High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2251/2004disposed of

Gurcharan Singh Andors v. State Of Hry

2024-02-01Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary7 pages

!"# $%&%'%!(%% % %' %!

)*+,-./,0121-3 4 4 -513/,61375*3/-+5,62 4444488,99*3+2 :,62;2 +*+,-.*6<*3* 44444,28-3/,3+

=;605*6*31375*3/-+5,62 4444488,99*3+2 :,62;2 +*+,-.*6<*3**3/*3-+5,6 44444,28-3/,3+2

!%>? @&A >!B$ C

%>% % '%!( 6,2,3+ 64*7*677*6D*9E/F-0*+,.-6+5,*88,99*3+213

4 64G-F,H,,+--31*E/F-0*+,.-6*88,99*3+I-24E +- 13

4 88,*914,4

J;**88,99*3+I-24*3/ 2+*3/2*K*+,/F1/,-6/,6/*+,/

L4 4 88,*914,4

J;**88,99*3+I-24EL*3/ 2+*3/2*K*+,/F1/,-6/,6/*+,/ M4 4 4 64N*7/125*305*3/*E//94=E*6<*3*4 OOOO %>% % '%!(P$B 4 5*99,37, 13 +5, 86,2,3+ *88,*92 12 +- +5, H;/7Q,3+R-6/,6 /*+,/ 4 4

E 8*22,/ K< +5, 9,*63,/ //1+1-3*9 ,221-32 N;/7,E S;6;T25,+6*ED5,6,K<*88,99*3+2D,6,0-3F10+,/*3/2,3+,30,/*2;3/,6 00;2,/*88,99*3+213

..,30,;R2 UQ8612-3Q,3+ V13, ),.*;9+2,3+,30, LU U.-6-3,<,*6 6,*/ D1+5 U U.-6+56,, <,*62 24

R U.-621WQ-3+52

) ,,

; 3+,$!

+ 2$ :%

53 3%!!

" & ) -$ 3 3%!-!" #

; 3%!+!

"# #

%$#

&# #' ( )

!( * + + )

+ ! ,!$ -

.-$ $ % +$" ++/ - ,! .$ .

)

+ # ) /- +# !$ ) $ .

) !

)

) /!- ! +# 1 %' ( ) - )+$)$ !,$ # 23

+!/.$) .

)# # %

!+,$!

!% 4$.

' %$

) $!

### , ) !

) ,,

%$ )$ .

,$+ %

) $!

5' ' &'

5' & ) -$ $!

3 - % +)

) $!

5' ' &' ' ' ) -$ $!

3 - % +)

) $!

!% +

6!#7 )$ $ .'!-$ ", )) !. $"

) $+)$ #

# 1 ,! $!

!) ! /$ . !+ . $ !%

) 8 +$ )

) 5 9

)

, $4"#

! !% $ 4$)

' + !%

) - !))

) $!

!% ### 1" ) $)

$+$

$ .

,, )

+ ,! $!

-$ , )$ . % $+,$

/" ,!$ # )%

) 8 +$ )

)5:9$

)

, $4"# # 1

) $ !

% .

)

%! , $' 4$ )

)

) ,,

!$ ) /!4#

!!"#$ % &' #($')# * "

+')"$ ! &' #(

!!"#$, # #(

- ')#$ #,

) +(!!

" #' #( +'"

+#'" "

- &'

)+" #( "# "+ .

#' #(

!!"#$ "

/+ # #(

!!"#$, .(' (

$"+

#' #(

- )"

, # % "

-$0 1'"#(,

-$0

-$0 1'"#($,

-$0 1'"#(,

-$0

-$0 1'"#(,

-$0

-$ +#

!-0 "

!!"#$ "

/+ # #(

!!"#$, .(' (

$"+

#' #(

- )"

, # % "

-$ '&

!!"# 2'$,

, , "

'" #( ')"

#(# #( - % !'" #' #( '' $## '& #( $'+ #-0 $'!

.""

'& #( &1! $0 "'# "

" "- '#( +$ 0 "

1$)$

#( +'"+ $$'" '& %!0 !#

+( '#( 0 $ " " #( $1

+"#-0 +'1 '1$ .$ !$'

# % #.

#( 1 "

(

&+" #( '"- '& '#+#

#! &' #( !$# $ 3( - (

!$' $)%1##

#(# #( ++)$

!!"#$

- #' +'1 "$# #( "4)

#( '#( ("

, "

## +')"$ ! $)%1#$ #(# #( #! ')# &# +#" #(

%- #( '$ +)#'", ($ (#!- +'"

"# "+

!!"#$, #( &' , -$ &' #(

$1$$! '& #( "#

!$ , ('.

, &&1$ #( "'""

"# '& #(

!!"#$ " "- '#( +1"! +$ "

#( '

%-#( 1 #( !

+')"$ !'" #( $

#( +'

"#!-, 7"'4 8)1, "4)

, " ($

'$#'" +&+!!- "1

!!"#$'("

"( "

'#( $ "

#( '!

