High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/931/2010disposed of

Baljinder Singh v. State Of Haryana

2015-02-24Bench- 4,Registrar-Judicial9 pages

!"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 3

3 !

66',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"$"#"',/7+(-8$"#1+&'%#( 7+&1$ 7'%7.-+#97,6-+:16$#(7+(,#+$#+6#(7,8-..-9,

+(#%#6$1-+5;

-'+(#%)- 8-%.18#7+($-07<781+#-8 =1+(#87'.$$-'+(#%)-8'%$"#%

8-%>*-+$",

+(#%#6$1-+5

-'+(#%)- 8-%;<#7%,7+($-07<781+# -85=1+(#87'.$$-'+(#%)-8'%$"#% 8-%*-+$",

+(#%#6$1-+4?

-'+(#%)- 8-%5<#7%,7+($-07<781+# -8=1+(#87'.$$-'+(#%)-8'%$"#% 8-%*-+$",

#"7,6"7..#+)#($"#6-+:16$1-+7+(,#+$#+6#07,,#(/<$"# $%17. -'%$1+

45-8 +&'%#( 7+&1$7'%7+("#%*1+-% (7')"$#%"7:#0%#8#%%#(

440%7<1+)8-%6-*0#+,7$1-+ 8-%$"#1+&'%1#,,"#,',$71+#(1+$"#-66'%%#+6#

"#67,#-8$"#0%-,#6'$1-+0%-&#6$#($"%-')"!? 7+&1$7'% 1, $"7$ 766',#( 7.&1+(#% 1+)" 9"- 1, $"# "',/7+( -8 !? %#6#1:#( 1+,$%'6$1-+,$"%-')"$#.#0"-+#8%-*"1,07%#+$,766',#(+(#%1+)"7+( 7*7.&1$ 7'%7+($"#%#78$#%"#67')"$"-.(-8!?7+(0%#,,#("#%+#6@ 7+()7:#81,$/.-9,-+"#%876# "#97,.71((-9+1+7%--*7+($"# 766',#()7:#7+#.#6$%16,"-6@91$"#.#6$%16%-( "#766',#((#*7+(#(7 ,'*-8.76,/'$!?%#8',#($-8'.81.."1,(#*7+( !?97,0%#)+7+$7$ $"#$1*#-8-66'%%#+6#

! '%*##$1+)"1,$"#87$"#%-8!? 7+&1$7'% #"7( ,#$$"#.791+*-$1-+/<.-()1+)$"#81%,$1+8-%*7$1-+%#0-%$-+5 ?

8-%$"#-66'%%#+6#9"16"$--@0.76#-+;

#"7,(#0-,#($"7$ !?97,*7%%1#($-766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"-+ ?

..(-9%< 7%$16.#,1+6.'(1+)737%'$167%9#%#)1:#+$-766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"7$$"# $1*#-8*7%%17)# '$$"#37%'$167%)1:#+$-766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"97,

5 "7+(#(-:#%$-7,91+(#%1+)"

66',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"(#*7+(#(7 .'A'%< 67% 7+( ,$7%$#( $7'+$1+) 7+( "7%7,,1+) "1, (7')"$#% # 7.,- 0"<,167..<7,,7'.$#(!?

#"7,(#0-,#($"7$766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)" 7$$#*0$#($-6-**1$$"#*'%(#%-8"1,(7')"$#%/<,$%7+)'.7$1+)"#%7+( 7.,-/<)1:1+)7+#.#6$%16,"-6@$-"#%

!> $

B% C3 "7+,0-@#7/-'$$"#7(*1,,1-+-8 !?-+;

?91$"/'%+1+&'%1#,-+$"#.#8$,1(#-8$"#7/(-*#+

66',#( 7.&1+(#% 1+)" 7+( #0-< '@"0%##$ 1+)" /%-')"$ "#% 8-% 7(*1,,1-+ "#%1)"$#<#-8!?97,8-'+(/.76@#+#( >

! -.

