0          -       



        

 

 - , 2   3        0( #  -    (   (

    !%.    4 8       (    (  0   9   -  

(   ,(         ( 

  -  

 9 (  &!& 

    -     -

 -         -     (  

(  0         0(      , 0(  

   -       

 0

   

        

(                  

  -     !

%%      

      # %%       ( 0(        (    -       

               -   

-        -    ( ,(           0 -    (

  (  0( -      23  - 23   (  0      

(  ,    ( ( 0



-  -    

          -       0 

 0   ( -    

 (    C;    ,(         E   



  (    (  &%#  4    ( (             ( 0    (0 -  -          J

           

  89  89 $" - 

      ( -  ((    - (    

              0  9   -   ( (0

          ( (0  -    ((      (       - 

 ( 

7(   0  (                 (   - 0(

 -      ( 8  -  (            ( (0 - 

 ( 0 (  $;    4 8     

               -   -      -     

         ((           

       0 

   7(                   -      (         (           0  0  (0  

(                 

(   (           0     (        (0    7(    0 

( 

   ##" $%!#  0   

8

       0 

  (      0(     -  0    (  7(    2  !"##  $%!&3  0 

 

)4!

!3!

,--* ),  3-5 3-2*

1250

1250

&!

'!

(!

 @    6 < A6' @   0 < A6'