$, ( " +)$

"4) $ #' (1 "

($ &1!- 1% $, .(+( $#''

+''%'#

%- 73 4 ! 3( *$ '& #( "4)

!$' '

%- 79 )1" ()("

" '" #(')( #(

"+ '" +' , #( '$ +)#'" ($ '

#( +$ "$#

&% '%# #'# & '$ ($ ) #&%#(( ( &% & $% ##$*(+,#$ %!# !&"$#&% *$&$% $ ! (

%'# #,# '%# #(!&$ )

& %'

% #$%( #(, (#)% &% &# (" $ .%!

( + .%#.$ % /0 #'# & % 1!()/ 2 34567822 975:7;22 <5=22 >?7?4@2

.#$ 0$ ) *$.

% ) ,# (

& ( '#%/ ( %' &$( "

*# /$ ( #$*$ ) %' % &% *$&$% +$

& %' $/#$ % / (# &$% B - %' B ,# . #(!&( % #$%( #(, (#)% $ (, ##$ ( +%! /% ( (, % #$ 2 C467D84;22 >EFG622 <5=22 >?7?422 HI22 JKFL782 B

A$ MB" $ %!# (" & %' &% *$&$% (# &$% B -" &%

$(#$% %' &$#&!/ & &&!

( ( '&( )% , %' #%#&( #$ '%#

/%# ,# N . '$# %'' (#N

% +#( # # '/$ ,N

% &( %'

$/$ #

!#" 0

$ *$. '!##$ ) &!

%' 1!

$& ( #(!&(

& '#%/ % ,# ( ' % #$%( %' % /% ( $# (, " #(,!

(#)% #)#( &% *$&$% (# &$% - &% &# (" #'# & & + /( %2 O7D22 3KD7;22 7FP22 QFH?64;22 <5=22 >?7?422 HI22 R7;S7F72 #$/$ T%

%' " (&$(( % " .#$

( )$*

$ + %.

( .# !

&% *$&( (# &$%

U" %.*# % V+ !#/ %!# .$ &%

$(#$ ) '& ,# ( (

& ( %' &$( @2 #(!&( $#

& % #$%( #(, (#)% +, / $

$W .0 %! %' ,# X!##" 2 97:Y664P22 <5=22 >?7?422 HI22 Z=J=2 M

#$ " &&!

( . &% *$&( (# &$% -" % V+ !#/ %!# #(!&(

& % #$%( #(, (#)% %! %' ,# %' #$)%#%!

$/#$ % / " +, %+ #*$ ) M ,# (

( ., (

!"# $%%

! &" "'

! $ !

$(!

!$%! $ " "! &"%)!!(! "!

!$**!)!

)$ + + ",)%! ! !.! " / 01231441// 567// 8919:// ;<// =1>2191?1@/

A # & !!

! $**! &$ *"(* ! $ ! !*! ! !* " # $

$ $$% !

! *". %$$ &

"!# & %! ")!(

! $ !%%$

$ ! "! $

$ !.$! * "B '" $)" $B $ $%"

! *! B!$

$ $!#

! ! !*! $%!$B ! "! )B

! $ !%%$ &$ ''*! $ $!C$ !

! '$* $ **.

$*!"'

!*$!+ + D/ 0;E1F1G// H12I<// J// 0K22;// HK661I2FIL1// 8E1I?E// 567// 8919:// ;</ / MK31>19/

! $ !%%$ &$ *"(* ! ! !* " D '" $ ! !*! "' . ".! "' B!$ '"

( $

*P )%"& "

!$ "'

! *". %$$ # & * &$ !*!

B!$ )B

! !%%$ ! " + ! ! !*! &$ *"(! !

$%!$B ! "!# & * &$ "! $ $

$%' ."

! *!

$ "**! ."!

$ B!$ )$*P $

! QB &$ '"

" )!. %!$ !+ + " / R1>G::4// =KF1>// 567// 8919:// ;<// RK231S/ #

!*! " T$$B

O# & !!

! $**! &$ *"(* ! ! !* " D# !*!

! ! !*!

$%!$B ! "!# +!+ A $B " "' .$U.. .! "'

"' "" . ".! # $

! "!

$ '$*!

! "B "'

$% '" B!$+ .%$%B / V>3K2// 12G// W9E:>6// 567// 8919:// ;<// H1>L121@/

O# !*! "

+ A+ #

! ! !*! $&$!

! $**!$ !%%$ # & &!! *"(* ! ! !* " X # X $ A D '" D "' B!$# &$ !*!

! !U ! "' $%!$B ! "!# & %! ")!(

! $ !%%$

$ $%!$B ''!! ! !*! "' ."

# $B $$B! !* (!%B$'$*!

!$ "B"' $%'"$%."

B!$+

#$ %&'

()(" *+, -. /$) !#) $0 1

234 1 564 7889:4; <7: 8=>3854; 9;4? 4853= 7; =@AB4 564 9C?4D4 =9?5 ?4;984; 564 :45484 =E 56?44 F47?: 5= D=56: 7; ;7F:1 AF 8=:3;4?3G 5675 564 =889??484 5==H CB784 3 7; 64 <7: =5 7 67A3597B =EE4;4?1?7564?7E3?:553D48=>385 I9?564?D=?41 3 J-$ !"