B% C*1$"7%*7)7:#7+-01+1-+A $-$"# #88#6$$"7$$"#1+&'%1#,,',$71+#(/<!?9#%#.18#$"%#7$#+1+)1+&'%1#,7+( 6-'.(%#,'.$1+"#%(#7$"

+"1,-01+1-+A 7+(A ="#-01+#($"7$ $"#07$1#+$97,+-$81$$-*7@#7+<,$7$#*#+$ ;

!5 $

B% C .-@ "7%*7 ,0-@# 7/-'$ $"# $%#7$*#+$ )1:#+$-!?7+("#%(1,6"7%)#-+ 4 #7.,-%#,0-+(#($-$"# #+D'1%1#,*7(#/<$"#1+:#,$1)7$1+)-881617.$"7$!?97,'+81$$-*7@#7+< ,$7$#*#+$ #7.,-+-$#($"7$!?"7(8%76$'%#,-8$9-'00#%$##$"

!47%$7%1+)""7(1+:#,$1)7$#($"#67,#7+(81.#(781+7. %#0-%$

+"1,,$7$#*#+$'+(#%#6$1-+55 %

766',#(7.&1+(#% 1+)""7,,$7$#($"7$"#97,1++-6#+$/'$"#97,87.,#.<1*0.167$#(1+$"# 0%#,#+$67,# #(1(+-$,'88#%7+<(1,6.-,'%#,$7$#*#+$7+(+-%#6-:#%< 7.,-97,#88#6$#(7$"1,1+,$7+6# !? 7+&1$7'%97+$#($-6-**1$ ,'161(# #"7(+-$)1:#+"#%7+#.#6$%16,"-6@"#"7,8'%$"#%,$7$#(

+$"#,1(#-8$"#(#8#+6#$"%##91$+#,,#,9#%##A7*1+#(

!#0-<7:1+(#%1+)""7,(#0-,#($"7$-+; ?9"#+"#97, 0%#07%1+)$-,#$-888-%"1,('$<"#"#7%(6%1#,8%-*$"#"-',#-8766',#( 7.&1+(#%1+)"

#9#+$7.-+)91$"'@"0%##$7+(*7(#7+7$$#*0$$- -0#+$"#(--% "#<)7:#0',"#,7+(@16@,7+($"#%#78$#%$"#(--%-0#+#(

"#<8-'+(1+$"#@1$6"#+7.7(<.<1+)-+$"#8.--% +#.#6$%16%-(81$$#(-+ $"#,91$6"97,.<1+)-+$"#%1)"$,1(#-8"#%,$-*76" '6@#$-897$#%97, .<1+)+#7%/<7+($"#97$#%97,,01..#(7%-'+("#% #,91$6"#(-88$"# #.#6$%16 6-++#6$1-+ -*#/-(<8%-*-'$,1(#%7+) '0 766',#( 7.&1+(#% 1+)"9"-7.-+)91$"'@"0%##$$--@$"#.7(<$-$"#"-,01$7.8-%$%#7$*#+$

!537&-%7%7+1+)"(#0-,#($"7$766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)" 9"-97,,#%:1+)7,7#0-<1+$"#*1.1$7%<97,-+('$<-+; ?

# #+D'1%#( 1+$- $"# 1+61(#+$ 7+( 67*# $- @+-9 $"7$ !? 7+&1$ 7'% ,',$71+#(/'%+1+&'%1#,-+"#%.#8$7/(-*#+('#$-"#%6-+$76$91$"$"# #.#6$%161**#%,1-+%-( #0-<7.&1+(#%1+)"97,+-$7$"1,"-*# $97, 7+7661(#+$1+9"16"!?,',$71+#(1+&'%<

"#$%17. -'%$"7:1+)$"-%-')".<7(:#%$#($-$"##:1(#+6#-+ %#6-%( 67*# $- $"# 6-+6.',1-+ $"7$ 766',#( 6-**1$$#( 6%'#.$< /< (#*7+(1+)(-9%<7+(67',#()%1#:-',1+&'%<-+"#%*-'$"7+($"#%#78$#% 7$$#*0$#($-67',#"#%(#7$"/<)1:1+)"#%7+#.#6$%16,"-6@ "#$%17. -'%$ %#&#6$#($"#0.#7-8$"#766',#($"7$!?*7(#7+7$$#*0$$-6-**1$ ,'161(#

!? 7+&1$7'%"7(,',$71+#(#A$#+,1:##.#6$%16/'%+1+&'%1#, -+ "#% ,$-*76" 9"#+ ,"# 97, 0%#)+7+$ /< E *-+$", "# "7, 67$#)-%167..<(#0-,#($"7$766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"*7(#7(#*7+(-8 .76, "#"7(+-$766#(#($-"1,%#D'#,$ "#%#8-%#766',#(7.&1+(#%

1+)"7$$76@#("#%-+"#%*-'$"7+(67',#(1+&'%< #7.,-0%#,,#("#% +#6@7+($"#%#78$#%"#)7:#7+#.#6$%16,"-6@-+"#%7/(-*#+

! '%*##$ 1+)" 1, $"# 87$"#% -8 !? # "7, 7.,- 67$#)-%167..<,0-@#+7/-'$$"#(#*7+(-8(-9%<7+($"#1..$%#7$*#+$*#$#( -'$$-!?

"##:1(#+6#-8!% *1$"7%*7!5% .-@"7%*7 7+(!>% 3 "7+9-'.()-$-#,$7/.1,"$"7$!?9"-,',$71+#( )%1#:-',#.#6$%16/'%+1+&'%1#,-+"#%7/(-*#+97,$-$7..<'+81$$-,'88#% 7+<,$7$#*#+$ -9-+(#%! '%*##$1+)"9"-97,/<$"#,1(#-8 !?$--@7/-'$8-'%(7<,$-.-()#$"#81%,$1+8-%*7$1-+%#0-%$ "# *#(167.#:1(#+6#6-*0.#$#.<,'00-%$,$"#:#%,1-+-81+&'%#(!?

$1,$-/#+-$#($"7$766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)",#$'070.#7$"7$ "1,918#*7(#7+7$$#*0$$-6-**1$,'161(# !"#%#7,"#.#$1+#:1(#+6# $"%-')"!7+(!5$"7$1$97,767,#-87661(#+$7.#.#6$%16/'%+, ,'88#%#(/<!?

+-$"#%9-%(,766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)""7,6-*#-'$ 91$"7,#.86-+$%7(16$-%<:#%,1-+$"%-')""1,(#8#+6#0.#7

;

!? 7+&1$7'%1,$"#918#-8766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"7+( ! '%*##$1+)"1,$"#87$"#%1+.79-8766',#( "#%#97,+-%#7,-+ 8-%$"#*$-6-*#-'$91$"87.,#1*0.167$1-+7,7)71+,$766',#(7.&1+(#% 1+)"187$7.."#"7(+-$$7'+$#(7+(*7(#7+7$$#*0$$-@1.."#% !#(-+-$ 81+(7+<%#7,-+$-%#&#6$$"#$#,$1*-+<-8!7+(!?7,%#)7%(,$"#%-.# -8766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"

#7%+#(% 6-'+,#."

#-.700#7%1+)8-%$"#766',#( 700#..7+$7.&1+(#%1+)"9-'.(,'/*1$$"7$$"#%#97,7(#.7<-88-'%(7<, 1+,#$$1+)$"#.791+*-$1-+ "#(#.7<"7,)1:#+7+7*0.#$1*#8-%$"#

> 0%-,#6'$1-+07%$<$-6--@'07,$-%<$-,'1$$"#1%6-+:#+1#+6#"#8'%$"#% ,'/*1$$#(

#7%+#( 7%<7+7 9-'.( ,'/*1$ $"7$ $"# 876$, 7+( 61%6'*,$7+6#,-8$"1,67,#9-'.()-$-,"-9$"7$!?97,+-$1+70-,1$1-+ $-,0#7@7+($"#%#8-%#$"#%#97,,-*#(#.7<1+.-()1+)$"#81%,$1+8-%*7$1-+ %#0-%$

!? 7+&1$7'%97,'+6-+,61-',7+(+-$7$7..81$$-,'88#% 7+<,$7$#*#+$7,0#%$"##:1(#+6#-8!!57+(!> :#+.-+)78$#% $"#-66'%%#+6#$"#1+:#,$1)7$1+)-881617.6-'.(+-$%#6-%($"#,$7$#*#+$-8 !?7,1$97,6-+,1,$#+$.<6#%$181#(/<$"#-6$-%,$"7$,"#97,$-$7..<'+81$ $-,'88#%7+<,$7$#*#+$ ! '%*##$1+)"97,/<$"#,1(#-8"1,(7')"$#% 9"- 97, $7@1+) 1+$#+,1:# $%#7$*#+$ 8-% $"# #.#6$%16 /'%+ 1+&'%1#, ,"# ,'88#%#( #7.,-*1)"$"7:#/##+9-%%1#(7/-'$$"#6"1.(1+$"#9-*/-8 !?