#$ ) ! ) -($"

%&'

()(" -. K L)MN O 9CC 564 :45484 =E 8=7889:4;1 8=>3854; 9;4? 4853= 1 <7: D=;3E34; AF 6=B;3G 5675 = 9:4E9B C9?C=:4 <3BB A4 :4?>4; AF :4;3G 63D 5= P73B 7E54? F47?: E?=D 564 ;754 =E 383;451 3 >34< =E 564 E785 5675 64 <7: =BF F47?:=B;75567553D4 O

$) Q) R)S %&'

()(" -. T)L)&($) ?3D4:

1 564 7889:4; <7: 8=>3854; 9;4? 4853= 7; :45484; E=? 56?44 F47?:1 564 3G6 =9?51 AF 46783G 564 E341 5= A4 C73; 5= 564 3P9?4;1 ?4;984; 63: :45484 5= 564 C4?3=; 7B?47;F 9;4?G=4 AF 63D1 57H3G 35= 8=:3;4?753= 5675 64 67; =5 8=DD3554;7F=564?=EE484 U63: =9?5 3 V)S!"%

#$ %&'

()(" -. W) X) ) 1

B34 O1 AF E=BB=<3G 564 ;3859D 3 Y)& %&'

()(" -. +(() K )!"&$N

1 7; 563: =9?5 3 J)L-

#$ %&'

()(" -. W) X) )N

?3D37B 7; Z)#!""[

#$ \ Y""( %&'

()(" -. K L)MN

?3D4:

7; 8=:3;4?3G 564 D353G753G 83?89D:5784:1 ?4;984; 564 :45484 =E 5647889:4;5=564C4?3=;7B?47;F9;4?G=4AF63DU64?4B4>75C7?7:?47;569: ]O

E 8=9?:41 564 =9?5 3: 8=:83=9: =E 564 D33D9D :45484 =E F47?: C?4:8?3A4; 9;4? 4853= =E 564 ?D: 85 U64 =^ AB4 9C?4D4 =9?5 3 _7:3? > 5754 =E `557? ?7;4:61

1 7; 563: =9?5 3 7P=? 3G6 > 5754 =E 7?F771

?3D37B 7; a7G;44C 3G6 b _4459 > 5754 =E 9P7A1

?3D4:

67>4 57H4 7 B4345 >34< 4>4 3 564 E784 =E D33D9D :45484 C?4:8?3A4; 9;4? 4853= =E 564 ?D: 85 7; ?4;984; 564 :45484 5= 564 C4?3=; 7B?47;F 9;4?G=4 3 564 :C4837B E785: 7;83?89D:5784:=E56=:487:4:

!"# # !

$"%! &%!'#

(

) *#%"# # #

!'!

'% '#

'#+ # #

!,$) %!

!%! '

$' %. '# /% ) 0$'#$+ # ,' ( ) $

' '# ' & 1#! '# %$$! '%%2

*# %$$! #

! '# ) $

( !

!"# '% ,

! '% !

$"% '# !3- $ -%$' %! %. !'! &-% /) '# '$

%$' 1%

. ! ' ) # $& '# - .

. '#) #

#%! '%

.'$ /$) !" '# $

%!" !& ') 0%$

'# $ %!+ '# , "&!' %. %! ' %! /) '# '$

%$'

!"# '

%!. $& ' '# !'! &-% %! # & $ '% '# -$ %

) !

$"%! /) # & *# . !

' !'! &-% /) '# '$

%$' .%$ '# %..! !

$ ' %! 4

' %! %. $& ' '

%!. $& 4. '# . !

&%!' !%'

1 '# ! %! &%!'# .$%& '#

' %. '# , "&!'+

!"# #

$"% '#

' !'! &-% /) '# '$

%$' .%$ '# $-' %..!5 & ! '

) 1 !"+ '#

!' # !" ..$ '# "!%& !) %. '$

%!"6 .

) %.. '# $ $ &-$%!! ! !'

$! !" %.

%!6 '# $ % %%!%& $&'

!+ '# %$' . !

3'! ' %! '% / &- ' *#+ ' 1%

$ '# !

%. ,' '% $ '# $ !'! '% '# -$ %

) !

$"%!+ 1# !# ! !" '# . ! !

.$%& +

7 '% +

7 #+ 1# # #

'% '# !,$ + & )+ !%, 8& $+ *,-

+ !"

' &+

/ $ !"#

& !"#

.$%&

7 '%

7 #+ 1# # #

'% '# !,$ ! '#

%&-! ' %! !

$ ' %! $+ 1 '# !

-$ % %. '1% &%!'#+ .

!" 1# #+ '# -$!'

& '% # /!

& *# %$ $ %. !'!

&% . '% '#

.%$

3'!' #+'#-$!'

- $'

)

%1 #%'%%-)%.'# %$ $/-

%!'#%!!' .

:;<;=9>?;@A?;BCD9

#%2 E@AFG9 H#'#$- 2 !"7$ %! I7J% H#'#$$-%$'

/ I7J%