!9-'.("7:#8-6',#("1,7$$#+$1-+-+.<$-,7:#$"#.18#-8!? 7+($"#6"1.(1+$"#9-*/ "#%#8-%#(#.7<1+.-()1+)$"#81%,$1+8-%*7$1-+ %#0-%$(-#,+-$67',#7+<(#+$1+$"#67,#-8$"#0%-,#6'$1-+

#7%+#(% 6-'+,#.700#7%1+)8-%$"#700#..7+$9-'.(,'/*1$ $"7$ $"# $%17. -'%$ "7, 6-*0.#$#.< 1)+-%#( $"# (#8#+6# $"7$ 766',#( 7.&1+(#%1+)"97,-+('$<7$$"#$1*#-8-66'%%#+6#7+($"#%#8-%#"#"7( +--667,1-+$-*7@#7+<7$$#*0$$-67',#$"#(#7$"-8!?

! 7+( !5 $"# 6-..#7)'# 7+( ,'0#%1-% -8816#% -8 $"# 766',#(67*#-'$91$"7:#%,1-+$"7$1$97,-+.<-+766-'+$-87661(#+$7. #.#6$%16,"-6@!?,',$71+#(/'%+1+&'%1#, !5"7(+-$0%-('6#(7+< %#6-%($-,"-9$"#81+(1+),7%%1:#(7$/<"1* 8$#%7..!97,$"# 6-..#7)'#-8766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"

-9-+(#%"#6"-,#$-,'00-%$$"#

; (#8#+6#,#$'0/<$"#766',#( +$"#7/,#+6#-87+<(-6'*#+$7%<0%--8$- ,"-9$"7$$"##+D'1%<#*/7%@#('0-+/<!56'.*1+7$#(1+76-+6.',1-+ $"7$1$97,767,#-87661(#+$9#7%#+-$1+6.1+#($-766#0$$"##:1(#+6#-8 !7+(!5

$97,0%-&#6$#(/<766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"$"7$"#97,-+('$< 7$$"#$1*#-8-66'%%#+6# !7+(!57.,-,'00-%$#(,'6"7,$7+($7@#+ /<766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)"

"#'$<%#)1,$#%97,+-$7$7..#A"1/1$#( /#8-%#$"# -'%$ !5"7,,#$'070.#7$"7$9"#+$"# +1$97,$%7+,8#%%#( $"##+$1%#%#6-%(,9#%#(#,$%-<#( !?"7(7.%#7(<)-$.#)7.7,,1,$7+6#

66',#(7.&1+(#%1+)""7(/##+(1%#6$#($-876#$"#-%(#7.-8$%17. -'%$

#9-'.("7:#(#81+1$#.<$7@#+,-*#,$#0,$-,#6'%#76-0<-8$"#('$< %#)1,$#%$-/'$$%#,,$"#(#8#+6#0.#7,#$'0/<"1* +:1#9-8$"#7/-:#9# "7:#+-"#,1$7$1-+$-%#&#6$$"#$#,$1*-+<-8!7+(!5$"7$766',#( 97,76$'7..<-+('$<-+$"#(7$#-8-66'%%#+6#

!-86-'%,#,0-@#7/-'$$"#876$$"7$"#7+("1,6-..#7)'# )7:#70',"$-$"#(--%7+(/%-@#-0#+$"#.7$6"#,$-#+$#%1+$-$"#"-',#

"#1+:#,$1)7$1+)-881617.9"-97,#A7*1+#(7,!47.,-(#0-,#($"7$ .7$6"#,9#%#8-'+(/%-@#+ $*7</#767,#9"#%#!?"7(,$7)#*7+7)#( $"##01,-(#7,18$"#(--%97,/%-@#-0#+#( :#+-$"#%91,#$"#7/-:# #:1(#+6#-8!47+(!(-#,+-$$"%-97+<(-'/$-+$"#$#,$1*-+<-8 !?9"-1,$"#:16$1*1+$"1,67,#

$ 97, ,'/*1$$#( /< .#7%+#( % 6-'+,#. 700#7%1+) 8-% $"# 766',#(700#..7+$7.&1+(#%1+)"$"7$$"##:1(#+6#-8!?$"7$,"#97, ,$%7+)'.7$#( /< $"# 766',#( 97, /#.1#( /< $"# *#(167. #:1(#+6# !# $"-%-')".<,67++#($"##:1(#+6#-8!?7+(8-'+($"7$,"#"7,,1*0.<

? ,$7$#($"7$$"#766',#(0%#,,#("#%+#6@ '6"70%#,,'%#*-'+$#(/<$"# 766',#( *1)"$ +-$ "7:#.#8$ 7+< 1*0%#,,1-+ $ 1, +-$ $"#67,# -8 $"# 0%-,#6'$1-+$"7$,"#97,,$%7+)'.7$#( 0%#,,'%#97,)1:#+-+$"#+#6@ /#8-%#:#%,"#97,)1:#+7+#.#6$%16,"-6@/<$"#766',#(

+:1#9-8$"#7/-:#876$,7+(61%6'*,$7+6#,9#7%#-8$"# :1#9$"7$$"#0%-,#6'$1-+"7,#,$7/.1,"#(/#<-+(%#7,-+7/.#(-'/$$"7$ 766',#(700#..7+$7.&1+(#%1+)""7,6-**1$$#($"#-88#+6#0'+1,"7/.# '+(#%#6$1-+,4?5;7+(5

;

#7%+#(% 6-'+,#.700#7%1+)8-%$"#700#..7+$7.&1+(#%1+)" 9-'.(,'/*1$$"7$$"#,#+$#+6#1*0-,#(97,-+$"#"1)"#%,1(# !#7.,- 8##.$"7$$"#,#+$#+6#"7,/##+797%(#((1,0%-0-%$1-+7$#.<

$1,+-$767,#9"#%#$"#:16$1*"7(%#76"#($"#:#)#$7$1:# ,$7)#-+766-'+$-8$"#7$$76@.7'+6"#(/<$"#766',#( 86-'%,#1$1, 8-'+($"7$$"##.#6$%16,"-6@)1:#+/<766',#("7(.#8$7*7%@#(1*076$-+ !?9"-97,+-$7/.#$-,0#7@8.'#+$.<7+(97.@8%##.<

-+,1(#%1+)$"#7/-:#876$,7+(61%6'*,$7+6#,9#7%#-8$"# 6-+,1(#%#(:1#9$"7$$"#,#+$#+6#-8<#7%,

91$"81+#7*-'+$1*0-,#( /<$"#$%17. -'%$8-%$"#*7&-%-88#+6#'+(#%#6$1-+5; 9-'.(*##$ $"##+(,-8&',$16#

-*1+)$-$"#6-*0#+,7$1-+0%7<#(8-%/<!?9#81+($"7$ 766',#(7.&1+(#%1+)""7(.-,$"1,&-/-+766-'+$-86-+:16$1-+%#6-%(#( 1+$"1,67,# 1,87$"#%1,-+.<7,*7..87%*#%"7:1+)7/-'$E76%#,-8 .7+( 86-'%,#!?9"-"7($7@#+$%#7$*#+$8-%7/-'$E*-+$",1+7 "-,01$7.91.."7:#$-/#6-*0#+,7$#( +-'%:1#9797%(-86-*0#+,7$1-+ -87,'*-8.76-:#%7+(7/-:#$"#6-*0#+,7$1-+797%(#(/<$"#$%17.

-'%$9-'.(*##$$"##+(,-8&',$16#

+$"#%#,'.$$"#&'()#*#+$-86-+:16$1-+7+(-%(#%-8,#+$#+6# 07,,#(/<$"#$%17. -'%$8-%$"#-88#+6#,'+(#%#6$1-+,57+(4?

,$7+(,,',$71+#( "#6-+:16$1-+%#6-%(#(/<$"#$%17. -'%$8-%$"#-88#+6# '+(#%#6$1-+5; 7.,-1,6-+81%*#( '$$"#,#+$#+6#8-%.18#1*0-,#( -+$"#700#..7+$7.&1+(#%1+)"8-%$"#-88#+6#'+(#%#6$1-+5; 1, %#('6#($-<#7%,

"#81+#7*-'+$1*0-,#($"#%#'+(#%1,#+"7+6#( $- = + (#87'.$ -8 07<*#+$ -8 81+# $"# 766',#(700#..7+$ 7.&1+(#%1+)","7..'+(#%)-78'%$"#%0#%1-(-8<#7%

+%#6-:#%<-8 #+$1%#81+#8%-*$"#766',#(700#..7+$$"#,7*#,"7../#071($-!?/< 97<-86-*0#+,7$1-+ ,$"#*1+-%6"1.(-8!?97,+-$$"#:16$1*1+$"# -66'%%#+6#+-6-*0#+,7$1-+97,797%(#($-"#%

!1$"$"#7/-:#*-(18167$1-+1+$"#*7$$#%-8,#+$#+6#

45-8,$7+(,(1,*1,,#(7+(

441,7..-9#(1+ 07%$

" #

#/%'7%< " # '.7$1